[MFM] Her first time with two cocks, last minute, at 7AM, has easily become one of my favorite threesomes of all time.

##The Context:

I’m a late 30’s total dad bod academic with olive skin that moved back to my undergrad alma mater during the pandemic to teach part-time and fuck around full-time. Feels important to say that I don’t fuck my own students, at least not while they are my students. Besides, there’s five other colleges within 30 minutes of me, so aside from awkward boomer colleagues disapproving how often their students know me and I them, this gig is a good life and full of free time. Free time I’ve used to explore polyamory (multiple romantic and committed relationships at once), which I consider the most advanced form of non-monogamy (have been swinging and otherwise open my entire adult life, lost my virginity in a group sex scenario and never looked back).

My biggest kink is fulfilling fantasies, comfortably pushing experiences into the unknown, and otherwise making my partners feel totally worshiped and slutty at the same time – hearing *”I can’t believe we did that”* and *”that was the best orgasm of my life”* gets my ego just as hard as my cock. One of my favorite go-to’s, if not the absolute best, for that effect is the first-time MFM threesome.

That’s where Abigale comes in. She’s 22, Irish-level alabaster skin with auburn hair, a senior ready to graduate and make her mark upon the world. One boyfriend, met through some prudish Christian sorority/fraternity mixer, lost her virginity to him two summers ago. When he broke up with her literally days later and she couldn’t stop thinking it was her fault for being “bad at sex”, one of her more experienced friends gave her my number. Her first text to me was “so I hear you can help ruin my life? <3” and two hours later she was bent over my bed squirting for the first time while another girlfriend sat in the corner tied up (she wanted to explore cuckqueaning, so I figured I’d kill two birds with one bone).

That was about a year ago and while her body image and self esteem still sometimes wavers, I am so proud at her new approach to her sexuality and you can see that confidence oozing out into other aspects of her life, especially school. Since then, the number of “firsts” we’ve explored for her (and many for myself) has hit so many notes. First blowjob, first anal, first outdoor play, first time playing with a girl – if she names it, I make it happen. Her biggest kinks are free use, DDLG, and breeding, and with how serious our relationship has gotten, I could see myself eventually knocking off the manwhore vibes and knocking her up. We’ve literally never had anything but amazing sex, to the point where we’ve both agreed the first time we do have a session that’s less than stellar, we’ll go out and celebrate.

The “reward” for me meeting Abby’s parents was the green light (we use the stoplight system of safewords) to share her with another guy. I didn’t need incentive to meet them at all, they love me and I them, it isn’t awkward even though it probably should be, and we’re going back for the holidays. But challenging each other like that is something we do often and ever since she knew I was actively looking and planning, she’d been even more eager than I was.

*”I can’t wait for Daddy to share me with his friends”* while I fuck her with my cock and a jelly dildo at the same time has become one of her favorites. We’ve had regular MFF threesomes and reverse gangbangs, but pussy isn’t really her thing so that was all for me and other girlfriends. And despite my encouragement for her to date and fuck as she pleases as long as she’s safe and has open communication, I was still only the second cock she’s ever had. Her only caveat: it couldn’t be a student and it couldn’t be anyone I knew previously, which I understood completely, Abby always needs a bit more of a princess touch and still struggles in preventing comparison between herself and my other partners in her head.

##The Setup:

Abby and I had gone to bed at 2:30 that morning feeling dejected and annoyed because the guy we’d found after sifting through so many replies, talked to all day and otherwise connected with and ready to meet, had completely ghosted us just minutes after we checked into the hotel room booked specifically for the three of us. Not being my first rodeo and knowing single guys love to blow their load on chat to the idea of real sex and then ghost, I even had a backup guy. Recent tests confirmed, also a good communicator, totally got that while some bi play was good the focus should be on her. He got off of work that evening, was at home showering and then BOOM… also ghosted.

Given my description above, you can imagine what this did to Abby’s mood and self-esteem, who was sleeping inside still in her lingerie: a lacy bra with free nipples, sheer backless panties that provided complete access to her holes, garters attached to thigh highs with bows at the top, and another bow in her hair – all matching, pink and white, the perfect combination to say “adorable slut”. We hadn’t had sex all day yesterday, which had never happened before, normally we can’t go a couple hours without me filling her up, even on road trips. And we’d fallen asleep with me gently edging her pussy. *”Shh, just let Daddy play”* makes her gush every time.

I was sitting in the car outside the hotel around 7am when Grindr pinged. The profile was in-between our ages, bi and verse, well written, good pictures, and otherwise hit all the notes. We chatted a bit with me basically venting about the two flakes, not thinking anything was possible. And then I realized he was just a few hundred feet away. Yep, same hotel. I asked him if he liked weed and wanted to smoke a bowl. A couple minutes later a tall slim black guy with a cute face and big hands opened the car door and sat down in the passenger seat with a *”What’s good?”*

After some initial conversation I use to make others more comfortable and a half bowl, we really hit it off. Jordan loved all the pics and videos of us I had on my phone and just completely got the vibe I was looking for and thought the sample scenario I described sounded perfect. He had experience with couples and sharing his own ex girlfriend, didn’t need to be prompted to ask about safety and pregnancy concerns (such a green flag), and was able to pull up test results from the week before on his medical records app, had an impressive education and job, had been a while since he’d had any sex, and was just the right amount of nervous but otherwise totally game. I really could not have asked for a better match and found myself pleased that all the other plans had fallen through.

