I suppose I’ll start with introductions. This involved me (Lissy), my best friend Grace and a man named Jamie.
Grace and I had been besties since grade school, so we treated one another like sisters. Jamie was a couple of years older and we’d frequently see him wondering around the neighborhood, typically spending a portion of his time vibing out at the park.
Jamie immediately stood out to me the first time I saw him, as he looked scarily identical to a young Leo DiCaprio (think Titanic). I mean, same hair, same boyish good looks. One difference, however, was his eyes.
They were more of an aquamarine color.
Also his build was slightly different. A bit more muscle than Leo had had back then. He wasn’t big by any means, but was built with lean, sinewy muscle.
Anyway, the first time we properly met Jamie was at the park. Grace and I were walking the trail and he came wondering out of the woods right across from us, nearly scaring the bejeezus out of us.
He couldn’t stop apologizing and actually appeared to be quite upset that he’d spooked us, so we reassured him that we were fine and invited him to join us on the rest of our walk. We wound up hanging out for a while, chatting and getting to know one another and once it’d gotten late, we exchanged numbers and then parted ways.
After that, we talked pretty regularly and Jamie would even come and hang out at Grace and I’s shared apartment once in a while, where we’d drink a little and smoke some weed. You know, just chill and have a good time.
Before I get into the next part, I just want to say that Grace and I were still virgins and had often joked about losing it together (not to each other but *together*).
So, one of these nights, we were all sitting in the living room, all on the couch. From left to right it was Grace, with Jamie in the middle and then me at the other end.
We’d had a few drinks at that point and had a nice little buzz going and we’d just finished smoking a fat joint that Jamie had rolled. Out of nowhere, Grace put her hand on Jamie’s thigh and looked up at him, her lips turning up into a grin.
“You know, Jamie, you’re a really cool guy. Real cute, too.”
Jamie kind of just chuckled and told her thanks. Grace then looked down toward me and I immediately knew what she was up to.
“Don’t you think he’s cute, Lissy?” She asked.
My entire face felt hot as Jamie’s eyes locked with mine and I felt so nervous all of a sudden. Like I was standing beneath a spotlight.
Instead of speaking, I just nodded my head.
Jamie chuckled again, giving another thank you. Grace’s hand traveled just a little bit further up his leg and Jamie drew in a slow breath. It seemed he’d finally caught on to where this was leading to.
“Do you like us, Jamie?” Grace queried, her fingers steadily growing closer to his crotch.
Jamie nodded quickly, looking back and forth between Grace and I.
“Do you like the way we look?” She asked.
Again, he nodded quickly, soft pink tongue darting out to wet his lips.
“Yeah, I do.” He responded airily.
Then, Grace took her hand from his leg and grabbed hold of his hand, placing it over one of her breasts. Jamie’s eyes widened in surprise, but he appeared to like what she was doing as a tent began to form in his pants.
“Lissy, how about you let Jamie touch you, too?”
I was kind of frozen in place for a moment as they both stared at me with anticipation and my mind was running a million miles a minute. As nervous as I was, I really didn’t want to miss out on an opportunity like this, so I mimicked what Grace had done and brought his free hand to my chest.
“Do you like how we feel, Jamie?” Grace then asked.
Jamie nodded again, his fingers gently kneading our breasts.
“Do you want to kiss me?”
“Very much.” Was Jamie’s answer.
She bit her lip and then leaned in, pulling him into a passionate kiss. Jamie continued to massage my chest while I watched the two make out, their tongues deep in the others mouth.
I couldn’t deny how hot it was making me and I found myself hoping that he would kiss me too.
Then, Grace broke their embrace and smiled, her breath a bit rushed as if she’d been holding it. Both of their lips were wet with saliva and I found myself wetting my own with my tongue in anticipation for whatever came next.
“How about you give Lissy a kiss, too.” Grace said, gesturing toward me with a nod of her head.
Without missing a beat, Jamie turned to me and leaned down, cupping my face in his palm before bringing his lips to mine. His mouth tasted a bit like weed and alcohol, but it was pleasantly sweet and I felt like I couldn’t get enough of him.
We kissed a bit slower than Grace and him had, passionate yet not as feverish. He took his hand from my breast and wrapped his fingers in my hair, gently tugging my head back before he took his mouth from mine and began to trail light kisses down my jaw and to my neck.
