Justin’s cock was shorter than mine but a lot thicker, and uncut.
Sandy was on her knees in between us, stroking our boners hesitantly but with a glint in her eye. ‘What in the fuck is going on?’ She laughed. ‘I don’t know but I’m not mad at it’ I said, almost gasping with pleasure…
****************************************
I met up with Sandy and Justin the summer after our junior year of college. We were in the same physics lab in high school and were good friends then but hadn’t really kept in touch.
Justin was handsome, tall, and athletic – a basketball player. More attractive and generally more popular than Sandy and I.
Sandy was a D-1 soccer player. Cute, mousy face, very short with a thick athletic ass.
I’m basically a nerd, but funny and charming – my personality making up for my less than average looks.
I had always had a crush on Sandy. I think Justin did too, but he was mainly interested in more traditionally attractive girls.
So that summer Justin invited us over to swim at his parents’ place while they were in North Carolina. We were going to have some beers and try to stay cool in that sweltering August heat.
Sandy started telling us about this drinking game she had played at school called ‘flip, sip, or strip’, which is basically guaranteed to end up in alcohol-fueled nudity and usually more.
One time they played it at a party and she ended up hooking up with some random dude in front of all her friends.
All three of us had been virgins through high school so Justin and I exchanged pretty surprised looks when we heard this. I felt a weird mix of arousal and jealousy hearing about some guy fucking Sandy at a house party.
We were all about 2 beers in at this point and I felt my liquid courage rising. ‘Sweet let’s play,’ I heard myself blurt out.
‘We only have on our swimsuits – we’d all be naked in 5 minutes,’ Sandy laughed.
Fast forward five minutes. Justin and I are indeed naked. Sandy is already topless and now stands up to slide off her bottoms. She gives us a little spin to show off her ass.
I’ve fantasized so many times about seeing her naked that there’s no way I’m hiding how excited I am. I’m standing there in front of them fully erect, throbbing. I’m average girth but long – just under 7 inches. ‘Damn, Bry!’ says Sandy, eyeing my dick. ‘Look at that thing!’
Justin is getting hard now too, but not to the same extent as me. I had never really seen an uncut cock before so am trying to sneak glances at it without him noticing. He notices.
‘Ok so what do we do now?’ Justin asks the obvious question.
Sandy answers by getting on her knees in between Justin and I. She starts playing with our cocks and in her excitement rubs the tip of mine against Justin’s. Instinctively we pull away from each other. Although secretly I’m writhing in pleasure from feeling my cock rubbed against his.
‘Oh fuck – sorry guys,’ Sandy says, embarrassed.
‘No worries,’ Justin smiles, meeting eyes with me for half a second. ‘Where were we?’
Sandy’s sucking our cocks now – alternating between Justin and me. ‘Dang this is way more fun than physics’, laughs Sandy in between mouthfuls of dick.
I’m going to nut any second now but for some reason am super self-conscious about finishing in front of Justin.
I excuse myself and go inside to the bathroom to finish up. I cum harder than I ever thought was possible, all over myself. I clean up as best I can, and just sit there dumbfounded at what just happened.
A few minutes later I hear a knock on the bathroom door. ‘Everything alright Bry?’ Justin asks. ‘All Good’, I reply, still slightly out of breath.
Through the door I can hear Justin’s and Sandy’s footsteps up the stairs to Justin’s room. Soon I can hear her moans of pleasure and the creaking of Justin’s bed.
I go outside, put my trunks back on, and crack open another beer.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/p3s52w/justin_and_sandy_mfm