Got a few messages about it after my last post so I thought I might as well share some stories from my quasi-groupie days for anyone that might be interested. I won’t name any names of course, but most of these guys would only be known to music nerds or fans of very specific genres anyway. I’m a petite, long-haired brunette. I was 21 at the time this took place.
Years ago a friend, Kay, and I went to a concert. She had a lot of connections and knew someone that got us into the band’s afterparty in a huge luxury hotel suite. We drank and mingled a bit before being approached by the band’s singer, ‘Noah’. We practically worshipped Noah, but he was married. I never slept with a man if I knew he was married or attached, and he was known to not cheat anyway. He was a flirt though, sitting in Kay’s lap and telling us we were beautiful.
Kay was a bit more scandalous than me and invited Noah to come to the suite’s bedroom with the two of us (we had ffm’d for someone before). Noah politely declined, but said his bandmates were available and that we could probably have our pick of them. Kay lost interest but I was up for some fun. Trouble was, I couldn’t decide between two of the band members I was attracted to. Jay, a very tall, bearded man, or Johnny, a cute Swiss guy with an appealing accent.
My eyes found Jay first and I asked Noah if he would introduce me. He took me by the hand and led me over to him. With very little introductory chat, Jay led me to the bedroom as party guests watched us with knowing smirks.
Jay was a huge man, 6’ 7” and broad. He was mid-forties and looked very elegant with his grey suit open at the collar. He was very cordial, but he had an intensity about him that made me both excited and nervous. I started heading for the bed but he stepped to me and lifted me with one arm under my ass so I was pressed against him. He walked backward to an armchair and lowered us both down so I was straddling his lap.
We sat like this for a while, chatting and both sipping on his whiskey and ice. I was excited by the close proximity of his groin to mine, and I began slowly grinding against him. He ran his hands up my thighs and pushed my dress up my hips until he could see my red, lacy panties rubbing against him. He gripped my hips and ass with huge hands before pulling the dress off over my head. I took my bra off and he cupped my breasts and licked and sucked my nipples.
Soon I could feel his hard-on pressing against my pussy and I was ready for him, so I started to undo his belt. I carefully unzipped his fly and pulled his pants and boxers down to reveal his already throbbing cock. I took a moment to admire it, running my hands over the length of it and rubbing his leaking pre-cum around the head of his cock, licking a little off my fingers. I pushed my panties aside, put the head of his cock at my entrance, and slowly lowered myself down on him, talking a little more of his length each time I rocked my hips downward.
Once I was used to his size I started riding him in a steady rhythm. His hands found my hair and pulled it so that I arched my back, pushing my tits up to his face so he could lick, suck, and bite as he liked. Between the nipple play and my clit rubbing against his body, I could soon feel an orgasm building. He noticed my quickening breath and asked me if I was going to cum for him. I nodded and quickly put one of his big hands over my mouth to try and stifle my moaning as I came hard, my pussy squeezing on his cock.
When I was finished he lifted me off of him, turned me around, and pushed his cock into me again. He held my hips, my hands on his knees, and thrust up into me hard and fast. I was overwhelmed by the intensity of it for a minute, then began to throw my pussy back in time with his thrusts until he came inside me.
I stumbled to the bathroom and cleaned myself up, but I ditched my soaking wet panties, putting my dress back on with nothing underneath. I rejoined the party flushed and self-conscious but still in the post-fuck glow. What I had been up to was obvious to everyone around me. I went back to drinking and mingling, but I couldn’t keep my mind or eyes off the Swiss man. I still really wanted him, but I wasn’t sure about approaching him, having no idea how he would respond to the prospect of fucking me after his band mate had.
After a half hour or so we ended up in conversation. He complimented my dress and I told him I wasn’t wearing anything underneath it. He got a little flustered and said that Jay was a lucky guy and it sounded like I was having fun earlier. I told him I was hoping to have more fun and I had another lucky guy in mind, smiling at him. He blushed but looked uncertain, so I told him he knew where to find me if he wanted me and left him to consider it.
Over the course of the next hour or so as the party was starting to wind down, I kept looking up to find Johnny watching me or checking out my body from across the room. Finally he polished off his drink and with a determined expression came over and, while I was mid-conversation with Noah, put his arm around my waist and steered me toward the bedroom.
I was thrilled he’d given in and I was feeling much more relaxed and bold this time around. I pulled my dress off immediately and lay naked on the bed. He undressed completely while I lay watching him. He was mid-forties, blonde, trim and had a virtually hairless body and an uncut cock.
He began to stroke his cock while standing in front of me. I loved watching but asked what he would like me to do to assist him. He told me to get myself ready for him. I laid back and spread my legs for him, giving him a full view of my recently fucked pussy as I played with my nipples. I reached one hand down to rub my clit and finger myself while he watched.
He climbed on top of me and kissed me deeply while teasing my entrance with his hard cock, then pushed into me. I was a little sore already and my pussy was still sensitive from my orgasm, making his cock in me feel very intense. He fucked me hard at a steady pace and I welcomed being able to lie back and let him do the work and admire him. It was so hot how he was moaning “oh mein gott” over and over in my ear. He threw my legs up on his shoulders to fuck me more deeply.
After a good pounding he pulled out, moved up my body and pushed his cock between my tits. I obligingly pushed them together so he could fuck them. As he slid his cock back forth I leaned my head forward to lick and suck the head of it to provide some extra lubrication. When he was close he jerked himself off, covering my tits and open, waiting mouth with cum.
I went to get up but he told me he would get me something to clean up with. He came back from the bathroom with my own discarded panties from earlier. He did his best to mop up the cum from my tits and face with the damp, scanty fabric and then put them in his pocket. I didn’t get those back.
We lay back for a bit, exhausted and relaxed. Someone knocked on the door and to my surprise, Johnny said to come in. I scrambled for my dress, both of us still totally naked. But it was just Kay letting me know she was very much ready to go. I dressed quickly while we said our goodbyes and Kay checked out naked Johnny, remarking that maybe she should have joined us after all.
I made sure to thank Noah for a lovely evening and Kay and I left hand in hand, me filling her in on the details of my encounters. I was pretty sore the next day but it made me smile thinking about the reason why.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/teqa3r/i_couldnt_decide_between_two_men_so_i_fucked_them
Good on Noah singing praises for his band mates.
Love this very hot to read damn