Me and my girlfriend were tricked into having an orgy [MF]

This takes place maybe around 2 months after my last story, in the build up to Christmas. It was a Saturday and me and Mary were spending the day together, we had no plans. We just chilled at her house, watching Christmas films and just relaxing.

At around 3ish, 4ish maybe Mary got a phone call from Emily. In the time that has passed from my last story to this one, Emily was in a kind of relationship now, a guy she was friends with benefits with had asked her if they wanted to start dating. Emily said yes and as far as I was aware, things were going well. I’d met him a few times before, let’s call him James. He was older than us, like 24 or something. Pretty good looking, better looking than I was, baby faced with a floofy fringe and pretty toned, but quite small like 5ft 5 maybe, he was very easy going, friendly, funny, just a nice guy really.

Mary picked up the phone “Hey Em, whats up?” She said. A conversation between the two started and I took myself to the toilet. When I came back Mary was out of bed and getting dressed. “Whats going on?” I asked.

“Emily asked what we were up to, I said not much and she said we should go out for dinner with her, Maddy and James” she replied. This didn’t bother me, I liked spending time with her mates, but at the same time it was freezing outside and I did enjoy being warm inside with just Mary. “Sweet” I replied “where are we going?” I asked

Emily wanted to go to an Indian restaurant just in town from Mary’s, we agreed we would meet at 6. Me and Mary got ready and walked 10 minutes to the restaurant. It was freezing outside, when we got to the restaurant we couldn’t see anyone so we got inside and got a table. Maddy turned up less than 2 minutes after us, she sat down and we made casual conversation. It must have been 6.15 before Emily and James arrived. We all sat down and ordered out food, we chatted and had a few drinks, I didn’t drink though, I still wasn’t mad about drinking after that one time.

Eventually the conversation got round to Emily and James’ relationship and exactly what it was. “So are you two like boyfriend and girlfriend for real now then?” Mary asked.

“Yeah, pretty much” Emily replied and James nodded “we really like each other, but we’ve still been afraid to put a label on it. We both want to stay open, as we’re young and I don’t know, we like to have fun”

“Emily said I can still fuck other people, as long as she knows about it, and its the same the other way around” James said

“Oh, oh uh, nice” Mary replied.

“Yeah its like what you guys have” Emily said to me and Mary. Mary blushed and said “oh no, were not polyamorous”

Emily looked confused “Really?” She asked “but what about you and Harry? Me and John?” She asked. Me and Mary didn’t really have answer, we just said we were happy experimenting with certain things, but always together and within certain boundaries, for example I couldn’t pick up a random girl and fuck her and Mary would be OK. Everytime we’ve opened up our relationship to other people we’ve been together and with people we both know well and trust. Emily and James weren’t like this, they could do whatever with whoever, as long as they didn’t keep it a secret from each other.

Maddy was still and virgin, she didn’t have much to input, but recently she had really come out of her shell a bit. She wasn’t awkward when sex was brought up anymore, she didn’t go red or hide. During this conversation she was nodding and listening, but obviously not inputting much.

We finished our food, I grabbed the bill, I have a good job that pays well and I don’t mind grabbing the bill in situations like this. Before we left we spoke about if we were going to all just go home or stay together, maddy said that her parents were away seeing some family for the weekend. We decided to crash at hers for a bit, it was only a 5 minute walk from the restaurant too.

We walked through the freezing cold and got to Maddy’s, I’d been here a couple of times before. It wasn’t an amazing house, but it was always clean and tidy, it was small but homey. We got inside and head into the living room. Maddy had a fireplace and we got a fire going, in no time at all it was nice and warm in the living room, we put on the TV and someone put on some peep show.

No one was really watching though, we were talking and laughing and eventually Emily was ready to get some drinks out, but Maddy didn’t want anyone drinking the alcohol her parents had, so Emily and James walked to the nearest corner shop to get some alcohol. When they left the fire was now really belting out some heat, I took off my jumper and so did Mary. The three of us chatted until Emily and James got back. They had only 1 big bottle of vodka and some coke.

I said I wasn’t going to drink, I had only had vodka once and wasn’t desperate to go near it again plus I had my car at Mary’s and had to drive home, everyone made a drink and we carried on talking. Eventually everyone had their jumper off due to the heat coming off the fire and Emily said we should play a game, she was always the person to instigate drinking games. She suggested we played never have I ever. And I can’t lie, I can’t remember what was being asked. But maddy was drinking A LOT. We eventually decided to stop playing as maddy was getting prettt drunk, plus the 4 that were drinking had got most of the way through the bottle of vodka already.

