Quite a few people reached out and wanted to hear more about Rebecca’s “Best Ofs” in college so I’ll highlight some other hot sharing moments we had before graduating. A lot of these were with my roommate David since we were all pretty close, however, she really started opening up over our last year in school. If you haven’t yet read the previous parts, I am linking them below for some context.
Part 1: https://www.reddit.com/r/cuckoldstories2/comments/vc7gqn/how_my_college_gf_cucked_me_part_1/
Part 2: https://www.reddit.com/r/cuckoldstories2/comments/vescfg/how_my_college_gf_cucked_me_part_2/
As we played with David more and more often, Rebecca and David had gotten a lot….closer. I had encouraged Rebecca to keep playing with David, even going so far to let them fuck whenever we were all around. I would join in from time to time, but I also loved just sitting back and watching or even hearing about it later. Rebecca would suck me off while telling me about how she got fucked earlier in the day. David or I used to knock before walking in, but now he would just walk in on us having sex and would join in. It was especially hot watching Rebecca start flirting and fucking David while I’d be in the same room. She would almost wait until I start something like cleaning the dishes or take a shower, so I would have to watch her in the act. We ended up creating a threeway (ironic) group chat between us so we can plan out our little sexscapades.
I remember my phone vibrating one day while I was in class. I look down at it and see Rebecca had sent over a few messages over text. I tried putting my phone back in my pocket and pay attention to whatever the professor was trying to teach that day. We went to a large school so i tried to stack a lot of classes on the same day so wouldn’t be back til late. I figured she was asking about dinner or general plans for the day, but it wasn’t long before I got some more messages with pics and vids from Rebecca. Usually it would just be a random meme or random pic, but every few seconds was one after another.Just looking down at my home screen, I was already imagining about what was in my inbox. I had already completed the lab assignment that was being reviewed and escaped class at the first break I saw. I made my way to the bathroom and into a stall before fumbling my phone out of my pocket. As I opened up her messages, my phone immediately filled up with her naked body. I slowly scrolled through the photos of Rebecca posing on the couch and after a few there were pictures of her lips wrapped around Davids cock. I slowly lowered the volume on the phone when I pressed play on the video that she had sent. Rebecca was already bent over the couch with David fucking her from behind. I could hear as she was whimpering everytime David thrusted into her.
“Fuck me” Rebecca moaned under her breath as David picked up his pace. Rebecca gripped the couch harder as she started to get louder in the video. The video cut out just as quick as it started. As I pressed play on the video again, I noticed I was already getting hard under my pants before I got distracted by Rebecca’s whimpering on the video. While watching I got another picture sent to my phone but this time it was from David. They were no longer in the living room but in my bed, Rebecca was laying back and spread out with a smile. A follow up picture was sent where he had her reaching out towards David’s cock. I immediately tucked my boner away and started making my way back to see the action live. As I got closer to the apartment, I received another message, this time a video, from David. The video was from David’s POV as Rebecca had her legs on his shoulders. David was pumping away as Rebecca yelled out how good he felt. Rebecca kept moaning before David cut off the video and sent it over. As I walked (ran) to the apartment, I was quickly able to hear Rebecca lowly whimpering from my bedroom. I dropped my stuff on the floor as I slowly opened the door into my room. I was greeted with Rebecca’s moaning face facing towards me while David was behind her fucking her deep. I watched Rebecca gasp as she David kept thrusting into her. Once David saw me walk in, he definitely picked up his pace and Rebecca started to talk about how good he felt. I quickly took my clothes off and started touching Rebecca all over. David ended up pulling out and cumming all over Rebecca as she laid back catching her breath. Still hard from watching them fuck, I climbed into bed for my turn with Rebecca.
Rebecca and David continued to have these fuck sessions that started ramping up in frequency. When Rebecca would stay over, I would encourage her to climb into Davids bed to play with him. It would be hot watching her naked body skip across the room and climb into Davids bed. I would jerk off while watching her hook up with David and eventually start working on his cock. She always loved sucking his cock first before getting on top and riding David. Even late nights with the lights off, I would hear the sloppy BJs she would give under the covers, the clapping of Davids cock on Rebecca’s pussy as she rode him, and her muffled whimpering every thrust he made. After they would finish, she would skip right back into my bed for some sloppy seconds. It was hot kissing her and fucking her knowing she had just fucked David minutes before. Tasting his cock in her breaths or feeling his cum on her body. In the mornings, she would wake him up with some morning head and play around with him a bit before the day started. Once she even invited him onto our bed while I was still sleeping. I woke up to her getting fucked on our bed. I heard her moaning on the pillow next to me and as I looked over David had her bent over pumping away. I never cared as I loved watching her slowly become a little slut.
