John and Ashley are both 21 years old, and have been married for three months now, and have a happy marriage. They are strict religiously, and follow a denomination called Virginism. It’s like Catholicism, in terms of birth control not being allowed, except they also follow some Mormon doctrines, like polygamy is allowed.
One day, after having a date, they arrived back at their apartment.
“I’m gonna use the bathroom real quick. And maybe we can rent a move after!” John said.
After getting out of the bathroom. He saw his beautiful wife fully naked on the bed.
“Tonight’s the night babe! We haven’t had it in weeks!” Ashley said.
John quickly got undressed as the couple made out passionately. Ashley got into the doggystyle position. John then put his penis into Ashley’s wet vagina.
“Oh yeah babe!” Ashley said.
Then something strange happened. For as long as he remembered. John always tried to get the butthole out of his sight when checking out his wife’s butt. However, this time he didn’t actually mind the sight of it, but actually kind of liked it!
“Wait… do I like my wife’s asshole?!” John thought to himself. “Nah! I’m just seeing things!”
John then caresses Ashley’s butt more, spreading her cheeks with each squeeze. His cock hardened slowly at the sight of her butthole.
“Am… am I… sexually attracted to my wives anus? No! Don’t be silly!… But… what if I put my thumb on it? Will she notice?… NO! DO NOT DO THAT!” He thinks to himself.
John keeps on caressing his wife’s ass while keeping his lustful thoughts about her anus to himself.
“You like this Honey? You feel so tight. I am going to start moving. Tell me if you want me to go faster.” John said. “Yes… please go faster!” Ashley replied.
John’s hips started to thrust into her faster. Ashley felt his penis moving inside of her. His stomach hit her butt over and over again making sure it is as deep as it goes.
“Do you like me rubbing your beautiful butt while I make love to you? John asked. “If your happy, I’m happy my love! Now keep going at it!” Ashley replied.
Then out of nowhere, John lost all self control and put his thumb inside Ashley’s anus.
“….John….” Ashley said in a negative tone.
John then took it out. As they looked at each other in shock.
“I uh.. don’t know what came over me there, Ashley. I am sorry. Your uh.. butthole was just.. I don’t know.” John said. “It’s fine!” Ashley replied.
“It’s fine that I stuck a finger in your anus? You are sure about that?!” John asked. “It wasn’t that far in” Ashley answered. “Wait, are you saying you wanted it farther or no?” John asked. “No” Ashley replied. “Okay, but what if I liked sticking my finger in your butthole?” John asked. “I mean if you stuck a thumb in. That’s fine. But nothing further.” Ashley replied.
“Okay, so you mean like this?” John said moving my hand to her butt and sticking his thumb into her anus.”I hope that wasn’t too sudden, honey.” I am clearly getting aroused by this again. He said. “It’s okay….” She replied.
John then continued to play with his wife’s butthole. “But can you promise something to me?” Ashley asked. “What is it honey?” He answered. “Can… we never have anal sex?”. She asked. Those words aroused John like never before for some reason.
“And why is that honey?” He asked. “I already had it and it was awful.” She replied.
John looked at Ashley and shock. “But isn’t anal sex not keeping yourself pure?! At least, that is what I was told by my parents.” He asked. “Anal isn’t sex. Which is why it’s even debated if married couples should even have it. Understand? And since birth control is a sin, anal sex is a way to see if you are compatible before marriage. But it can only be done with seven people.“ She replied.
John then almost fainted with excitement. “You mean, if I did it with seven women who weren’t you. I wouldn’t be sinning?!” John asked. “I guess not actually!” She replied.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/sw3bdi/buttsex_harem_chapter_one_fffffffm