A Lost Connection, Part 2, Final [M/F, Romance]

[Part 1](https://www.reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/uvsh4x/a_lost_connection_part_1/)

Henry seemed like he was doing great in life. He had just finished college himself and from the pictures he had posted it looked like he landed a job as a teacher. She studied the picture a little longer and realized in the background it was their old high school! She scrolled a little farther down and saw a post he had made that explained that he was moving back to town after being away at college in a different state and was going to be teaching at Killion High. She opened up her messaging app and started to type.

**Henry! I just saw your friend request, oh my god I can’t believe I forgot to add you again after I started college. How is life?? I saw your post that you are moving back here. We should get lunch and catch up!**

A few minutes passed and there was a reply.

**Jenna it’s so nice to hear from you! Yes, let’s get together for lunch, ive missed you so much! Are you free tomorrow? I don’t start my teaching job for another week so I have some free time to reorient myself to Killion. I can’t believe it’s been four years. Is The Coffee Club still open?**

She replied.

**Yes it is still open and still has the best coffee in town! How about tomorrow at noon?**

**That sounds great! I’ll see you then!**

She felt an overwhelming sense of joy flood her. She hadn’t seen Henry for four years now. They used to be such good friends in high school getting into so much trouble together. She couldn’t believe that he was going to be teaching there now! She laid back down and smiled as she reminisced.

She remembered one time they were in math class together and the teacher had already had so many problems he had split both of them up to either side of the classroom. That didn’t stop them though, they were so stupid. Henry would make an obnoxious bird sound, the teacher would spin around and yell at the class, then she would return the call with a forced elephant sound. There was also that one time after the football game. Henry and herself had left early and were going to go teepee Olivia’s house. Olivia had egged Henry’s car at the last game and they had to get her back.

Jenna paused for a second. She remembered going to teepee Olivia’s house, but she hadn’t thought about that for forever. There was more to it. She remembered afterwards in Henry’s car they had parked in the 24-hour diner’s parking lot laughing while music played. Both of them shared a silence when their favorite song came on and Henry leaned in for a kiss. They made out in the car for a few minutes, then she pulled back. She remembered Henry saying it was a mistake, they played it off, then it never happened again.

The next day Jenna got up early to get ready for her lunch with Henry. She went through around four outfits before deciding on a dark green crop top, her ripped black skinny jeans, and she teased her a little bit. Henry had texted her again that morning asking if they were on and she said of course. Sam had also texted her that morning to let her know that he loved her, to tell her that he had to head out to his parent’s house who lived about an hour away, and again asked her if she had thought over the proposal to move with him. She responded saying that she loved him, told him about her old friend who had moved back into town, and said that she was still thinking it over but to tell his parents that she said hi.

After spraying her peach perfume and putting on her shoes she headed out to The Coffee Club. She parked her car and could see Henry inside already at the counter ordering something. She stared at him for a few minutes from the parking lot. She could tell that he had lost some weight. Either that or he was working out and gained some muscle. He still looked like Henry to her though and she smiled. He turned around for a glance from the counter and saw her in her car outside. He gave a small wave and a smile in return.

When she walked inside she immediately went in for a hug. It had felt like so long. She could smell his cologne on him, it was almost the exact same scent that Sam wears. She felt his arms wrap around her and she knew for sure now that he had been working out. She could feel his muscles press against her.

“I can’t believe you came back,” she said to him.

“I can’t believe you never added me to your new profile after high school, but here we are,” he joked.

“It was an accident, I just completely forgot and I really only have business acquaintances and some people from college on there. I just wanted to make a new profile to-”

He cut her off. “I’m just kidding with you Jenna, it’s great to see you. Here, I got you a matcha espresso fusion. Is that still your favorite?”

“Oh my god,” she thought to herself, “he still remembers my favorite drink.”

“Yes,” she said out loud, “that’s still the one and always will be.”

They laughed together. Both of them went to a table and sat down and started talking. They covered all four years both of them had been apart and described their college experiences, jobs they have gone through, and talked about both of their lives.

“So, are you seeing anyone,” he asked her.

