Short story. More if any interest.
Met a girl years ago in college through OKC (dating site). Around my age (early 20s at the time) and was interested in whatever. She was a Jewish girl with an alt style (thicc but not overweight) with C cups (maybe) and maybe 5′ 6” (I’m 6′ 2″). She was kinda bratty and kept a trimmed bush and told me to “deal with it” because she didn’t want to shave fully all the time (I liked it though).
We hooked up a couple of times and had to work around avoiding her roommate (almost getting caught once). Eventually we talked kinks and she confessed to wanting to try 2 guys at once. I wasn’t 100% on board with it at the time but wanted to please her, so we compromised: We’d have another join but only her and I’d fuck (and she could suck him).
We ended up finding another guy in her dorm (huge dorm and diff floors so it wouldn’t be super awkward). He was skinny and we were similar dick size (although his was longer ultimately) and he understood the boundaries. We were planning on meeting up at 1 that day since some of us had classes later. Her and I were hanging in her room waiting for him, even fooling around and had gotten completely naked since he was running late. Finally heard a knock on the door at about 130, and I almost answered naked but decided to at least put on my basketball shorts and she threw on a large/baggy shirt. I answered and we did the whole awkward handshake and “nice to meet you” formalities and she gave a wave and a “hey” since she was a little shy.
We talked for a bit and he apologized for being late, etc. and she also told us that her roommate was coming back at 2 so we had limited time. We were cool with it and she invited him to lay down. The bed was just big enough that they could fit on it (awkwardly) and I had to fuck her from the edge. I was putting on a condom while she was sucking him and decided to take her shirt off.
While she was also tying her hair up, she asked if I’d be down to turn her camera on and she’d video. I was hesitant but ultimately cool with it, despite it being on a Coolpix camera (fancy shit at the time) and us fumbling to set it up for a few minutes while he sat back and stroked himself.
We had a few trial and errors due to me trying to fuck her with the awkward bed height, having to stop a couple of times and find things I could stand on, etc to get a comfortable position. They would even stop and watch me do so, despite me saying they could keep going, but she was super sweet and said she wanted to wait for me, and tried to make small talk, him asking if we’d done this before, etc. and her joking “apparently not”.
Eventually we got a good balance, him horizontally on the bed so I could get on the edge. We only went for about 5 mins before her phone rang and she needed to answer since her roommate was calling. After hanging up, she sighed and said her roommate would be here shortly and we need to pause things. She got up to start putting on underwear and asked if we wanted to maybe try again that night if we were all free. We said we’d be down and coordinated a plan if things worked out.
Despite the trials and lack of time, still had a lot of fun.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/zvfcpq/mfm_spoiling_college_fwb_with_another_guy_in_her