College friends (FF) drag [M]e off to unexpected threesome – Part 1 [FFM]

*This is the true story of the first hookup between members of a college comedy group: me (Scott), my good friend Erin (the “one who got away” for reasons Part 2 will make clear), and Molly (our slutty, up-for-anything mutual friend). All of this unfolded at a large(ish) public university on the west coast, circa April or May 2007. Everyone involved was 21 years old. Will write Part 2 (and additional stories) if people like it.*

__

“Come home with me.”

My friend Erin just turned to me and blurted this out in front of everyone, while the cast party was winding down.

“What??” I was a little drunk (well, we all were). So it took a moment to register. “You mean, like—”

“Yes. Come home with me.” She took my hand as if to drag me back to her apartment.

I looked up at my friend Jackson, who’d heard the exchange through the din of the party. He raised his eyebrows.

Still, I knew what I had to do.

“I can’t, Erin—you know this would just ruin our friendship.”

She pleaded with me again but I was insistent. Jackson, being the good friend that he was, helped me extricate myself from the situation and get outside to wait for the bus that would take me back to my apartment on the other side of campus.

“Honestly, brother, mad respect,” he said. “I would’ve had a hard time resisting.”

I sighed. It had been sorely tempting; I’d been surprised and flattered by Erin’s sudden desire for me and was turned on just thinking about her. But we’d been good friends for the past couple of years and this was just the right thing to do.

Right? Right.

Jackson’s bus came first. Which wound up changing the course of the night.

“See you, brother.” He waved and climbed aboard and took his seat. I was alone at the bus stop.

Just then, my phone rang.

It was Erin.

Maybe she felt weird about things and was calling to apologize? Or maybe she was going to double down.

Either way, she was my friend and I cared about her. So I picked up the phone.

“Hey, Erin,” I said.

“When I was dating Derek, Molly and I tried to get him to have a threesome with us,” she said, referencing a mutual friend. “But he said no, for whatever reason.”

My heart started to beat a little faster at the thought.

“What!” I exclaimed with a laugh. “What an idiot.”

“I know, right?” she said. There was a long pause.

“So,” she finally said. “Are YOU an idiot?”

“I, uh—”

“Where are you?”

“At—at the bus stop like right outside.”

“Good. Get back here and I’ll call Molly. I want to fuck you both tonight.”

Who was I to argue? What was left of my resistance crumbled. Lust took over.

I practically jogged the couple of blocks to her building and bounded up the stairs, knocking when I reached her unit and paused to catch my breath.

As she opened the door to her apartment, Erin kissed me—hard. I kissed back hungrily, my hands exploring her body. Her ass. Her supple breasts through her sweater.

She pushed me away for just long enough to shut the door and then whip the sweater over her head, revealing a black bra, and then plunged back. I slipped my hand under her bra cup, feeling her nipple harden under my touch. She gasped and I used my other hand to unhook her bra behind her back. It fell away and she chuckled.

“Wow, smooth move,” she said sarcastically.

“Lots of practice,” I said with just as much sarcasm.

She gasped again as I took her pink nipple in my mouth.

There was a loud knock at the door, which startled us both.

Erin went to the peephole, glanced conspiratorially at me once she’d confirmed who it was, and then opened the door without bothering to hide the fact that she was topless.

This was greeted by a loud cackle from Molly, who came in and took off her jacket and started to suck on one of Erin’s nipples even before Erin had closed the door.

Then she turned around and saw me.

“Oh fuck yes,” she said. “I love that we’re doing this.”

“Me, too,” said Erin. “So, what are you two still doing with clothes on?”

They started to come off, in a whirl. First we both pounced on Molly, who giggled as Erin pulled her jacket off while I started to work her shirt over her head. As it came off, I planted a kiss on her lips; she threw her head back and groaned and leaned into it passionately. Erin undid Molly’s bra and I started to fumble with her belt. She stepped back from me just long enough to pull down her jeans and then step out of them.

Meanwhile, Erin (who hadn’t taken her jeans off yet) dropped to her knees and went for my belt buckle. I felt a thrill at what was about to happen and pulled my shirt off just as Molly was standing up, unashamed of her lithe, sexy body and perky A-cups with small nipples. She was wearing a pale blue thong but nothing else and looked at me hungrily, coming in for a passionate kiss as I set my shirt aside. Her smooth skin against mine felt amazing. I felt her erect nipples brush me and one hand cupped her left breast while I reached for her ass with my other hand.

“Fuck yes, Scott,” she said. “Touch me.”

I looked below as Erin pulled my pants to the ground and helped me step out of them without breaking my lip-lock with Molly, relished the sight of her own (somewhat larger) breasts with larger areolas. She set my pants to the side and pressed her lips to where my cock was bulging through my boxer briefs, kissing it and then running both hands over it before expertly pulling down by underwear and letting it free.

