[MFF] I (23M) was seduced by my Friends with Benefits’ (22F) best friend (22F)

*Real events, fake names.*

So, I have been in a no-strings-attached, Friends with Benefits arrangement with a fellow student at my university, with whom I share several classes, since Spring semester. Her name is Rachael and she and I started out with a flirty chat when she sat next to me in a lecture. This led to me asking for and receiving her number, which led to drinks, which led to other extracurricular activities. She is tall, with dark brunette hair, and fit with an athletic body. She is very in-tune with her sexuality, too. She made it clear from the beginning that she liked me but, despite that and all the fun we were having, wanted to keep things casual, open, and noncommittal. Frankly, I was impressed with how she was so upfront about her stance and feelings and I agreed to keep the outlined arrangement. She suggested that we both go get tested for STDs and clarified that while she does routinely take birth-control, she would appreciate it if I used condoms, and to those things I also agreed. Things have been working out great for several months; we are good friends that fuck and that is all it needs to be. Then, the following happened about a month ago.

Rachael and I both live off-campus in our own apartments. However, she lives closer to campus than I do, so we often end up at her place, either before, after, or between classes, to hang out and enjoy the benefits of our friendship. She and I were walking from our last class to my car when we ran into Beth, Rachael’s best friend who also attends the university, but doesn’t share any of the same classes as us. I had been around Beth several times but didn’t know her very well. But I always thought she seemed “fun”.

As we were chatting, Beth asked Rachael if she could catch a ride home. Rachael looked at me then at Beth and said, “Well, uh, Mark is my ride today.” Rachael had taken an Uber onto campus and was planning to get a ride home with me. Despite knowing what Rachael and I had planned for ourselves, I shrugged and said, “Yeah, sure I could give you a ride.” I had no clue where she lived but figured it was the nice thing to do. Rachael then hastily clarified that we needed to go to her place first as she had to get ready for work. I asked Beth where she lived, and she mentioned that it was only about 5 minutes’ drive away from Rachael’s place. That seemed reasonable to me, so we all headed off.

When I pulled up outside Rachael’s apartment, Rachael asked if we wanted come in for a bit. Beth and I both agreed. As we walked into the apartment, Rachael declared that she needed to get in the shower and made her way towards the bathroom. Beth took a seat on the couch while looking at her phone. Rachael noticed that Beth was not paying attention and silently motioned at me to follow her. So, I did. When we both got inside the bathroom, she reached inside the shower stall and turned it on, then spun around and dropped to her knees in front of me just as I was closing the bathroom door. I laughed and asked her what she was doing. She looked up at me with her big brown eyes and grinned while her fingers began negotiating with the clasp of my belt. I grinned back and asked, “What about Beth?” Without hesitation, Rachael replied, “What about her?” I shrugged it off and watched as she unbuckled my belt, unbuttoned and unzipped my jeans, and tugged them and my boxers down to my ankles. She grasped the base of my semi-hard cock with her left hand and looked up at me. “I love how it doesn’t take much to get you going” she said before wrapping her lips around the head. I inhaled deeply through my nose and watched as she took my dick into her mouth, sliding her tongue underneath the head of my cock and working it around in a circular motion. It wasn’t long before I was rock hard.

After only a minute or two, Rachael stood up and began getting undressed. I kicked off my shoes and stepped out of my jeans and boxers with my 9-inch cock hanging heavily. I pulled my t-shirt off over my head and felt Rachael’s fingers wrap around the shaft of my cock. She stroked my cock gently while I slid my hand between her legs and onto her pussy. I used the tip of my middle finger to rub her clit and separate her labia. Rachael cooed softly and pulled away, finally stepping inside the running shower, pointing the shower head off to the side. She turned her back to me and put one hand on the shower wall, bending over slightly at her waist. I watched as she rubbed her pussy with her free hand, her middle and ring fingers disappearing inside her. I stood watching and holding my cock and said, “My condoms are in my backpack in the car.” Rachael replied with her fingers still probing insider her, “Just c’mon.” So, I stepped inside behind her and she bent over further, getting up on her tip-toes,and presented her pussy to me. I slid my cock between her thighs and rubbed the head of it up and down the length of her pussy before shoving it inside her. Rachael groaned and loudly exclaimed, “Ooooh fuuccckk!” as the full length of my dick slid inside her with a single slow thrust of my hips. She pushed her ass back against me and we started fucking harder.

