My Best Friend’s Sister (Part 5) – Super Bowl Sunday [MF]

It’s the third quarter of the Super Bowl. During the halftime show, I had let my eyes wander over to where Stephanie was sitting with her roommate Brooke. It was a hot day, so they wore shorts and tank tops, unencumbered by bras. Both were wearing black converse sneakers.
They looked tasty, and I was hungry.
I had been hooking up with Stephanie for the past few months. She was my best friend’s sister, so we had been keeping it under wraps. We had had a threesome a few weeks ago with her brother’s ex-girlfriend, but we hadn’t seen her since.
Stephanie had told Brooke about our secret and wild relationship, and I had asked Steph if Brooke would want to join us sometime.
Brooke was similar to Stephanie in both height and build. Both petite, around 5”6, thin but toned frames as they both were vibrant and fit. Brooke had black straight hair that went just past her tanned shoulders. Stephanie was Italian, and Brooke’s family was originally from France.
Brooke and Stephanie had met in college and became best friends. They had some experiences together in the past, a few make-out sessions, a drunken hookup, been around each other naked thousands of times, but they had only been friends, and both had always dated guys.
Brooke lived with her college boyfriend until the end of last year, and the girls had recently moved into an apartment together. Brooke had only dated the one guy and hadn’t had much success with the guys she was meeting.
Stephanie had me over frequently, and Brooke had heard our “good times” and confided to Stephanie that she was lonely and asked Stephanie what it was like to get wild with me. Stephanie had explained some juicy details and antics that we had shared before mentioning that I had shown interest in Brooke joining us. A few days later, Brooke asked if we wanted a threesome.
We had decided that the next time we were together, we would let it happen naturally if the mood felt right.
And Super Bowl Sunday was the day.
Thoughts of skin on skin and tangled limbs danced across my brain as I let my eyes have a feast of Stephanie’s tanned, toned body. My eyes bounced over to Brooke’s thin but firm thighs, imagining them around me. I let my eyes make my way up to her chest. Her nipples were poking out of her tank top. I looked up to her face, and she was looking right at me.
She was giving me a “Are you enjoying the view?” look that
made my heart beat fast, but I played it as cool as I could, giving her a “Yes, I am.” look back, letting my eyes check out her rock-hard body from tip to toe, before locking eyes with her again and raising my eyebrows, letting her I liked what I saw. She smiled and bit her lip before looking back to the TV.
The game was back on. Brooke stood up to get a drink from the drink cooler. The cooler that I was standing behind.
She slowly floated toward me like a siren. Her feminine power made her glow as the sunlight hit her. It was 95 degrees outside, so it could have been that too.
She stepped up to the cooler, bent forward as she reached down, opened the lid, and grabbed a beer. A drip of sweat rolled down her neck and in between her cleavage. My eyes followed as I saw her loose tank top fall forward to reveal she wasn’t wearing a bra. I watched in delight as I got a glimpse of her small dark nipples peeking out of the shadows.
I looked up, and she was looking at me, looking at her. This time, her face
wasn’t saying, “Enjoying the view?” it was – “Stop looking and do something about it” as she looked down at her semi-exposed breasts,
staying bent forward to give me a few more moments to gaze.
My focus shifted as I saw Stephanie watching the interaction. I smiled as we locked eyes, knowing it was her idea not to wear bras. Stephanie’s side boob was tantalizing. She smiled back, pulling her tank subtly to the side to show me her soft, pink left nipple, and gave me a nod to tell me both girls wanted this.
Brooke sat back down next to Stephanie and whispered something in her ear. Stephanie raised her eyebrows, tantalized by whatever Brooke was saying. Both girls kept whispering as they looked over at me. Brooke’s eyes went wide as Stephanie whispered to her. Brooke’s eyes went down to my crotch. A look of intrigue and desire washed across her face.
I smiled wickedly at her. Fucking her with my eyes. Telepathically telling her all the things I wanted to do to her. I felt my dick getting hard in my pants and showed them the outline of my cock.
