The lesser man (MF)

I never really thought I would find myself in this sort of situation. Let this be a warning to everyone out there. Make sure you and your spouse are sexually compatible before marriage. I always held a relatively high opinion of myself. I was always popular, I know I’m attractive (~6’1” and in decent shape), and I have a successful career. In fact I’ve been the one to turn down hookups much of my life as a serial monogamist. I don’t even think any exes have complained about my bedroom skills. But now I’m regularly listening to other men fuck my wife.

I met Sara shortly after a nasty breakup. Maybe it was karma, I cheated on the poor girl and she found out. Nothing more there, I was the asshole and I needed to do some serious soul searching. Sara really did seem to be the answer. After Chelsea nearly murdered me, I returned to my hometown. My company has an office here and I was able to easily transfer.

I met Sara at church of all places. My mother had convinced me to accompany her and I reluctantly agreed. I saw her from some distance away though I tried not to stare. Sara was around 26 then. She had long straight blond hair that hung just a bit past her shoulders. She stood around 5’4” and I could tell she was slim. At the time I didn’t think much past staring at her little bubble butt while maintaining the illusion of paying attention.

After the service there was the usual milling around. I said hi to a few people and then went to find my mother. She was talking to another woman around her age. She introduced her as Ms. Miller and I waited politely, if impatiently. After a minute or two, Ms. Miller asked if we had seen Sara, though I didn’t know who she was at the time. She mentioned her daughter had also returned home after completing some program I later learned was a mission. As we were about to make our exit, Ms. Miller excitedly waved at someone behind me and exclaimed, “Oh there she is!”

I turned around and quickly made eye contact with a demurely stunning blond walking towards us. Her blue eyes shone brightly above a small button nose. She was smiling widely and there was a certain spring in her step. I was immediately infatuated. Gathering every ounce of wit and intelligence I had, I smiled dumbly and said, “Hi.” Then nothing.

She took it in stride though and smiled straight to my soul. “Hi, I’m Sara.”

Our respective mothers started immediately embarrassing us. I was angry at the time before I realized how brilliant a move it was on their parts. Comments about how cute we would be together left us both blushing and looking at each other. Now that my brain had started working a little bit I introduced myself and we all started talking then decided to go eat.

We had a bit of an odd romance after that. She was a true believer and lived a humble but wholesome life filled with family, church, and her work as a veterinarian. We fell deeply in love though her religious leanings kept us celibate. I asked her to marry me before the year was up and we concluded the ceremony shortly after.

The night of our marriage, after our guests had retired and we finally made it to our rooms, I swept her up and immediately deposited her on the bed. A year of no sex had gotten to me and despite my attachment to my left hand, I wanted something more. She was eager as well. 27 years of virginity is enough to weigh heavily on anyone.

She laughed, “Alex, at least let me take this dress off.” She sat up and pushed me back while smiling the same smile I had fallen in love with.

“Ah ha! I suppose clothes would be in the way.” I said smiling like an idiot. It was the sort of talk meant to lighten the mood but there was some palpable anxiety as I unzipped her dress and exposed her creamy white skin. She was slender but strong, especially in the arms. Most vets have to be. I planted kisses across her shoulders and felt her shudder.

My hands ran up and down her sides as she roved the top part of the dress. My hands suck to the front and cupped her C cup breasts. Her nipples were hard as diamonds and she moaned my name as I massaged them. She was quick to remove her bottoms and turn about. The hair on her mound was neatly trimmed and she shielded herself as she saw me drinking in the sight of her.

Realizing the ridiculousness of what she was doing, she removed her hands and gave a weak chuckle, “force of habit.”

I could see she was still nervous. “You’re stunning Sara.” I meant it, I was mesmerized by her subtle curves. I could also smell her arousal. I was barely able to control myself and avoid ravishing her before she was comfortable.

“You’re still dressed,” she said softly and drew close. I bent over and kissed my naked wife, running my hands down her back and cupping her modest ass. I started to remove my jacket but she took it and folded it over the chair. The rest of it all followed in short order and she took each piece of my suit, folded it neatly, and set it over a chair.

Before long I stood before her, naked and eager. I could see her looking over my toned body. She was excited and aroused though still nervous. I was just eager. “Come here, ” I said to her and pulled her close. Kissing her softly, “don’t worry, I’ll be gentle.” Her breathing was still elevated as I pushed her onto the bed.

I just laid next to her at first, looking deep into those beautiful blue eyes. We started to kiss and I felt the hunger in her body. She would push into my hands as they ran over her and she quickly threw a leg over me and we intertwined and my slowly hardening cock was caught between us. I pulled her harder into me as her hands pulled me into her, leaving marks that would be there for days.