One day David had a friend of his, Josh, come over for the weekend to visit around our school. Josh had gone to high school with David and they were previously on the same soccer team. He was a pretty good looking dude, fit and funny guy. Rebecca had thought the same and started to tell me how good looking she thought Josh was. She definitely didn’t hide it laughing at his jokes and playfully touching him. Josh looked a little nervous whenever she got touchy but always pressed on. Later that first day, David even asked if Rebecca was going to fuck Josh the way she was flirting. I thought David was getting a little jealous asking this haha. Rebecca and I always talked about having her fuck other guys and now she was interested in doing so. After going from roleplaying with a dildo to finally taking cock, she finally started getting confident fucking others. That weekend there were some pretty hard storms that kept a lot of people home so bars were pretty empty and parties weren’t really happening. The first night wasn’t too eventful, all of us had gone out for some drinks while Rebecca got a little flirty before heading back for the night. Josh crashed on the couch in the living room while the rest of us went back to our room to “sleep”. Rebecca told David she was interested in fucking Josh and in exchange for his green light she would stay with David for the night for his fun to make it up to him. David countered with wanting to be involved in the threesome with Josh and Rebecca quickly agreed. He mentioned that Josh had a girl back home but Rebecca only took that as another reason to try and seduce him. As they started to fuck, I began to fantasize about Rebecca taking another new cock.
The next morning Rebecca woke me up and said she was going to make us some breakfast. She had changed into a sheer oversized white tee while she went topless underneath. After a little bit I went out and saw her and Josh in a deep convo. Josh got a bit startled and tried to keep his cool. While we ate breakfast, Josh kept stealing glances at Rebecca’s chest and I knew he was hooked. After Rebecca worked her teasing magic for a bit, David and Josh went out for a bit while we hung back. While out picking up some drinks, David mentioned to Josh that Rebecca liked to sleep around and bragged about how he would fuck her. David later told me that Josh thought Rebecca was cute and how he would love a round with her. Rebecca and I talked a bit about how she would start ‘seducing’ him and we came up with a Blackjack/Truth or Dare/Strip- type card game. Basically, whoever got closest to 21 will be able to ask whoever was furthest (or busted player) any truth or dare question. If someone hit a Blackjack, everyone else would have to take off a piece of clothing and take a shot on top of the Truth or Dare at the end of the round. We used the Joker as the Cut card which also acted as a Wild – Anything Goes. With this in mind, I pre-shuffled the deck of cards we had and made sure to throw in quite a few blackjacks to create some luck for all of us. We figured the Dares would be used to continue to strip once we started drinking and getting some clothes off.
After Josh and David got back, we did a little pre-gaming before we went out for some food and drinks. While we were out, the weather was still pretty shitty out and bar hopping didn’t seem like it was gonna be an option. We figured we would try it the next day but in the meantime we went back to the apartment to drink the rest of our alcohol. During the ride back, Rebecca sat in the back seat with Josh getting all touchy-feely with him. As we had a few more drinks, Rebecca came up with the great idea of playing Truth or Dare Blackjack. As we sat down and I fake shuffled, I explained the additional rules which included the strip and drinking and noticed as Josh and David smiled and exchanged glances with Rebecca. The first few hands were pretty innocent, take a drink or a get to know you question amongst ourselves. Not long after, the first blackjack was dealt to David and we all started laughing. As we took our shot, we pondered what would our first clothing piece we took off first. Josh was cheeky and took off his socks while Rebecca went right ahead and took off her sweater showing off another low cut shirt. We finished up that hand and Rebecca was the only one to bust. Confidently, she asked for a dare from David since he had the blackjack. David dared Rebecca to take another piece of clothing off. Rebecca laughed as she quickly thought about what else to take off. She reached underneath her shirt and took off her bra to show off to the group. Josh mentioned he liked the lace on it and Rebecca told him how she was wearing a matching set with a wink. It wasn’t long until we saw Rebecca’s tits poking through her shirt.
The very next hand Rebecca got the next juiced blackjack and I jokingly complained how it was just getting good. The guys basically took off our shirts as Rebecca checked us out with a smirk while we took our drinks. Josh and David had both busted while I stood on a 15 secretly throwing the game for Rebecca. Since Josh had already taken off his socks, she followed up daring him to take off another piece of clothing. Josh, having run out of options, ended up taking off his jeans hanging out only in his boxers. We all laughed as we played out the next few hands with the dares slowly getting more and more interesting. David dared Rebecca to kiss him and later dared Josh to feel Rebecca up. He slowly put his hands over his shirt and, being drunk at this point, I told him don’t be a pussy get up under there. Rebecca giggled as he made his way under his shirt and squeezed her tits a bit. As he was bent over grabbing at her, Rebecca reached for his junk pulling it out of his boxers as he sat back down. I ended up pulling the next blackjack and sat back laughing as I knew what happened next.
Josh opted for his drink first as he watched Rebecca slide off her pants revealing the matching panties. Josh slowly took off his boxers, half-hiding his cock from being seen by the rest of us. David took off his boxers too, leaving Rebecca and I the only ones with underwear on. Rebecca had lost that hand as well and I dared her to suck my dick until it got hard. Rebecca leaned over pulling my cock out from my boxers slowly kissing and licking it. David took this time to grab Rebecca’s ass while Josh slowly rubbed himself. It wasn’t long before I was hard as a rock and Rebecca popped back up with a smile. I noticed Josh was turned on but couldn’t hide it all behind his hands. Rebecca asked me to play another hand as she glided her hands over Davids cock. David had doubled down on a 11 to pull a 21 and Rebecca busted immediately after, almost wanting the dare to come. David dared Rebecca to get Eiffel Towered without using my dick. Josh looked at me with an awkward smile, not knowing what to say or do. He’s here naked with a half chub, what else was he going to do with it.
