Context: Brother finds my diary, tells his friend (my ex) about an mmf dream, and invites him to lunch w us.
Anyways, he shows up and at first it’s awkward. We go inside to eat and for a while its just them two talking. I can feel both of them looking at me at times but I ignore it. Pablo gets up to go to the bathroom or something and suddenly its just us. Edgar grabs my hand and leans in, “tell me about the dream Maria” and for some reason I decide to stop being shy.
“ I don’t remember too much of it but what I do remember is two guys. Both of them were taller than me and I think they were friends. We were at a club or something and i think i was wearing that brown top and a short skirt. Then, in the dream, we started dancing and I was dancing with both of them. One was in front of me and one was behind me and we were really close cuz the club was kinda packed. And then, they said they would drop me home and we were in my driveway. My mom was away so I let them come inside and we were all sitting on the couch. We were gonna watch a movie so I changed into some leggings and a random shirt. Anyways we started the movie and I don’t remember why but i had to go outside to close the gate. When I came back in the guys weren’t on the couch and the movie was paused. I was so confused and I called out like guys? I walked to the bathroom but it was empty and i even checked the kitchen and the lobby. Thats when i saw my bedrroom light open and as i walked down the hallway I saw both of them: standing shirtless leaning against my doorframe. They laughed and I remember laughing too. ‘Aren’t you gonna invite us in?’ one of them said. We went in the room. I stood by my bed with two half naked men in front of me and watched as they closed the door and dimmed the lights. They looked at me and came even closer. One of them cupped my butt in his hands and the other one kissed my neck and whispered ‘do it’”
At this point, Edgar is hanging on my my every syllable and I can see Pablo starting to come back. “So did you do it what happened tell me” he says quickly as Pablo sits back down. He looks at us smiling and says “oh i know this story. The club one right? Thats the one i read…” i nod cuz im mortified and Pablo continues my story “Obviously she took it off and they kept telling her what to do. And Maria kept doing it.” Pablo smiles and Edgar finally says what we all know he’s been thinking and wanting to ask:
“You’re okay with talking about this?”
“I mean you guys are that open with each other?”
“Damn i wish i found my sisters diary”
“Actually fuck that what else did you do in the dream”
“Well, to be honest the dream ended before we actually did anything real. I remember them turning me around and telling me to lose the leggings and after I bent over and pulled them off. I was standing in my bra and panties and then i woke up; I didnt find out what happened after”
Pablo chimes in: “and as for the other stuff, Maria and I talk about our problems, even sex stuff sometimes. We even talked about this and if it would ever happen in real life. I told her it would just be between us. Actually you never answered my question”
They turn towards me and I take a deep breath. I have to be rational. It was fun telling the story but I need to be honest (and lowkey not a tease. “I don’t think I could do it, even if it kinda maybe was good to think about. First off, I dont wanna fuck a random guy or guys and I think i would get scared. Also, everyone would call me a slut and rumours would start spreading. And even if all of that wasn’t true, I definitely couldn’t handle that, especially if it went badly”
We sit in silence for a minute and I eat my fries quietly. Then Edgar blurts out, “We stole a car last week and I sold it for parts to this guy downtown” I am confused but before I can respond Pablo goes “I let my ex peg me once” Then, Edgar says, “Yeah and my sister is pregnant with her ex’s kid and we dont know if shes gonna keep it”. Pablo looks at me and says finally, “and i think I might be bi cuz I lowkey kissed Edgar” I stare at Edgar in shock and he nods at me. I heard that Edgar liked guys too but I had never even thought of it being a possibility for my brother. They keep going with these random confessions until I ask, “wait why are you telling me this stuff”
“Because now we all know stuff about each other and you know how good we are at keeping stuff on the DL” says Pablo. I start to say “yeah but still…” when Edgar interrupts me.
He says, “Maria, Pablo isn’t a random guy. I’m not either, jus sayin. No one would say anything after, obviously, and if you want we could pretend it never happened after. I wont ever push you but remember how excited you got when we tried that new thing? (something we did when we were together long story) And we’ll both promise to stop whenever you say no matter what. If you’re down to maybe try it…” Reluctantly, we start talking about it, just in hypotheticals at first.
*If youre still reading this far ty and im sorry for rambling. Send me an eggplant emoji and ill let you ask me one question of your choice ;)*
We talk about location and decide on our house because everyone at my place works at night. We talk about limits and safewords: no anal, everyone wears a condom, no one gets to cum inside my pussy, and no double penetration for sure. I say that im unsure about Pablo fucking me and decide to decide in the moment. We agree that Orange is gonna be our safeword and finally talk about the “when”. We decide on Thursday night to talk about it again and to give ourselves time to think about it. We are walking out to our cars when Edgar stops us and asks, “Will you wear the brown top and that skirt?” and Pablo add in, “yeah with heels?
They’re both smirking at me and, ngl cuz i do like dressing up: “Fineeeee”
Anyways ty for reading I’ll upload the next part when I can.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/12eey04/f_part_2_of_a_threesome_with_my_brother_fmm
That’s hot
Giiiiiirl 🍆