Rachael is an enthusiastic sex partner, and this time was no exception. She was loud with her moans, making no effort to hide what she and I were up to. I held onto her narrow waist and pounded hard and eventually she climaxed with a crescendo of moans as her body quaked. I took a step backwards, removing my cock from Rachael’s pussy. She turned to face me before dropping to her knees. I stroked the head of my dick and pointed it at her pretty face, blasting ribbons of hot cum across it. She giggled and grinned and I stood breathless.

I took a moment to wash off and stepped out of the shower as Rachael began soaping up. I dried off, got dressed, and said my goodbyes to her then returned to the living room to find Beth, still sitting on the couch in the same spot, still scrolling through her phone. “Hey, you ready?” I asked and she silently nodded and stood up.

We got back to my car and headed off. There was a quiet awkwardness to the drive. I knew there was no way she didn’t hear us. Regardless, she gave good directions, but otherwise there wasn’t much conversation, which was out of the ordinary for Beth as she is typically very outgoing and personable. When we reached her place, she opened the passenger door and twisted to step out before looking at me and offering, “You can come in if you want.” I stammered and said, “I don’t know… I should probably get going.” Beth asked, “You sure?” The way she asked insinuated that I should reconsider her invitation. I relented and followed her to her apartment, the entire time wondering what is going on.

Beth is attractive, but not in the same manner as Rachael. Where Rachael has a traditionally pretty face, Beth is a bit more ordinary. Rachael is tall and petite, very fit, with long legs, a tight butt, and perky B-cup breasts. Beth is about the same height as Rachael but has a thick, curvy figure, but definitely not fat: thick thighs, a big ass, and huge tits. Rachael has long, straight dark brunette hair. Beth has wavy strawberry blonde hair. Rachael is demure and reserved, Beth is typically extroverted and lively, which made the quiet car ride seem unusual.

We get inside and Beth walks into her kitchen and sets her handbag down on the countertop. She then asked if I wanted a drink. I said, “Sure, whatever you’re having.” Beth takes out two cans of soda from her refrigerator and sets one down on her kitchen bar. I walk up and take my can and we each open them at the same time. Beth stood in her kitchen, I stood just outside the kitchen with the kitchen bar separating us. There was a loaded pause as we both had a swallow of soda before Beth broke the silence, “I bet I fuck better than Rachael.”

I heard her more clearly than I have ever heard anything in my life but still asked, “…what?” She sat her can down, pulled something out of her handbag, then took a step towards me around the corner of the countertop and repeated herself. I laughed, a little embarrassed, and said, “Well, I have no reason to doubt you…” She replied, “You can find out for yourself if you want.” and held up the condom that she had just retrieved from her bag. I just looked back at her silently, unsure of what to say next. Beth continued, “I know you two aren’t exclusive and she and I have shared guys before. I think you’re really cute and it was so hot overhearing you two.” I wasn’t sure what to think. She was right; Rachael and I are not exclusive to each other, but Beth is her best friend. I knew this was dangerous territory but, my penis brain took over. I blushed and asked, “You sure about this?” She nodded. “Alright. Yeah…let’s go”, I said. Beth bit her lip and smiled, “OK. Let’s go.”

I stepped up to Beth and took the condom from her and leaned in to kiss her. We kissed for several moments before I could feel her beginning to unbuckle my belt. Once she had gotten my belt undone, I reached down and unbuttoned and unzipped my jeans. She slid her hands inside the waistband of my boxers and pushed them and my jeans down. I kicked off my shoes and stepped out of my pants. Beth caught her first glimpse of my dick and gasped a bit, “Wow! Rachael said you had a nice cock, but damn!” I stood smiling at her and gave my cock a few encouraging strokes. She pulled her blouse off over her head then shimmied out of her jeans, revealing her curvy body and matching bra and boy-short panties. She motioned towards her sofa and said, “Have a seat.” I took off my shirt while making my way to the sofa and sat as I was instructed. Beth came to stand directly in front of me and stared at me with her fiery green eyes as she reached up behind her back and unclipped her bra. She shrugged off her bra’s shoulder straps and tossed it to the side. Her big tits defied gravity and her nipples were small but erect and flush, with perfectly round areolas; the most impressive pair of tits I have ever seen with my own eyes.