At this point, me and Mary were huddled together as were Emily and James. Me and Mary starting kissing, only playfully, but I could tell the alcohol had made Mary slightly horny, she was looking at me, giving me the “fuck me” eyes. I wasn’t sure what to do, I mean it wouldn’t surprise me if mary wanted to get down and dirty there, nothing we hadn’t done before . But I didn’t have any condoms on me, I said I had to go to the toilet and Mary came with me.

As soon as we reached the bathroom, Mary jumped on me, kissing me and rubbing her hands over my body, I kissed her back, feeling her up too. I pulled away from the kiss and said “We can’t, not here. I don’t have condoms with me”.

“Fuck, really?” Mary said, disappointed. I had a box of condoms at Mary’s and a box at mine, but I didn’t bring any to dinner as I didn’t expect to be in the situation. “Okay, well soon we will just make an excuse to leave and head back to mine” Mary said. We straightened ourselves up and headed back into the lounge.

“That was quick” Emily joked, obviously alluding to the fact she thought we fucked. Neither of us said anything as we sat back down. “Lets play another game” Emily said, trying to kick some enthusiasm into everyone. Me and Mary didn’t really want to, we wanted to leave so we could have sex. However we agreed we would stay a bit longer, with the alcohol running low, and maddy not drinking anymore, Emily said we should strip. This peaked mine and Mary’s interest, we agreed to stay and play.

Emily suggested we played a card game she picked up from university, I don’t really remember the rules but it was something along the lines of everyone picking a card out randomly, and depending on what cards we had, the “loser” had to take off an item of clothing.

“How come we always end up naked infront of each other” Mary asked

“Because I think its hot” Emily said “and funny, plus this is James’ first time with us, its like a rite of passage now”

We played a couple of rounds and clothes starting being taken off. I was in my trousers still, but shirtless, James was in his boxers, with an obvious hard on. Mary was in her bra and panties as was maddy, and Emily still had her bra, underwear and trousers on. I lost next, before I could take my trousers off, Emily suggested something different. I was told to blindfold myself, then have the girls line up infront of my and one at a time I had to grope their arse. I then had to determine whose ass was whose. If I got it right, I could remove one item of clothing from a person of my choice, if I got it wrong I had to completely strip.

Everyone agreed they were happy for it to happen, obviously this meant that Emily had to take off her trousers. She did so and I got blindfolded, the girls shuffled around infront of me and then James called out “go” and I reached forward. With both hands i found the top of the thighs of the person standing infront of me, I slid my hands up to the arse and had a feel, this wasn’t Mary for sure. The ass was very very smooth, I had a feeling this was Emily.

“Next” James called out and my hands were left empty, next up was Mary, I knew before I even got to feel her arse properly, the way her skin was, the juicyness of it, I was 100% sure this was Mary.

“Last one” James called out, once again my hands were greeted with another ass, and again it was very very smooth, but the ass wasn’t as high up as the other two, and Emily was the smallest. But I was certain Emily was first. I had no real idea and it was a 50/50 between the first and last.

The girls moved away and I took off my blindfold, “OK well number two was definitely Mary I said” everyone nodded and I got a wink from Mary “but I’m not sure about the other two” based on the height difference, I went with Emily last and Maddy first. I was wrong, I had to completely strip. I took of my trousers, and before could pull down my boxers, Mary did it for me, I let my cock hang as everyone got an eyeful and I sat back down.

It wasn’t long until Mary was naked, then Emily, then James. He was average size, similar to myself, he was bald down there whereas I kept myself trimmed and tidy, he was pretty confident with his body. Maddy was the last one with underwear on. She was finally just told to join us in the nude, but she had to pick one person to undress her. She hesitated before picking Emily. Emily went over and pulled down Maddy’s panties. As I looked across I could see maddy had a small bush now, she was shaved the last time I saw her naked, but it looked as though it had been a while since she shaved last. I prefer a small bush on a woman and seeing her got me pretty hard.

“What now” Mary asked as the group sat in a circle, everyone naked looking at each other.

