I[F] Finally agreed to my boyfriends[M] Fantasy

I hope this is an ok story to post here. I’m not a pro writer but enjoy trying so any constructive criticism is welcome.

So for starters this happen a few years back with my ex. We had been together for roughly 2 years at this point. We got on well and the sex was always good, not great but I wasn’t the most adventurous so it was good.

Firstly a little about us. I was a bit more skinny back then. Always been the athletic type with longish dirty blonde hair. My bf was also pretty skinny and we both leaned towards the submissive side.

So anyway we were at home one day and I could always tell when he was upset or had something he wanted to talk about. He would get quiet and kind of dismissive of everything. Like he was upset. This day was no different. We sat eating dinner and he was completely withdrawn. Hardly talking at all. I asked what was wrong and he of course said nothing so I left it. About 5 minutes later he blurted out. “I want to ask you something but I’m scared you will get mad” I of course assured him I wouldn’t get mad even though I didn’t know what it was. Unfortunately and regrettably I did get mad.

He shuffled in his seat before starting a long winded explanation that basically said he was interested in being a cuckold and for me to be with other men. This unfortunately is where I got mad. I told him it was disgusting and why would he ever say these things to me. I cringe thinking about it but at the time I was a young inexperienced shy girl who thought of that type of thing to be completely wrong. He got up and left the table. I sat crying as he went into the bedroom.

I didn’t go in for a while and in that time I sat and thought about it. I needed to know why. So I went in to talk to him. We talked and cried and laughed together for a good 2 hours as we sat on the bed. In the end we decided that if he still wanted to share me I would be willing to have a threesome, for me that was a big step. We had sex that night and I felt very close to him.

We decided to set up an account online that he would run. Talking to guys before setting up a group chat. Few guys came and went that I just couldn’t connect with. Before he set me up with Justin. He was the type of guy I would have been too nervous to talk too irl. Tall handsome but best of all was that he was so charming as we all talked and he understood what we were looking for. After a few weeks of talking we set up a date one Friday night.

I was obviously nervous but still excited. Although it wasn’t exactly what my bf was after he was super excited also. I wore a nice dress and a pair of sandals out for dinner. My heart beat out of my chest when I seen Justin. He was exactly like his pics which was a big relief. He greeted me(Morgan) with a kiss on the cheek and my boyfriend(Eric) with a handshake. He didn’t stop complimenting me all night. After not long we headed to the hotel we had booked for the night.

It was clear Justin was in control from the start. Dominating the conversation, he had an aura about him. When we got to the room I was ready to go. Justin approached me and got Eric’s permission to kiss me. It was immediate fireworks between us. I stood kissing another man while my boyfriend watched. I didn’t want him to miss out so I called him over to kiss him also.

Before long we were all undressing. Both Justin and Eric had similar size cocks, average would be the right way to describe them. They had me sit on the edge of the bed and suck them both. I felt so bad in this moment and their words of encouragement did wonders for my confidence. After a while Justin went and grabbed a condom. He turned me around and fucked me doggystyle. He really knew how to fuck a girl. My hands gripped the bed as I tried to suck Eric but I struggled with the rhythm. He moved to the head of the bed and watched.

Justin ended up being the only one that fucked me that night. Eric said if he did he would cum immediately so he was happy with jerking off and getting sucked occasionally. Not long after he finished Justin thanked us both and headed on home. Eric and I cuddled and talked about it long into the night. We agreed it was so much fun and wanted to try it again.

I just realised this was getting really long. I have many more stories and more with Justin if anybody is interested. Hope you all enjoyed.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/pb28vs/if_finally_agreed_to_my_boyfriendsm_fantasy