Sharing [M]y ex[F] with [M]y best friend.

This all happened three years ago with my now ex girlfriend (Ally) and my best friend (Tye). Ally and I had been together all through college where we had first met during our freshman year. Tye went to the same college as us, and him and I have been best friends since high school.

All three of us were very close, so it was tough when we parted ways shortly after graduation. We used to see each other every day and now we were lucky to see each other twice a year. Ally and I had gotten pretty serious and had moved in together about 10 hours away from where Tye was now living.

Tye and I are a lot a like, we even look alike and often get mistaken for brothers. Tye was always a romantic and often came on too strong with his feelings.. He never had trouble getting girls, but getting them to stick around after professing his “undying love” way too early was another matter. Classic Ted Mosby and classic Tye lol.

Busy with our new and first real jobs post college, Ally and I hadn’t seen Tye for over a year. We still kept in contact and he of course had fallen head over heals in love again with some coworker that he’d only been seeing for a couple of months.

This new girl had kids and a long term boyfriend, which I had told Tye was a recipe for disaster at best. Of course Tye told me they were madly in love and she was going to leave her boyfriend soon.

One day, I got a call from Tye in the middle of the afternoon, which was unusual. He was entirely distraught, as this girl he had been seeing, and whom was planning to breakup with her boyfriend for him, had instead gotten engaged. I thought it was pretty clear this girl just used Tye to make her boyfriend jealous to finally pop the question, but I didn’t say anything to Tye, it wasn’t the time for it.

Instead we planned to finally take a long weekend, hangout, and help our friend get over this girl. I tried to get some other buddies to come too, but it was too short notice, so it was just going to be Tye, Ally, and me. Tye’s parents are decently wealthy and happen to own a really nice cabin on an awesome lake that they are always too busy making money to use. Ally and I met him at the cabin for a weekend of fishing, swimming, drinking, and getting over his latest breakup.

When we arrived, the first thing we did after cracking open a beer was change into our swimsuits and hit the little private beach on Tye’s parents’ property. It was a warm, but late September day, so we basically had the lake to ourselves, with most of the other cabin owners too busy to come up on a weekend since school had just started up for those with kids.

Ally is a tall brunette, b cups and a runners body, slim but still muscular. Ally was also a bit of a show off and had decided to wear a pretty skimpy purple bikini that didn’t leave much to the imagination. In fact, you could see these sexy white tan lines on her tight little ass and boobs from a summer spent wearing more modest swimsuits.

It was already pretty late by the time we had arrived and finally gotten down to the beach, so it got dark pretty quickly and we decided to get a fire going. The three of us sat around the fire as it got dark out and we’re drinking pretty heavily as we chatted and caught up with each other’s lives.

Being late September, though it had been beach weather earlier, it was getting pretty chilly out. I looked over at Ally and could clearly see her hard nipples poking through her little bikini. I said maybe we should go in and change into something a bit warmer, but Ally and Tye said they were fine and just threw a few more logs on the fire and scooted their chairs closer.

As we were joking and talking I kept catching Tye glancing down at Ally’s hard nipples. To be fair, I was too and I think she knew it. I whispered in her ear that we could see she was a bit cold and she shot back so we both could hear.

“What? Are you guys really offended by my nipples?” She said with a mischievous grin.

“Not at all!” Tye laughed.

“Sorry!” I said. “ I just wanted to make sure you knew.”

“Of course I knew.” Said Ally. “I just didn’t think it was a big deal.”

“I sure don’t mind.” Said Tye.

“What a surprise.” I said sarcastically, but with a smile. “It’s not a big deal.” I told Ally. “I don’t mind either.”

We talked and drank some more and then went to bed. Tye had been kind enough to let us sleep in the master bedroom since it had a king size bed. As soon as I shut the door behind me, Ally jumped my bones like she never had before.

She pushed me down onto the bed and straddled me while she took off her bikini top. Ally had these beautiful half dollar sized and very pink nipples that were still very hard.

“Do you like these as much as Tye did?” Ally said wryly and she ran her fingers over her stiff nipples. “I don’t think he looked away all night!” She laughed.

“Can’t blame him,” I said as I flipped her on her back and buried my face in her small bust, gently nibbling on her erect nipples as she let out a little gasp. I moved my hand down between her legs and into her swimsuit bottoms, she was already soaking wet, and I was beginning to understand why.

“I bet Tye wishes he was me right now.” I whispered as I slipped a finger into her tight wet pussy.

“Yes!” Ally moaned. “That’s so fucking hot.

It wasn’t surprising that Ally was attracted to Tye. As I stated before, we both look a lot alike. We’re both just over six foot, blonde hair, and athletic, muscular body types, but I was surprised how much the thought of him was making her horny. Up to this point in our relationship, our sex, while good, was pretty vanilla. Even so, I decided to take a risk.