My penis was hardening to full erection and rapidly made itself known as it poked into her stomach. “Fuck..” she whispered as her hand wrapped around my sizable shaft. I was around 7.5 inches long and fairly girthy. I moaned as her hand slid up and down my hard shaft. Her smooth skin felt like heaven and I wanted more. She jerked my cock a little roughly but soon found a workable rhythm.

As she grew more engaged by my penis, I asked, “Can I lick you?”.

She smiled, “If I can lick you too.” I smiled and assented before flipping her around.

She settled her neatly trimmed pussy over my face and I reached around her legs and kneaded her tight ass. I started running my tongue around the outside of her virgin pussy. Already I could tell she was tight and it made me even hornier. I worked up and down it penetrating a little with my tongue.

I could feel her hand still moving up and down my shaft though she was mostly breathing hard and whimpering from my attention. I could feel the occasional lick or kiss but she had yet to take it in. It was then that I finally assaulted her enlarged clitoris and her thighs clamped down on my head. I kept solid contact as she bucked a little and ushered in two more orgasms in swift succession. Unfortunately she also forgot about my dick but I figured these were some of her first orgasms.

She was soaking my face and I figured it was time. I rolled her off of me and she laid there limp for a second before I positioned myself over her. “Are you ready?” I asked and she nodded.

I started pushing against her opening and she half moaned half screamed. “Oh fuck.”

I feased back after getting my tip wet and pushed again. This time I got a bit further before her sounds stopped me out of concern. “Are you ok?” I asked.

“One more time.” I pushed and got the same distance before she pushed back against me. “Ow. she said involuntarily.

“I think it usually hurts the first time.” I said, a little confused. I had taken a girl’s virginity before but it wasn’t like this. She shook her head with tears in her eyes.

Our first time ended in disaster. She wouldn’t let me try again and we just cuddled that night. We tried again the next morning but had much the same result after she was licked to an orgasm. We decided to seek an expert opinion.

The doctors had a fancy name for what she had but essentially it was a small vagina. Somehow it didn’t develop with the rest of her and was permanently narrow and short though she could still get pregnant. Usually it was fine but combined with my large penis size, we are just completely incompatible. I was not going to be able to enter her and she could never accommodate me. Any children would have to come via C-section after IVF. We were devastated.

It was around that time we started having real issues. Our sex life went from lots of oral and playing with toys to virtually nonexistent. I started watching more porn and I think she did too. One day she finally asked me, “Alex, do you still love me?”

“Shit Sara, of course I do. I’m frustrated but I’m just as committed as always.” I meant it too. We were in it for the long haul.

She looked down then back up at me, “I had an idea but I don’t know how to bring it up. Promise you won’t get mad?”

I looked quizzically, “I promise I won’t yell but I can’t promise I won’t feel emotions. Just tell me and we can move forward.”

She took a deep breath. “Well. My hoo-ha is narrow and short but it’s not that narrow and short. You’re just thick and long.” I nodded, a bit worried where she was going. “Well what if we found someone smaller.”

I took a deep breath. “You mean to have sex with?”

She nodded, “and maybe you could have sex with their partner? Like a swap.”

I sat and put my head in my hands. “I won’t lie, I’ve been so frustrated. And the docs say there’s not a real solution past what we are doing. I don’t know if I can do this forever. Let’s try it and see if it works for us.”

She smiled and threw her arms around me. We’d been a little dour recently and it was nice to see her so pleased. “I already have a couple I think we should contact!” She pulled out her phone and pulled up a couple from a personals site. She had already shared some images.

The woman was a pleasantly plump woman. She had long black hair and looked to be near 30. Her breasts were large and round. She also had the ass of a goddess. I was into it. The man in contrast had something of a dad bod. He had a gut and the pictures of his cock were a little pathetic. Or they would be if it weren’t exactly what we needed. He wasn’t particularly attractive but would do for now. Honestly if he worked out some and tanned a little he would be great. I gave Sara my assent and left her to it.

I thought I’d have time but a few hours later there was a knock at the door. Sara yelled, “That’s them!” I was shocked that they were here already but walked to the door.

Before we opened it I whispered, “Why didn’t you tell me! I didn’t realize!”

“Sorry I just got excited.” I rolled my eyes but my horny brain was taking charge and we opened the door.

The man from the internet stood there. He was about 5’6” with a little bit of a gut and I could see a bald spot forming on top of his head. However he carried himself confidently and stuck a hand out towards me. “I’m Harry, nice to meet you.”

“Hey Harry, nice to meet you.” I said and Sara gave him a hug. His hand almost felt delicate in mine but she looked horny and excited the way she had looked that first night together. I knew I was taller, fitter, and more attractive but suddenly I felt emasculated. “Where is your partner?” I asked hesitantly.

