All characters are 18+. Please leave your comments and feedback below! Thanks!
**P.S.** the bold and italicized text is someone’s thoughts/inner monologue, but can also be external actions.
[Part 1](https://www.reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/olaqbs/an_uneasy_proposition_mfdomsubblackmail_part_1/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3)
[Part 2](https://www.reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/on2k8c/an_uneasy_proposition_mfdomsubblackmail_part_2/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3)
Here is the background. This is a fictional story.
**Jessica**: F21. Main female of the story. 5’2″, blonde, c cup, petite, slender, athletic, great ass. Slutty at times, but loyal.
**Ben**: M18. Main male of the story. 6’1″, athletic build, brown hair, Kelly’s boyfriend.
**Kelly**: F18. Jessica’s younger sister. 5’4″, blonde, c cup, carefree, Ben’s girlfriend.
**Setting**: *Jessica and Kelly’s house*
——————————————————————————————————————————–
*Trump card*
The room was still dark. Jessica leaned back and stood in front of him again, but backed up a few steps. She slowly unclasped her bra and and then seductively tossed it to the cushion on Ben’s left as he sat there, enjoying Jessica’s little show. Her breasts slipped out and bounced as they fell free from the undergarment. She giggled as she bounced her breasts up and down for him with her hands, pinching her nipples and pressing them together slightly for his pleasure.
Ben smirked, though Jessica couldn’t make out his facial expressions. He rubbed the cushions on either side of him to signal his contentment with her performance as he was anxious for more.
“Oh, you like that? You’ll like this better then…” Jessica said as her sexy voice trailed off.
She reached down and leaned forward slightly, bending a bit as she began to slip her fingers between the side bands of her thong to peel it off of her body. She slowly slipped it off past her thighs as it fell to her ankles. Ben couldn’t help but stare at the perfectly naked princess in front of him and then stuck his palm out face up, clearly indicating that he wanted her thong. Smirking slightly and letting out another giggle at the gesture, Jessica complied as she slipped it off one foot and then the other. Completely naked, she stepped closer to him and let it dangle and rest in Ben’s palm. Ben gripped Jessica’s thong tight in his grip, suddenly realizing that it was wet from her own excitement the entire time. Though he couldn’t see her wetness, he could certainly feel it now in his hand. He needed to taste it.
Ben moved the thong up to his face, letting it dangle from his mouth from the crotch area as he licked Jessica’s wetness from it. She watched, even more aroused now than before and began to lean down to sit on Ben’s lap facing him, but Ben quickly reached out with his arms nearly at full length and grabbed her hips, stopping her. He pulled his right hand back and took her thong out of his mouth, setting it on the cushion beside him.
***Ah, can’t let her get that close to my face…***
He slowly spun her around to make her sit on his lap instead as he brought his right hand back to assist with that.
“Oh, you want me to sit on your cock like this?” Jessica said playfully after being spun. “Okay, babe.”
With her facing away from him, Ben let out a slight sigh of relief, now not having to worry about her stopping their sex session prematurely. She started to sit back and down, letting her shapely butt linger in Ben’s gaze for a few moments as she reached down between her legs with her right hand to grab hold of his shaft below her. Ben lowered his left hand and pressed gently against her left butt cheek, taking the moment to caress it and squeeze it in his grip. He brought his right hand up to his mouth, licking his middle and pointer fingers so that they were wet to the touch. He slid his left hand a bit lower to be positioned underneath Jessica’s butt cheek to keep her from sitting as his wet fingers approached her glazed pussy as she remained partially bent over in front of him.
***Why is he hesitating?***
Jessica pondered only momentarily as she then felt the warm wet touch of Ben’s fingers glide against her pussy lips. She let out a hushed moan in excitement at his touch. Her grip on Ben’s cock loosened as she let go and placed both hands on her knees. Ben used his fingers to gently pry her lips apart, circling gently and playing with her clit as she hovered above him. He felt a bit more of Jessica’s weight rest on his left hand as she was becoming comfortable sitting in his hand as he played with her. She was lighter than Kelly anyway, so he didn’t mind her weight at all.
“Oh, yes…” She cooed, enjoying the attention as she felt the fingers begin to work her over.
Ben slowly back his fingers away, now with her wetness on them as well as he licked them for her taste. He squeezed Jessica’s butt cheek to signal for her to sit down as he pulled down a bit on her. Getting the cue, she lifted herself off his hand slightly and reached back down for his cock. She grabbed the rod and lowered to sit on it. The head of Ben’s cock finally made contact with Jessica’s sweet lips, which caused a grin to flash across his face as the horny girl continued to lower herself, taking the head partially in a slow manner before attempting to go further.
