Cumming inside [M]y ex’s sister [F], years later… [PART 4]

Part 3 here: https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/vm89y8/cumming_inside_my_exs_sister_f_years_later_part_3/

We sat and smoked for a few minutes, until our food arrived. Elena ran out to get it in her pajama pants and t-shirt, we ate ravenously (partially because of all the sex we’d had but mostly because of the weed), and then we settled back in on the couch.

I was Chromecasting from my phone, so the image of Elena’s older sister—who I’d hooked up with for a few months about four years earlier—filled her big flat screen TV, her lips closed around the tip of my cock.

“Ready?” I asked, so turned on to be watching an old sex tape with my ex’s sister that I was already breathing heavily, my cock swelling in my boxer briefs.

“Fuck yes,” said Elena, her eyes flashing. I could tell that her nipples were hard under her baggy t-shirt.

She slid over next to me on the couch, reaching over to grab my cock through my boxer briefs, and I pressed PLAY.

It took a second to buffer, but then the larger-than-life image of Elena’s older sister started to move. We watched as she bobbed her mouth up and down on my cock, crouching over me as I lay on my old bed, moaning as I filmed her and reached down with the other hand to guide her head.

I looked over at Elena. After a half-second of watching her sister suck my cock, at first biting her lip and then widening her eyes and opening her mouth, she turned and saw me staring at her. Smirking back at me, she reached over and pulled as I lifted my hips to take off my boxer briefs. Tossing them to one side, she crouched over me and looked up at the screen, positioning herself just like her sister, and then brought her warm mouth down around the tip of my cock.

She looked up at me as she took me deeper into her mouth, and then glanced sideways at the screen, trying to match her sister’s movements. My eyes darted between them—at Cat’s face gazing up at me on the massive TV screen as her mouth bobbed up and down on my cock, pausing every few strokes to take me as deep as she could—and then down from the TV screen at the face of Elena, her younger sister, as she gazed up at me and tried to take my cock even deeper.

“Holy shit,” I gasped. “That feels so fucking amazing. You are so fucking good at that.”

Between the two sisters, there was no contest. Cat had been enthusiastic about giving head, but she’d been tentative and a little squeamish about taking me deep into her throat. Elena, on the other hand, seemed almost able to unhinge her jaw, because she could take me as deep as Cat and then push further. I could feel my tip swelling in her throat, her teeth against my pubes and her hot breath against me, as my entire length pulsated in her mouth and throat.

Then, on the video, Cat sat up for a second and brought her mouth up to kiss me—and we flipped around and she laid on her back while I brought the camera down to her pussy.

Without missing a beat, Elena followed suit, pulling her pajama pants down and off. On instinct my hand went between her legs, making her gasp and prompting her to spread them for me as we both watched her older sister spread her pussy lips open for my camera phone.

Elena looked down at herself. I licked one finger and began to slide it up and down her silky lips, exactly as I was doing to Cat in the video.

“Oh, f-fuck,” Elena was moaning, her eyes glued to her own pussy lips one second and her sister’s the next. On the screen, I was working one and then two fingers inside of Cat while she gasped. So, naturally, I started to do exactly the same to her younger sister, fingering Elena as she pulled her lips back, both of us high as balls and tingling with eroticism.

The weed made every nerve ending super sensitive in a way that felt deeply sensual. I savored every detail of her pussy as I felt each fold and crevice with my fingers, peering inside of Elena as I sank my middle finger in up to the knuckle. First I felt for her cervix, feeling my semen and her juices pooling there from our last fuck. Then I pressed my finger against the roof of her pussy and pressed slightly, causing Elena to gasp in pleasure.

I worked another finger inside of her, stretching her out a bit and listening to her moans mingling with her sister’s on video. Her eyes were glued to the screen now, watching me work Cat’s pussy the same way I was touching hers.

“F-fuck I love w-watching you touch her, while you t-touch m-me,” Elena moaned. Onscreen, I saw myself lean down and begin to lick Cat’s clit.

So I did the same to Elena, withdrawing my fingers and licking from the bottom of her slit all the way up to her clit—but agonizingly slowly. All while lightly tracing the fingers I’d drawn out of her pussy down until they pressed, slightly wet with pussy juice, against her puckered asshole.

“You taste just like her,” I said between licks, holding eye contact with Elena. She stared back at me and just moaned raggedly, her mouth agape, overcome with horniness.

