Our first threesome wasn’t quite what I was expecting [MMF]

For my previous stories, please check my profile, I have descriptions in old stories of everyone involved in this one.

Before we get to the main point of this story, let’s get some back story in and fill in some gaps.

The start of this story takes place about 2 months after the group stories I’ve already posted about. Me and Mary enjoyed the thrill of having someone involved in the bedroom with us but we were yet to act on it and actually try anything. One evening, I was playing video games with friends and I received a Snapchat from Mary, we only used Snapchat for one thing and that was nudes. I opened it and to my delight I saw a picture of Mary naked, kneeling infront of her mirror.

I sent her a message asked what brought this on, she replied and said she was in the mood and was going to watch some porn and masturbate and she wanted to send me pictures throughout. I received another picture and this time she was in the same position with her legs slightly apart. The next image I received she was in bed with her laptop next to her. This was then followed up with a picture of porn hub on her laptop and the caption “what shall I watch”. I sent her back a message saying “watch something with 3 people in it, see if you can get any ideas for us” trying my luck.

I was expecting her to snap back with a video on an ffm threesome, however to my surprise she had found herself an mmf to get off to. As a straight guy I was a little taken back, I never even considered having a threesome with another guy, Mary was slightly bi curious which is why we started having these conversations so I always assumed if we were to have a threesome, it would be with another girl.

I sent her back a message telling her I was surprised at her choice and what she thought about it. I got no response for a long time and I assumed she was getting down to business. Enough time had passed that I came off my computer with my friends and got into bed. I snapped a picture of my nude body and sent it to her asking “Have you finished? Or can I join in?”. She came back and showed me her watching another mmf threesome. She told me it was her third one. “Is this something you want to try then?” I asked. She came back with a picture of her pussy soaking wet and the caption read “look what the idea of it has done to me”

I was conflicted, I was open to new things and wanted to make Mary happy, but at the same time I didn’t really like the idea of Mary with another guy, in anyway whatsoever. I told her we would have to talk about it in person and decide what we wanted to do.

The next day I picked her up from work and we came to my house, we went upstairs and sat on my bed. Mary couldn’t wait to hear my thoughts on the idea of an mmf.

“So?” She asked.

“To be honest, I don’t know. I’m not against it but I have some reservations” I replied

“Hey, of course. We don’t even have to do it at all if it makes you uncomfortable?” She told me. “I’m not even 100% sure it’s something I want to do. Watching the porns that I watched last night it just looked like fun”

“I just don’t know how I’d feel about seeing you with a different guy, and I’m surprised that you would be OK with being with another guy?” I said

“Its a scary thought for me, but I’m always getting more confidence in myself, plus you would be there the whole time with me and that would put my mind at ease” she replied “and to be honest, I don’t think I would be comfortable fucking another guy. I had just imagined I would use my hands and mouth”

This made me feel a lot better about the whole idea. I couldn’t get my head around the idea of seeing Mary fuck another dude. But the idea of her just playing with them felt OK to me.

“I suppose I would be more comfortable with that too” I said “but who would we ask? I certainly don’t want any of my friends near our sex life.”

“I was thinking about this, maybe Harry?” Mary asked “I mean he’s already seen us both naked, and we watched him cum whilst he was watching us. I guessed it would just be a step up from what we’ve already done?” She said

“OK, well firstly, I never watched him cum, that was just you. And secondly would you really be ok with that? If something went wrong it could ruin your friendship?” I asked

“But I can trust Harry” she replied “I know he wouldn’t take things too far and our friendship means a lot to each other that neither of us would want to ruin it”

“I guess there’s no harm in asking him what he thinks, he could reject us” I said.

Mary picked up the phone and called him, she told him that she needed to ask him something and when he was free to meet up. He said he was free then next day after he finished work.

The following day, I picked him up from work and the three of us went to Mary’s
“So what did you want to ask me about” Harry asked.

Me and Mary looked at each other, we decided it made sense for her to propose the idea as it would be weird coming from me. “Me and John have been talking, and were thinking about maybe having someone join us in the bedroom” Mary said, blushing as she did so.

“Oh” Harry said “what kind of thing did you have in mind?”

“Well after what went on at Jack’s a while ago, we’ve been exploring what turns us both on and what things we want to try” Mary explained “and a few days ago I saw some videos of 2 guys with a girl and thought it looked like fun. We would have to set some ground rules obviously, but you’re the only guy I would feel comfortable enough with to try this. I trust you”

“Well I definitely wasn’t expecting this, but for sure. I’d more than happily join you guys, I assume you’re OK with this John?” Harry asked me.