“Wow, babe…” Jessica moaned gently and sighed with some difficulty in her voice, realizing that she needed to get used to his size again.
***I mean it has been a some time since we had sex because of our last fight…***
Ben smirked again as he realized that he was bigger than Jessica was getting regularly and helped her a bit. He wrapped his hands around her bare waist and started to cautiously bob her body up and down as she held onto the shaft below until she forced herself down onto his cock, inch by inch.
“Ughh…yes…” She exclaimed with another moan, feeling his size in her fully now.
Jessica reached down and grabbed Ben’s hands on her waist, surprising him as she pushed them off from her body.
“Let me.” She said in a whisper, partially turning her head back towards him as she said it.
Ben let his hands go back to his sides as he watched her lean forward and begin to bounce herself slowly up and down his shaft. It was a beautiful sight to see as Jessica’s butt slid up and down his cock. He never thought the day would come, but it finally did, though it wasn’t how he expected that it would happen.
***Wow, she’s tight. Jessica only just now sat on my cock, but she already feels better than Kelly…oh, right…please stay asleep…***
She pressed her hands on his knees for support as she bounced up and down slowly at a steady pace, enjoying herself as she let out adorable moans of satisfaction that was music to Ben’s ears. Ben took his hands and placed them behind his head, truly enjoying the girl and smiling wide at how things turned out so well in his favor all thanks to his parents and her parents going out of town together and of course, Jessica’s own stupid and hasty mistake in her texting. She continued to moan and work her pussy on the cock hard for a several minutes as she varied her pace until Ben began to feel her clamping down.
Ben watched her back of her head intently as he felt her pussy walls closing in on him until she finally stopped moving and convulsed, twitching as she was cumming all over his cock. She continued to shake and squeal in increasing volume until Ben quickly reached forward and pulled her back into his chest, keeping her seated on his shaft, but muffling her mouth with his left hand to keep her from waking Kelly. Jessica waited a moment and then pulled his hand away from her mouth. Letting out a panting giggle, she began to compose herself again.
“Sorry…babe…I got carried…away…” She said as she almost forgot that she was doing this in the dead of night.
Now holding her close in his arms and on his lap, Ben kept his hold on her, letting his left hand wrap around her chest to latch onto her right breast as his right hand brushed Jessica’s hair away from her neck. He tilted her head to the left slightly as he gently kissed her neck and earlobe, which caused her to moan softly. He squeezed her breast as he thrusted slightly from underneath, bouncing her a bit. He repeated this motion a few times with hard thrusts that caused more passionate moans to escape Jessica’s mouth again.
“Mmm…more…” She cooed.
Ben moved both hands down her stomach and to her waist as he gripped her firmly and began to bounce her slowly up and down on his cock with ease. Jessica’s natural lubing up of Ben’s cock made it easy for her to glide up and down the shaft as she gripped her breasts and squeezed them, playing with her nipples as she was bounced around. Darkness and heavy panting and breathing continued until a creaking noise was heard at the top of the stairs. Jessica’s ears perked up.
“Wait!” She whispered with caution.
Ben didn’t relent as his panting grew and his breathing more labored. Jessica felt the throbbing cock in her getting closer and closer to exploding. A light flickered on at the top of the stairs just out of sight, but enough to create a bit more of an illumination downstairs. Fortunately for Ben, Jessica’s back was to him, but he opened his eyes at her slapping on his right thigh to get him to stop.
“Todd! Wait, stop.” Jessica said in a slightly agitated whisper.
He opened his eyes to see the back of her head more clearly and suddenly realized that Jessica might find out. His eyes slowly moved towards the side slightly as the new bit of light from near the stairs suddenly caught his attention.
***Oh, crud…***
“Ben..?” Kelly said sleepily from upstairs.
Jessica and Ben froze. Neither one of them wanted another light to come on and for Kelly to come downstairs, but for different reasons. She didn’t want Todd to get in trouble with her parents again and he didn’t want Kelly to know that he was banging his girlfriend’s sister in the middle of the night. Jessica couldn’t get herself off the cock fast enough to Ben’s dismay. He was so close to cumming that he honestly didn’t care if he got caught or not. Pulling herself off, she shot up and scrambled, looking for her underwear, but not looking at Ben in her rush. Ben shot up and grabbed Jessica’s thong as he zipped up his pants and started to move.