I slid off her panties and as I pushed my hard cock into her wet and pink little pussy, I whispered, “what if this was Tye’s cock?” She didn’t say anything but smiled and placed her hands on my ass and pulled me deep inside her. She gasped and told me to fuck her. As I fucked her, she was pressing her hips back up into mine and it wasn’t long before we had both cum. As we lay relaxing, I joked that I was pretty tired, but I could go get Tye to give her a round two if she wanted.

“Well, if you insist…” She smiled, but her face was bright red.

“Would you legit be into something like that?” I asked.

There was a pause before she answered, as if she was working up the courage to tell me, or unsure if she could be truthful.

“Be honest.” I encouraged. “I promise I won’t be upset.”

“I think the idea of it is super hot.” She admitted. “But I’m only into it if you would be too. I’m totally fine with it staying a fantasy and I definitely don’t expect it to be with your best friend.”

“Honestly, who’d be better?” I asked. “Tye’s a good guy and would never tell. You think he’s attractive, right?”

“Of course. But don’t you think that could cause problems.”

“I think it’d be fine. I trust you both. And I know for a fact he’d be into it.”

“How on earth would we bring it up though. That sounds super awkward.”

“No idea.” I admitted.

We left it at that and went to bed, but I couldn’t believe how much the thought of this was turning me on, even post sex clarity I was into it. I was very comfortable in my relationship with Ally and I trusted her completely. The thought of sharing the body of someone I loved with my best friend was an intoxicating thought. I think a big part of it was wanting to show my buddy how lucky I am to have a girl like that. Basically almost a weird kinky version of bragging lol.

The next day we woke up and immediately started drinking.

“You can’t drink all day if you don’t start in the morning.” Tye said as he made us some Bloody Mary’s to go with our breakfast. We were still a bit hungover from yesterday, but in high spirits and ready to get after it today too.

“I heard you two perverts going at it last night. Banging in my parents bed is fucked up! You’re cleaning those sheets before we leave!” Tye said with feigned annoyance.

“Sorry about that.” I laughed.

“Yeah, you should be! It’s not like I just got over a breakup or anything. Now you guys rub your perfect relationship in my face?!” Tye said with a smile, but maybe only half joking.

“Aww, we’re sorry.” Ally said as she went over and wrapped him in a tight hug.

Ready for another day on the lake, Ally was already in her swimsuit and a cute coverup. The bikini was white this time, which contrasted nicely with her tanned skin, but was more modest than yesterday’s.

“It’s okay, you can make it up to me by changing back into that bikini you wore yesterday.” He smirked.

Ally smiled and gently punched his arm, “are you gonna let him talk to me like that?!” She asked me.

“What you want to do? The man’s grieving!” I laughed.

“I guess, but you watch yourself. And cheer up! We’re here to have some fun!” She chided as she slapped Tye’s ass.

“Now who’s being naughty!” Tye complained.

“Sorry, I couldn’t resist! You guys both look great in these sexy little trunks!” We were both wearing trunks that only went just below mid thigh.

Ally coyly flirted with Tye all day as we took out the pontoon for some swimming and fishing on the mostly deserted lake. Tye stopped in a large cove that was extremely private. Ally insisted on putting sunscreen on us both, her hands lingering on both Tye’s and my abs.

Ally lied out in the deck in her little white bikini, her sweat glinting in the sun while Tye and I did some fishing.

“You don’t get many days like this in September.” Ally said as she rolled onto her back. Her ass looked absolutely amazing. “Can you get my back? I think I’m burning.” Ally said to me and gestured to the sunscreen.

“Hey Tye, can you help her? I think I got a snag.” I lied.

“No problem.” Tye replied.

I watched out of the corner of my eye while Tye rubbed the sunscreen onto my girlfriend’s shoulders. I watched as his hands and fingers moved to her lower back, slowly massaging it in.

Ally was starting to make these quiet little moaning sounds as Tye’s fingers worked their magic. I saw Ally reach behind her and move Tye’s hand to her tight ass. Tye hesitated and glanced at me, catching me watching. I just smiled and nodded in approval. Tye smiled back at me and continued.

Ally’s moans were getting a bit louder now, which was encouraging Tye to be bolder, running his hand higher and higher up the back of her shapely long legs. The muscles in Tye’s back working as he vigorously massaged my girlfriend’s nearly naked body.

I set down my fishing pole and walked over to them. Tye paused and looked at me inquisitively, perhaps worried I was going to put a stop to this. Instead, I stooped down and gently shimmied Ally’s swimsuit down to just below her cheeks, completely exposing her beautiful ass for Tye. I then took half a step back to observe and give them space.

Ever the wise guy, Tye remarked, “I don’t think your ass needs any sunscreen. Your ass is ghost white and could definitely use some sun.” He laughed and I smiled.

“You’re totally right.” Ally said, “I really need to get rid of these tan lines.” She untied the knots around her neck and back and her top’s straps fell to the deck. Then she slightly lifted her butt up into the air, giving it the slightest of wiggles, beckoning Tye to pull her bottoms down the rest of the way.

