[M]y girl[f]riend and my jerk off bud. Part 1: Getting caught

Back in the summer of 2001, I was in my third year at a mid sized American Midwestern university. Me and my dorm roommate, Brandon, had rented an apartment just off campus and were staying in town over summer break. Brandon and I had become really good, if not best, friends over the last two years. We would run together almost every day, drink and party, and go on double dates with our girlfriends.

We would also jerk off together watching our favorite porn VHSs on the old TV/VCR combo. Alone time is hard to come by in the dorms and we had already walked in on each other several times when one night Brandon asked if I minded if he rubbed one out so he could sleep. I said I could use a release too, and the next thing I knew we were dicks out. On our own beds, no touching, just watching that primo late 90s porn, stroking our dicks and shooting ropes together. Just bro stuff, right?

We did measure and compare cocks, naturally, and Brandon was considerably larger than me. The tape measure put me at 6” long and 5” around – but my man was packing a 8”x7.5” baseball bat of a dick. Shockingly thick, especially the top half. Huge balls and huge loads too. He was pretty humble most of the time, but he definitely like to jokingly remind me he was the bigger man from time to time. Otherwise physically, we were both similarly built, toned, six-packed, smooth, 6 foot tall 22 year old twinks.

When the sock was on the door handle, you could hear his girlfriend screaming from the common area at the end of the hall. This made it all the more surprising when she dumped him before going home for the summer to get back with her High School boyfriend. I guess a perfect dick isn’t everything.

So that sweltering summer, it was me, my girlfriend Kirsten, and a very sad Brandon just hanging out and getting lit every night when we weren’t at work. We all had service industry jobs and we’re working like dogs while we had the time.

Kirsten and I had been together for about 6 months. She was a petite blonde haired green eyed little pixie of a 21 year old with perky little A cups and a perfect little peach of an ass. She was considerably more experienced than I was and we had a very active sex life, sharing all our wildest fantasies with each other.

One night in mid-July, Kirsten got cut early from her serving job and didn’t call and let me know like she would usually do in those circumstances. She came rolling into the living room unexpectedly to find both of us on opposite ends of the couch shirts off, pants around our ankles, furiously stroking our cocks to Jenna Jameson getting railed by Peter North on the TV.

Kirsten screamed, “OH MY GOD YOU GUYS WHAT THE FUCK!!!”

As I frantically tried to yank my pants up. I stammered out my embarrassment I saw Kirsten’s eyes widen and mouth drop – she’d obviously just noticed Brandon’s enormous dick.

With a frustrated, “What the fuck Kirsten, you don’t even live here and you just come barging in…” he stood up, grabbed his clothes in a bundle, and strolled past Kirsten to his bedroom, heavy dick swinging back and forth comically, a heavy pearl of precum dripping onto the floor. He made no attempt to cover himself. His door slammed shut as I got dressed. Kirsten was now laughing her ass off. At least she wasn’t angry.

“I knew you guys were close but goddamn you freaks.” she cackled.

I laughed awkwardly. “Well I mean hey, he’s been depressed and hasn’t had any pussy in a while so we just…you know…sometimes we…”

“Yeah yeah sure baby, jerk off all you want….but what the fuck Brandon’s dick is huge. Like why…how?!?” she giggled as she sat down on the couch next to me. She rubbed my now nervously deflated cock over my pants.

“Yeah he’s definitely a lot bigger than me. I don’t know I guess he’s just gifted.” I said as Jenna Jameson was in the background getting railed by a huge cock.

“So do you guys do this often?” She asked with genuine curiosity. “Have you ever touched each other? Oh my god have you guys fucked a girl together?”

“I don’t know maybe like once a week…..and no we don’t touch…..and no, we haven’t shared a girl before.” I said shyly as my cock grew rock hard again.

“Would you ever? I mean, do a girl together? Your dick is rock hard right now you know…” she said as she stared into my eyes.

We had talked about having a 3 way before, several times in fact. Kirsten’s biggest fantasy was to be shared by two guys at once. She even said she’d have one with another girl just to make it even if I wanted – but she really wanted to try it.

I knew where this was headed. Part of me wanted to give my beautiful girl whatever her heart and body desired, the other part of me wasn’t so sure I wanted it to be with Brandon and his big fat home wrecker – a third part of me really wanted to watch her squeeze that beast into her tiny little pink pussy.

I responded after a long pause, “Yeah, I’m down to fuck you with Brandon, sure. If that’s what you’re getting at. I’d have to ask him, we’ve never really talked about that. I’m not sure how I would go about that though.”

“Oh please,” Kirsten purred into my ear as she continued rubbing my crotch and kissed my neck, “Brandon would totally have sex with me and you know it. And I doubt he’d be intimidated by you being there too. I doubt that guy is intimidated by anyone.”

“What’s that supposed to mean?” I said, feeling a really confusing combination of jealous, offended and horny.

“Oh please, baby, don’t be jealous – you’ve seen his dick, it is what it is. I’m surprised he’s not more arrogant, honestly.” Kirsten said, sounding impressed. “I should probably apologize to him for barging in here anyway don’t you think? Or are we just going to pretend I didn’t just walk in on you two having a wank in the living room?”

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/xo4wpk/my_girlfriend_and_my_jerk_off_bud_part_1_getting