“You have to leave!” Jessica said in a panic, simply pushing the figure forward as he ran towards the front door.
He opened the door quickly with her thong in hand as the bottomless Jessica took notice from behind and angrily whispered as she lunged forward to grab them, “Babe, I need my underwear!”
Ignoring her, Ben ran out the front door as Jessica just barely missed. She hesitated in closing the door as she looked at the figure running down the street instead of to a parked car, but quickly dispelled her concern as she assumed that he parked somewhere else to avoid suspicion in case someone else like Kelly or Ben noticed a parked car in the driveway that wasn’t any of theirs. However, she also noticed that he looked a bit different as he ran past the street light nearby causing her to tilt her head slightly in confusion. Suddenly, she heard a footstep and creaking of a stair that snapped her out of it. Jessica closed the front door in haste and locked it as she realized that she had no underwear on. Scrambling like a headless chicken, she hopped over the couch and buried herself in it. Realizing that wearing nothing but a bra was not going to look good when Kelly saw her, she committed to just going with it. Laying down, she put her right foot up on top of the sofa and spread her left one out slightly as she began to rub her clit with her eyes closed.
Kelly flipped on another switch as she made her way down the stairs. Each thud of her steps caused more trepidation in Jessica as she hated the idea of humiliating herself like this as a cover.
“Jessica…?” Kelly asked, startled at the sight of a foot hanging over the sofa.
Looking over the back of the sofa to get a better look, she laughed and giggled, “What…what are you doing?”
Jessica pulled her foot back and covered herself her exposed lower half with her hands as she curled up and grabbed a nearby throw pillow to cover her embarrassment.
“Uh…nothing?” She responded shyly.
“Why’d you came down here in the middle of the night to masturbate?” Kelly asked with light chuckle, though still sleepy from just getting up.
“A..a change of scenery, I guess?” Jessica said with nervous laughter, though it wasn’t remotely believable.
“You’re weird.” Kelly stated plainly with a bit of a grin. She yawned now and looked around the room before stating her main reason for coming downstairs, asking, “Have you seen Ben?”
“Ben? No, why would I? He isn’t upstairs with you?” Jessica asked innocently, caught off guard by the topic.
“I can’t find him anywhere.” Kelly said, now confused that he wasn’t downstairs either.
***Huh, Ben isn’t here? I would’ve saw him or heard him leaving since he would’ve saw Todd and me down here for sure.***
“You know…you should be careful, Jess. What if Ben saw you? Would’ve been pretty embarrassing for you…” Kelly asked and said in a joking manner.
Jessica just stared at her sister with a look of disgust on her face at the thought. “Ugh…don’t even.”
“Hmm, he must have headed back to his house for some reason.” Kelly pondered out loud, not necessarily for her sister’s insight, but more so just to think out loud.
Suddenly, Jessica’s eyes went wide as she looked down at the pillow that protected her dignity.
***Wait…Todd felt…different. He never said a word to me…did he? Why wouldn’t he kiss me? He even looked different outside near the light….like….he ran towards….OH. MY. GOSH.***
A knot in the pit of Jessica’s stomach began to form as her mind was ravaged by thoughts of what could have, but should never ever have happened.
***Wait, don’t panic. Call that idiot, Todd, and find out where he went. He should be driving back now.***
“Jess, you okay?” Kelly asked with a bit of concern as Jessica was standing up now, but still covering herself with the pillow.
“Yeah, I just need to go to the bathroom. You know, I’m just going to go back to bed. You’re right. It would’ve been real bad if Ben saw me down here. I won’t be doing this again.” Jessica said, a bit flustered as she started to run up the stairs.
“Okay. I’m going to get a glass of water.” Kelly said as Jessica just made it out of sight. Kelly didn’t watch her sister’s naked butt running up the stairs, but just said it to an empty room as she walked off to the kitchen.
Jessica ran into her room and dropped the throw pillow onto the floor with little regard for it as she grabbed her phone from her nightstand. She quickly went to her texts to see what she had last said to Todd and found the text with the message that she had sent earlier. Determined to find out if he was still driving back, her slight smile quickly turned to one of disgust and shame when her eyes tracked up and locked onto the name, “Ben” at the top.
“WH..WHAT?” Jessica stammered as her arms went limp and fell to her sides.