During our conversation I’d seen Abigale’s good morning text asking where I was, so I texted back:

*”Be on the bed edging yourself when I come back inside. Daddy found the perfect guy to share you with.”*

*”what?! now? how?”*

*”Yep, he’s in the car smoking with me. Meets all of our criteria and then some. That okay?”*

*”omg I’m nervous, but yes.”*

There are emojis in there too, but this is Reddit so just imagine lots of monkeys covering their eyes and dirty winking faces.

We left the car and I handed him the door key card and said something like *”The room is 504, give me a couple minutes with her to make sure she’s comfortable and doesn’t feel pressured, then come up when I ping you. No promises or expectations, remember her safewords, but it sounds like this is about to be awesome.”*

##The Deed:

I felt Abby jump a bit when we both heard the door to our hotel open and close. Jordan walked in and saw her in the middle of the bed, laying on her back, me still clothed on the far side of the bed with one hand between her legs and another pinching the nipple her bra did nothing to hide. He kicked off his shoes and came right over to her other side to join me. We groped and caressed her, both of us reaching for multiple fingers of coconut oil to massage into her shoulders, thighs, and legs.

*”Flip over and show my friend how good your ass looks in your new outfit,*” I said Abby obliged with a giggle.

More coconut oil, four hands, and us both taking turns with the percussion massager she’d been edging herself with before we came in had her a loose relaxed wet mess in a matter of minutes. She arched her ass up when Jordan’s fingers began circling her bud, *”I bet this ass is a pleasure to fuck”* as he slipped one knuckle in. We continued talking about her and degrading her as if she wasn’t in the room, each phrase eliciting more gasps and moans from her. After a few minutes, she was practically on her knees from lifting her ass up to put more pressure between our hands and her pussy. I unhooked the bra and pulled it out from under her, smacking each side of her ass one after another, just enough to leave a slight handprint, with a *”Turn over again”*.

*”I think it’s time he gets to taste this magic pussy of yours, what do you think?”* I said. Jordan didn’t even wait for her to respond, nor do I think Abby was capable of many words at this point. She just nodded with her mouth open as he assumed a position at the foot of the bed. Her already wide eyes drilled up into mine as his tongue hit her clit. In the car, I’d basically given him the playbook to her pussy, so immediately the volume of her moans doubled. *”But remember, you don’t get to cum unless there’s a cock inside you.”* She could barely gasp a *”yes”* in response.

I knelt down beside Jordan and we each took a leg, spreading her as wide as we could. In unison we made a trail of sloppy and biting kisses down her thigh until we were each licking and sucking on a lip of her pussy. At first we took turns on her clit, he went high, I went low, he went left, I went right, but eventually our tongues were just dancing together all over Abby’s pussy, the both of us always finding a way to make fitting two mouths between her legs. At one point Jordan left me, and I peered up between her folds to see him sucking on her freed boobs, his right hand on the other with his left around her neck. I licked two fingers and put them right at her entrance, applying slight swirls of pressure at the roof of pussy, more tight than I’d ever felt it.

And then… SMACK. Jordan backhanded her face with a *”Didn’t we just say you don’t get to cum yet?”* The slap was just the right amount of force, exactly as I told him she loves. Just enough to leave her cheek red. Abby looked right at me with a *”omg, how much did you tell him?!”* face then back to Jordan with a timid *”yes sir”*. As if he could read her mind, Jordan said, *”That’s right, your Daddy told me everything”*.

Now knowing Jordan was cool playing up the DDLG, I hopped off the bed and started undressing and Jordan followed my lead. *”Are you gonna be a good girl for Daddy and his friend or does he need to slap you again?”* Already in total sub/little space, Abby merely nodded with an open mouth and total blowjob eyes.

We resumed our positions and she reached out with her arms. The look on her face feeling two cocks get hard in her hand was priceless, total slutty glee and exactly why MFM is my favorite threesome combo. We got a little closer so both our now-hard cocks were laying across her face and she went back and forth licking and rubbing them across her lips. I can still perfectly visualize the contrast between his black cock, my tanned cock, and her pale face as I write this. And it felt even better when she rubbed our cocks together in her mouth at the same time. We had each a hand between her legs and she pulled our us away from her mouth to say *”will somebody please fuck me already?”*, which elicited a slap of my own across her face. Now all four of her cheeks were flushed.

*”Lift your butt”* I said, positioning a pillow under her, *”As luck would have it, Jordan here got tested just last week, so he’s going to fill you up.”

