Summer 2017, I was 21, back in my hometown and got invited to a house party that a friend I used to hook up with in high school was having.
I hadn’t talked to Heather in a couple years, she graduated a year before me and moved out of state for a bit but recently came back and moved to the nicer city close by. I remember coming across her new IG profile and thought she looked great so I followed. I got a follow back and after a few days I get a DM from her. Nothing really happened then, just caught up with each other, she asked why I followed, I told her she looked good and we kinda just flirted a bit but that was it, she stopped replying before we could arrange something, and I wasn’t gonna bother her. Two weeks later, I get a “wyd” dm from her at 3 am that I missed.
I dm her back the next morning and she just said it was cool. After a few mor messages she says she’s having little party with her new friends and that I should come. I wasn’t sure if I wanted to drive 45 mins to party with a small group of people I’ve never met, but I didn’t wanna ruin my chances with her so I tell her I’ll just let her know.
Fast forward another 2 days and I get a DM from her best friend, Mary. Mary and I graduated together and sort of had a thing for each other as well. We were pretty close for a bit in school, I’d say closer to her than I was with Heather. She would hang out with our group a lot and there was definitely some tension between us. There were a few times where we would drunkenly make out but we always acted like it never happened and stayed friends. But now she was engaged, lived with her NAVY boyfriend on base in another state.
It was weird when I got the DM. Very surprising because we didn’t really talk to each other much since graduating. She just asked what was up, that she was visiting soon and we should hang out. She then brings up the party that heather is throwing and says that would be perfect for us. She says some other old friends will be there so I decide to go.
Now it’s the day of the party and Mary DMs me again. She says “don’t forget about me ;)”. I reply “don’t worry” but couldnt help but be confused. At first I thought she was just trying to help her friend get some dick, but maybe she had other intentions? I thought I was just overthinking at the time. She’s always been friendly. Any way, I get through the day start to get ready for the night. Heather asks if I’m coming, I say “yes, dress hot” and she replies “you too” with a kiss emoji. So I assume it’s on with Heather. She then asks if I can grab some beer. I oblige and head that way. As I’m nearing the house, Mary dms me and tells me to let her know when I’m here so she can help.
I pull up, let Mary know I was here and wait for her to come out. As I see her walk out the from door I get out to give her a hug. Mary was a very cute girl. Only about 5’1 maybe, long brown hair, light skin, wide hips, flat stomach, not much of a rack but I’ll never complain. She was wearing a big tie dye t shirt that she had cut up, exposing some skin, and black leggings. We hugged but she didn’t want to let go when I tried. She clung and looked up at me smiling and said “omg you still smell the same”. We laugh, I say she’s weird and we head inside.
We walk in and are greeted by some familiar faces, which was pretty cool. Lotta guys I hadn’t seen in years. Then I run into Heather, who was also very short, cute face, 5’1 as well maybe, kinda pale, short black hair that went to her shoulders with bangs. Curvy body, pretty nice rack, c cups, and a nice bubble butt. Wearing a tight white spaghetti strap crop top and tight black jeans. She was always a good fuck so I looked forward to ending the night with her. At least that’s what I thought what was gonna happen.
The night goes on, after a few beers I need to break the seal and use the bathroom. At first I was gonna ask Heather, since it was her place but couldn’t find her. Mary was right next to me so she showed me where it was. Once I get out, they’re getting the beer pong table set up and we make teams. Mary and I decide to team up. Heather didn’t want to play so she just kinda hovered around in the back round.
We smoked the first team, only had to drink like 3 cups. The second team made it close though. As we lost more cups and got more alcohol in us, Mary was getting more handsy with me. Laughing really hard and grabbing my waist, touching my back and stomach. And I couldn’t help myself either, I’d put my arm around her in celebration and would place my hand where her shirt was cut up in the back so I could feel some skin, ya know. I started to wonder if Heather noticed because I had said I needed to use the bathroom again, and she immediately grabs my hand to lead me to it. As we’re nearing I just say “are you gonna help me or something?” She replies “no, idiot, just showing you where it’s at”. We laugh and I joke again “but I need help with my pants” as she giggles and walks out but stops to look at me, biting her lip. “Maybe later” she said. I laughed and closed the door. “Oh, it’s on!” I thought. Once I’m out, we finish the pong game and after a few moments, some of us head outside to smoke some reefer.
We walk back inside to play card/drinking game, and I tried to sit right next to Heather but before I could, Mary picks up another chair and quickly places it between Heather and I before I could sit down. I kinda knew what her intentions were at this point but didn’t want to believe it so I ignored it. The game went on, we all got more drunk and a few minutes after passing around a joint, Heather gets up and says “oh god” and runs to her room. We all looked at each other and knew what was up. The spins. Mary got up to check on her, and after about 30 mins she comes back to say she’s in bed now.
We continued to play for bit longer, and as we played, Mary would lay her hand on the thigh. I’d be a liar if I said I didn’t like this attention from her, I always wanted it. That and the alcohol made me not care for the rest of the night though. I found myself putting my own and on her thigh and stroking it. After a while people started to leave. It was around 4 am and the rest of us too wasted to leave yet went to the living room to play music until we fell asleep or something.
I sat in the couch and Mary followed to sit right next to me. Everyone else were chatting and on their phones while her and I talked. I don’t remember what about but eventually we both ended up in the kitchen. She was telling me about what was going on with Heather and asks what I’m gonna do for the night. I definitely wasn’t gonna drive home, it was late, I was drunk, and lived 45 minutes away. I say I’m just gonna crash on a couch and she offers the bed in the spare room with her. I asked if she was sure, and she kinda just looked around the room, back to me and nodded yes.
