I didn’t think we had chemistry but that didn’t stop us from fucking in her car later that night [MF] [M31] [F25]

(ended up long af so skip to *** for the naked stuff)

I’m brand new to being single after ending a long-term relationship. So I’m still refining my sense of when people are into me or not

Anita and I matched and had some banter, but you know how the apps are. Sometimes there are days between replies. We randomly started to vibe when she said cookie butter was her favorite ice cream flavor

me: i didn’t even know cookie made a butter

her: Anything can make a butter if you put your mind to it

me: my mind went to turnips

me: dont ask me why

her: Gross but possible

me: wanna get turnip butter on friday

her: i think i would rather eat dirt

me: wanna get dirt on friday

her: hmmm tempting :)

me: i hear [bar in major city nearby] has good dirt

me: also beer which i will be drinking

me: and jazz which i hear both dirt and beer thoroughly enjoy

her: sounds sick im in

!!!. We did hit a snag as schedules moved around and I thought it was over, but sent her my number and was surprised to see her text me the day before we were thinking about meeting.

“hey it’s me anita the one who wants to get dirt with you tomorrow”

So yesterday, I pick a cute cafe nearby. Its an afternoon date and we both have plans later in the night. I get a chai for her as she parks. Then she walks in and holy. shit. She looks even better than her pictures. 😳 5’3″ dressed with a dope multi-pattern cardigan and cordorouy pants. super Petite

We walk around the city, I show her some sights, we make small talk. Turns out she’s finishing med school and while we have a lot in common, theres still something missing. Like the conversation wasn’t flowing naturally, which is usually where I shine

I’m like ok, maybe we can bounce back with cocktails. So I show her a couple local spots, where luckily I know the staff and they are extra friendly w/ us bc theyre homies

Eventually she has to catch a subway to her social event, and im like ok let me walk you. As we’re walking I look up the trains over and its long AF, so I say fuck it and order her a car. She’s sweet and protests, but she drove out all this way and whatever, I’m used to paying for my ex all the time (not bitter at all lol)

I walk her to the pickup, and as I go in for the farewell, suddenly we are making out haaard in the middle of the sidewalk. My hands explore her and I’m drooling to realize her tits are big for her frame and turns out her ass is round and tight. Fuck. A nearby traffic cop cleared his throat, which I heard & ignored, then said cmon guys you gotta move. Lol.

As the uber pulls up you could hear a slight whine in her voice that it was here already. 🥵 I said ok just lmk when you finish tn, you have to come back here to get your car anyway

While shes gone I hang out with some friends in the area at my local bar, and the texts between us slow to a crawl. I know shes busy but bc I’m so new to this I wonder if she is really into me or not.

So we’re chillin, I’m trying hard not to get too fucked up bc holy shit bartenders can drink when its an offnight

Then there it is! Around 11pm Anita lets me know shes on the way back. I head over, and the second I see her, I move to continue our make out sesh…she feels very receptive. After a quick pitstop at a nearby bar so we can pee, I walk her to her car and we’re switching who is being pressed up against the car while making out. There’s a garbage truck doing some midnight collection & it’s windy.

A lightbulb finally goes off and I realize she is indeed into me and just really quiet/submissive.

I ask her if she wants to get in the car and she nods shyly. “It’s really messy” she says and I come back with “I don’t mind messy”

******

For reference, I’m 5’10”, athleticish build (bouldering but more skinny now since the breakup), tattoos & piercings, and parted coarse curly hair that goes down to around my ears. My ex would say my cock is long and I’ve been told by other ppl its girthy. I’m pretty sure its just an average cock but I’ll take the compliments 🥰

Once we’re in I’m on top of her for a second, then shes on top of me, then I’m on top of her again. We’re taking off layer by layer and tossing them on the floor. The windows start to steam up which was really turning me on and i finally get to see those nipples. They’re small and suckable (yay). I’m really into nippleplay but once I start licking them, it felt like while she enjoyed it, I wasn’t getting the response I wanted. So we get her pants & panties off and to my surprise, she has the cutest little bush. I’m a little drunk and felt around for her clit and then thereee it is. She started to pant and moan and seemed to love my tongue circling around it, with my lips as kind of a seal. I start fingering her and she’s thrusting her hips into my mouth. 😚

She’s little but packs a lot of power into those thrusts lol. I’m getting super turned on and when my pants come halfway off, she asks if I have a condom and oh fuck no I do not.

But my cock’s in my hand and I see her staring at it. I say look, I want to fuck you now but I also want to keep fucking you tomorrow and later (which is my drunk horny brain’s way of being respectful)

I’m stroking my cock, and she’s thrusting her hips up towards me, hands on her face, going “I-I-I…”

I bring my cock closer to her pussy and she is lifting her hips completely off the backseat to get me inside her asap. I rub my cock up against her and sloooowly work my way inside her, bc 1) it feels amazing and 2) i dont want to rush it in case her mind changes

My cock is maybe 30% inside her at this point and I’m going deeper.

me: do you want me to fuck you?

her: …i w-want you to fuck me (a whisper)

me: do you want me to fuck you?

her: i want you to fuck me (a little louder)

me: do you and me to fuck you?

her : p-please, please fuck meeeee

I cut her off a little at the end and really start pounding her. The car is completely steamed up and I can feel it shaking sideways while her tits jiggle wonderfully. I’m trying my best not to pay attention to the men in service vests that are 10ft away and 1000% knew we were fucking (what homies btw for not messing w/ us)

It’s hard to get an angle, then we clamber about for her to ride me a little, and while shes tiny I can see she’s bending her neck over awkwardly. She still manages to ride the hell out of my cock, and while it’s tough to thrust back, I play with her asshole & feel her work herself until she starts shaking, slowly losing momentum and getting all dazed. Yay 🙂

Even though its cramped, bc I’m greedy I have her get on her stomach and fuck her from behind. Unfortunately I can barely get an angle in and with the confining car situation + the random garbage truck I’m having trouble finiishing. So mental note that I owe her my cum and def want to fuck that pussy from behind if this happens again

We wrap up, make out here and there, talk a little but the convo is about as dead as it was earlier. lol

It’s 1am, turns out she has to drive 50m back to her med school (???!!!), so she drops me off and after checking that she made it back ok, I promptly pass the f out

We already starting flirting thru text again so hopefully theres a part 2 and we can take our time. ♥️

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/104alba/i_didnt_think_we_had_chemistry_but_that_didnt