I sat and pretended to watch the game, letting the anticipation rise. We
continued to give each other glances and teasing looks until I couldn’t handle it anymore.
As the third quarter ended, I casually stood up, walked across the living room, and leaned forward so I could whisper in both their ears.
“Come with me,” I instructed before standing up and walking down the hall to the spare bedroom of our friend’s house. I drew the curtains and turned on some mood-setting music.
Less than 30 seconds later, I was joined by Stephanie and Brooke. Making sure no one noticed, Stephanie shut the door behind her and locked it.
I sat on the bed as I knew what was about to happen.
I watched her pull her white tank top over her head, exposing her C cup breasts that swung freely in the sunlight streaming through the semi-closed blinds—like spears of light, piercing her toned abdomen.
Without a word, she continued to undress and peeled her daisy dukes and red thong off her legs. She was now standing completely naked in front of Brooke and me, with only her Converse sneakers still on. She had no shame. Her sexuality gave her confidence. She was proud of her body and excited to be in this situation.
I looked to Brooke, who was still standing by the door, a little surprised by her friend’s lack of inhibition and her vibrant energy. But she was enjoying what she was witnessing. She looked to Brooke, giving her a reassuring smile before she turned towards me, got on her knees, undid my pants, pulled out my hard dick, and started sucking.
Stephanie pulled my dick out of her mouth and looked at Brooke.
“Join us whenever you want. Or just watch!” She said warmly like she was inviting her to stay for dinner.
Brooke nodded shyly as she watched her friend devour my cock.
“Do you want to take your top off?” I asked like I was offering her a drink.
She nodded again, taking a step towards the bed. She slowly pulled her tank top over her head, exposing her hard, dark nipples on her cute B Cups. She pressed her chest out, enjoying me watching her.
She started undoing her shorts as her confidence grew. She was getting into the moment and letting her insecurities go. She let her shorts drop to reveal her black panties. She did a slow spin, letting me take in every inch of her.
She stuck her thumbs into her panty line and peeled them down her thighs, revealing a trimmed bush and a small cherry tattoo on her right ass cheek, complimenting her beautiful stretch marks.
Stephanie turned her head and smiled as she watched her best friend approaching us in all of her naked, confident glory.
Stephanie started rubbing her clit as she jerked me off, still watching Brooke. As Brooke got to the bed, Stephanie stood up and wrapped her arms around Brooke’s neck.
The two embraced and shared a sweet kiss and started swaying to the music, giggling in between kisses.
Stephanie leaned into Brooke’s ear.
“We’re going to fuck him now.”
Brooke giggled and nodded. Stephanie’s smile disappeared, a look of sexual passion taking its place.
She turned and stood in front of me with her legs open. I started playing with her. She moaned softly.
She turned herself around, so her ass was in my face, lifted her left leg, and lowered herself onto my dick. She was warm, tight, and insanely wet.
She started riding on me slowly as she beckoned Brooke to come closer. Stephanie held her hand out, and Brooke took it with a smile as she watched her roommate grinding me.
Stephanie let her hand fall to Brooke’s waist and pulled her in close. They began kissing as Stephanie continued to ride me.
Stephanie is the most adventurous girl I have ever met; nothing turns her on more than doing stuff out of the ordinary. This was our first threesome in a few weeks.
She was getting excited.
She started bouncing, getting faster and grinding harder as she continued to make out with Brooke, their hands rubbing all over each other’s bodies.
Stephanie was getting close. She stopped kissing Brooke, leaned forward, rested her hands on my knees to give her a better angle, and started to cum as she grinded hard on my dick.
Brooke watched in glee as she started to massage her tits, loving to see her friend in ecstasy and excited for her turn.
She bent over to untie her shoes.
“Leave them on,” I said as I pulled Stephanie’s hair like she liked when she was cumming. I kept my eyes on Brooke as her roommate came on my dick. Brooke’s eyes flashed with desire.
