[MF] Giving my hot, athletic neighbor a messy creampie

The following story is about a girl who I met at my apartment complex. It’s quite long, but I have a VERY good memory, and have memorized nearly all details of the hot night that we spent together a few weeks ago. Buckle up for the ride.

The fitness center at my apartment is small and cramped, but has enough machines and free weights that I can use it to get in a quick afternoon or morning workout in addition to my regular gym membership. Most of the time, the people using the fitness center are just older people who sit on the bikes for 30 minutes, or teenagers with no clue what they’re doing who grab random pairs of dumbbells and flail them around like maracas before leaving. Over the last few months, I started noticing a particularly attractive young lady working out in the fitness center. She was small, only about 5’2 and 100lbs, but was clearly very athletic, with nicely toned legs, arms, and a stomach. Whenever I was in the fitness center along side her, I couldn’t help but peek at her from time to time. I typically don’t creep on girls at the gym and try to focus solely on my workout, but my god, the way her ass moved as she ran on the treadmill or did squats was a work of art to behold. On several occasions, she was working out in a sports bra, giving me a good look at her defined stomach as well. Her face was youthful, with big brown eyes, a petite nose, and curly, light brown hair usually tied into a ponytail or bun. For a couple weeks, our interactions were limited to friendly smiles as we saw each other. I was definitely attracted to her, but didn’t want to creep her out and was nervous about starting a conversation with her.

After about a month of running into her at the gym, I finally broke the silence with her. It was a simple request, just asking her if she was done using some discarded 20lb dumbbells on the floor, to which she replied I could use them. I noticed the US Women’s Soccer shirt that she was wearing, and asked if she was a soccer player. I didn’t expect her to engage in a conversation, but she ended up telling me about her history of playing soccer from elementary school to college. I was surprised to hear from her that she graduated college 4 years ago, as she looked young enough to be a freshman in college to me. It felt good having broke the silence with this girl after a month of awkward smiles and brief glances.

After that interaction, we started slowly developing a rapport each time we saw each other. We had a couple friendly competitions, such as who could do the most pull ups or last the longest doing wall sits. We even arm wrestled one time, and although I beat her easily, I was surprised at how much strength was packed into her relatively small frame. I learned her name, Charlotte, and also learned that she was living with her mom in the apartment complex after she lost her teaching job last year due to COVID. She complained that it was annoying having to live with her mom and wanted to move to a cheaper city. I floated the idea of having her come over for dinner one night to get away from her mom, and to my delight, she was receptive to the idea. We exchanged phone numbers, and set up plans to have dinner that Saturday.

Saturday rolled around, and I got a knock on my door at about 6:00. I opened the door and Charlotte was standing there, very nicely dressed for what was just a casual dinner. She was dolled up with makeup and earings, and even did her hair as well. Meanwhile, I was just wearing a polo shirt and jeans. She gave me a hug and remarked on how she might have overdressed, but I told her she looked great and not to worry about it. I cooked up some teriyaki chicken for the two of us, and we sat down at my dinner table for some more conversation. I spontaneously decided to light a couple of candles at the table and dimmed the lights, causing her to remark that it was “romantic.” To tell the truth, I didn’t intend for it to be a romantic evening and just planned on getting to know her better before asking her out formally, but I started to get the feeling that she was attracted to me, given both her remarks and how nicely she dressed up for the evening.

After dinner, I asked Charlotte if she wanted to stay and watch a movie. She agreed, and we made our way over to my couch to watch Tropic Thunder. We got about 5 minutes into the movie when she scooted closer to me on the couch. Seeing my chance, I turned to face her, and she turned her head as well. We locked eyes, and I went in for the kiss. Her lips were soft and delicate, and I could taste the fresh lipstick as we got more passionate and explored each other for the first time. We both turned fully towards each other, and I gently grasped the side of her neck, tilting her head backwards so I could kiss and gently bite on her neck. She was gasping and moaning as I worked my way down her neck before sucking on the side of it, leaving a large hickey. I let her take the lead after that, and she started tracing her tongue across my teeth, inviting me to start french kissing her. We found ourselves exchanging deep, passionate tongue kisses, just the way I always like them. I pinned her down against the couch, kissing her while occasionally pausing to bite down on her neck and shoulder. We paused briefly so she could slip her dress off, revealing a sports bra and tight athletic shorts underneath. I’d always been very attracted to her, but tonight was special, as I had a closer look at her body, and now could do whatever I want with it.

