Is [M]y Sister In Law a good girl?

This happened on Friday and I’m still coming to terms with what she meant. 90% of this is probably all in my head, but it really excited me and I would love some input. I’ve written about my interactions with my sister in law before you can read them on my profile if you are interested.

I’d booked a two night stay away this weekend for my wife’s birthday. It’s a place near the coast and somewhere we’d never been before but it was highly recommended by a friend.

We’d arranged for my wife’s sister to look after the dog, and she told us she’d make some lunch before we set off on the two hour drive, which was very nice of her.

I was playing with my dog as my sister in law prepared some lunch. My wife had left the room, and I wasn’t really paying attention to what else was going on in the room. Focused on the dog, playing fetch and praising her as she brought back her favourite toy.

I’d say the normal stuff like, “Who’s the best girl”, “bring the toy to daddy”, stuff I would say without even thinking. This goes on for a few minutes, totally innocently, until my sister in law comes out with “Do you think I’d be a good girl?”. Without even thinking I replied with “you’d be the best girl too.” I’m not even sure how it sounded or how it would have come across. We shared a moment of eye contact, but my wife came back into the room before either of us responded. I went back to playing with the dog, and she talked to my sister with no mention of what we had just said.

We ate lunch, and said our goodbyes. I gave her a hug as normal before we left but it lingered on for a second longer than it should.

I fucked my wife a few times over the weekend, with her sisters words in my mind the whole time.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/sh79m8/is_my_sister_in_law_a_good_girl

14 comments

  1. If anything happens next time you see her we need a update, though as much as it could be innocent I don’t think her coming up and saying is she a good girl leaves any room for the innocent card. She knew what she was doing

  4. That’s without a doubt a wild ass statement. I would have interpreted it the same way you did. Maybe she likes you haha

  8. That’s a lot farther than some funny or even flirty innocent remark.

    That sounds exactly in the same vein as when I was balls deep in my FWB the first time she says “am I a good girl daddy?” With big eyes and I reply “you’d be better with my hands around your throat” and she went fucking nuts with it.

    This is a danger zone and you better be ready for the potential consequences if you engage and indulge.

  12. A lot of women are dick teases so my advice is if you get the opportunity fuck her in the ass and show her how to be the best girl.

  14. Be careful man, she probably legit wants you to fuck her. I heard that you don’t want to cheat (good, monogamy for the win), but obviously control yourself if there’s a situation wheres it’s just you and her and she tries something.

Comments are closed.