So I was about 25 and was dating some geourgeous 22 yo women. She was so cute and stacked. However, she was still a virgin, and I was after it for a couple months, one time I even had her top off and she had the most perfect body…. But as she stared up at me as scared as deer in headlights, I couldn’t take her….We didn’t love each other and that to me would have been wrong, so I waited hoping….
One night after our date I went home a little earlier than usual. When I pulled up the driveway my older neighbor was having a fire in the backyard with his GF. I grabbed a couple cold ones and jumped the fence and sat down by the fire with them. I have lived next to this guy most of my life, hardly ever said a word to him but here I sit for some reason shooting the shit.
I grew up with all his daughters, 5 of them. The oldest was my same age and we are friends to this day, I was never attracted to her, then another daughter….but the third daughter… awe man. Me and a friend of mine used to do all kinds of dirty things with her when we were kids, honestly it was just kid stuff and learning the difference between boys and girls. One time we even had her jerk u off at the same time when we we’re like 13.
Anyways, back to the fire. We’re talking and then around the corner of the house comes his 3rd daughter, I had forgotten she moved back from somewhere, had two kids and divorced I guess.
She was all women now man, all women. She came out in a silky robe and clearly had just showered. It was like a dream come true. I was so worked up especially because of my dating situation.
She comes and sits down and we start to talk and I can hardly look at her, her dad sitting there knowing what was on my mind….and hers. After awhile her dad gets up and says well, I have to take my GF home.You kids don’t stay out here too long… he knew, I knew and she knew. Then he got in his truck and left.
He wasn’t gone five minutes and we started playing truth or dare. That’s when I notice a shadow in the window, it had to have been one, if not both the younger sisters listening in and watching….which was weird but I didn’t care.
Dare: show me your tits…..they were perfect.
Truth: what are you thinking about doing to me? I’m gonna take that robe off and fuck you.
Truth: did it turn you on when you jerked us off as kids? Hell yea, I masturbate thinking about it all the time.
Dare: show me your cock. I pulled it out so fast… then in my peripheral vision I can still see the shadows in the windows… oh well, enjoy the show girls.
Dare, suck it, suck my cock.
She jumped up opened up her robe, got down on her knees and sucked me off like a champion. I could see her beautiful body, rubbing her tits, heaven. While I’m leaning back enjoying every second of my childhood fantasy come true….I look and still see in the shadows, them watching. I’m looking right at them….they dont care… they watch.
Like five minutes later i let loose in between those sweet little lips and WOW, that was awesome.
We sit back and talk a few minutes, a little more childhood dirty talk and before I know it, I pin her to the ground in the deep summer grass and pound away at that pussy. Probably the best I ever had, I roll her over on her stomach she puts her ass in the air and I hammer away and right when im about to cum, she without me saying a word rolls over and has me finish on her tits, I did hit the tits, face and hair, all the while, with an audience.
I didn’t want to date that girl but I did like us fucking that one night…. It was glorious and I think her little sisters liked the show too, I would see the younger one in the store or out and about from time to time and they would give me the most lustfull looks….
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/rsuahe/the_time_i_fucked_my_neighbor