I had just graduated High school, and was living in a apartment with a roommate. My roommate was out of town and I decide to have a party. There were somewhere around ten and sixteen people over, drinking and having a good time. One of the girls at my party (Sheryl my wife now ), I had dated in high schooI. We had banged a few times, in high school. Sheryl was at the party with her girl friends. Sherl was looking hot with her mini shirt and spaghetti strap tank top, the top fit snug on her, perfect firm “c” cup tits. I wanted to fuck her that night. I reminisced about the first time I fucked Sheryl in my truck. Sheryl is 5’8″, shoulder length brunette hair, perfect real tits, muscular legs, landing strip and razor sharp tan lines. I lasted about ten minutes of fast fucking and came in condom. She was not on the pill and did not want me shooting off in her pussy.
One of Sheryl’s girlfriend Stacey, was at the party.
During the party, Stacey and I went out side. Stacey told me that Sheryl wanted to date me again and hook up.
I came back inside to get beer. I noticed my roommates bed room door was shut and locked. Due to the volume of people at the party I did not know who was missing. I went to the kitchen to get a butter knife to pick the lock.
When I quickly pushed the door open there was my future wife, naked on her back spread wide, on the bed. One of my older brothers friends, Bruce, was getting up off of her. His face looked like a glazed donut, he was naked. He must have ate her pussy, prior to fucking her. I was super jealous. Sheryl’s pussy looked perfect. Her dark landing strip and puffy swollen pussy lips were exposed. I stared at her sweet little cum covered pussy.
This was some time ago, cuckolding was not even a thing. I wanted to kick Bruce’s ass! I was pissed and jealous. I told Sheryl and Bruce to leave, and I shut the party down. I thought I would be the one screwing her that nite.
Four months went by and Sheryl and I hooked up again. She was just a fuck to me now. I was screwing other girls too. I did hookup with a few of her friends during this time. Fucking her girl friends and other girls , during this time is what made her lust for me again.
I screwed her for a long time before, I took our relationship serious again. She was giving her self exclusively to me during this time.
We have talked about that night. She told me Bruce and her were drunk , and they did fuck and she sucked his cock in the bed room. They hooked up a few more times and then broke up. I don’t believe her, when she said they broke up because Bruce has the smallest dick she has ever sucked and she could not cum when they screwed.
I still run into Bruce around town. He is a much smaller build than me. I know the situation makes him uncomfortable. I am not going to stomp a mud hole in his ass. I can’t blame him, if I was in his shoes, I would had fucked her too.
I have been married to Sheryl now for 12 years. She keeps telling me she wants to see me fuck another girl. I keep thinking about our past, and don’t feel like it’s a good i idea. I cant help but feel if we do a three some with another girl, she will then resent me and think anything go’s, like I di
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ysvny6/the_first_time_my_prior_girlfriend_now_my_wife