I was absolutely buzzing with electricity at the feeling of his warm mouth on my skin, and my arms had wrapped themselves around the back of his neck as I pulled him against me.
Then, all too quickly, he stopped and pulled back, our eyes meeting as he uncoiled his fingers from my brown locks.
“That was good.” Grace purred and we both looked back at her, quickly remembering that she was there. “Why don’t we take this to my bedroom?”
Jamie and I looked back at one another and then back to her as we nodded our heads in agreement. We all got off of the couch and piled into her room, Jamie and I sinking down onto the bed side by side as Grace flipped on the light and shut the door.
“You know, Jamie, Lissy and I are both virgins and I think I can speak for both of us when I say we want you to be our first.”
Jamie looked a bit surprised by that and looked back and forth between Grace and I. She didn’t give him a chance to respond before she pulled her shirt over her head, quickly followed by her bra to expose her bare breasts to us.
“Why don’t you help Lissy out of her clothes?”
Jamie turned to me, his eyes gauging mine as if to ask if I were okay with that. I just gave him a little smile and that seemed to be enough to appease him.
I drew in a sharp breath as his finger tips brushed against my sides as he lifted my shirt up and over my head. He didn’t need to remove my bra since I hadn’t been wearing one to begin with and without any urging from Grace, he immediately brought his mouth to my right nipple.
Boy, oh boy, I lost my shit when he did that. It felt so insanely good as his warm tongue circled and flicked over my hardening bud. There was a strong, electric pulsing between my legs and I could feel my wetness starting to pool in my underwear.
My hands wrapped themselves in his hair as my head fell back, a light moan escaping from my lips.
Grace sank onto the bed on the other side of him, perched on her knees as she pressed her naked body against his back, bringing her mouth to the nape of his neck. Suddenly, he took his mouth from my tit and turned his head to pull Grace into another deep kiss.
I watched as Grace pointed a finger toward Jamie’s belt buckle and I wasted no time to reach out and undo it, pulling it open before unclasping the button on his jeans. Jamie broke their kiss just long enough to push his pants down his legs, leaving only his boxers to cover his now fully erect member.
I helped bring his pants the rest of the way down, peeling them from his ankles before dropping them to the floor. Grace and him stopped kissing before she whispered something in his ear, to which he then turned back to me and guided me down onto my back before working my pants off same as I’d done for him.
Not only my pants though, he took my panties as well and I could see his eyes burning with lust as he gazed at my wet lips. Then, he hooked his arms beneath my thighs and spread them apart, dipping his head between them before plunging his tongue between my folds.
My head was absolutely spinning as he ate me like I was his last meal, the room filling up with my moans of ecstasy. It wasn’t long before I exploded with orgasm, fingers clawing at the sheets.
During that time, his hand had found its way between Grace’s legs and it looked as if she were ready to cum any second as well. He didn’t stop licking me until she did and then he pulled her in for a kiss, giving her a taste of my essence.
Then, he guided her onto her back and began to eat her as well, his fingers slipping between my lips next. First, he circled my clit, flicking over it and causing me to twitch as I was still a bit sensitive.
Then, they trailed firther down until they found my entrance, one sinking deep inside of me before he worked in a second. Not once did he get rough with me – he was gentle the entire time as he slowly thrusted his fingers in and out of me, hooking them upward to hit my G-Spot as his thumb teased my clit.
He had me cumming again in less than a minute, my entire body shaking uncontrollably as my legs instinctively clamped around his wrist. Grace was moaning pretty loud at this point, her fingers pulling at Jamie’s sandy blonde hair as he brought her closer and closer to the edge.
Only when I’d come down and relaxed a bit did he continue to tease my vagina. He didn’t stop touching me until he’d finished off Grace.
When he had, he pulled me into a kiss, same as he’d done to Grace and spread her taste all over my tongue.
Once we’d finished, Grace took Jamie’s hand and guided him up to the head of the bed, directing him to lie down on the pillows. She then turned to me and waved me over, so I crawled across the mattress on my hands and knees until I was next to them.
“I want you to sit on his face while I suck his cock.” She said and I locked eyes with Jamie before I got up and stood over him, grabbing hold of the headboard before lowering myself onto my knees until I was hovering just above his mouth.
He wrapped his arms around my thighs and pulled me down onto him, his tongue immediately getting to work. I bit my lip to stifle a moan but it was hard to hold myself together, as he had me incredibly sensitive already.
