A couple of weeks after moving into my roommate’s (you remember Gary right?) place, we decided it’d be fun to throw a party. He invited some of his friends and his brother, I invited some of mine. It turned out to be a healthy mix of people. A couple hours in and there’s beer pong in the basement and people are making out on the couch and there’s a fire going on in the backyard. Well as it happened Gary’s brother was just as cute as Gary. A little taller perhaps and less stubble. He and I were talking and at some point we both agreed to be each other’s beer pong partners. When it was our turn to play someone said we should play strip beer pong. One removal of clothing per cup made.
What the hell, I was already home so if I had to get naked at least I didn’t have to go anywhere. We get to playing and it’s clear that Gary’s brother (Eric) was not very good. Oops. That game did seem to take forever for some reason…:P After the game I finally got to put my bra back on Eric and I started making out. Gary never went to the basement that night, so he saw or knew anything about this. Since my room was also in the basement it was easy to sneak Eric in. What was not easy was keeping quiet…. He was rougher than his brother and he was also a fantastic kisser. That made it pretty difficult to keep quiet.
After we fucked we both returned to the party. It didn’t seem like anyone heard us, or at least they didn’t care. So, I went upstairs while Eric stayed down. I ended up outside around the fire. It was a pretty nice night, not too hot or cold. I saddled up next to Gary and we all just bullshitted for a few hours. The party started dying down pretty hard past one am. Gary and I still hung out, obviously, and when everyone else had gone home (yes even Eric left) we moved our conversation to his bedroom. It soon devolved into a make out session and I was getting flashbacks of fucking Eric. Honestly, it turned me on more knowing that I had made out with both of them tonight. Gary was more intentional and softer in his touch than his brother. For science I figured I should have a fresh comparison of everything else since my sample from the move in was now a couple weeks old. So I got down on my knees and sucked him till he was good and ready to fuck me. If I’m being honest, Eric was bigger, Gary was better. Experience does help boys 😉 I also have never told them, so neither of them know they both slept with the same woman. Until now at least.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/wqbexs/fm_fm_getting_fucked_by_my_roommate_and_his