She hesitated. Hearing him ask that brought her back into the thought of her upcoming decision. She didn’t let it show on her face, but hearing that wrecked how happy she was to see her old friend. It wasn’t his fault at all, he didn’t know, but she felt that sinking feeling in her chest.

“Yeah, yeah I have been seeing someone. We’ve been together for about a year now,” she told him.

“Wow, that’s awesome. That’s really great to hear, I am really happy that you found someone Jenna.”

“Yeah. Kyra, Olivia, and Blake didn’t think it would happen so they made it happen for me,” they both laughed again but Jenna’s felt forced. “Are you seeing anyone? Did you bring anyone back from Tennessee?”

“Nope, I sure didn’t. Not too much luck out there I guess,” he replied.

“So where are you staying now that you’re back in town?” she asked him.

“I got an apartment off of Cedar Street and it is way more nice than I pictured it before I got here,” he let out a small chuckle. “Wanna check it out?”

“Of course, let’s go!” she said with another smile.

They both headed out from The Coffee Club and met at the apartment on Cedar. He led her up the stairs and through the door. It really was nice she thought to herself. He already had quite a bit in there and it was even decorated a little for him only being here for about a week. They walked in and he offered her a glass of water while she sat down on the couch. They carried on the conversations from The Coffee Club laughing, smiling, reminiscing.

“Oh my god, do you remember that time I tried to kiss you outside of Howie’s Diner? Jesus Christ what was I thinking,” he put his head in his hands laughing.

She remembered it alright. She remembered how she wanted him to keep going too but respected when he pulled back. They were just kids and she was too nervous to say anything. He was her first kiss and she didn’t know what to do. She thought to herself while he laughed. He was her first kiss and her first love.

“If only I would have had the confidence to keep going,” he joked aloud.

She moved over to him and put her lips on his. He kissed her back for a second or two before pulling away, again.

“Woah woah woah, Jenna I don’t think-” he was cut off by her.

“I don’t love him. He’s flying to New York at the end of the week and he wants me to come with him but I can’t. I can’t leave. I mean I do love him, but it’s over. He just doesn’t know yet,” she said in almost one breath.

“Jenna, I don’t know if-” she cut him off again.

“It’s okay Henry. Finish what you started,” she smiled.

They leaned back in together pressing their lips to one another. He could feel her tongue moving into his mouth and her hand moving back and forth on his thigh. He reached up and cupped her breasts.

“I’ve wanted this ever since that night Jenna,” he said softly.

“Me too, Henry. You could have fucked me in your car that night, I wanted you to fuck me in your car. I’m all yours now,” she breathed.

He lifted off her shirt and she stood up unbuttoning her pants, sliding them down afterwards. He followed until they found themselves naked on his couch. He pushed his hand down her front and rested it on her pussy spreading her apart and gently touching her clit. She moaned while he moved his fingers down and entered her.

“Henry I want you to fuck me. Please fuck me. Fuck me like you wanted to in your car. You can do anything.”

He moved down grabbing his cock and slowly pushed it into her. She let out a quick breath feeling it fill her, deeper and deeper. He was much bigger than Sam was. He started moving in and out feeling her wet his cock. He reached up behind her head and grabbed a fistfull of hair at the base of her head and pulled her up to meet his face while he continued to fuck her. He pushed his tongue inside of her mouth feeling her moan in his own. He started to pick up the pace bottoming out inside of her.

“Henry, I’m going to cum. You’re going to make me cum. Please make me cum. You can cum inside of me. Fill me up, please fill me up, it’s okay,” she moaned.

He gave three more forceful thrusts and she could feel the warmth of his cum flood her at the end of the third. She let out a loud moan as she came around his cock feeling both of them pulse together.

“Jenna, that was amazing. I wish I had the courage then but this was just as good as I imagined that night,” he spoke softly.

Jenna heard her phone vibrate on the table. She reached over and checked it. A text from Sam. She half read it but didn’t really digest it, then started to type.

**I don’t think I can go Sam. I’m sorry. I hope you accomplish everything you want and find someone nice. I just came to the realization that I think I might be more happy here. Take care Sam xx**

Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/uxxv4f/a_lost_connection_part_2_final_mf_romance