“Well, me and James have something to tell you guys” Emily said “we kinda planned for this” everyone looked a bit shocked but listened up

“I’ve told James everything we’d been through as a group and he said it was really hot and he said he wanted to join in. I said I could probably get us into that situation pretty easily, he just had to follow my lead” Emily continued. Oh shit, she had meant for this to happen, the fact it wasn’t the spur of the moment, but more being lured into a trap turned me off slightly. “So what kind of thing did you have in mind?” Mary asked, she didn’t seem to mind as was eager to find out more.

“Well whatever you guys want to” Emily said, she had clearly planned to get to this stage but not beyond as she wasn’t sure what we would all be comfortable with. “I was hoping we would all keep an open mind, and see what happens” Emily said. I mentioned that I didn’t have condoms with me. Which kind of limited what we could do, safely at least. We all decided to just see what happens as a group, nothing was off limits for now, but we would all take things slowly. Me and Mary got together and started kissing, as did Emily and James. Maddy ran upstairs without saying anything.

“Should we?” Mary said to the group, asking if we should check if maddy was OK, but she quickly returned, holding a small vibrator in her hand. “Nevermind” Mary said as we started kissing again. Sitting across from each other, me and Mary could freely explore each others bodies with our hands. I was now fully erect, and Mary had her hands around my cock. I rubbed her tit as my other hand made my way down to her cunt. I looked to my right and saw Emily hunched over James giving him head, he was laid back with his eyes closed. Behind Emily I could see Mary playing with herself with her vibrator, I could hear it humming from where I was sitting.

I laid Mary back and buried my face into her pussy. I ran circles around her clit with her tongue, with 3 fingers inside her doing the most. I could hear her moaning, when suddenly I saw another hand reach across and grab Mary’s free tit, it was Emily, who was now on her back with James returning the favour to her. Mary sat up and pulled her vagina away from me, I stood up on my knees, cock hard swinging slightly from side to side. Mary motioned for me to get between the two girls. I shuffled over and Mary grabbed my cock with one hand and started stroking me. “Madds, come here” Mary called. Maddy stopped what she was doing and shuffled over.

The three girls sat around me, with mary the only one touching my cock. Emily shuffled to the side to focus on James and made some room for Mary to sit infront of me. “You can join in, madds” Mary encouraged “you don’t have to just watch if you don’t want to” maddy nodded, but still didn’t move towards me. Mary sat up and took my cock into her mouth, I looked down at Maddy who was staring right back at me, she clearly wasn’t going to move first, I leant down and placed my hand over her boob, grabbing it as I did. I felt her whole body shaking as touched her, so I pulled away, i didn’t want to cross any boundaries. “No” she said as I was pulling my hand away “its ok” she followed up. I reached out again and grabbed her tit, she was still nervous I could tell. Mary stopped sucking me off to encourage maddy.

“Aee you ok?” Mary asked her, maddy nodded and smiled, and moved her own hands towards her vagina. I kissed Mary and put my other other hand on her tit. I peeked across to see what Emily and James were up to, they were in missionary and James was thrusting fast. I then remembered we had no condoms, so I wasn’t sure if I was going to fuck anybody. Mary said we could just risk doing it raw, but I had to pull out early. She said she could take the morning after pill too if she had to. We agreed we would risk it, and in a flash Mary got into doggy infront of me and motioned for me to enter her. I obliged and pushed my cock into her. I hadn’t been in raw since the time we camped together,  it was better than I remembered. Warm and wet, when Mary tensed her vagina I could feel it grip me.

I still had my hand on maddy’s tit as this was going on, until she held my hand and  pulled it towards her pussy, I followed her lead and eventually my fingers made their way through her bush towards her cunt. I ran my hand down the front of her pussy she was absolutely soaking, I was struggling to multi task and had to well and truly slowed down fucking Mary, she pushed back against me to remind me she was there and I did my best to please both girls at once, it was no good and I was getting out of rhythm. Mary pulled away from me as she didn’t want to risk going too far with no condom and allowed me to focus on Maddy. I turned my attention to her, I had 2 fingers inside her, put now I could use my other hand to rub her clit.

I watched as Mary made her way towards James and Emily, who had transitioned into cowgirl. I focused on maddy, but kept checking to see what Mary was doing. With both hands pleasuring maddy, I could feel she was enjoying herself as my fingers got soaked. I looked across to Mary, who was now making out with Emily, as Emily was riding James. The girls had their hands over all over each other. I wasn’t sure if James was going to get involved and I wasn’t sure if I wanted him to. I had gone slightly limp whilst I was working on maddy and watching Mary but I suddenly felt a hand grip me.

