I understand that the title is an absolute trip for anyone not prepared. So let me be the guiding hand that leads you into this (grantedly) fucked up, but very hot and exciting situation for me and my boytoy. Now my BF is what I call a pseudo-cuck. I doubt that’s the right term, but the principle is he likes me “cheating” on him. I put cheating in quotations because I have permission to mess around with any guy I want, but he is aware. The difference between him and what I consider to be full blow cuckholding is that he doesn’t like me to humiliate or directly push it in his face. There’s no bringing a bull home in front of him. It’s just small stuff like leaving my Reddit Chat or Fetlife open on my laptop for him to see. Or coming home with marks or obvious signs of sex. Anyways, we both absolutely love each other and love how sexually adventurous we are. He knows I have an incest kink and he has the cheating kink, so an idea started to formulate.
He thought it would be incredibly hot if I seduced and fucked his dad. Because of our relationship, this dad will very likely become my father-in-law one day. So this was fairly extreme for us, but something we both began to fantasize about heavily. There was even a period where my boyfriend “mentioned” that it would be pretty hot if I started cheating on him with some older guys in his father’s age range. All of this is buildup to what was the desired outcome. Now my father-in-law (I know that’s not what he is yet, but it makes the story easier to say. Forgive me) is a wonderful man. He’s been single for a good decade now and is always looking for a girlfriend or someone. I’ve talked to one of his ex-gfs when we were drunk and trust me, dude may be older but he is still as virile as an ox. So the plan was formulated. I would slowly use the time when we were together to try to seduce him.
We’re together most Summers as we spend half of our vacation time at my family’s house and the other half at his. We also mix up holidays and try to spread those evenly as well. Point is, during the Summer my father-in-law has a cabin near a lake in the Black Hills of South Dakota. We love spending time their for the camping, trial riding, and swimming. I’ve mainly used this time to push for that seduction. Standard stuff. Being very touchy feely with him. Wearing clothing that would barely count as clothing or swimsuits. Just in anyway trying to get him to notice me. I’ve also managed to manufacture an incident where he walked in on me naked in the bathroom after a night of heavy drinking. Each Summer he seems to buy in a little more and more. Becoming more comfortable. Becoming more appreciative. In fact, this Summer he even let me sit on his lap when he was sober. I won’t list it all, but I know there have been some wanting looks sent my way or nights spent pleasuring himself to the thought of me. I’ll always remember the time I lost a pair of panties and found them in my father-in-law’s bedroom.
All of this is to say I know somewhere in his heart he wanted me. So, I took the chance and took the dive this Summer. In June, we were in the Hills with him. Simply having fun. My father-in-law has a pontoon style boat and that’s where we spend a lot of our time when on the lake. My boyfriend was inside sleeping off a hangover while my father-in-law and I were about a hundred yards out from the dock just floating and relaxing. I was sunbathing and he was very clearly trying not to look as he read a book on the front of the boat. I decided to take the chance. It was a Monday midday so there weren’t many people on the lake to see. I asked him to do the most cliché thing, but the only thing I could think of at the time. Put sunscreen on me. For all of those who just rolled your eyes, I did so as well while writing that. Either way, he agreed and I flipped over for him.
He was rubbing my back, but not in the way that a simple application of sunscreen would go. Rubbing like he wanted to feel more. So I invited him to do so. Asking him to make sure he got sunscreen everywhere. Under my bikini tie. On the sides of my breasts. Underneath my bottoms. Soon enough there wasn’t even any sunscreen and he was just feeling up where I told him to. I got him to untie my top so when I flipped around, he got me topless. I asked him to “put sunscreen” on my breasts since they were now exposed. But in a very specific way. I had him straddle my tummy as he did. So I could reach down and stroke the very obvious bulge in his pants. He felt up my breasts and gave them some love. I mean, for a girl who’s flatter chested, I love when any amount of attention is paid to me like that. All the standard stuff. Groping, squeezing, kissing, and sucking.