“Oh she can’t make it today.” Sara and Harry answered in tandem.

“What?” I started but Sara grabbed me and pulled me to the kitchen.

“Please babe, I need this. She promised to come next time. It’s not like we’ll be able to swap back and forth anyways.”

“I don’t know..”

Suddenly her face turned dark, “well I know. You had sex before meeting me and I’ve never even had the chance.” Tears started forming in her eyes. “Please let me have this.”

I sighed and I knew I had lost. She gets stubborn and I could end up kicked out. “Ok, let’s take it slow though, make sure he’s a decent guy.”

We returned to the foyer and then led Harry to the living room. I indicated a spot to sit, “Would you like a drink?”

“Sure,” he answered as I went to the kitchen to grab some beers. When I returned Sara was sitting close to him on the couch and his hand was resting on her thigh. She was turned directly to him and chatting animatedly. I gave out the beers and had to sit away from them.

“So Alex, Sara was telling me about the issues you all are facing. That’s quite a turn isn’t it?”

I grunted sullenly and Sara launched into the whole story about how we found out I couldn’t fit. She told it humorously and he laughed at the right moments. I decided I didn’t like him.

“So what happened that your partner couldn’t make it?” I finally blurted out.

Sara answered, “He already said she was busy, don’t be rude.”

Harry chimed in, “It’s not really my place to tell you her business.”

I wanted to ask more but settled on drinking my beer. I quickly finished mine and got another while they chatted. I noticed Sara touching him more frequently and a small hard bulge forming in his pants.

He whispered something to her and they stood up. “We’re going to go to the room.” Sara said and my jaw dropped. Before I could say anything they had scurried off. I noticed my dick had gotten incredibly hard. Was I turned on by this?

I snuck closer and listened against the wall as I heard Sara giggle. There was the rattle of a belt being removed and the shuffling of clothes. I was stunned that my normally conservative wife was so eager to see this stranger naked, hell we even waited till marriage.

“Ohhhh it’s so cute and sexy,” I heard her coo at him. I was still just listening though the door was slightly ajar.

“Suck it bitch,” he said and I saw red for a second but then the sounds of a blowjob commenced. She never let me talk to her like that. The sounds of her blowing him filled the room complimented by his occasional groans. “Mmmm, play with yourself and loosen that tight pussy for me.”

“Yes daddy.” My jaw dropped yet again. I finally had the courage to peek around the corner. She was on her knees and her hand was between her legs, frantically working to stimulate her. I could see her mouth going from around his little dick to the side and then down to his balls. His penis was under five inches and somewhat thin but it was hard as a rock. We made eye contact and he smirked.

“How do you like my cock baby,” he asked while looking at me. “Is it better than your husbands?”

“Yes daddy, its so easy to suck and my mouth doesn’t get tired. But I want you inside of me.” He instead pushed her head back down on his raging erection. She had always sputtered when I did that but instead she sucked harder and slobbered over his dick while her hands played with his balls.

Finally, he stood up from the chair and then moved to the bed. She followed, still unaware I was watching. He turned to face her and she kissed him. They continued a long slow kiss like they had been lovers for years. Her hand traveled south and started stroking his cock and he massaged her tight ass. I heard them moan into each other’s mouths. She hadn’t ever been so passionate with me.

He pulled her around and bent her over the bed facing away. I finally entered and pulled out my raging erection. I was reminded of how much bigger and thicker I was and how wrong it all felt but I just kept stroking as he entered her. Sara made the most erotic noise as he did, like 27 years of sexual frustration were finally released. Harry started with short, soft thrusts and Sara almost immediately tensed up. He laughed, “Wow you were really bottled up, I only thrust five or so times before you came.”

She laughed raggedly, “That was my first orgasm from a real man.”

“But not your last,” he responded and started thrusting into her again. He was going harder now and Sara kept cumming on his little dick. She was practically panting and repeating a mantra of “Oh Baby.”

They finally changed position and Sara clambered on top. She saw me but gave no attention. She was focused entirely on Harry. She started grinding on that hard pole and moaning. She played with her fantastic nipples as Harry kneaded her ass while she ground his genitals into sweet oblivion. “Oh baby, Oh Alex, his cock is perfect. It’s perfect for my tight little pussy.”

I was stunned for a second but the erotic sight and her dirty talk pushed me over the edge and my seed spilled on the ground. Harry also released around the same time, thrusting up into her as she wildly writhed on top. After a few short thrusts Sara collapsed on top of him. I sat down and everyone just breathed. I quickly cleaned up my mess and went to the bathroom to take a shower and have some space. By the time I finished I heard them fucking again.

Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/rw6fp7/the_lesser_man_mf