She fell back slightly and sat on the edge of her bed, still with no bottoms on and shuddered as she raised the phone up to check it again. It was Ben’s cock she sucked on, his hands all over her body, his cock inside her, his cock that she came on, it was all Ben….the entire time. She laid herself down as she locked her phone and let it drop out of her hand and onto the bed next to her.
“How…did I not…?” She began as she crawled up and turned over on her stomach, burying her face into her pillow to muffle herself before screaming, “AAAAHHHHHHHHH!!!!”
***The next morning***
Ben sat at the kitchen table and sipped his cup of coffee as he eyed his girlfriend, Kelly, at the stove as she made them breakfast. Kelly wasn’t a chef, but she knew could adequately feed herself if she had food to make. Jessica, on the other hand, wasn’t so talented in the kitchen. She wasn’t useless in the kitchen per se, but since Kelly was a natural, it made less sense for her to try to compete at all.
“Babe, I still don’t get how you ended up homesick after putting me to bed last night.” Kelly said with a laugh.
Ben looked up Kelly from behind, starting with her bare feet, up her skinny legs until he reached her light pink, oversized sweatshirt. She was only wearing a light blue thong underneath. Getting lost in her beauty, he snapped out of it to answer, “Yeah, I know. I just like my bed, but I don’t think I’ll have that problem again.”
“Oh? You know, I could always come over too and then you’d have me and your bed.” Kelly said with a grin as she turned and walked over to Ben.
She leaned down and kissed him on the lips softly and pulled away a bit to give him a chance to respond.
“Hmm…that is an idea, but wouldn’t Jess notice?” Ben said, concerned that the parents might be upset upon hearing of this.
“I’m sure that she won’t mind.” Kelly said quickly as she kissed him once more.
She pulled back and walked back over to the stove as the bacon sizzled. The eggs were still yet to be made as Kelly looked over at the fridge.
“Ben, can you grab the sausages from the freezer?” Kelly asked.
“Sure, babe.” Ben replied as he got up and opened the freezer to get them.
“Oh, and can you ask Jess if she wants any sausages…actually, if she wants any breakfast? I don’t want to make more if she doesn’t want.” Kelly asked as she was busier and had her hands full with making breakfast than she was a minute ago.
“Yeah, okay, sure.” Ben said as he left the package on the counter near the stove and headed out of the kitchen.
As he started up the stairs, he started to think about Jessica and their steamy night together. He still regretted that he wasn’t able to finish, but found a consolation prize in finishing himself off at home since neither girl was available at the time. Taking a deep breath, he knocked on her bedroom door lightly, but ended up opening it quietly after hearing no response. He looked inside and saw Jessica in bed, but she was face down and under the covers. The only part of her that was visible was her left foot, which was hanging off from the bed. He walked over and lightly grazed her toes with the fingers of his left hand, back and forth a bit.
Jessica wasn’t asleep. She was wide awake, but lost in thought trying to determine if last night was just a really bad dream and if not, how to deal with the consequences of it.
“Kel..” Jessica started as she remained face down, but was interrupted by Ben’s voice.
“Jess.” He said in a normal voice without any whispering.
Jessica’s eyes went wide as she quickly pulled her foot from his grasp and turned herself over, wrapped up in her sheets in front of him as she sat up slightly. Clearly wide awake, she glared at him.
“Ben, what are you doing in my room?” Jessica hissed, but tried to maintain some level of composure.
Ben looked at her with a smile. “Kelly wanted to know if you wanted breakfast. She specifically wanted to know if you wanted sausage.”
Jessica curled herself up a bit more as she blushed visibly. It was enough to tell Ben exactly what he wanted to know. She looked up at him like a scared, defenseless animal. He reached into his back pocket and slowly pulled out Jessica’s thong from the previous night. He extended them to their full size in the air and turned them from side to side to poke at her further.
“You know…I always double-check before I text.” Ben said with a bit of a laugh as he shifted his gaze from the underwear to her.
“Oh, shut up…I thought…I thought you were my boyfriend!” Jessica said with anger in her voice as she watched him play with the underwear that she willingly handed over to him. “I…I can’t believe you would trick me like that!”
“Hmm…if I recall correctly, you did all of the work with your ‘apology’.” Ben said smugly with emphasis on the word, apology, as he put the prize back into his pocket and reached down to adjust the crotch of his shorts as his cock was beginning to get hard.
His adjusting drew Jessica’s overall attention before she caught herself and looked back up at him with fury in her eyes. The thoughts of passionately sucking his cock flashed in her mind again before she shuddered at the thought of it and of being tricked so easily.
