This one is really long and a little vanilla but I hope you still enjoy it!
I’m not really sure how much time went by but I know my sister had turned 19 so it was probably about 5 or 6 months later that I first got to hang out with Amy again. She had been around my parent’s house but usually in my sister’s room with the door closed or just to pick her up, that sort of thing. I’m not sure if she was avoiding me because of awkwardness about what happened on our trip or because she had a new guy. All I know is I couldn’t stop thinking about how close I had come to actually sleeping with her.
On one Friday or Saturday night in the summer my sister mentioned that she was going to be hanging out at our local pub with her new boyfriend and a bunch of our friends and that if I wasn’t doing anything I should come too. I played it cool and said maybe I’d come by for a beer but honestly I was excited. It wasn’t even just about Amy, I wanted to see her friend Sarah too. I had always had a crush on Sarah, she was a blonde of about average height with a pretty face and curves in all the right places. She loved to show off her amazing cleavage, jokingly pushing her tits together or leaning over towards a guy and laughing. On top of that she had a bit of a reputation for being easy which I’ll be honest I had always found incredibly sexy rather than a turn off. She had been away at school all year and I hoped at the very least to hear some slutty stories about her having fun during her first year of university.
When I got to the bar a bunch of my friends were sitting on the patio so I felt like I should join them. I was probably only there for about 10 minutes when Amy and Sarah came outside for a smoke. Sarah was wearing a grey vneck t-shirt that made her tits look amazing and Amy was in a tank top with a low back that let you clearly see a lacey white bra. Sarah blew a kiss and gave me her usual cute smile and I waved back while Amy rolled her eyes. When they went back inside I waited about 5 minutes, finished my beer and then followed spotting their group sitting at two separate tables about 10 feet away from each other. My sister introduced me the three or four people I didn’t know, one of which was Sarah’s new boyfriend James and the others I can’t even remember. I should have known, she always had a “boyfriend” even if she was fucking 3 other guys but shes a whole different (HOT) story a few years later.
I noticed Amy had gone straight up to the bar and was glaring at the smaller of the two tables “Hey, are you pissed off because my sister got a boyfriend? Or is it because Sarah did?” I joked thinking she’d laugh and roll her eyes like she usually did when I made lesbian jokes.
“Ugh, fuck off tonight seriously.” She looked at me annoyed. Amy had never looked at me or talked to me like that before and I think I stood there for a good 20 seconds surprised by how hostile she seemed.
“Sorry, damn, I was just kidding.” I stood beside her while I tried to get the bartender’s attention and she continued to look over towards the tables.
“Great now I pissed you off too. Guys suck.” She sighed dramatically.
I laughed “I’m not pissed off, whats with you tonight?” I turned around following her eyes to the two groups and realized who she was watching. Kyle, the guy she had been “seeing” casually who I think was a year or two younger than me was sitting at the smaller table. I guess he and Amy had some kind of argument before seeing each other at the bar that night and now he was chatting up this really cute tiny blonde girl I didn’t know. It was pretty clear just from watching for a few seconds that the other two people at the table were trying their best to have their own conversation due to the awkwardness of sitting directly across from two people who are clearly flirting way too hard.
“Your sister brought her boyfriend and Sarah showed up with this random dude…” She said pointing at James a little too obviously “and my guy won’t stop hitting on that little bitch.” She pointed again so I took her arm and lowered it.
“Stop pointing at people!” I told her laughing as I sort of held her in place “Come on, lets do a shot and sit down before someone steals that last chair.” She smiled at me, it was a small smile but it was better than her sulking. We did a shot, probably something disgusting that we thought was cool back then and went to sit at the bigger table with my sister and Sarah. I pulled out the chair for her and nodded.
“Its the last seat, you sit and I’ll sit on your lap.” Amy said casually. I sat down and spread my legs just enough that she could sit on my left leg with both of hers between mine facing away from the other table. No one really noticed us sitting together as being a big deal considering the bar was packed but I got the sense she thought she could make Kyle jealous. Whenever she talked to me she turned her head so her lips were right beside my ear and her arm was around my neck. While Amy was talking to someone further down the table my sister’s eyes caught mine and she gave me a bit of a puzzled look. I shrugged my shoulders as if to say I don’t know and she looked back to whoever Amy was talking to.
As the night went on Amy got more and more comfortable flirting with me in front of both my sister and Kyle, even once refusing an open seat at the table telling everyone she really liked the one she had. No one at our table could see that I was rubbing her back underneath her tank top with my left hand while my right was resting on her thigh. Eventually she started playing with the hair on the back of my head, slowly running her nails through it. Around that time Kyle got up and waved to our table, walking out of the bar holding hands with the cute blonde girl.
“Whatever…” Amy muttered under her breath as she watched them leave before turning back to me “We need to leave soon.”
“Whats up?” I asked a bit confused.
She put her mouth so close to my ear that her tongue was basically inside it “Well, it’ll be awkward if we aren’t finished by the time your sister gets home.”