“You have the perfect cock,” she said, grabbing and beginning to stroke it. Molly’s hand joined her. I gasped at their touch.

“Holy fuck,” said Molly. “You’re pretty fucking big, dude. How come this is the first I’m hearing of it?”

I laughed and started to reply but my mind went blank the instant Erin took me in her mouth. Molly seemed to lose her train of thought, too.

“Fuck, that’s so hot,” she said, reaching down to lightly trace her fingers across my balls and whispering into my ear, ““She’s sucking your dick.”

Erin was working her tongue across the head of my cock excruciatingly slowly, then opening her mouth and taking as much of me into her throat as she could; I could feel her back teeth against my shaft.

I groaned in pleasure. Erin opened her eyes and looked up at Molly and me and, without taking my cock out of her mouth, motioned for Molly to join her. Molly sank to her knees, first running her tongue along the side of my cock while Erin worked the tip and then nudging her friend out of the way to take me in her mouth.

Then, she pulled her head back, seemed to take a deep breath, and thrust her mouth forward, deep-throating my throbbing cock. I felt its head pulsate, already on the verge of cumming, and saw it bulge in her throat.

Her eyes watered but she held me deep for a long moment.

“Holy fuck,” said Erin, pushing Molly’s head from behind. “She can take the whole thing.”

Molly reared back, gagging slightly, and sat back to stroke me for a moment, pleased with herself.

“You like that?” she asked, her green eyes flashing.

“That was the most insane thing,” I said.

“Challenge accepted,” said Erin without missing a beat. She sank down on the other side of me.

Unsure at first of her intentions, I gasped as Molly began to work me into her throat again, more slowly this time. I could feel her tongue on the underside of my cock and her throat muscles relaxing as she consumed me.

Then, suddenly, I felt Erin’s tongue flick against my asshole and nearly exploded.

“Oh fuck!” I cried out. She licked me again, starting to build a consistent rhythm, and I felt her fingers come up to play lightly with my balls.

“Oh fuck,” I said, “You’re getting me close already.”

Instantly, both of them stopped. I couldn’t tell whether I felt more disappointed or more excited.

“I want to taste you,” Erin said to Molly, who nodded excitedly. “And I want you inside me,” she said to me.

My cock had never been harder. I was grateful for a short break to collect myself.

Without another word, Erin led us into the living room; I realized we hadn’t made it further than just inside the doorway, where our clothes were spread all over the floor. She motioned for Molly to lay down on the coach, then helped her take her thong off.

Her pussy had soaked through the thin fabric and it glistened, her lips so engorged they were slightly parted to reveal the pale pink just inside. I was mesmerized and immediately reached out, dipping the very tip of my middle finger between her glistening lips. Feeling her warmth, her slickness, feeling her pussy spasm when she moaned in pleasure at my touch. It felt like electricity.

Then Erin leaned in and I moved my hand around so she could lick Molly’s clit, and we worked her pussy together for a moment. Until my right hand wandered down to Erin’s jeans and I could stand it no longer.

I pulled myself away, focused animalistically on my friend Erin all of a sudden. I reached underneath her and undid her pants button and zipper, then came around behind her and pulled her jeans and underwear off at once.

As I pulled the legs off over her ankles, I found myself staring directly at her swollen pussy, just inches away. I licked my fingers and then used them to open her up, peering into the pink folds as she groaned into Molly’s pussy.

“Fuck me,” she said.

“Should I get a—” I started to ask.

“I have an IUD,” she said “I want to feel you raw.”

Eagerly I got on my knees behind Erin and began to tease her opening with the head of my dick, lubricating it little by little so I could push deeper inside her. As I worked my way in, I used my fingers to pull her cheeks back. I watched her asshole pucker as I went deeper and deeper, her moans becoming more guttural as she continued to eat Molly’s pussy.

“I can’t believe he’s inside you,” Molly said to Erin, holding her hair as she licked her clit. “It’s so fucking hot to watch you take his dick.”

Just then I bottomed out inside Erin’s pussy, feeling her walls pulsate around me as the very tip of my cock touched her cervix. I pushed very slightly deeper and held myself inside. She was so warm and tight and wet.

She shuddered and lifted her head up to look back at me, Molly’s pussy juices running down her chin.

“That’s all of me,” she moaned. “You’re stretching me out.”

I pushed deeper still, sending her splaying into Molly and spouting gibberish, and then began to pull slowly out—only to slam back into her as deep as I could go. I worked up a rhythm, pounding her.

Erin moaned and writhed under me, her pussy gripping my cock as I fucked her. She was a mess of pleasure. Soon, she forgot all about Molly, who sat up and started to play with her tits while I fucked her. Then Molly got up, letting Erin fully take the bed, and came around and just watched me fuck her friend doggystyle for a second.

