[M]y first surprise foursome with my gf and my old crush and her bf [MFMF] [Part 1]

I was at a party with my girlfriend at the time when she came up to me and proposed something.

She was my first girlfriend that I was very actively sexual with. She was curvy with DDs and always was changing the color of her long brown hair – let’s call her B. She was 2 years younger and was always horny. I would sneak in through her bedroom window (she and strict parents) and we would fuck until the morning. We experimented a lot too, anal, dirty talk, face sitting, risky outdoor spots… to say the least we had fun.

This particular night we were at a party and I could see her chatting with our mutual friend that I’ve always had a crush on. She was equally curvy and had the most gorgeous lips – let’s call her P. I had heard stories of P’s sexual exploits but never knew how true they were.

After they’re done talking, B comes up to me and pulls me away from everyone. “Do you want to have a foursome with P and her bf?” My jaw dropped, I stumbled over my words, I couldn’t believe it. B’s face said it all, she wanted it… hell I wanted it. She asked me to ask P’s bf if he was down. We were good friends so I didn’t mind – let’s call him N.

“Dude they want to have a foursome with us. Are you down? I’m down if you are”

N was down.

We left the party immediately and went to Ns big house, his parents were out of town.

We were all giggly and nervous but being we were all friends we were comfortable and excited. We decided the best way to break the ice was to skinny dip in his pool. This is when things quickly picked up speed.

B and P started making out in the pool, giggling and putting on a show for us. N and I were just watching together letting them go. I could see B playing with Ps tits under the water. Right after P suggested we move inside.

It was my first time really getting a good look at P and N nude and outside of the water. I couldn’t stop staring at P but I also couldn’t stop staring at N. I wanted to touch both…

——————

This is my first time writing this so let me know what you think. Happy to post part 2, which is the good stuff.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/zdbvba/my_first_surprise_foursome_with_my_gf_and_my_old