Stephanie let out a soft sigh of contentment before she threw her head back and took a deep breath, and laughed.
I lifted Stephanie off me. Stephanie was mine and always followed my lead. I grabbed her thin hips and moved her, so both women stood in front of me as I sat on the bed.
I had two gorgeous, naked women standing in front of me, ready for more.
“You wanna go down on him?” Stephanie asked Brooke.
“Okay,” replied Brooke sweetly.
Brooke grabbed my hard cock. She lowered her head down and put it in her mouth.
I didn’t feel anything.
“No, babe, you have to actually suck, not just put your mouth on it.” Explained Stephanie as she leaned forward and grabbed my dick.
“Like this,” she said as she began expertly sucking my cock, giving her roommate some help. Brooke had another go. She began sucking.
“Good!” exclaimed Stephanie. “Now play with his balls but remember to keep sucking.”
Brooke did as she was told, and it started feeling good. I couldn’t wait any longer. I needed to fuck her. Now.
I stood up, twisted around, and threw both girls forward on the bed. Stephanie laughed as she got into position, sticking her ass high in the air. Brooke followed her friend’s lead and got into position next to her.
I started fingering Stephanie as I bent my knees and slowly inserted myself in Brooke’s cunt. Brooke buried her head in the bed as she let out a long, deep moan.
Stephanie looked back at me with a “What was that?” look and laughed as I smiled and chuckled at the muffled sounds Brooke was making. She hadn’t had a dick this big before, and she loved every inch.
“I think she likes it.” Joked Stephanie.
“I think so,” I replied as I thrust my cock deep inside Brooke until my pelvis was digging into her ass.
I quickened my pace. With every stroke, Brooke would utter another muffled word.
*Thrust*
“Oh”
*Thrust*
“My”
*Thrust*
“God.”
“Oh. My. God. Oh. My. God. Oh. My. God. Oh. My. God.”
I pulled her hair and lifted her head off the bed.
“Get in front of her,” I instructed Stephanie as I continued to pleasure Brooke.
Stephanie crawled forward and flipped around, so she was now sitting on the bed, facing Brooke and me with her crotch in Brooke’s face.
I let go of Brooke’s hair, so her face fell forward, and she started eating Steph out as she took my thick cock from behind.
The sight of my best friend’s sister getting eaten out by her roommate as I fucked her was so hot. I was about to cum.
Steph must have felt the same way as she watched her brother’s best friend fuck her roommate as she ate her out. She started masturbating as Brooke kept going down on her. Stephanie began to cum again as we locked eyes.
I kept thrusting until Brooke started screaming into a pillow, and her body started shaking before I pulled out and came all over her ass, with the last few drops flicking on her Cherry tattoo.
Bullseye!
We all collapsed in a pile together on the bed and caught our breath.
We got cleaned up in the guest ensuite before heading back out to the party.
The game had finished, and everyone was outside having a barbecue. We slipped out of the house periodically and mingled with our friends. No one seemed to notice we were missing.
As the party died down, the three of us left and went to the store to get more drinks before heading back to their new apartment.
The three of us hung out all night.
I woke up with the two girls lying naked next to me in Stephanie’s bed the
following day. I checked my phone, and I had a voicemail at 2 am from my friend Ali, who had hosted the Super Bowl party at her house.
She had left a drunken message saying she had seen us go into the room and asked that I check with her next time before having sex in her house.
I felt guilty before a thought grew in my brain.
She hadn’t scolded me.
She didn’t say – “Don’t do it again.”
She had told me to check with her beforehand. Was she telling me that she wanted to join in next time?
Stephanie woke up and cuddled me as I put my phone down and smiled to myself. Entertaining thoughts I had never had about Ali before.
Stephanie looked at my smile and then noticed I had a boner.
“Ooh, what are you thinking about?” she asked as she started stroking my dick.
I turned to her and smiled.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/szxf1x/my_best_friends_sister_part_5_super_bowl_sunday_mf