I beckoned Molly over, momentarily taking my cock out of Erin and offering it to Molly, who first licked it greedily and then aimed it back at her friend’s wet pussy, putting me back into her and watching fascinated, her face inches away, while I drove deep inside Erin. She reached out and touched us both right at the point where my dick was disappearing into her, working her fingers inside of Erin alongside it.

It felt amazing. Clearly, Molly was a total freak.

We locked eyes and immediately needed to be all over each other.

I pulled out of Erin and kissed Molly, pushing her down on the bed. Erin stood up and helped us arrange ourselves, then grabbed my glistening dick and placed it at Molly’s entrance, right against her parted lips.

Molly looked up at me and we held eye contact as I slid inside her wet pussy in one smooth motion. We both inhaled and I reached out and pinched her nipple. Erin was at first as mesmerized by the sight of my cock sliding in and out of her friend’s pussy as Molly had been. But then she got on her knees and joined me in playing with Molly’s tits, leaning down to kiss her.

This left Erin’s pussy right in front of me as I was fucking Molly, so I worked a finger into her silky hole, reveling at the feeling of being inside two of my friends at once.

“Oh my god, I can feel him,” I heard Erin exclaim. Looking down, I saw she had her hand on Molly’s lower belly; when she pushed down, she could feel—and all three of us could see—my cock bulge through Molly’s stomach. Seeing this seemed to drive all three of us wild.

“Fuck me, pound me,” Molly said. “Fucking rearrange my guts.”

I went at her like an animal, driving myself into her deep and fast and over and over again. Erin started to rub Molly’s clit at the same time. I could feel her fingers brush my cock once in awhile.

“Oh fuck, oh fuck—I’m going to cum so hard” cried Molly, and an instant later her entire body tensed up. Her nipples were hard and I could feel her pussy spasming around me as she came. I did everything I could to hold my own orgasm back.

I slowed my pace and all three of us took a beat to relax as Molly came down from her orgasm. I slowly pulled out of her and looked up at Erin. She was offering herself to me with her eyes. Something about the moment we shared made me want one thing more than any other: to cum inside her.

I grabbed Erin playfully and laid her on the bed, putting her knees behind my elbows. I felt Molly’s mouth on the end of my dick and then saw as she gave Erin’s pussy a playful lick and then leaned back. I felt her fingers on my cock, positioning me at Erin’s opening, and I held myself there for a long moment, my head just barely parting her lips, teasing her.

“Yes,, yes, oh yes,” she whispered over and over again with increasing desperation, her voice quavering. “Yes. Oh—oh yes, please. Please. Fuck me. Oh please, I want to feel you deep—”

I suddenly plunged my cock into Erin as deep as I could go. She screamed in pleasure and I felt her fingernails on my ass as she pulled me into her.

Somehow Molly’s head was right there, her tongue dancing across Erin’s clit and my cock at once as I pounded in and out of her. I also felt Molly’s hands playing with both of us: pulling back Erin’s lips, tugging lightly on my balls, occasionally getting a finger into Erin while I fucked her. I knew I wouldn’t last much longer.

“Oh fuck, you’re going to make me cum,” Erin said. “Don’t stop.”

Molly began to lick us both feverishly, driving her closer to the edge—and me with her.

“I’m getting close, too,” I gasped.

“Don’t stop!” Erin said.

I felt Molly work a finger inside Erin, alongside my cock. “I want to feel you fill her up.”

“Fill me up with your cum,” said Erin “Cum inside me. I want to feel you drip out of me.”

At that instant, Molly slipped one of her other fingers into my asshole and I came hard, unloading rope after rope deep inside, right up against Erin’s cervix, feeling her pussy spasm and hearing her moan as she came at the same time. In addition to the finger she now gingerly withdrew from my asshole, Molly had two fingers on her other hand inside of Erin, along the underside of my cock. I felt them move as she seemed to milk any remaining cum out of my urethra and into her friend’s quivering womb.

I savored the feeling of Erin’s pussy for a moment, feeling my cum fill her to the brim. She moaned as I slowly withdrew, pulling my dick out of her and feeling her slick tightness grip me. When I finally pulled the head of my cock out from between her lips, a gob of my thick semen dripped down from her swollen opening—and Molly caught it on her tongue just as it dripped past Erin’s asshole, causing a shriek of surprise followed by a gasp of pleasure as Molly licked back up to Erin’s pussy and began to eat my sperm out of her.

“This was the most incredible night of my life,” I said, reaching for a Kleenex to wipe my dick as I watched Molly lick my cum out of Erin.

She stopped, and they both looked at me.

“Was?” said Molly. “Like this is over? Like we’re finished?”

“Babe, we’re just getting started,” said Erin.

“Enjoy the view for a minute but then get back in here,” said Molly, turning back to Erin’s pussy to bury her face again. “I want you to cum in me next time.”

My cock twitched. The night was young.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/tz6pod/college_friends_ff_drag_me_off_to_unexpected