*”My very first creampie”*, Jordan quipped. Which elicited another giggle from Abby and an *”Oh shit, you are in for a treat”* from me.

After Jordan positioned himself in front of her, I took his cock in my left hand and rubbed it up and down her pussy. By the time I positioned him with a *”Lean forward a bit”*, he was even harder and Abby had begun bucking her hips. The head of his cock had barely entered her, my right hand now on her clit with the left still around his shaft, before Abby screamed *”oh my god”* louder than she ever had. Her face was twisted in pure agony as waves of shudders rippled from her shoulders down to her thighs. I let go of Jordan’s cock to help hold her in place and give him more room to thrust.

And then, still within the very first thrust, Jordan goes *”Oh shit”*, pulls out due to I guess habit, and completely hoses her down. My hands, her abdomen, even her face and hair, just rope after rope of thick cum blasting from his twitching cock. His orgasm lasted so long I counted at least three more solid spurts after putting my hand back with a slight jerking motion.

As soon as they were both breathing again, I took more control. *”Swap positions, you sit up so she can blow you while I fuck her from behind”*

After they both got into position, I immediately noticed that Jordan’s pull out game wasn’t that strong. Her pussy was dripping cum and still so tight I’d have needed lube without it. She was cumming again before thrust three. I bottomed out and reached around to flick her clit only to hear gasps and gargles as she tried and failed to keep Jordan’s growing cock in her mouth. After seeing the look of pure bliss on Jordan’s face and a *”yes Daddy!”* from Abby in response to my *”You ready slut?”*, I really started to fuck her just how I know she likes. Shallow, deep full thrust, find the spot and just don’t pull out much to keep hitting it, once she’s cumming, go shallow again. Once I got a rhythm, it wasn’t enough for Jordan to hold her hair back for her, he switched to completely bracing his arms against her shoulders and even pushing her back onto me in perfect tempo with my thrusts. It may have been the hardest I’ve ever fucked her, almost to the point where I couldn’t feel much and she was left with bruises.

It was only a few minutes before I heard a *”yellow”* from Abby, so I pulled out, jumped off the bed, and grabbed two water bottles from the fridge (nice catch Jordan!). A breather and a little bit of water was all she needed for more. *”It’s time for you to ride Daddy”*, I said. Jordan and Abby hopped off the bed and set their water down. I gestured to the little hotel desk covered in toys from my travel bag, *”Use anything you like, with good judgement, and when you’re ready, slide in with me”*.

Watching her climb on top of me while she used her hand to impale herself on my cock must have been the last he needed to be fully ready again because Jordan opted not to use any toys. At first she rode me leaning back into him, her right hand on his cock and her left arm wrapped around his head behind her. God she’s so hot. Definitely another platinum mental image for the spankbank. Jordan was kissing her neck and biting her shoulders with both hands spreading her ass. Eventually she let go of him and fell into me. I held her close as I started to thrust from below. I felt Jordan’s hands on my balls, which I *”Yellowed”* simply because they are too sensitive to any extra stimulation before I’ve cum once. He let up and said, *”Toss me the oil”*.

I stopped thrusting to do so but then stayed still to watch her face as I felt him push two fingers into her pussy alongside my cock. We’d used toys for DVP before, but his ability to curl his fingers back and forth, pushing my cock into her g-spot, meant that once I started thrusting even the tiniest bit, Abby was cumming doubly hard that she had yet. Just guttural moans, completely gone. And before she could come back to her senses, I felt his fingers retreat and the slight bounce in the mattress as he positioned himself and his cock.

It did take us some time to get both cocks in, but once we had it, words don’t begin to describe just how stupid awesome real DVP with two cocks is. Abby immediately went back to eyes-in-the-back-of-her-head status as soon as we found a back and forth rhythm. Jordan couldn’t keep his eyes up, what a sight that must have been, and when I felt him slide a finger in her ass, I lifted her up a bit with one hand around her neck and was able to get a thumb on her clit. At this point thrusting for me wasn’t an option, but Jordan started going ham. I was basically crushing her clit with my thumb and when she came, I immediately moved my hand from her clit and shoved two fingers in her mouth because her screams were just rock concert-level at this point. Then I heard Jordan moan hard as he bottomed out, the warm cum covering my cock as both of them twitched and spasmed finally had me explode with a thrust of my own. And then suddenly we both just flew out of her pussy and Abby started squirting. I’ve never heard so many ways someone can say the word *”wow”* but it was the only word in her lexicon as we all climbed off of each other.

I grabbed towels as Jordan got dressed, it was 9am at this point and he was late for work. We did both get his number and are planning to meet again, both all three of us together and each separately. Abby and I continued to have just the most amazing sex, rehashing the encounter and reaffirming our connection to each other. The anal against the wall of the steam shower was especially hot.

And now she’s asking questions about the logistics of a gangbang…

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/qtu193/mfm_her_first_time_with_two_cocks_last_minute_at