I told Rebecca to go ahead as I slowly jerked off and she got into position. I could see Josh’s cock twitch as Rebecca first grabbed it while David was already rock hard sticking his dick in her face. Rebecca sucked Davids cock while she slowly jerked Josh and he got harder and stiffer. Rebecca turned her attention to Josh and began sucking his dick while David stood up and got behind her getting ready to fuck her. David was slowly teasing Rebecca with his cock, getting ready to stick it in, meanwhile, Rebecca got Josh excited as she used her tongue to play tease the head of his penis. David gave me a smirk as he pushed into Rebecca’s wet pussy. Rebecca was very turned on and started moaning as David picked up his pace. Normally, when she was getting fucked I would let her do her thing while I watched or she would invite me over to slowly tease while David had his way with her but now Josh was much more active in the “threesome”. As Rebecca got distracted by David’s cock fucking her, she would slow down on Joshs cock causing him to get a little impatient. He eventually would slowly start thrusting into her mouth to get her started again which would get a bit awkward for her.
Rebecca, always up for the challenge, slowly started taking over control so she can get into a good rhythm to handle both Josh and David. It wasn’t long before she was sliding along Davids cock and alternating taking Josh’s cock in her mouth. Seeing her get comfortable take two cocks, I made my way over to throw an extra cock in the mix. Rebecca laughed a bit as she started to jerk me off but remained pretty distracted by Josh. David must’ve gotten excited as he was tryna slow her down and pulling out trying not to pop. I definitely wasn’t too far off seeing how hot it was seeing Rebecca almost being overwhelmed with cocks. David pulled out and stepped back jerking off a little trying to cool off, but I’m not really the type to hold back. I sat back on the couch and had Rebecca and Josh come over. Rebecca got on top and mounted me while she started riding me. I could feel how wet and freshly fucked she was as I twitched inside her. Rebecca reached out to Josh’s and positioned him behind the couch. She started slowly jerking Josh off behind me as she pulled him closer. He basically had his dick laying on my shoulder as she started to suck him off again. I watched as his cock got wetter and wetter every time she went for another mouthful. I could see Josh’s cock as it bulged and twitched in my face as Rebecca knew I was watching. As I got closer to finishing, Rebecca started whispering in my ear about how nice his cock was and she was ready to fuck it which practically made me explode.
Rebecca giggled as I finished inside of her, she was still there slurping on Josh’s cock in my ear. As I caught my breath, Josh made his way over to sit down on the couch next to me. Rebecca gave me a deep, wet kiss before climbing off me and jumping on Josh. It was funny to watch Josh go from nervous and unsure what to do to completely lusting over Rebecca as she grinded against his cock teasing him. He was biting his lip waiting for it as she rubbed up and down his shaft. Rebecca eventually reached down to grab Josh’s cock to guide him in as he let out a gasp. Rebecca started moaning as she took more and more of him in. Josh must’ve hit some spots since Rebecca was almost yelling at some points. David must’ve been feeling left out as he made his way back over and I moved out to give them some space. Rebecca was riding Josh deep, wrapping her hands around his neck, while she fucked him hard. You could hear Josh started to pant as Rebecca asked for it harder and harder saying it felt so good. She knew I liked watching her get fucked and would love to almost narrate to me, always got me going again
The whole time David was trying to get Rebecca’s attention, guiding her hand towards his cock or trying to pull her head away. Eventually she gave in, still trying to ride Josh but leant over trying to suck David off. After a while, this must’ve been uncomfortable for Josh as he got up, rotated Rebecca around, and started to fuck her again from behind so she could still keep David in her mouth. As he picked up his pace, you could tell Rebecca was pushing back trying to take as much of his cock as possible. I watched as Josh grabbed on to Rebecca’s hips to be able to maintain balance as he thrusted away slowly getting close and closer to climax. I watched as Josh’s face slowly let go and tried to pull out, but she made sure to push back up against him so he would finish inside her. Eventually Josh escaped Rebecca’s clutch and climbed off the couch chuckling at what just happened getting that post-nut clarity. I had signaled Josh to come over and Rebecca quickly moved right onto David to complete her trifecta. I spoke to Josh for a bit telling him a bit about our situation, how I even encourage it, glad he was down to join in and make it a really hot night.
Eventually we notice Rebecca run off leaving David behind on the couch smiling. We end up getting dressed and having a couple more drinks in the apartment that night, talking and even highlighting some of the stuff that happened fucking Rebecca which was really funny. When I walked back to my room that night, Rebecca was basically already passed out. She talked about how hot it was fucking someone new and in front of David as well. She mentioned Josh had a really thick cock that filled her up in a new way. She sometimes played with David and I together, but adding a third was definitely something new for her. She was definitely exhausted that night and I didn’t blame her. I always called this her first “train”, but she was adamant that only applied to 5 or more guys, what do you think?
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/11o46gc/how_my_college_gf_cucked_me_part_3