I looked down to see maddy looking back up at me with my cock in her hands. She had a very very loose grip, but started to stroke me, i focused on her and trusted Mary to not push anything without me being there. I motioned for me and Maddy to change positions, so we could reach each other easier. We laid on our sides next to each other, touching each other. I looked at her and she smiled back at me, I leaned in to kiss her she she reciprocated, it was just a peck, no tounges, but I could tell she enjoyed it. I got had again, but Maddy was still holding me with not much grip. To try and get the message across that she had to hold me firmer, I confidently thrusted my fingers hard and deep into her. I felt her body tense and she gripped me harder as I did this. Maddy let out a little moan and it was obvious she enjoyed it. I did it again, and she grabbed me harder again, I did it again, and again, and maddy replied by holding me firmly and stroking me faster. I tilted my head back with the pleasure and looked over at Mary. The three of them had changed positions, mary was on her back with Emily giving her oral. Emily was in doggy and James was fucking her from behind. I was OK with what I saw and turned my attention back to maddy.

I kissed her again and asked if she wanted to 69. I said you can just use your hands if you want, it’s up to you. I turned onto my back and sat maddy on my face, she was still soaking. My face was squashed as she sat down a bit too aggressively on me, before realising and lifting herself up slightly, I reached up and slid in a couple of fingers, I felt her hands wrap around my cock, this time more firmly. I stuck my tounge out and took a long slow lick up her cunt. I thought she was going to collapse as her legs wobbled when I reached her clit. Her pussy tensed and I licked her clit again, she moaned loudly. I couldn’t feel much going on with my cock as I was taking maddy to places she hadn’t been before. I sped up and licked circles around her clit. She was grinding her hips on me and I assumed she was close. I slowed things down, I didn’t want her to cum yet as I wasn’t sure if she would stop when she did.

As I slowed down I could feel her hands start working me. I was going soft again from the lack of action until I suddenly felt her whole body move forward and a pair of lips wrap around my cock. I could feel her moving her mouth up and down, but I couldn’t feel her using her tongue. I didn’t mind, I wasn’t going to push her, we stayed like this for a few minutes until I heard Mary next to me

“Can we speak for a second?” She said to me. Maddy stood off me and I got up, Mary lead me over to the far corner of the lounge and we sat down. “We need to decide on our boundaries” she said to me. I thought i was in trouble for doing what I was doing with Maddy. “Yeah sure, I just thought that cos um” I started stuttering. “Hey, i don’t mind” Mary said “I’m happy for you to do what you want with either girl, I’m talking about me and James” I was sort of relieved as I wasn’t in trouble, but also nervous because I wasn’t sure what Mary wanted “well, what do you want to do?” I asked “more or less with what we did with Harry?”

“I’m not sure” Mary said “we don’t have any condoms anyway, so we won’t be fucking, but maybe he could do other stuff to me too?” Mary asked. I wasn’t sure, but l wanted to support Mary with what she wanted “I don’t mind” I said, “I trust you to make up your own mind” she kissed me and said “of course, I love you” I kissed her back and said I love you too. We walked back over to the group.

Maddy was sat alone, using her vibrator again as she watched Emily and James fuck. We both walked over to maddy. It was slightly awkward again as maddy seemed to have lost all the confidence she had gotten. Mary made me lie down and got on her knees infront of me, she made space for maddy to sit next to her. Mary grabbed my cock and started stroking me until I was fully hard again. Mary then took me into her mouth all the way, before coming back up and holding me toward maddy to do the same thing. Maddy leant in and wrapped her lips around me, she was a lot less forceful as Mary and only took me halfway before coming back up. Mary went in again but used her tongue to lick around my head and up my shift. She then motioned for maddy to copy and she did, following in the footsteps that Mary laid out for her.

I watched as the two girls took it in turns to suck me off with maddy taking Mary’s lead. Eventually they stopped and Mary straddled me in cowgirl, I was in raw again and Mary rode me a lot slower than usual, being careful to not make me cum. I motioned for maddy to come closer to me and we kissed, I grabbed her breast as she played with herself. Mary was playing with her clit as rode me and watched me kiss maddy.

Emily and James had made their way over to us, and were sat just watching us. Emily then asked “can I?” And motioned towards my cock, Mary got off and let Emily take me into her mouth. She took a long slow lick up my cock, then stopped and asked “so have you two decided what you’re comfortable with?” She got back to work on me as Mary replied “I’m happy for John to do what he wants with who he wants, and we’re happy for me to experiment with James, but no sex as we don’t have condoms”. We all looked around and agreed we were happy. Before anyone could move, Emily straddled me and eased herself down onto my cock. She was just like I remembered, slightly looser than Mary, but warmer, wetter.