I sat staring back up at her, taking the sight of her all in. She turned her back to me, tucked her thumbs into the waist of her panties, and began pushing them off. She bent straight over at her waist as she shoved her panties down past her knees; the back of her pussy shown between her luxurious thighs. I reached my arms up and caressed her big round ass while she remained bent over. She had a pretty little asshole and plump pussy with large labia. I used my thumbs to spread her labia apart and glistening ribbons of wetness suspended between them. Beth braced herself against her knees and cooed. I used my right thumb to collect her wetness and rub her clit. After a few seconds, Beth stood up and turned to face me again before kneeling onto the couch on top of me. She shoved her tits in my face and I took the nipple of her left breast in my mouth. I sucked on her nipple as I felt Beth’s hands surround the shaft of my dick. I grabbed the condom wrapper and tore into it, placing the condom over the head of my cock while Beth helped roll it down onto my shaft.

Then she raised up off my lap and inhaled sharply as she sat all the way back down onto my cock. “Mmm, god…damn!” she moaned before beginning to gently rock her hips and bounce her ass up and down on my lap. I slid my hands down onto her ass and squeezed her cheeks while she bounced. Beth rested her forearms on my shoulders and ran her fingers through my hair. The rhythm of her bouncing ass increased in frequency before abruptly stopping. She breathed harder and deeper as she grinded her hips back and forth. She pressed her forehead against mine and asked, barely above a whisper, “Is that good?” I nodded in response, squeezing her ass tighter and lifting her up slightly. I thrusted my hips upward while holding her up and Beth cried out in pleasure and laughed, “Ohhhh my goddddd!”

After several minutes of intense riding, Beth stopped and stood up, running her fingers through her tousled hair. I stood up too and she led me into her bedroom. She sat on the edge of her bed and I guided her to lay back, lifting up her legs and burying my face in her pussy. I caressed her tits and she grasped the back of her calves as my tongue lapped up her wet pussy. Beth’s moans were nearly involuntary at this point but she managed to demand, “Fuck me.”

I stood up and slid the length of my cock along her clit. Beth stared back up at me. Her eyes rolled to the back of her head as I shoved myself back inside her. I leaned forward, holding myself up over her with my arms as my hips began thrusting down into her, harder and faster. The rhythmic way her tits bounced and swayed drove me wild. She screamed out, “Fuck! Yes! Don’t fucking stop!!” and I didn’t. Eventually, Beth cried out in pleasure while twisting, turning, and shaking and I shoved myself in as deeply as I could and held there, cumming inside the condom.

I pulled out and laid down next to her, each of us panting out of breath. We laid there, our bodies touching, but no words shared, for what seemed like ten minutes before Beth turned her head towards me and said, “Shit, that was good!” I blurted out with a laugh and agreed, “Yeah. Real good.” A few more minutes of silence passed and the awkwardness began creeping in. I sat up and mentioned that I should probably get going and she agreed. We each cleaned up; I put my clothes back on and Beth put on pajamas. I said goodbye and drove home.

During the drive, I started getting worried. Many thoughts ran through my head, “Had I just cheated on Rachael? I’m not a ‘cheater’. No… She and I aren’t actually in a relationship. Is she going to be pissed if she finds out I just fucked her best friend?” I got home, showered, made some dinner, and started chilling on the couch when I received a text from Rachael, “Beth’s amazing, isn’t she?” followed by a winking emoji. I took several minutes to respond, typing a response then deleting it and starting over. Eventually, I sent, “Yeah, she is.” Rachael responded almost immediately with the laughing emoji then said, “She does this every time, I swear.” I asked if she was mad and this time she took longer to reply, “No, why would I be?” “I dunno…”, I said. Rachael then typed, “Don’t get weird on me!” with the tongue-out emoji. Then she started complaining about work and the conversation seemed typical to ones we usually have.

The next day Rachael and I met up for some lunch plans we had made previously with some other friends and everything was as if nothing had happened. Oh, and, I wouldn’t say Beth fucked better than Rachael but definitely not any worse.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/riwbdf/mff_i_23m_was_seduced_by_my_friends_with_benefits