Charlotte invited me off the couch, telling me that she wanted me to pin her against the wall. Without hesitation, I gently shoved her against the wall of my apartment as our kissing became more aggressive and primal. I explored every inch of her skin with my lips, bending down so I could kiss her thighs as well. I lifted her off the ground and drove her into the wall again, delivering more forceful kisses and bites to her neck that elicited loud gasps of ecstasy from her. By this point, I had a powerful erection developing, and paused briefly to take my jeans off. I didn’t intend to get fully unclothed at that point, but Charlotte pulled my underwear down with a devilish grin on her face. She wrapped her hand around my fully erect cock, giving me a few rubs before sticking it fully into her mouth. That tiny mouth of hers was tight around my cock, and she proceeded to give me an amazing blowjob that nearly left me ready to finish within 30 seconds. We met eyes as she sucked me off, and I could see a look of pure desire in her eyes as she continued to thrust my cock deep into her throat. I had to stop her before I came too quickly, and directed her onto my bed.

Charlotte perched herself on the edge my bed, teasing me and saying that if I wanted her so bad, I would have to take her. I took my shirt off and sized her up, telling her that a big, strong man like me would have no trouble taking down a little girl like her. She laughed and beckoned me, and I lept on the bed, immediately moving to pin her down. Charlotte was quick, and I found it difficult to keep hold of her so I could pin her down. Her legs were also very strong and were able to keep me at bay for quite some time as I struggled to get a hold of her. The whole time, she was laughing madly and taunting me. Eventually, I managed to pin her down, holding her hands above her head. She looked sexier than ever as I held her in that compromising position, as if she was surrendering herself for me to do as I please with her.

“You’re mine tonight Charlotte, you know that? I’m gonna have a lot fun with you.”

“Mmm-hmm,” she replied, pretending to grimace uncomfortably, but a smile escaped her lips as she seemed to relish in the thought of me using her.

I started going to work on her chest, sucking and biting on her breasts. That seemed to drive her more crazy than anything I had done to her that night, especially when I sucked on her nipples. Her breasts were relatively small, but quite firm, and her nipples were perked up just nicely for me to hold in my lips. My erection was harder than I’ve ever felt before, but I wanted to make sure she was primed and ready for me to go inside her. I continued to hold her down as I kissed my way down her body, making my way to her thighs and just barely licking the outside of her pelvis. I could feel her whole body convulse as I traced my tongue close to her pussy, and she responded with an affirmative “Mmmmmmmmmmm” sound that was music to my ears. I freed up one hand to grip the back of her scalp, pulling back on her hair while simultaneously delivering another round of vicious bites and suction to her neck. I escalated my teasing, taking off my underwear fully and rubbing my rock-solid cock against her panties.

“Oh yes, I want you inside me riiiiight noooowww,” she pleaded as I thrusted.

“I bet you do, you greedy slut,” I responded.

“Oh fuck yes, I’m your slut, I want you to use me like the dirty fucking slut I am.”

Hearing those words come out of her mouth was a bit unexpected, but I enjoyed hearing them just as well. I ripped off her panties, and immediately noticed that she was practically gushing.

“You’re so fucking wet right now,” I remarked.

“Yeah,” she replied, breathlessly.

Scarcely able to contain my excitement, I slid my index and middle fingers inside her pussy. With a few motions of my fingers, she was writhing and scarcely able to contain screams of pleasure.

“No fingers, I want that cock, I want your cock inside me right now!” she demanded.

Without a word, I retreated my fingers, positioning myself to enter inside her. She spread her legs as far apart as possible, and used her hands to spread her pussy apart as well. Even with her labia spread as far open as possible, I had trouble fitting myself inside her. My cock is about average length, but is extremely girthy. The thought of using lube popped up in my mind, but I decided to just go for it anyways. I grabbed onto her hips and slid my cock inside her pussy, helped by the natural lubrication that she produced in anticipation of my cock. After a few brief half-thrusts to lube up my cock, I pushed it in as far as possible with a slow, controlled thrust. As I felt her tight, warm pussy envelop my cock, I was already starting to envision how I wanted to finish her; with a massive, impregnating load of semen. I wanted her to drip with that sticky white liquid and have it soak through her panties for the whole weekend.