I pressed my wet fingers against her asshole very slightly, making her gasp, and timed it so that my tongue contacted her clit a second later. When I flicked my tongue against her clit again, and then again, she came almost instantly—shuddering and pulling my head up against her and crying out as she watched the footage of me eating her sister’s pussy.

I pulled away after a second, as she came down from her orgasm. She was breathing heavily and her nipples were hard.

“Holy fuck,” she said. “I came so hard.”

“I noticed,” I laughed. Elena had been much quicker than her sister—on the video, I was still working Cat toward orgasm.

“Watching this shit, while doing it with you,” she said. “It’s… probably the hottest thing I’ve ever done in my life.”

“Same here,” I said, feeling insanely turned on.

Cat started to moan louder, so we both paused for a second to watch her cum against my tongue.

“Holy fuck,” Elena moaned. I looked down to see that she was playing with herself lightly as we watched.

I started to stroke my cock in anticipation of what I knew was up next.

On video, as Cat came down from her orgasm, I crawled up to kiss her and slowly worked my cock into her pussy. So I crawled over Elena, kissed her deeply, and felt my throbbing cock brush against her pubes as we made out, lost in one another for a moment.

It took a couple of tries, since I was trying to do this hands-free, but eventually I felt my cock align with her slick lips, felt how hot and wet and inviting her opening was, and slowly sank myself inside her. She moaned and reached down to spread her lips for me, opening herself up so it was easier to work my cock all the way in.

I turned my head and watched onscreen as my shaft began to thrust in and out of Cat’s raw pussy. Elena was watching, too—we could both see her lips gripping me as I withdrew and then plunged back in.

But I was barely moving inside of Elena, just savoring the feeling of her tight, hot, wet opening stretching to accept my entire length. After a second, she realized what I was doing and started to buck her hips against me, desperate for me to start thrusting in and out the way I was fucking her sister—but in response I just pressed my hips down and forward, holding myself agonizingly still inside of her, feeling my cock pulsate against her walls, feeling every detail.

“Oh my god, f-fuck me,” Elena was moaning, working herself almost to a fever pitch, watching as I fucked her sister with abandon. “P-please fuck me, give it to me—”

Without warning, I stopped teasing her and started to fuck her back, HARD—in time with her rolling hips—and she nearly screamed in ecstasy, one hand rubbing her clit and the other grasping at my cock as I plunged in and out of her, feeling it driving deep between her lips, occasionally reaching down to tug lightly on my balls but mainly just feeling us fucking, touching my cock right where it was going inside of her, in a way that drove me wild.

On the video, I saw that Cat and I had slightly changed positions—I’d pulled her hips up. So I paused my rhythm for a second to do the same with Elena. She saw what I was doing and handed me the pillow from behind her head. I put it under her hips, raising them toward me and thus changing the angle I’d be thrusting into her. Then I lined myself up and started fucking her again, both of us watching me fuck her sister as I started to go inside her.

You could see how slick with juices my cock was as it disappeared into Cat again and again while she rubbed her clit with one hand. Then, on the tape, she took her other hand and started to press it into her lower stomach, looking down at it. On video, I started to do the same with my free hand, pressing on the other side of Cat’s lower stomach and causing us both to moan deeply.

“W-what is she doing?” Elena asked, unsure at first what was happening on the video. I grinned at her.

“I’ll show you,” I said.

I was railing into Elena again and again, looking down at the spot where my cock penetrated her swollen pussy. Her hips were elevated, just like Cat’s in the video, so that her hipbones and flat stomach were below where I was thrusting inside.

Taking one hand, I pressed lightly on Elena’s lower stomach, just as I was doing to her sister on the tape. When I did so, she moaned—it seemed to pull a bit on the skin near her clit, enhancing the sensation. But for me, it had another benefit: pressing down on her pussy from above applied pressure to my cock deep inside her. And with this angle, it also meant I could faintly see her lower belly ripple whenever I thrust all the way inside, the tip of my cock visibly poking through, just below her belly button.

Elena brought her hand up, too, imitating what Cat was doing, and pressed next to my hand. She gasped as she felt my cock moving inside her—and then looked down and saw it ripple in her stomach.

“Oh my fucking god,” Elena moaned. “I can feel you in my guts.”

I thrust harder and deeper, causing her to cry out and driving her to push with her hand even harder. I felt the pressure from inside her, felt her hand squeezing against my cock, saw it moving. Watched her sister writhing on my cock the same way on the TV screen.

Elena’s moans mingled with her sister’s again as we heard Cat start to cum and both looked back at the video, watching her body tense and release as she rubbed her clit while I fucked her.

