We weren’t married at the time. I’m 42 now. We were still in college.
Her friends in college (and from high school) were named Casey and Emily. Emily wasn’t anything especially hot (some decently nice tits and just looked like she would fuck you) but Casey was a pure hottie. Cute face, big eyes, huge tits.
So we were all big drinkers and we were really turning it on this night in Dallas. We brought it back to my small apartment and I got the idea to play Truth or Dare.
They said yes but Casey was definitely not really into it. I always said dare. They thought they had their friend’s boyfriend for a crazy time so they went with it. First dare was nakedness so not only did I disrobe I stayed naked. The hottest thing was Casey said “there’s no way you’re THAT big.” I never said I was big! She implied my dick was big.
Casey luckily said Dare so I said TITS instantly. Her tits were big and had those small light nipples only blonde girls had. Even Emily seemed impressed. She put them away quickly though.
Emily gave us a Truth so I asked her if here and Casey ever kissed. She said they had and knew what my next Dare was. She was so casual about it.
Three rounds or so went by and keep in mind I’m still naked. When I had a dare I said fuck it and asked if they would both suck on my cock.
Emily would definitely do it but Casey was really not sure. I walked Emily close to me and I had her stroke me. Casey couldn’t believe what we were doing so she just watched I guess.
Emily straight up started sucking my erect cock and Casey kind of stared in awe. I could see she was shocked so I added audible things to make it more real. I asked her if she could believe her friend had my cock in her mouth. I asked her if she could see Emily’s tongue lick along my vein. I asked about her friend and if she could believe she was seeing my hard cock like this. She sat in disbelief mostly with her mouth open.
So that’s when I reached for her pussy. Emily kind of gasped when I did this. Casey just stood there and let it happen. She was wearing shorts and I ripped them apart. I took her hands and had her stroke my cock. Her mouth was still open as I made her stroke my cock. I put her head on my cock. I told them I couldn’t believe my girlfriend’s friends were sucking on my cock. Then Casey started to moan as she sucked me.
I had a mirror so we went over to that side of the bed. I had Emily on her back and I had Casey doggy. I wanted her to stare at us fuck. My dick looked so big in her tiny pussy. Casey looked straight up scared as I fucked her. I pulled myself out of her and into Emily’s mouth. I asked her if she liked how Casey tasted. I told Emily she was sucking on Casey’s glistening cunt juice. When I got them pretty close in the mirror I pulled in and out of each of their pussies. I guess Emily had an idea I wanted to cum and she told me I could cum in her. I told her no she was a dirty slut and I wanted to get Casey pregnant. Casey said no and shot me on her face. We fucked later again that night. Casey was way more into it later that night.
We’ve never done anything like that since but we mentioned it once or twice since then. I told Emily I loved fucking her when her husband was at the store. Casey was definitely not cool about it after the fact but I told her how beautiful she looked with my cock in her. She said “I know.”
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/u3vlr4/the_threesome_i_had_with_my_wifes_friends_21_m