Everyone was watching us, until Mary called James over to her. I watched as he walked behind me and towards Mary. I kept my focus on Emily as she bouncee on me again. I looked at Mary as she grabbed James by the cock. Emily bounced again, lowering herself all the way until I was deep inside her. I carried on watching as Mary stoked James. Slowly at first, gradually speeding up. She laid him back, as she’s done so many times to me and took him into her mouth. I wasn’t as bothered this time seeing this as I was the first time it felt more natural. I mean I literally had my cock deep inside another girl raw. And it was amazing, I had no room to complain. I only then realised that maddy was alone again watching on.

I called her over to me and Emily, I told maddy to sit on my face as Emily continued to fuck me. I could feel sensations running through my entire body. I was focused on maddy, but could feel Emily grinding me. It wasn’t going to be too long before I came like this. I could hear people talking, I couldn’t quite make out what was being said as maddy had her legs covering my ears. Suddenly both girls lifted off me. Emily stood up still rubbing her clit, keeping the feeling from the sex we were having and maddy had a line of saliva attaching her cunt to my mouth. I looked to my right and saw Mary and James in 69. This really weirded me out, it was one thing seeing Mary play with another cock, but another seeing someone have his fingers and tongue in my girlfriend.

It turns out the talking i couldn’t hear was Maddy asking to suck me off again, she had a taste for it now and wanted more. This time she didn’t have Mary to lead her, and she kneeled in front of me again where she had been before and starting repeating what she was doing earlier from memory. It felt good, but I can’t lie, you could tell she was inexperienced. Emily had made her way back over to Mary and James and I watched as Mary lifted herself from James face. They kissed and the two girls used their hands to stroke James.

I continued to switch my focus from Maddy to Mary until Mary got up and joined us. She kissed me and said she wanted to be fucked. Me and Mary very quickly got into missionary. We fucked slowly for a while, until we looked over at the sound of James cumming, he was viggoursly fucking Emily in doggy, until pulled out and came over Emilys back. He sat back on the floor as he took in his orgasm, maddy got some tissue for Emily and helped her wipe the cum from her back.

James cumming first signaled for the rest of us to get a move on. Maddy was the closest, she had been watching again, using her vibrator to get off. It wasn’t long before she orgasmed as we all watched, she turned off her vibrator and sat up to watch the rest of us finish.

“OK, who’s next?” Emily said. The three of kissed and touched each other, until Emily laid down in front of me, I went down on her as Mary sat on Emilys face. I had no problem with that. I got Emily to cum next, using my fingers and tongue I felt as she tensed herself before her pussy vibrated and relaxed. She moaned and she was done. Despite orgasming, she carried on eating out Mary until she came, which wasn’t long after. I watched her cum sitting on Emilys face, rubbing her tits and she was being licked out. She stood off and I was the only one left. I was limp again and started using my own hand to come back to life.

I got hard again, but still no one came to help me, I kept going, with everyone watching me. I wanted some help, but didn’t ask. I was getting close, but was a bit upset with the fact I was making myself cum. I could feel I was close and I started moaning, I tilted my head back and closed my eyes as I was getting ready to cum “john” I heard mary call, she was lying infront of me on her back “Come over me” she ordered me, I was so close I got on my knees and aimed at her body. I shot my first load up her chest and over tits, my next load hit her stomach and so did the next couple. My last load came out slower and landed in her bush and slightly on her pussy. Oh god I thought, I panicked as I thought it was bad to cum there, but Mary reached down and rubbed my cum around her clit. Holy shit that was hot.

Maddy got some more tissues for Mary, but Mary had started using her hands to wipe up my cum and was licking it from her fingers. As maddy approached her Mary held her fingers out with my cum on for maddy to try, she hesitated, before sucking Mary’s fingers, she then screwed up her face as she tasted my cum, she clearly wasn’t a fan. Mary used the tissues to finish wiping up and we all sat naked for a while, even maddy wasn’t in a hurry to redress.

The TV was put back on. We all sat naked infront of the fire. But it wasn’t long before some of us were ready for round 2..

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/pfskb2/me_and_my_girlfriend_were_tricked_into_having_an