Skip to the ~~ for spectacularly average sexy time.
I have been a long time lurker on this sub and decided to share one of my stories from college. It’s nothing crazy, but something that gets me going whenever I think back to those days. This was the drawn out process of how I lost my virginity to a goody religious girl.
Freshman year of college had just started and I had messed around with some girls in high school, but never had sex. I am a pretty average dude in decent shape at the time (18), 5’11”, short dark blonde hair, fit with strong legs, and a thin but muscular upper body. I moved into the dorms in August and am lucky enough to have been a tech nerd who got assigned to live on the life science floor with all the biology majors. In our school, almost all biology majors were girls, and while we had gender specific rooms, we had co-ed floors. We were one of 4 male rooms out of 22 total on our floor.
Once classes and everything gets going, our floor got a routine going of nightly hang outs in the common areas and this one girl started to take a liking to me and asked me for my number within 5 minutes of meeting me. Being that shy, nerdy tech kid, I enjoyed this. She’s a short little thing at 4’11”, maybe 100 pounds while wet, dark hair, tan complexion, and cute glasses. We start talking and she’s actually a super innocent seeming girl. She is very strict to her religious beliefs, got a little tense and awkward whenever sex got brought up in group conversations with all the horny freshman in the dorms, and very reserved in the way she dressed and acted. This is one of those things that kind of intrigued me about her, cause I could sense there was more to her than she ever showed.
We started hanging out more often and inviting each other to our shared dorm rooms throughout September. We each had a roommate, but that didn’t stop us from cuddling and watching movies in bed. One night, she fell asleep in my bed, which was only a twin, so I just cuddled up to her and fell asleep as well. I was stuck behind her all night with that awkward boner and a face full of hair and no where to go. She sleeps like a rock so I never really think she noticed. In the middle of the night I wake up to see she kept her shirt on but took her bra off, went back to little spoon, and moved my hands to her surprisingly large boobs (later I found out to be a C cup). I was taken back by this with her attitude towards anything sexual brought up previously, but welcomed it without any question. We just slept that night and went on with our normal routine for the next few days. Class, hang out, movies, and more sleep overs.
At this point, I’m progressively getting more frustrated with the lack of sex, but even when she did spend the night, my roommate randomly show up and I wasn’t sure what she wanted. I decided to go home for our fall break in October, but the morning before I left she moved my hands to her boobs again and was actually awake enough this time for me to ask if she was ok with that. She seemed quite happy and quick to respond with a yes, but then hopped out of bed and went back to her dorm to get ready for class. She texted me in the middle of it saying she was quite lonely. Most everyone took that weekend to go home as most of us were only a few hours from home, but she wasn’t. I decided to head back to school early to get a night alone with her and see what would happen, as any 18 year old would do if he thought it could be the day he gets to sleep with a girl for the first time.
So it’s Saturday night at 11 PM and I am just pulling into the dorms. After a quick late night Wendy’s run with her and the few friends left in the dorm we went back to her room. Her roommate is gone and we get the whole night to ourselves.
~~
We start by just sitting and talking to each other than she straddles me and we start making out. She’s a little thing that’s so easy to throw around, it was pretty fun being able to do so freely with no worries about someone barging into the room. She was wearing gym shorts and a quarter zip up sweater with nothing underneath as she often did when she spent the night. After kissing her neck and rubbing her up, I slowly start to take her sweater off and see if she’s good with it. She then proceeds to take it off the rest of the way. I see her seemingly perfect perky C cup breasts and immediately start to kiss and suck on them. This was something she seemed to really like as she was moaning and giving me some great verbal feedback. I stay there for a bit taking it all in, then she takes my shirt off and tells me to take my pants off. 18 year old me pulled a rookie move and didn’t grab a condom! But then I remembered, my roommate had a stash in his drawer and told us to grab one if we ever needed it. I ran 2 doors down back to my room while shirtless, grabbed it, then ran back to her room faster than the time it took me to cum from first blowjob back in highschool. Anyways, I asked her if this was really ok as a super nervous virgin, and she confirmed. We started and I fumbled with the angles on sticking it in her while thinking this was nothing like porn made it seem. Once I got it in, we stayed in missionary for a long time. I was pretty nervous and not enjoying it as much as I should have, but I was overwhelmed by the smells and sounds of sex that I didn’t really expect. I did enjoy watching her perfect boobs bounce back and forth while sliding in and out of her at an awkward pace. Over time, I ended up on my back and she took control, sliding up and down on my 6 inch, slim and slightly curved cock. This is when the euphoria took over and she and I both started to enjoy it. I figured out the rhythm then about 5 minutes later I exploded into the condom. This whole process took like 45 minutes, which was probably the longest single session I ever had without cumming. After this, it was always much, MUCH quicker. ?
It took me a second to recover, but I knew I immediately wanted more. Thankfully, so did she. So I grabbed another condom, and we went right back to it. This time I picked her up and carried her across the room staying inside her the whole time and put her on her roommates bed and began to fuck her hard there. (I did this as payback because one night while we were sleeping in her room, I heard to her roommate fucking a dude with us in the room and pretended to be asleep. My girlfriend never woke up.) Her roommates bed was the perfect height so I could stand comfortably and get the perfect view of her while fucking her. This time I could tell I had kind of figured it out as she started to get really loud which turned me on more. I was still convinced that was just a porn thing til that moment. I got her to cum this time, and I came soon after her while she was still on the bed.
We ended up spending the rest of freshman year fucking each other exclusively and ofen, learning oral on each other, and other vanilla sex things that seemed crazy as a freshman in college who just lost his virginity. I know it isn’t the dirtiest or craziest, but it was my first, and I still enjoy thinking back to it til this day. She was lots of fun at first, but my interests outgrew hers and we split at the beginning of sophomore year.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/daca20/losing_my_virginity_to_my_religious_college_gf