“I’ll tell them I’m gonna go back to the patio, you go out the front door and meet me around the corner.” I instructed trying not to sound too excited. She nodded in agreement, finally giving me the big smile I was used to getting from her. I went out towards the patio but walked right by it into the parking lot where Kyle and the little blonde were making out, I assumed waiting for a cab. I hurried over to the corner Amy would have been coming around and made it there just in time kissing her hard and pushing her towards the wall of the bar to stall her. She wrapped her arms around the back of my neck and pushed her tongue into my mouth while pressing her body into mine.
“Seriously we should hurry…” She whined trying to pull away with my hands on her waist. The cab turned the corner into the parking lot.
“Kiss me one more time first.” I growled biting my lip as I looked her up and down.
“Make me…” She said in a bratty voice. I grabbed the back of her head and forced her lips to mine, when I think back I realize now we were both pretty drunk at this point but at the time I remember thinking how smooth I was distracting her. She bit my lip playfully and wiggled free taking my hand “Come on!” The cab was at the other end of the parking lot when we turned the corner.
We walked back to my parent’s house and I led her to my room in the basement. She sat down on my bed and grabbed me by the belt as I walked towards her, I ran my hand through her hair and she looked up at me smiling “Have you been dreaming about this?”
“Only every night since the trip.” I answered as she pulled my jeans and boxers down together leaning over so close to the already throbbing head of my cock that I could feel her breath on it.
She gave it a long soft kiss barely touching it with her lips and looked up at me “Get a condom.”
I rushed over to my drawer and took a condom out while she was lifting her tank top over her head and sliding her jeans off. Her panties were white with a lace pattern to match the bra. She looked so hot almost naked, sitting at the edge of my bed with her tanned skin, perky tits and long dark hair. While she opened the condom I unclasped her bra and she moved her arms to let it fall off and to the floor. I don’t know what it is but having her put the condom on me was a huge turn on, she was the first girl I’d ever been with that had done that and it made me even harder than I already was. I reached down and grabbed her with both hands by her cute ass lifting her up and into me, she instinctively wrapped her legs around my waist. my cock was throbbing pressed against her panties as I switched our positions so that I was sitting and she was on her knees on either side of my legs. She raised herself up and pulled her panties to the side as I wrapped my hand around my shaft and guided the head to her waiting shaved pussy. Amy lowered herself slowly reaching down to part her lips around my thick head looking into my eyes as she did.
“Don’t push up, let me get used to it.” She whispered and I just nodded as she took the first few inches inside of her. I threw my head back and swallowed hard, she was so incredibly tight it was taking everything I had to not just start pounding up into her. She was lifting herself and lowering again slowly, each time taking more of me inside of her. I reached a hand into her panties and grabbed her ass while she set the pace riding me.
She moaned “Don’t wreck my panties…” so I took my hand out and started to play with her tits, pushing them together and trying to suck on both her nipples at the same time, moving just slightly to go from one to the other. She responded by speeding up, starting to take all of my length for the first time, her face was starting to blush and I could tell she was really enjoying it. I loved being ridden because as hard as a woman does it I’ve never been able to cum in that position.
Her breath started to quicken and she pointed to a spot on her neck just below her jaw and managed to say “Kiss me… Kiss me.. right… right here…” I wrapped my arms around her so that our bodies were more closely pressed together and started to kiss and suck on the exact spot she had pointed to. I could feel her body tense up and she buried my cock as far inside her as she could get it, grinding more than riding as she started to cum “Oh my fucking God don’t stop!” she moaned as her legs quivered against my thighs and I continued to suck hard on her neck. Her grinding started to slow and she raised herself up off my hard cock reaching down to adjust her panties.
“You didn’t cum?” She asked surprised slightly out of breath while eyeing my still hard cock in the clear condom.
“Not yet.” I growled grabbing her and throwing her back onto the bed as she giggled. I pulled her panties down quickly and positioned myself between her legs pushing them apart. I guided myself back to her wet slit and ran the head up and down her pussy lips while she used her feet to try and pull me into her.
“Fuck meeeee…” She whined and I quickly obliged shoving almost my entire length back inside of her. She swallowed hard and I laid over top of her wrapping my arms around her back with her perfect tits pressed to my chest. I started to thrust squeezing her tightly against my body and the harder I fucked the higher her legs went on my back letting me get deeper and deeper. She started to push her ass up off the bed to meet my thrusts “You fuck me so deep, I want you to cum inside of me…” She whispered in my ear as I thrust and grunted, I was wearing a condom but I knew what she meant. I started to fuck her fast and hard, our bodies slapping together, fucking her like I was just using her to cum. I pushed as deep as I could and started to explode, my balls emptying for what felt like a minute.
I rolled over and collapsed beside her. Amy reached down and took the condom off of me wincing a little but smiling at the same time. “You deserve to rest.” She said sticking her tongue out at me and walking into my washroom. When she came out she put her panties back on but slept pressed up against me without her bra.
In the morning we made out a little in my shower before I snuck her out with my parents and sister still sleeping.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/d8ebpy/m_y_sisters_hot_f_riends_part_2
If you only made out with me in the morning that would be the last thing we’d ever do together…
Did you and Amy get together some more?