I finally managed to get a hand into his trunks and around his glorious cock. He’s pretty similar size to my bf and that’s not a bad size at all. Age didn’t slow this man down as I think he could have punched a hole through porcelain with that thing! Anyways, finally got him to take them off and let me blow him. I sucked his cock in a way I hope no one has ever done before. I worshipped that thing like my life depended on it. I even let him facefuck me. Fucking his daughter-in-law’s tight throat while pulling on my hair braids for leverage. We went like that for while before he decided to return the favor. Bending me over the side of the boat and eating me out from behind. I never would have guessed, but I think he liked the exhibition side of it. Having his slutty daughter-in-law bent over the boat and moaning his name while he ate me out. Finally, I couldn’t take it and begged for him to fuck me then and there.
He plowed into me from behind. He started gently at first, but there was a clearly defined moment it all changed. I called him Daddy. I begged for Daddy to fuck me silly. To “fuck me like his son never could”. As soon as I begged for my Daddy to fuck me like an animal, he did so. Right there on the lake, in sight of the beach and any other boats that may have passed by. Soon he wanted to lay down, but not in missionary. He pulled me back and slid his hands under my legs. This older man put me in a fucking full nelson almost. I’ve always dreamed of being fully fucked like that and he was the first to do so. My father-in-law rearranged my pussy practically with the angle and how hard he went. Fucking me wildly and growling like an animal. I rubbed my clit as he fucked me which brought a series of orgasms that easily are you there on my list of favorites. At some point I mentioned to him that “Daddy still had another hole he could use”.
I don’t know if he had always wanted anal and just never had before, but fuck if this man didn’t suddenly look like a kid in the candy store. In that same position, I helped guide him into my tight asshole and he went to the races. I’m thankful he let me stroke him with some spit first as he started fast. His demeanor changed. He had always been a cool and collected guy, but suddenly he was that 16 year old virgin trying not to finish within a minute on his first time. Moaning and bucking wildly. I enjoyed every second of it as he anally fucked me. Eventually we had to change positions again. This time me face down on the floor of the boat (thankfully it had softer carpet) and he was railing into me. My sweet father-in-law had become my sex crazed Daddy and was telling me about how I was his dirty slut and how I was acting like a perfect little whore for him. I loved every word that dripped from those lips. He switched a few times between my ass and pussy, but seemed to find a home fucking into my cunt from behind. I begged Daddy to choke me and he laid on my back while wrapping an arm around my neck. Squeezing lightly as he fucked me. It was almost everything I had ever dreamt of with him.
Eventually we had to finish. All good things come to an end. I begged Daddy to cum on my face and he obliged. Pulling out and standing. Letting me stroke and lick his cock until he finished. It wasn’t the biggest load but it felt great on my face. I sucked him dry and cleaned him. (Thank God I’m religious about anal cleaning) and we finally were done. It took him awhile to get in order, but afterwards we talked. I promised I’d keep it a secret from his son (obviously I didn’t, but you know the deal, he doesn’t). And we returned. I abandoned the whole “leaving clues” thing for the moment and just told my boyfriend what happened later that night. I think he’s jerked off to me telling him the story a few times now. My father-in-law and I haven’t done anything since, but we’re going back at Christmas. Maybe Daddy Santa can give me a present for being such a naughty girl~
That’s all I have. I’ll updated if anything happens. Hope you enjoyed!
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ph85a6/f_my_boyfriend_wanted_me_to_cheat_on_himwith_his
Damn, I’m so jealous of this story.
While I get the consensual cheating situation. Seems a bit wrong to get the father involved without him knowing its OK. Because if he doesn’t know its OK with his son, he might be in a serious moral quandary as to come clean. If he doesn’t come clean, wouldn’t your BF lose trust in his father knowing that he is willing to bang his GF without his consent and not tell him?
So fucking hot.