“Yeah, once we’ve established what we’re all comfortable and not comfortable with. I don’t see the harm in trying” I replied

“Sweet, so when were you guys thinking of doing this? I have to be home by 7 tonight as my grandparents are round for dinner. But next Saturday I think I’ve got a free house for a few hours” Harry said.

Me and Mary looked at one another, next weekend worked for us and we were actually going to do this. “Thats fine for us” Mary said as I nodded along.

It was sorted. Next weekend me and Mary were going to have our first mmf with her long time bisexual friend.

Over the course of the next week me and Mary spoke in depth about what we were happy with, what limits we had and what we would do if either of us felt uncomfortable during the act.

Saturday finally rolled around and we headed to Harry’s. This was the first time I had been in his house, it was very big, his parents obviously had money. We went upstairs to his room and we were greeted with an explosion of colour. He had pride flags on his walls mixed with posters of album covers and film promos. His bed was in the centre of his room, it was a very eccentric double bed with silky sheets.

Me and Mary sat on the edge of the bed as Harry sat at his desk. We talked through what limits we had. “So I’m only going to have sex with john” Mary told Harry “but I want to use my hands and mouth to pleasure you. You’re more than welcome to touch my body, including my breasts, ass and legs. But for now everywhere else is off limits”.

“Thats not a problem with me” Harry said “I don’t mind if either of you touch me anywhere, you can both touch my cock and my ass if you want I don’t mind”

“I just want to be involved with Mary only” I said. We had set out the ground rules and everyone was happy. We all agreed that we might all change our minds at any time and if anyone wants anything to stop, or if anyone wants to try anything new. We would all stop as a group and talk about it.

“Ok, well let me put some music on and we can get started” Harry said. He turned around and faced his desk where he had a little speaker on his desk. He connected his phone and starting playing some music quietly.

In meantime, me and marry kissed. We once more checked in with one another before starting and then we got to business.

Mary took off her top first and threw it to the floor. She moved her back to me in order for me to take off her bra. I unhooked it and she threw it on top of her shirt. She turned to faced me and we kissed once more, I grabbed her tits as we made out and Harry took off his shirt. Mary finally took off my shirt before turning to face Harry. She pushed her chest out towards him, inviting him to grab and a handful. As she faced Harry, Mary slid one hand back towards my crotch and started rubbing my cock over my shorts. She slowly moved her other hand towards Harry before doing what she was already doing to me, to him.

I felt my heart skip a beat. The girl I was in a relationship with was feeling up another guy. It was a very weird sight for me, despite having over a week to prepare myself for this. I already found it to be a bit overwhelming. Not being 100% sure how I felt I didn’t say anything for now and continued to watch Mary. Me and Harry both started getting aroused. I could see the lump in his trousers as I’m sure he could see mine. Mary pulled her hands away and stood up. She faced away from where me and Harry were sat and pulled her trousers down her legs. As she bent at the waist, me and Harry both looked on as her thong did very little at concealing her pussy from view. Mary stood back up straight and turned to face us, she was standing in just her thong, looking at the 2 guys sat in front of her.

She came to me first and grabbed my shorts and boxers by the waist. She pulled them down as my cock sprang from its concealment. She then turned towards Harry and did the exact same thing to him, I watched on as his semi hard penis was revealed to us both. Mary wasted no time in sitting back down in-between us, still in her thong, the only piece of clothing left between the three of us. She reached out with both hands, one towards me and one towards Harry and grabbed our cocks simultaneously. I watched on as she worked us in her hands in sync with one another, slowing rubbing us up and down. Harry became fully erect before I did and eventually Mary had to use both hands to get me hard.

My nerves had settled, despite finding it very very weird seeing Mary handle another dick the same time as mine. I got more used to it the more it went on. Now we were both hard, Mary went back to having us in each hand, jerking us both off simultaneously. I caught her eye and she smiled at me, she was clearly enjoying herself. She leaned in and kissed me and I kissed her back.

It was time for Mary to get fully naked and she asked Harry to do the honours. I was jealous as pulling down Mary’s underwear was something I enjoyed. I watched on and he slid down her panties to her knees and she opened her legs. Mary’s pussy was off limits to Harry, but all mine. I took the opportunity to reach across and start rubbing her. Harry did what he could and grasped at her breats. It was a sight to behold. Mary was still stroking us both as I used my hands on her pussy and Harry used his hands on her tits. Mary got wet enough for me to slip in a couple of fingers and I did so. She moaned and I started to finger her. And she slowed down what she was doing to our cocks.

