See “Sister Peeper” for backstory
My friend Cate worked at the adjoining bar and we’d walk home together most nights. Despite living together, she and her sister had an passive aggressive relationship that could be openly antagonistic. Rhea seemed to have her life more together and guys gravitated to her more. Cate was pretty enough, not gorgeous or anything; full face, big tits, thick thighs, athletic with a dark complexion and blue eyes.
One day the power went out so she and I were sitting on her balcony smoking, her in a bikini and me in shorts. I asked where yRhea was when I noticed her room door closed despite the heat and Cate said she was staying with a guy. That was fine, we were just there to “fill our biological needs” as she put it. I listened to Cate complain about Rhea, which wasn’t uncommon when it was just us, we talked about how fun it would be to live on the beach like this forever and other usual high convos.
Cate then asked how I felt about Rhea staying over with another guy. I told her fine but she didn’t seem certain, but seemed to let it go. A little while later she asked if I’d ever shotgunned, which I’d never heard of. She told me to take a drag from the bowl, then as she leaned over, told me to blow it in her mouth. Our lips touched and our eyes met. She smiled as she exhaled. I kissed her and we started furiously making out.
She slid open the screen and we tumbled to the floor. She untied her bikini as I took off my shorts. I asked about a condom and she told me don’t worry about it (the only family similarity it seems). Her tits were better than her sisters and I pushed up to watch them bounce. I fucked her hard, partially out of jealous her sister was fucking another guy. I guess she could tell I was getting close because she moaned for me to cum in her.
With power and AC we were drenched in sweat. I rolled off of her and she laughed, telling me we could be one another’s secret :)
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/rk4ezs/not_sure_which_of_us_was_getting_used_mf