“You must have been really horny, much hornier than I thought, for you to not realize I wasn’t your boyfriend.” He said to taunt her.
He was right. How could Jessica not know? At some point, she must have put two and two together. If she did, she wasn’t going to reveal it, especially not now. The tension in the room was intense as the two stared at each other in a bit of a stalemate at the moment though Ben knew that he was winning given that she wasn’t responding to his verbal jabs.
“We both know that you had your fill of sausage last night, but I think you probably want some more.” Ben said as he rubbed his crotch again in front of Jessica.
***I can’t believe this little jerk…well, he’s not so little…Jessica, get a grip. Right, right. I’m NOT sucking this jerk’s cock again!***
“Get aw..” Jessica started, but was quickly spoken over by Ben.
“I’ll let Kelly know that you want breakfast.” Ben said calmly, but with a grin as he knew what she was thinking.
The look on her face and her eyes sharpening towards him was plenty of communication as her displeasure with his play on words and taunting her was reaching its limit.
“Can you please get out so I can get up?” She said to him with disdain.
“Hmm…I wonder if you’re…” He said as his voice trailed off before quickly lifting the edge of her covers to see if she had any underwear on.
Jessica snapped and slapped the covers back down as Ben darted back to keep from getting hit by her.
“Oh, no panties, eh? No wonder you wanted me out first.” He chuckled from a safe distance.
“Stop, Ben! You little jerk!” She unloaded. “I’m going to tell Kelly about what you did. Did you even think about her…at all last night? I wonder what she would think!”
“Hey, I was just going to flip on the light to catch you because of your texting mishap. It’s not my fault that..” Ben started calmly because he knew he had her caught.
“You sat in the middle.” Jessica interrupted and said blankly as she stared at him. The statement was enough to shut Ben up for a moment before he looked at her somewhat confused, but then responded.
“And….you sat on my cock. Happily, I might add, as you did end up cu-” Ben said with a smirk in an annoying matter-of-fact voice, mostly to remind Jessica of just how eager she was to cum on his cock. Yet, he was quickly interrupted by an annoyed and angry Jessica before he could finish his sentence.
“You sat in the middle seat of a sofa that seats three people.” She said with a stern look on her face. “…I DIDN’T CUM ON YOUR COCK.” She added with clenched teeth and a death stare now.
“Yeah, so what…?” He said, still not following her as his voice indicated further confusion. “Oh, and you definitely did.” He added with a snicker.
“If your plan was to simply catch me for the texting thing, then why didn’t you sit closer to the lamp to turn the light on like you said? You can’t reach the lamp from the middle seat.” Jessica finished with a tone that made it seem as though she had a point as she had no more to say on the other issue.
Ben thought about it for a moment as he looked down at the floor, still not understanding what she was getting at with this conversation.
“Umm…the middle seat was more comfortable, I guess?” He said very unconvincingly, yet innocently.
Jessica’s anger subsided and the expression on her face changed towards Ben as she smiled, which confused Ben further as she didn’t seem mad at all now.
“No. I’m going to tell Kelly, and my parents, and your parents.” Jessica said plainly. “You had no intent to turn on the light and to tell me that it was you.” She added as she held onto her covers a little bit more loosely now.
Ben stood there like a statue, dumbfounded as the words began to process in his head. Suddenly, the fear began to sink in as he looked at the floor again, that is, until he slowly lifted his head up and met her eyes again with a smirk. Jessica looked at him as her own smile began to fade.
“Are you really going to tell them, what? That you sucked my cock in the middle of the night while Kelly was asleep? That you rode my cock until you came? That you only stopped when Kelly was coming down the stairs to catch you? Great plan.” Ben said, letting his words sink in for Jessica, who was staring blankly at him now, realizing that she would have to admit to all of that.
The anger returned and her face turned red again as Ben’s grin widened.
“Right. Thought so. You have cute undies, by the way. I’d like to see you in a pair with the lights on though. Put on a pink pair and get your butt downstairs for breakfast. Oh, and I want your only bottoms to be that pink thong, princess.” Ben said with a smirk and an air of confidence that only emerged now.
“UGH!!! Shut up, Ben! GET OUT!” She shouted, enraged and embarrassed, as she sat there defeated while Ben snickered and ran out of her room as he shut the door and ran back downstairs.
“I can’t…I can’t believe that all just happened…!” Jessica said quietly to herself as she sank back down in bed.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/osfhjt/an_uneasy_proposition_mfdomsubblackmail_part_3