Everyone else seemed have crashed out or left already so we head to the room to see it’s a fuckin bunk bed with boxes on the top so we shared the tiny bottom bunk. She turned on a red lava lamp that was in there and then turned off the lights. I laid down first and then Mary and talked for a few minutes. She started showing me her new tattoos and then lifted up her shirt and pulled down her leggings a bit to show me tats she had on her ribs and hip/thigh. After I got a good look, she didn’t bother fixing her clothes, I can see her black lace bra that was almost like a top, and a black thong peaking as her hip was exposed. She asked if I had gotten any so I lifted up my own shirt to show her a recent one below my chest. Before I could pull my shirt back down, Mary had placed her hand on the tattoo and started tracing it with her fingers, slowly her hand down moving down to then trace my abs.
Now her head is resting on my chest, and my arm around her. We continued to talk about school and our relationship. She confessed that she wished we would’ve had more, and I the same. She then starts talking about her engagement and how she felt rushed into it, she doesn’t love him, he cheats, blah blah blah. I wasn’t sure if it was all true, but I felt I should at least comfort her by saying something about it. But before I could finish what I was saying, she had grabbed my face and we started kissing. As soon as I pulled her in closer, her hand immediately went to my belt and started undoing it.
She was moving fast, lips still locked, desperately trying to get my pants off so I help kick them off. She gets up to take off her leggings and underwear and then climbs on top of me. We kiss some more until she shoves my dick into her. We start off slow, kissing as she rides me and then she sits up to put her hands on my chest. I take her shirt off and she takes off her bra. I sit up to suck on her tits for a bit as she’s still riding and then lay back down. Then she plants her feet on the bed, so she’s squat riding, and then grabs the base of the bunk above us and rides harder. She looked so sexy riding me this way. After a while, she hops off and starts giving me head. He ass was sort of pointing in my direction so I grab her hips and legs as she’s still sucking and move her to the 69 position and I start eating and playing with her pussy. I’d never been with a girl that had pussy lips as big as hers.
She gets back up and gets into the same position except reversed now. Still hanging on to the bunk above, Im grabbing her ass, helping her bounce on my dick until she squirts on my stomach twice. Then she gets back on her knees and starts riding it slowly. Then we moved to doggy. It was too cramped for me so I tell her to hang off the side of the bed while I stood up. As soon as I inserted she let out a deep moan so I knew this was the spot. I start slow and then pick up the pace and her moans get higher to almost squeals. She starts to squirm, head buried, reaching for more sheets to grab and then she lets out some grunts as she came. It was kinda funny, I’ve never made a girl grunt as they can before. I pull out, my dick dripping, and she’s laying there shaking, face down still. I then go back down on her and eat out everything, ass and pussy. “Oh my fucking god” She moaned, muffled by the sheets. After that I laid back down and she started to suck my dick again. Also giving my balls some attention.
She stops and says “come here” as she’s laying on her back. I get in between her legs and start going in missionary. I buried my face in her neck, kissing it. I started giving long, hard strokes until she squirted again. After a few minutes I began to worry I was too drunk to cum, but I lifted myself up to look at her pretty face. Just looking in her big green eyes, seeing her make those hot facial expressions that girls make during sex, was enough to get me to climax. I ask where she wants it and she wraps her legs around me and says “I’m on the pill” so I kept pumping until I shot my load inside her, kissing her as until every last drop is gone. We made out in that position with my dick and nut still in her until I was soft.
We laid there, in each other’s arms for a few more minutes until she got up to clean herself. I put my underwear back on and laid back down. She came back, still naked, and laid next to me. She tells me thanks as she starts kissing my chest again. I confusingly say “you’re welcome”. I thought she was ready for round 2 but I was already beat. I checked the time and it was almost 6 am so we must’ve fucked for a little over an hour. Luckily she said she was exhausted so she turned around and fell asleep. I laid there, staring that the bunk above, replaying what had just happened in my head until I pass out.
She wakes me up not even 3 hours later, telling me Heather is in the shower and it’d be best if I bailed already. I agreed, and I stumble out of bed to get dressed. She was still only in her bra and thong, so I tell her she’s looking good. I’m sitting on the bed with only pants on and she walks over to kiss me. We kiss on the lips, and then she bends over to give me a hickey on my chest, and then kiss in the lips again. I get dressed and walk to the front door. We stop to hug and kiss one more time and I leave.
Later that day she texted me to talk about it. We just talked about how much we enjoyed it, IF we should do it again, blah blah. We decided not to do it but we eventually did the next week. This fling went on for a month. She would come stay at my house for a few weekends. It ended when she went back to the state her fiancé was stationed in. I don’t think she even told Heather about it because after she left, Heather and I became regular fuck buddies for a while. During that time Heather would confirm that Mary’s fiancé was indeed an asshole and cheats to my surprise. But whatever I guess. It didn’t matter to me anymore.
I’m still friends with both, Heather and I moved away at the same time. Mary and her fiancé ended up eloping and have a child now but I’m actually still friends with her. I had dinner with her and another friend last month before I moved again.
But that’s about it. I have another story about a recent hookup with my longtime friend/roommate that I’ll be posting soon. But yeah. Thanks for reading!
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/pauwav/how_im_went_to_a_party_to_hookup_with_a_girl_but