Author’s note: I was going to wait a while before touching this story again but U/NiggooGW left a comment that made me laugh and inspired me to go ahead and give you the next part so shout out to him/her.
“Anal?” I felt my cock stir.
I looked at Sarah wondering if she could tell how excited I was pretending not to be. Anal was one of her hard limits, I made the mistake of trying to go for a finger when drunk and almost suffered a kick to the face. She held a smile albeit apprehensive letting me go and sipping her coffee.
“Yes, I like butt stuff and if you are a good boyfriend maybe I’ll play with your butt too!” She squeezed my midsection before bursting into laughter. I must have tensed at the idea of my butt getting attention.
She got up and replaced Sarah between my legs giving me our first kiss. “Don’t worry, I’ll be gentle.”
This was happening so fast my brain was caught between logic and arousal. At this point the coffee was an ill planned diversion since I couldn’t even reach it with Casey occupying my space allowing me a close up at her breasts that I could now see had some tan lines.
Sarah played the aggressor last night being that she was in control feeding herself with arousal and intoxication. Today it seemed the tables had turned and in the light of day Casey was the more sexually agressive one, how do I not fuck this up?
I had to be the one in control. I made up my mind and kissed Casey deeply, grabbing her ass and forcing her to moan in my mouth. “You want this dick, you gotta wait for coffee.”
“Mmm, yes Daddy.” She purred, seemingly liking my attempt at control, calling me something Sarah never did. She let me go and rubbed her hand over Sarah’s back who now wore a smile behind her steaming cup.
I do not know about anyone else in the world but a naked woman, in my kitchen with the morning sun glowing behind her holding a cup of coffee and a smile is primo erotica in my eyes. I relished the view while Casey rested behind her putting her hands around Sararhs waist placing her head on her shoulder looking at me before kissing Sarah’s neck.
“Since Daddy needs his coffee.” She kissed up her neck and nibbled on her ear. Sarah’s focus immediately drifted away from me to the sensation she was feeling. Her legs uncrossed and opened as if Casey was commanding her via telepathy.
“How about I take you back to bed and I can see what you taste like.” One hand slipped between my girlfriend’s legs and I watched her eyes flutter to a close as she struggled to keep the coffee cup in her hand while pressure was being added to her clit and lips roaming her neck.
“I have never fucked a woman before, I am figuring this out as I go. All I know is, I like it and I am sure you will teach me about every little thing you like, want you?” I couldn’t have been more erect if they replaced my blood vessels with iron.
“Mmhmm.” Sarah nodded shakily, putting her cup down, opening herself up to her friend, seemingly forgetting the hangover that plagued her minutes ago.
“Good. Well Daddy.” She looked up at me and spread Sarah’s lips with her fingers exposing my girlfriend’s pussy to me as if I had never seen it, somehow wrestling any control I had away from me.
“I am about to take our girlfriend to have my first real lesbian experience. When you are ready to say fuck coffee my ass will be waiting.” Casey smiled, taking Sarah’s hand and guiding her out of the kitchen.
Sarah looked back and mouthed “OH MY GOD!” with a smile before disappearing down the hallway.
I looked at my coffee, I looked at my cock straining to understand why it was ignored. “What the fuck just happened?”
I was stunned and picked up my cup just out of a need to do something with my hands while my brain caught up. “What am I doing!” I put my coffee down and sprinted down the hall coming into the room just in time to see Sarah on her back legs spread with Caseys fingers buried in her. Casey swayed her ass at me looking back at me.
“Just in time Daddy, I am about to taste her for the first time.”
My brain was too slow. I needed to regain control.
“No.” I got on the bed grabbing her waist and pulling her to the end of the bed. Casey wanted control because she was new to our relationship but it was still OUR relationship and SHE was the addition.
“Sarah sweetheart, come help me fuck our new toys ass.” I gripped Casey’s waist and pulled her to me and without hesitation she dropped into her arch and looked back at me with a sly smile.
“Yes Daddy.” She smiled scooting towards us using a title I never got from her, she usually just called me “babe”, somehow I had graduated. I reached out to her while sliding my cock up and down Casey’s exposed slit refusing to penetrate.
I kissed Sarah smiling at her. “What did you call her last night? Tell her what she is.”
I slapped Casey’s ass, still meeting Sarah’s eyes. Casey moaned attempting to back up on my dick, I moved. “She’s a slut.” Sarah beamed.
I slapped her ass again. “Tell her what she is, baby.”