Behind me, I could hear Grace sloppily sucking away and I looked back over my shoulder to see her on all fours between his legs, her head working up and down along his shaft. I felt my insides clench at the sight of his staff, wondering to myself how much it was going to hurt when he slipped it inside of me.
It wasn’t porn star huge or anything, but I’d peg it around 7.5 to 8 inches long and it looked to be pretty girthy.
I turned back toward the wall as I felt myself getting close, white knuckling the headboard as I felt myself getting ready to release. It happened a few seconds later and I tried to pull myself away from his mouth as it was just too much, but he held me firmly in place, gently sucking at my tender clit.
I was absolutely screaming, writhing against him and squeezing his head between my legs. However, he would not relent.
Then, he stopped moving his tongue for a moment, letting out a low grunt before he began to lick me a little more feverishly. My head fell back and I let out something between a moan and a whimper, opening my eyes to see that Grace was now riding him, her eyes closed as if in deep concentration, her hips rhythmically rolling back and forth.
I found myself hoping it wouldn’t take her long to finish, as I wasn’t sure how much more licking I could handle. I was so sensitive by that point that just his warm breath against me was enough to curl my toes.
It wasn’t long until I was cumming *again*, gritting my teeth as wave after wave of ecstasy rolled through me.
Behind me, I could feel and hear Grace picking up her pace, her skin slapping loudly against Jamie’s as she bounced up and down on him. A moment later, she yelled that she was going to cum and then let out a series of loud moans as she began to slowly rock and back and forth, riding her orgasm all the way to its end.
Once she rolled off of Jamie’s lap, he finally stopped licking me and released his grip on my thighs. I lifted myself up onto shaky legs, collapsing onto the mattress beside him.
“What are you doing?” Grace asked breathlessly. “You aren’t done yet. It’s your turn to take a ride.”
However, Jamie seemed to have other plans. He didn’t give me a chance to move before he rolled over on top of me, using his knee to part my legs.
We started kissing and I could feel how wet I’d made his face, my taste and smell all over him. He hooked an arm beneath one of my thighs, pulling it up toward my chest as he positioned himself at my entrance.
Slowly and carefully, he began to ease himself inside of me. There was definitely some pain as I stretched around him, but I was so wet at that point that he’d bottomed out after three strokes.
He began to pump in and out of me, so tenderly and soft, all the while still kissing me. His fingers lightly stroked my face and he broke the kiss just long enough to look into my eyes and tell me how beautiful I was.
It was so passionate and personal that I honestly forgot Grace was even there.
After a moment, he took my hands in his, entwining his fingers in mine as he pinned them gently to the bed above my head. Not once did he quicken his pace or get rough with me – he was so loving and tender the entire time, kissing my lips and my neck, whispering sweet words in my ear.
About ten minutes had passed before I felt the pressure of an incoming orgasm building inside of me and I whispered into his ear that I was going to cum.
“Me too.” He groaned in response, bringing his lips to mine, keeping his pace steady and consistent until I clamped down on him and came *hard*.
I could tell by his heavy, uneven breaths that he was getting ready to do the same but he made sure that I’d ridden every last wave of my orgasm before he pulled out and blew his load into his hand.
We all just kind of sat there for a minute, collecting ourselves and catching our breath before Grace got up and tossed Jamie her used panties.
“You can use that to clean up with.” She said with a wink.
Once we’d all gathered ourselves, we got dressed and smoked another joint before Jamie declared that he was tired and was going to head home. We walked with him to the door, chatting along the way about how we’d all love to do that again sometime.
Jamie told us that he would be free for the next few days, so we made plans for him to come over the following night. He gave Grace and I each a tender kiss before leaving and then her and I just looked at each other and lost our shit.
“That was so fucking hot!” She whooped and I couldn’t have agreed more.
We spent the next hour or so recounting everything that had happened, both of us in agreement that we could not have picked a better lover. Jamie was incredible in bed and I found myself wondering how many girls he’d been with to become so skilled at love making.
After a while, we both said our goodnights and retired to our rooms. Jamie would be coming over the following evening, so we needed to rest up as much as possible in preparation for our next session with him.
There was no knowing then, but this would eventually blossom into a full on poly relationship between the three of us.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/ouyltv/first_time_was_also_first_ménage_à_trois_fmf