I snapped out of my vision and looked down at Charlotte. She looked deeply into my eyes and told me that she always thought I was extremely handsome, and had fantasized about me for weeks. I told her that I felt the same way about her, and gave her several deep, powerful thrusts to express my satisfaction. She moaned loudly as I pushed my cock as far as possible, and just as she was catching her breath, I started rhythmically pounding her pussy. Thankfully, the time I spent in the gym doing hip thrusts paid off, as she was left breathless from the thrusts I delivered. I leaned my head down and bit down onto her neck while continuing to thrust, and almost immediately felt a convulsion through her body. She let out her loudest moan yet, and told me that she had just came from those neck bites. I asked if she needed a break, but she told me to keep going.

I flipped Charlotte over and started doggy style, gripping her hair and gently yanking her head backwards. Despite her muscle, she was still quite small, and I was somewhat afraid of hurting her. However, she seemed to sense my hesitation and said to me, “harder, fuck me like you hate me!” I pulled on her hair harder and gave her ass a reverberating smack. After weeks of watching her ass on the treadmill, I was overjoyed at getting to feel it in person. “Oh fuck yes, punish me!” she said in response. I gave her more smacks to that nice, firm ass of hers, then pulled her by her hair over to the edge of my bed so we could be seen in the mirror above my bathroom sink. I had done this before with girls, and all of them found it extremely hot. Charlotte was no exception.

“Look at yourself, you fucking slut. Look at how much you enjoy being fucked, and I’m not even wearing a condom. You’re so fucking filthy to let me use you like this,” I said to Charlotte, using one hand to reach around and grip her throat as I fucked her from behind.

“I don’t care, I don’t want a condom, I want you to finish inside me. I’m on birth control,” she said.

“I’m not even close to being finished with you,” I said back to her. Now that I knew she wanted me to cum inside her, I felt even more obligated to do so.

I briefly pulled out of her and invited her to mount me. Once again, she had a bit of trouble fitting it in at first, although she was wet enough that it didn’t take as long as the first time. Those athletic legs of hers did wonders as she bobbed up and down on my cock. I assisted her by thrusting my hips in time with her legs to ensure that she was getting as much of my cock as possible. She looked extremely pleased from our session so far, and she said to me that she wanted me inside her every night. I reached out to grab her tits, and she reciprocated, bending over slightly so I could raise my head up and suck on her nipples once again. In response to the sucking, she started bouncing her hips faster. I thrusted harder in return, and after about 30 seconds of progressively faster riding, I said to her “You’d do anything for this cock, wouldn’t you?” That phrase seemed to be a huge turn-on for her, and she let out another orgasmic moan. “I just came again,” she said, dripping with sweat.

“It’s my turn now,” I said, sliding out from underneath her and pinning her to the bed. “I’m going to fuck you until you can’t walk tomorrow.” I wrapped one hand around Charlotte’s throat and squeezed gently.

“You call that choking me?” she said devilishly. “Try harder, little boy.” She seemed to be switching roles from submissive to dominant. “I’ll show you, little girl,” I said back to her, tightening my grip around her throat. Charlotte took her fingers and raked them across my back, causing me pain but also pleasing me greatly. Fighting for dominance is a massive turn-on for me. She started squirming to get out from underneath me, and I struggled to stay on top. I used my bodyweight to hold her in place, punishing her for her disobedience with several deep, slow thrusts that almost seemed to reach her cervix. She managed to slip out from underneath me, then took her fingernails and dragged them down my chest. “I bet you think you’re such a man, don’t you?” she asked, licking her lips. “And I bet you think you’re such a strong, powerful woman,” I said in response. She quickly tackled me, and although I could have easily stopped her, I wanted to see what she would do with me at her mercy.

Charlotte stood over me for a moment, then turned around, placing her ass directly in my face. “You’re going to please me, little boy,” she said. I started licking her pussy, and she went to work on my cock once again. It was the first time I’ve done the 69 position, and doing it with Charlotte made me fall in love with it. After sucking on my cock for a bit, she started licking my ballsack. The feeling of her tongue was extremely overwhelming, and I started laughing uncontrollably and instinctively tried to push her off me. “Oh, are your balls that sensitive?” she said coyly. She gave my balls another long, lingering lick, causing me to practically have a seizure with how overwhelming the stimuli of her tongue was. “I know just how to humiliate a man like you,” Charlotte said to me, straddling me with her legs. She pinned my arms above my head, telling me that she was going to tease me until I cum. We started kissing again, but she was now taking the dominant role by biting on my neck, leaving vicious hickeys. She bit hard on my shoulder several times, then eyed my chest.

