I’ve been a long-time reader of stories on this thread and finally decided to share a story.
This was a long time ago, but a favorite of mine. I had recently transferred as a junior to a new university on the east coast and was in my first semester there. I was assigned a dorm room and since I didn’t know anyone I spent a fair bit of time getting to know the people in my hall.
A few doors down was a group of girls who were a mix freshman and exchange students. Most of them were hot and silly, but there was one who was a shy girl named Samantha who was short (5’1”), bit chubby (maybe 135-140), large breasts, pouty lips and thick dark hair. A short Jewish girl with an oversized rack, if you know the type. She was that nerdy type who probably didn’t get a lot of attention in high school. On the other hand, I was that typical 6’4”, in shape, athlete playing a varsity sport in college who everyone thought would be out always banging the tall blonde. Secretly though, I personally always had a soft spot for these types of girls.
All of us were new to the college and started hanging out frequently watching movies and goofing around. It wasn’t anything major but one day Samantha hit me up on a text saying she was bored and was curious what I was up to, at the time I didn’t think anything of it. I had just finished a paper and was getting ready to go to bed but I said I’d be probably watching a movie while I try to fall asleep.
She mentioned she wasn’t tried yet and asked if she could join me to watch the movie (Fight Club I think). I said sure and 2mins later there was a knock on the door. She came in wearing some short silk shorts and and a tie died Grateful Dead shirt with a bra underneath. Now we had watched movies with others before, sat next to each other with not a hint of tension. I liked her as a friend and never really thought twice about her sitting down to watch a movie on my tiny twin bed.
30mins in she snuggle up next to me and said she wanted to get more comfortable saying she was hot. It was hot in the room and being an oblivious 20 year old, I was like “OK”. Off came her shirt and for the first time I realized how hot she was, she didn’t make a move but just got close again and resumed watching the movie.
Meanwhile, I stopped watching the movie 😀. My arm was around her, now touching her side on the bra and I instantly started getting hard. She put her hair down which then fell on her large and supple breasts and pushed closer. Instantly this nerd, chubby girl switched in my brain to a sexy woman I needed to have and I knew I had to make a move. Her breasts were supple and milky white in her lacy bra, the way her hair rested on them drove me wild and she had a tiny pudge underneath that gave her a sexy supple look making me imagine what her pussy might be like underneath.
I reached further around and started playing with the lining of her bra while pulling her closer. Being the 20 year old me, I was pretty bad at reading signals (I kinda still am), so I wanted to move slow as I wasn’t confident she meant anything by losing her shirt 🤣, looking back at it I am sure she was wanting this to move faster. And then she looked up at me with those pouty lips and without saying anything I moved in for a kiss. It was hot, and passionate with our tongues interlacing. Our hands wandering all over our bodies, she was a bit clumsy as she reached down, fiddling with the button on my shorts. Meanwhile I snapped her bra loose quickly, letting her breasts come free. They were larger than I thought and they rested above her tummy with larger nipples that stood upright begging to be sucked.
I leaned down and with one had took her left breast into my mouth while I slide my right hand down her shorts feeling her cotton panties, which were soft and damp. I rubbed the outside of them feeling her soft pussy and I could tell she was hairless. She moaned quietly as I tasted her breast. I was so turned on and I couldn’t take it anymore, I had to know how she tasted so I pushed her down while making out with her now in missionary with our bottoms still on. I started moving down kissing her neck, then breast then stomach, slowly pulling down her now wet panties to reveal a small, perfect and glistening pussy ready to be devoured.
I dove in, her hands running through my hair as I slowly and methodically teased the outside of her pussy, and then when she couldn’t take it anymore, I started really diving in deep lapping up her wetness as she moaned. I kept going until she pulled me up and started passionately kissing me her juices still all over my mouth. And now with my cock pressing close to her.
I get up and go to my drawer to grab condom, she asks me what I am doing and I tell her. Only for her to say “I’ve never had it raw before and I’ve always wanted to, do you want to try without”. I ask if she is sure and she says “I am on birth control, let’s try it, it will be fun”.
Well you don’t have to ask me twice! I jump back on top of her and she grabs my cock (I’m around 7’ and thicker than average based on feedback) and lines it up to go in. She is so wet and my cock is covered in precum, but as I push in she is really tight. That kind of tight where my head took some pushing and then in a moment “pops” in.
I slowly slide in, putting an inch deeper each time. She continues to moan and press her hips into mine. My entire length is now all the way in and we start moving faster and faster. I am sucking on her breasts thinking of how much larger they would come if she got pregnant (later in life I discovered my breeding fetish). I can feel my self getting ready to come as she tightens around me. She reaches down and starts massaging my balls, saying “give it all to me baby, fill me up.”
This pushes me over the edge and I start cumming hard, pushing my cock as deep into her as I can, almost making my pelvic bone hurt as I press into her. My cock is pulsing and with her massaging every ounce of cum out of me. She comes right as I shoot my last rope of cum into her, squeezing every last bit out.
We collapse in my tiny dorm room bed, laughing in post orgasm glow while my cock throbs inside of her. We make out for a bit with me inside of her and when I pull out, she squeals a bit and cum pours out of her on the bed. She sat there and played with it a bit saying how good and “weird” it feels coming out of her. She takes a taste, gets up, saying “time to clean up” and heads off to the bath room.
That was the first but definitely not the last time Samantha and I came together.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/wtabfg/samantha_surprises_me_mf