“Shes a little anal whore.” Sarah growled at me, kissing me intensely, grabbing my dick and stroking it, teasing her friend who tried to catch the tip to rock back on it.
“I am your little anal whore Daddy please fuck me.” Casey begged in desperation and lust.
I slapped her ass as hard as I could and we both watched my handprint turn red on her ass while she moaned.
“Fuck this is so hot, fuck her Daddy.” Sarah whispered to me stroking my dick a little too hard proving how turned on she was.
I put my hand on hers and slowed her down looking her in the eye. “Put your dick in her.”
I tried not to think, whoever was in control of my overly stimulated brain was not to be disturbed. Whatever deep primal personality that had laid dormant up until this point needed his time in the sun. My Sarah, my sweet Sarah, the woman that was just a few days ago thought being freaky was sucking my dick while I played computer games kissed me and pushed my dick into her best friend.
She held onto the base of my dick while Casey desperately fucked the half she had access too. Her pussy was soaked and feeling how wet she was while feeling the same heat in Sarah’s mouth while our tongues danced was a combination I would crave forever. Casey let out staccato breaths under us slapping her hips back trying to get me deeper and without warning Sarah let go just in time for her to take my entire length in one stroke.
“OOOHHH Fuck!” Casey shuddered, pulling back to the tip of my cock and slowly taking it all, wiggling the whole way down my shaft. We both watched her get comfortable and pick up speed again.
Sarah took her wet hand and brought it to my chin turning my face towards her and licked Casey’s wet pussy off her pinky. “Fuck her good Daddy.” She moaned, leaning back on her ass and spreading her legs to play with herself watching us.
I focused my attention on Casey grabbing her waist again and meeting her thrusts causing a forceful slap of her ample ass on my thighs. She let out a guttural moan as I started to pump in and out of her. I slapped her ass trying not to lose my rhythm getting into the feeling of a new pussy and trying not to cum too early.
Casey beat me to it screaming out and pulling herself away from my cock as she bucked in orgasm. I slapped her ass hard while she came and looked at Sarah who was rubbing her clit furiously and pulling a nipple her eyes transfixed on her friend. Casey in mid recovery threw her ass back up.
“Please fuck my ass, cum in it Daddy please.” She begged, reaching back spreading her ass showing her needy hole for only a moment before she filled it with one finger then two roughly pushing them in and out.
Sarah moved quickly, grabbing my cock and leaning down to spit on it, stroking it again to be the gatekeeper for her friend’s pleasure. I moved my hands and let the two women work together to line me up and press my cock against her ass. Up until this point I had never done this before and didn’t know what to expect. I pressed hard while Sarah held on with her eyes trained on Caseys opening. Casey groaned into the mattress while we watched her ass open up slowly and swallow the head of my cock. Sarah spit again, rubbing it into my shaft while Casey controlled the depth in which she was penetrated.
Sarah relocated behind me putting one hand on my chest and the other on the base of my cock massaging my balls with her fingertips and planting kisses on my neck. “Cum in her ass Daddy I know you are close.” She whispered.
I nodded in agreement feeling her tight ass slide closer and closer taking it all.
“Fuck Daddy yessss!” Casey forced out from under me picking up the pace. “Fuck me, fuck me!” She cried out.
I felt the sensation in my balls coming as I thrust in her tight back door. Sarah felt it and moaned in my ear to cum, Casey felt me stiffen and screamed.
“GIVE ME ALL OF IT DADDY!”
My cock exploded, I couldn’t hold myself up and Sarah acted as my counterbalance rubbing my balls forcing them to give up everything I had. Casey was relentlessly thrusting back in full strokes letting her sphincter grip my sensitive head and push in causing me to convulse and feel the tinge of pain from over stimulation. I gritted my teeth pushing my breath out in a deep groan while my two women tried to force me into a heart attack before casy let me go and fell forward.
I fell right on top of her and rolled over trying to catch my breath seeing spots in my vision. The room was filled with nothing but labored breaths for several minutes until Sarah climbed next to me kissing me and whispering in my ear kissing my cheek.
“I love you.”
Of course not to be left out Casey rolled over and kissed me whispering in my ear.
“You fuck me like that again I am goign to fall in love too.”
I smiled sandwiched between the two of them. “A wise friend u/NiggooGW once said “Fuck Coffee!” And they were right.
We burst into a fit of giggles and drifted off to sleep once more.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/plxrp7/sharing_is_caring_two_girls_one_bf_pt_2