I plan on making this an actual erotica novel one day. So a heads up there. HMU if you wanna help write it:
Ruby[F20] had just broken up with John[M21]. She wanted to forget the rules and have pre marital sex. John was tempted but at the end of the day. Had to refuse. She then said that she didn’t want someone who was going to wait until marriage. And she broke up with him.
John then came home to pack for tomorrow. He was going to college. He’s never been so far from home. He was so upset about Ruby, then he fell over crying. Mary[F21], his adopted sister, came to comfort him.
She then revealed that since they aren’t biological siblings, that she loves him romantically. John was in shock. But then they ended up making out.
John wanted to stop before it became lustful. He didn’t want to make the same mistake as he almost did with Ruby.
Mary then suggested anal. She said it’s not sex and doesn’t count. Since Mary’s biological father was the priest, he took her word for it.
They then lost their anal virginities together before cuddling in bed. Mary revealed that she doesn’t want John to leave and he said he doesn’t either. They then fell asleep together.
When at college, he got a call from the father, telling John how proud he is that his daughters are going to be virgins for life. John was shocked to learn that Mary and all her sisters[F20, F19, F19] were in training to become nuns.
He then became sad because he thought Mary wanted to fall in love and get married one day.
He then started dating Ashley[F21]. Who doesn’t want anal ever. And John is okay with that.
Then when coming back from college for good. Him and Ashley were engaged. But then he realized anal doesn’t count as sex, thus it doesn’t count as cheating either.
I forgot to mention that the father wanted John to watch them while he’s gone on a business trip. He wants John to check their hymens while he’s gone. Since he trusted John so much. He wants to see if they are still virgins while he’s gone.
John was then alone in the house with all four virgins. And a fifth. Madison[F19]. Being in a house with 5 attractive virgins, and knowing anal isn’t cheating. Things got tempting for John.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/uss9v8/21_f4a_anal_sex_harem_w_religion