For about 5 minutes we stayed like this until Mary got onto the middle of the bed and onto her knees. She faced Harry as she wiggled her pussy in my face. I saw her face go down towards Harry’s cock. She was obviously starting to give him head. To take it off my mind I buried my own face into Mary’s pussy and focused on the task at hand. However it wasn’t long until Mary said “just fuck me already”. I had gotten her wet enough and reached for my bag where I had the condoms. As I got out of bed I saw Mary going down on Harry in full view. It still didn’t look right to me but she was clearly enjoying herself, as I’m sure Harry was too.

I grabbed a condom, rolled it on and slid into Mary from behind. She let out a rather loud moan and it sounded as if she took a brief break from sucking off Harry to do so. I continued to fuck, as Mary continued to suck and we went at it for a long long time. Occasionally Mary would reach back and grab my balls, or rub herself. Doggy was the position that always gets me close to cumming the quickest. I eventually had to slow down, I didn’t want to cum before Harry, despite the fact I was the one having sex. Mary must have been enjoying herself as she groaned when I slowed down. “Have you cum” she called back to me.

“Not yet, but I’m very close” I replied. Harry also chimed in “I’m not too far either, but I struggle to cum from head” he said.

“Do you want me to just use my hands to get you there then?” Mary asked

“Thats probably your best bet” Harry said “I can do it myself if you want”

“Dont be silly” Mary replied “here, lie down next to each other” she positioned me and Harry next to each other. She then sat herself on top of me and reached across to grab Harry’s cock. Up until now, I’d avoided looking as his cock as much as I could, but I looked over and watched what Mary was doing. He was about the same size as I was, but perhaps not as girthy. As Mary rode me, she synchronised the motion of her body to jerk off Harry, he moaned a couple of times next to me and it was obvious he was close. I started to panic as the way Mary was holding him, he was going to shoot his load over Mary and myself, and I didn’t particularly want another guys cum over me.

“Mary!” I said, she looked across and realised he was close, she stopped riding me, infact she pulled herself off me and just sat on my lap instead. She sped up what she was doing with Harry. He reached out and grabbed her arm, this was it, I was about to watch my girlfriend make another guy cum. He orgasmed and cum started flying out of his cock. It hit Mary on her tits and face, and some of it just came out over Harry himself. He relaxed and slouched back into his bed. Mary, with another man’s cum over her. Turned her attention back to me. I had gone slightly limp from the events that just happened. She used a towel to wipe off the cum from her body and came back to me. She sat herself onto my face and leant forward to suck me off. 69 was one of our favourites as we always managed to get each other to cum like this.

Within no time I was fully hard again and Mary was getting close to orgasm. Harry had finished cleaning himself up and was watching us from the side. Mary came first, I felt her hips start grinding as her pussy got a lot wetter. She squeezed my fingers that were inside her. A lot less was happening to my cock as this was going on, Mary moaned and moaned loudly. She finally came back to earth and she finished sucking me off. Usually when we finish like this, Mary will aim my cock at her body and I’ll finish over the both of us. But this time Mary was feeling wild. As I came she put the head of my cock into her mouth. I felt her lips wrap around me and it tipped me over the edge. I pumped and pumped and I filled Mary’s mouth. She had licked my cum from our bodies before, but this was different. Everything I had to give was going straight into her mouth. I finally gave my last little pump and she lifted herself up, sucking my head until her lips met. She faced me and swallowed.

“Wow” me and Harry said simultaneously. She pulled out all the stops to ensure she gave me a better finish than she gave Harry. Me and Mary hugged and kissed before cleaning up and getting dressed.

We left Harry’s and got back to my car.

“So did you have a good time?” I asked Mary.

“I did, but I don’t think I would want to do it again” she replied. I was surprised by this as Mary had really gotten into it.

“Why’s that?” I asked.

“Well, I enjoyed being the centre of attention, I had both of you worshiping me at the start, but then Harry just became a bit of an inconvenience. I wanted to give you all my attention but I kept having to make sure I wasn’t neglecting him” she said.

This was music to my ears. I’m glad Mary got to try something that she was curious about, but even more glad that I wouldn’t have to share her with anyone else. I was worried she was going to come out and say next time she wanted to go even further and fuck someone else too. We kissed and drove home.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/pa1icb/our_first_threesome_wasnt_quite_what_i_was