“Mmm, such a muscular man, I do love a muscular man,” Charlotte said, sucking on my chest and and nipples. “All that muscle is extra sensitive too,” she continued.

Charlotte continued to kiss, bite, and lick all over my torso, occasionally giving my cock and balls a brief lick. I couldn’t take much more teasing, and used all my strength to throw Charlotte off of me. With all my strength. I grabbed her shoulders and threw her down into the bed.

“Little boy, huh?” I said, holding Charlotte’s arms above her head. She smiled, clearly relishing in the moment, but bit down hard on my arm. In response, I gave her a gentle slap. “Harder, little boy!” she demanded. She clearly wanted me to go all-out. I gave her another slap, this time much harder, and then pulled hard on the back of her hair while delivering more vicious bites to her neck, then breasts. She seemed extremely pleased from that, and I leaned in close to say to her,

“I’m going to show you who’s the man here. You know how?”

“Hmm?” she responded.

“I’m going to cum right inside that pussy. I own that pussy, and I can do as I please with it. You know what else?”

“What?” she said, with a wild grin on her face.

“I’m going to get you pregnant tonight.” I wasn’t entirely sure that Charlotte would respond positively to that, as I know it can be a somewhat sensitive topic. However, Charlotte responded very enthusiastically to what I said to her.

“Yessssss, please, I want you to get me pregnant. Fill me up, pleeeeaaaase,” Charlotte said to me in a begging tone of voice.

With that, I gave Charlotte the fastest, hardest thrusts I could muster. I was somewhat exhausted by that point, but gave her all the energy I had left. I wrapped my hand tight around her throat, making animalistic grunting noises as I pounded her pussy into oblivion. I could feel her orgasm again, but didn’t stop. I wanted so badly to fill her and wasn’t going to stop for anything. Her face was completely flushed, and she looked nearly out of breath. I envisioned once again how perfect and hot she would look with my cum dripping from her pussy. I closed my eyes and pictured the image in my mind, then opened them again and looked down at her face, realizing that she was directly looking into my eyes.

“Cum inside me, cum inside me,” she repeated quietly.

I mustered otherworldly energy and thrusted even harder and faster.

“I want you to cum inside me, get me pregnant, pleaaaase,” she said, much louder.

As I looked deep into her eyes and heard those words straight from her lips, I could feel a rush from the base of my cock to the tip.

“I’m gonna cum, I’m gonna cum,” I said.

“YES, CUM INSIDE ME,” she practically yelled out.

With that said, I finally let loose what I had been building up the entire night. I pushed out a practical tsunami of semen as deep as possible, directly into Charlotte’s pussy. It was the kind of ejaculation where just when you think you’re finished, another wave of semen rushes out, like the aftershock of an earthquake. I leaned my head backwards and exhaled loudly, relishing the moment, while Charlotte let out one final gasp of ecstasy as my juices flooded inside her pussy. I gave a final couple thrusts, then finally pulled my cock out. Semen was still dripping from the tip. My cock was extremely sore by that point, but I didn’t care at all. Charlotte sat up and I examined her pussy, spreading her labia and letting some more milky white fluid run down her thighs. Charlotte turned to face the mirror once again, relishing in the sight of my excess juices leaking out from inside her.

“That was really, really fucking hot,” she said to me.

“Oh yeah, that felt really fucking good,” I said back to her. “You are really on birth control, right?” I said, as I started to get a tinge of nervousness.

“Yes, I promise. I’m definitely not ready to actually get pregnant,” she replied.

I was relieved to hear that from her, and we started cuddling for a bit. We were completely silent for about 15 minutes, relishing in the pleasure we had just felt from getting to fuck after many weeks of slowly growing attraction to each other. Eventually, we started pillowtalk. It got surprisingly deep, and we both decided that we would continue to see each other. Charlotte and I have fucked several times since then, and we have a lot of fun with each other as we try out new positions and roles. Tonight, we’re planning on experimenting with her dominating me the entire night.

I’m not exactly sure if I’m ready for a long-term relationship at this point, but Charlotte is hot, athletic, and our sexual chemistry is off the charts. I’m very glad I took the initiative to speak to her, and even if things end up eventually fizzling out between us, I will have been more than satisfied with our time spent together.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/qur5ir/mf_giving_my_hot_athletic_neighbor_a_messy