“I’m—I’m cumming,” Cat moaned, her body convulsing around my cock.

It turned me on insanely to be watching Cat have an orgasm while balls deep in her younger sister. It seemed to drive Elena wild, too—and combined with her own clit rubbing while I fucked her, it pushed her over the edge for the second time.

“I’m c-cumming,” she moaned, just a second or two after her sister. I drove my cock harder and deeper, feeling her cervix flutter against my tip as her pussy began to spasm around me, gripping my cock harder than ever.

I felt myself begin to swell, my balls tightening. It wouldn’t be long now.

On the video, we watched as I suddenly pulled out of Cat and she sat up, grasping my balls with one hand and bringing her tongue to the underside of my cock as I started to cum. The first gob streaked across her forehead and into her hair, so I moved my cock down a little and shot the next rope into her eye (which was shut tight) before dipping the tip of my cock into her mouth. You could see it twitch a couple of times, pumping the last of my semen onto her tongue.

I was so horny, and so caught up in the sights and sounds and sensations of fucking one sister while watching my old sex tape with another, that watching myself cum on Cat’s face triggered my orgasm while I was fucking Elena.

Almost without warning, I felt it wash over me. I groaned, and my whole body twitched, as the first spurt of semen, deep inside of Elena, took us both by surprise. On instinct, I pulled out quickly and she sat up—just in time to take the next spurt on her cheek and across her nose, another warm gob landing on her chin before she took me in her mouth, sucking the last of it out of me and feeling my cock spasm against her back teeth, draining the last of my sperm into her throat. I felt her throat muscles contract around my cock as she swallowed. Then I slowly drew my cock out.

On Elena’s TV, the video had stopped on the last frame—a still image of Cat’s cum-covered face as she smiled, one eye open and looking at the camera, one hand coming up to wipe the semen out of her other eye so she could open it, too.

I looked down at Elena, her gorgeous face bearing a close resemblance to her sister’s, now similarly streaked with my cum. She looked at the TV and then smiled at me, and I fumbled under my discarded boxer briefs, feeling for my phone.

“That was the hottest thing ever,” Elena said.

Having found my phone, I opened the camera and snapped a photo of Elena smiling at me as my cum dripped down her face, making sure to frame the photo so that her sister’s cum-covered face on the TV screen was clearly visible, as well. Then I varied the angle and snapped another few photos, making sure to capture my cum dribbling out of her pussy, too.

She giggled after smiling for the photos and I texted them to her.

“I mean, holy shit,” I said as we both started to get dressed again.

“Yeah,” Elena said, wiping my cum off of her face with the t-shirt she’d been wearing and then pulling up her pajama pants. She went into her room, tossing the t-shirt in her dirty clothes hamper and grabbing a fresh one.

“So, uh,” she said as she came back into the room. “Any chance you can send me that video?” She inclined her head toward the TV—the one of Cat and me I’d been Chromecasting.

I looked at her and narrowed my eyes.

“I mean, I dunno,” I said.

“Oh come on, please?” she said. “Obviously I’ll send you one of me in return.”

“Deal,” I said quickly. We both looked at each other, still roiling with animalistic desire, knowing we’d each be getting off later watching videos of the other.

She poured us each a glass of water and we sat in her kitchen, chatting comfortably for a few minutes. Eventually, as she’d told me to plan on doing earlier, I got up to leave.

“This was… uh, insane,” I said to her as I tied my shoes.

“Fucking insane,” she said. I stood up again and she kissed me, lightly touching my cock through my pants leg, stroking it up and down a handful of times. “We should do this again. Soon.”

“I’m in,” I said, reaching unashamedly into the waist of her pajama pants and feeling her bare pussy, dripping with her juices and with my semen. She gasped, her hand still on my cock, and we just stood and caressed one another for a second—before she pulled away, a mischievous look in her eye.

“Drive safely,” she said.

I took a second to catch my breath, smiling at her.

“See you later,” I said. “Send me that video if you want, and I’ll send you ours in exchange.”

She smiled at me.

“Oh, don’t worry,” she said. “You’ll have it by the time you get home.”

Not quite 10 minutes later, as I was driving home in the dark and just reveling in what had just happened, I felt my phone vibrate. Elena’s name popped up on the Bluetooth screen—a test notification.

My cock swelled, feeling more than a little sore. Still, I couldn’t wait to see what she’d sent me when I got home.

*Love any and all comments! To be continued…*

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/vpa3w0/cumming_inside_my_exs_sister_f_years_later_part_4