This was several years ago when wife and I was really into partying, drinking, Swinging (unknown to our friends) etc.
So anyways, we were at a house party. The house belonged to a close friend of mine who was still single. He always had girls over, some ugly, some ok looking, but never really anyone worth cheating on my wife with.
We guys were heavy drinkers at the time. We drank just about whatever we could get our hands on. There were several girls there I had seen before. There were also two girls i have never seen before. I talked to all of them the same. No one got any special treatment although a couple of them had better bodies than the rest. I dont recall much except that everyone left and it was just my friend, wife and I, and about 3-4 random girls.
The friend took 1 girl to his bedroom and they disappeared for the night. I stayed and drank a few more shots with the girls and dozed off on the couch. Wife told me to sleep in the other bedroom if I was tired so I did. I was a mix of tired and buzzing from the alcohol, maybe even drunk. My friend had a spare bedroon with two twin size bed pushed side by so it was like a king bed. I do remember that I was the only one on the bed when i went to sleep.
I woke up around 5 or 6 with the urge to pee so I got up and went without realizing who was on the bed with me. When i got back, i realized i was sleeping between my wife and another girl. It was actually wall, girl, girl, me, then wife on the edge. The 2 girls were laying on their sides both facing the wall and their backs towards the door so I couldnt tell who was who. My wife laid on her back. Anyways I went back to my spot between my wife and that girl. We were all under a light bkanket. I was wearing joggers/sweats and a tank top, laying on my back. Wife must have heard me, since she adjusted herself and put her hand on top of my groin area.
The girl next to me was also wearing a tank top so our shoulders were skin to skin. Eventually just realizing i was skin to skin next to a girl besides my wife, my dick got hard and my wife knew it. She started to stroke it slowly from outside my pants. I couldnt help it anymore and decided to fuck her so i turned my head to kiss her and she signaled me to be quiet and to turn and face the other girl so i did. She then started touching the other girl on her ass who was wearing what seemed to be yoga pants. The girls started moving around in her “sleep.” Wife pulls my pants down enough to get her hands on my balls and plays with them as my dick twitches. I reached my arm back ro rub wife’s legs but she quickly moves my hand and places it on the other girl’s hips.
It was really hot thinking I might get caught. I left my hand there and wife started stroking my dick, teasing my dick head, rubbing all that precum around it. I couldnt help it anymore so i decided to move my hand up to the girl’s boobs. But as soon as i moved my hand off her, she scooted back to where her ass was on my dick. My wife paused since she was stroking it. She slowly moved her hand away and started rubbing my bare ass. My dick was twitching so hard at this point. I put my arms around the girl like a hug from behind and moved my head next to hers. She discreetly grabbed my arm and started humping me real slow. I am pretty sure til this day that she didnt know my wife was awake.
Eventually the humping got harder and faster. I put my hands on her boobs and played with them from outside her shirt. Felt like maybe B cups or C cups at best. Eventually i moved my hands down and try to pull her pants down but she playfully moved my hand away back to her boobs but under her shirt this time. We humped on each other for another few minutes til she reached behind her and started stroking my cock. She hesitated for a second when she realized my cock was out but quickly recovered and stroked it as i squeezed her boobs.
At one point, she tried to look at me without being obvious but she stopped before she turned all the way around to where i can see who she was. She moved my arm to her pussy area. She also paused slightly in between. I didnt think anything of it at the time. (This oart is important for later). I tried to rub her clit from outside but couldnt get a good feel of where it was so i stuck my hand inside her pants. It was pretty tight. I couldnt move my fingers much and she probably didnt feel comfortable so she pulled my hand back out. Damn, i was so close, i thought.
Well, she then pulled her pants down and grabbed my hand again and put it back on her pussy. Keep in mind my wife is awake this whole time caressing my ass and back, etc unknown to this girl. I was now rubbing her clit and it got wetter and wetter as my dick got wetter and harder. I moved her hand away from stroking me so now i was humping on her ass. As she got more in the mood, she adjusted her ass to where now my dick was in between her thighs. I guess it is called a thigh job lol. I tried my best to get it as close to her pussy as possible. But every time, my tip felt her opening, she would squeeze my dick with her thighs to prevent penetration.
So i just kept rubbing her thighs. My breathing hot harder and she put her hand on my thigh. At one point, i think she touched my wife’s hands but probably didnt know it. My wife moved her hand and now this girl was caressing my thigh and pushing her ass against me as i am playing with her clit. She starts to move around a lot. Her hips moving in a motion along with my fingering. I think she is about to cum but was afraid if she cums, she might not let me finish so i thrust my dick harder between her thighs and move hand up to grab her neck like a playful choke.
She grabs my hand and starts sucking my finger with the pussy juice on it. “Fuck it. Stick it in,” i hear. Wife hears it too and lightly taps my shoulder to make sure i hear it. I move my hand down to her thigh and lift it up a little and move my hip up and my dick slides in easily with all the lube. We both moaned kind of loud at the same time and giggled. I quickly covered her mouth and start thrusting. I wanted it to last forever. But the build up was too intense. I tried my best to make her feel good first. Lucky for me, she rubbed her clit as i fucked her. Eventually she came before me and i was about to cum. I moved my hand down to her boobs and squeezed it hard and she queezed my arm hard too. I wanted to cum inside her. I knew my wife wanted me to cum inside her too but right before i was about to cum, i grabbed her waist with both hands and pulled her tight to me and locked her with me. I blurted out “im gonna cum” and she heard so she said “cum on my ass.” And i pulled out as quick as i could and came on her ass. It was less than 5 minutes since i penetrated that pussy.
My cum sprayed all over her ass. I moved my hands off her to get more comfortable and to rub my wife’s legs, signaling that i felt good. Wife smeared my cum all over the girl’s ass with her hand and gave it a soft spank. Then put her hand in my mouth for a few seconds. We all paused for a good minute then i put my hand around the girl again and wife put her hand around me. We dozed off for about an hour so, at least. Later on i was waken up by my wife for us to go home. My pants were still down to around my knees and i could smell the sex as soon as i lifted the blanket. Wife was in doorway but the girl was facing the wall so i squeezed her ass before i left and she kind of squeezed my hand signaling she was awake.
We got home and fucked talking about it. Neither of us knew who it was. But we kept roleplaying netween the two prettier girls. Wife said the ugliest one left before they came to bed. The two girls came to sleep first while wife was in bathroom plus she was kind of buzzing too so she didnt know who was who. In fact, she didnt even remember any of their names. I thought this narrowed it down to the 2 new girls i have never seen before but wife didnt know most of their names lol.
Anyways, about a week later we go back, drink some more and one the girls came to me when no one was around and said “i knew shit would go down last week” and smiled. I gave her a confused look, pretending i didnt know and she pointed at my arm tattoo. This is when i realized that she recognized it as she moved my arm to her pussy. We have fucked a few times again after that without her knowing that my wife knew. Eventually she did let me creampie her but that is a different story.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/s325ih/fucked_a_girl_not_seeing_her_face_while_laying