Tye obliged. I briefly glimpsed her well kept, small brown bush as Tye took them off. The thought that Tye had seen it too was making me very hard, which was impossible to hide in our swim trunks. I noticed Tye was also getting hard in his tight swim trunks, the outline of his cock head clearly visible. Tye and I used to play football together and I knew first hand from the locker room that his cock was a fair size bigger than my own fairly average one.

Tye’s cock was getting bigger as he massaged the sunscreen into her pale bare ass. Getting braver and hornier by the second, I watched as Tye spread Ally’s cheeks apart, exposing her tight asshole and furry little pussy. I could tell from here that Ally was already soaking wet as her pubic hair looked clearly moistened.

I watched with delight as Ally moaned and raised her ass in the air while Tye began slowly rubbing her pussy in large slow circles. I couldn’t take it anymore and pulled out my cock and slowly started stroking it. Tye also took this as permission and pulled down his trunks, exposing his 8ish inch smooth cut cock that had just a hit of stubble. He took his hand, wet from Ally’s pussy, and used it as lube while he stroked his cock.

Ally rolled over onto her back, completely exposing her large, stiff, pink nipples and pussy. She watched us for a second while we jerked off to her tan toned body with those beautiful tan lines.

“I’ve been dying to know what you look like naked.” Tye told Ally with a huge grin.

“I’ve been dying to know what your cock feels like in my pussy.” She replied. They both looked at me with a sheepish grin. I just nodded while I stroked my cock. Tye spread her legs and slowly pushed his big cock in her tight pink pussy. Ally gasped as it entered. They started slowly but picked up speed quickly. Tye’s ass rising and falling as I heard the sounds of Ally’s wet pussy being penetrated. There moans were mingling together and I felt like I would burst.

Ally pushed Tye out of her and repositioned herself on top. I watched as she guided Tye’s cock back inside her warm, wet cunt. I watched as my girlfriend rocked back and forth, taking the entire length of my best friend’s big cock. Ally was so into it she was gushing. Her bodies natural lube was coating Tye’s cock in a white foam like substance born from their friction.

Ally began getting very load and vocal as she got close to orgasm.

“Shhh”, I chided, “sound carries well across the water.”

“Come here and shut me up then.” Ally challenged. I walked over and she began sucking my cock while still riding Tye. I could tell by her moans muffled by my cock that she was close to cumming. Tye apparently was too.

“Oh fuck, I’m gonna cum guys.” Said Tye.

“Cum in her pussy.” I said. “That’s where you want it, right babe?” I teased.

“Yes.” She screamed, way too loudly after taking my cock out of her cute mouth, now slightly smudged with her pale pink lipstick. Then she picked up the pace, aggressively riding Tye’s cock until he blew his load deep inside her. The feeling of Tye’s hot cum inside her must have put her over the edge and she quivered and stopped jerking me off as her body tensed in orgasm.

“Fuck, that was amazing.” She said.

“It’s not over yet.” I reminded. “I still need some help with this.” I gestured to my erect dick.

“Well, then cum here baby.” Ally said. She laid on her back and spread her legs. I watched as Tye’s cum slowly leaked out of her. I took my finger and swirled his cum all around her pussy, rubbing it gently into her already sensitive clit. This made Ally go wild and she begged me to fuck her. Tye sat to the side watching, enjoying the show.

I put my cock inside her with ease. As I pushed inside her more of Tye’s cum was pushed out. Seeing this drove me wild and we fucked with a reckless abandon while Tye looked on.

“Cum in my pussy babe. I need both your loads.” This sent me over the top and I came buckets inside her, pulling out halfway and panting her face, toned tummy, and tits with cum as well.

All three of us lay there on the deck breathless for a moment. Ally broke the silence by asking for a towel while she absentmindedly rubbed my cum around her large pink nipples.

“I need something to cleanup with.” She said. I still can’t believe what happened next. I don’t know what came over me, but i spread her legs again and went down on her double creampied pussy. The taste of our cum was salty in contrast to the sweet smell of Ally’s pussy.

“Holy crap that is hot.” Ally said between moans while I cleaned her cum filled pussy with my tongue.

“Tye, come clean my nips and tummy?” Ally teased.

“I don’t know…” Tye said unsure.

“Please, please?? I can’t promise we do this again unless you do it.” She joked. Tye smiled and came over to lick Ally’s tits. When I talked to Ally later, she said having two guys clean the cum off her body with their tongues was the hottest part of the whole threesome. Judging from how vocal and encouraging she was, I believe her.

After coming one last time, Ally announced she didn’t have anything left. Tye and I didn’t either. We got dressed and headed back to the cabin. All three of us were smiling ear to ear.

When we got back, Ally and I went to the shower to clean up.

“That was amazing.” I said, “but you missed a spot.” I took my finger and wiped a small droplet of cum off her face and showed her. She popped my finger in her mouth, swallowing the cum promptly.

“Time for a shower.” She said. “We definitely need to do that again.”

“We do.” I agreed.

We basically spent the rest of the trip fucking Ally. When we finally left, we promised not to tell anyone about this and to also do it again as soon as possible.

Thanks for reading!

Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/qvowa9/sharing_my_exf_with_my_best_friend