All characters are 18+. Please leave your comments and feedback below! Thanks!
**P.S.** the bold and italicized text is someone’s thoughts/inner monologue, but can also be external actions.
Here is the background. This is a fictional story.
**Jessica**: F21. Main female of the story. 5’2″, blonde, c cup, petite, slender, athletic, great ass. Slutty at times, but loyal.
**Ben**: M18. Main male of the story. 6’1″, athletic build, brown hair, Kelly’s boyfriend.
**Kelly**: F18. Jessica’s younger sister. 5’4″, blonde, c cup, carefree, Ben’s girlfriend.
**Setting**: *Jessica and Kelly’s house*
——————————————————————————————————————————–
*A flawed invitation*
Jessica came down to enjoy a light dinner with her sister and Ben as the three ate pizza and then moved to the living room to watch a movie. Ben and Kelly were curled up together on one end of the couch, Kelly’s head under Ben’s chin as she was more so pressed against his chest, while Jessica sat curled up at the other end towards the edge of the sofa, leaving her butt and feet facing Ben and Kelly. Ben couldn’t help but glance over at her from time to time, wondering how Jessica managed to text him instead of her boyfriend.
Just as he happened to linger staring a little too long lost in thought, Jessica turned and caught him as she stared back puzzled until Ben quickly averted his eyes back to the movie. It was apparent to him that Jessica was playing the waiting game more so than anything else, hoping that Kelly would pass out as she normally does during movies and that Ben would also follow suit. He considered his options and wasn’t quite sure what he was thinking when he replied back to her text as he did. It was a mistake on Jessica’s part, sure, but his action was completely intentional and he wouldn’t be able to explain his way out of it. Suddenly, it dawned on him that he could just call her out on it when midnight rolled around and then have a good laugh about it. Sensing a huge weight being lifted from his shoulders as he found a way out, he smiled as he found himself finally able to relax a bit.
Some time passed, and it was about 30 minutes to midnight. Jessica feigned a comical yawn to signal that she was tired, which caught Ben’s attention as he avoided looking at her this time, but simply heard her as his ears couldn’t avoid it. She looked over at Ben and Kelly, the latter, passed out as expected and Ben simply watching the movie, but pretending to be somewhat sleepy and tired.
***Perfect…Kelly is asleep as expected and Ben looks to be almost there as well…***
“Well, it’s getting late. I think I’m going to turn in.” She said to Ben deceptively with another fake yawn. Ben wanted to laugh as she was putting on quite the performance, but managed to keep it together.
“Oh, looks like this girl is out like a light.” Jessica added, pointing to a sleeping Kelly in Ben’s arms.
“Hmm?” Ben peered around slightly to get a better look at his sleeping girlfriend, realizing that she was right. “I should probably wake her.”
“Oh, there’s no need to do that!” Jessica whispered as she leaned in towards them and reached out to touch Ben’s left hand with her right hand, stopping him from attempting to shake Kelly awake.
“A big, strong guy like yourself should have no trouble carrying her up the stairs to bed, right?” She added to prompt him to action as she slowly pulled her hand back.
“Yeah, no trouble at all.” He replied casually finding her deceptive behavior cute and attractive. It was the most interaction between them in quite some time.
She sat back and watched with a grin as Ben slowly made the sleeping Kelly straddle him before standing up with her secured in his arms like a baby.
***Hmm…okay, good, he’s stronger than I thought. He should be able to get Kelly to bed without waking her.***
Jessica stood up as well and began to lead the way to the stairs. Ben followed as he carried Kelly, but then noticed that she wanted him to go first as she stood at the base of the stairs and turned to face them.
“Aren’t you going up?” He asked her curiously.
“Yeah, I’ll get the lights down here first.” She said unconvincingly, not realizing that she was only fooling herself as Ben had remembered the part about unlocking the door in the text.
“Okay, sounds good.” He said as he started up the stairs slowly.
Jessica watched for a while until they were mostly out of sight before she went to the front door and unlocked it quietly. She turned out the lights and turned off the TV before heading up as well, waving to the back of Ben’s head as he disappeared with Kelly into her bedroom. Jessica went to her room and closed the door only partially as she wanted to make as little noise as possible when Todd came inside. Too much creaking of the door could be enough to wake the others. She used her time to get ready.
Ben used his right hand to scoop Kelly up higher into his arms, grasping her right butt cheek firmly as he pulled the covers back and then laid his girlfriend inside. He glanced down at his phone to see that there was still about 30 minutes until midnight. Ben shut the bedroom door and then made his way over to the desk in the room and sat at the chair, playing on his phone to kill the time. As the minutes went by, he looked on at Kelly from time to time as he heard her snoring lightly. Content with about 10 minutes remaining, he slowly got up and put his phone back into his pocket as he walked over to the bed and then looked down at Kelly once more. Brushing her hair aside, he pulled the covers back over her as he slowly backed away.
“I’ll be back in a few minutes, babe.” Ben whispered to the sleeping girl.
A slight grin appeared over his face as he planned to catch Jessica and foil her plans. He turned the light out in Kelly’s room and quietly stepped out as he closed the door behind him. As he started down the hall towards the stairs, Ben noticed that Jessica’s door was still slightly open, but that the light was out. He chuckled to himself as he went down the stairs, careful to make as little noise as possible. Ben glanced over at the unlocked door and made his way over to quickly lock it. The sofa was empty and inviting as his gaze fell upon it. He wandered over and took a comfortable seat as he waited.
***Hehe, she thinks she’s so sneaky…this is going to be so funny.***
Now sitting in the dark with both of his hands out to the sides flat on top of the couch cushions, he rubbed them a bit in a circular motion, getting himself ready to flip the lamp on when Jessica came down. Several minutes went by and eventually it was just after midnight. He sat there in anticipation as though he was the parent about to catch his rebellious teen daughter in the act.
“Well, it’s a few minutes after midnight. Maybe she figured out that she texted me instead, or maybe she expected him to go up to her?” Ben pondered quietly, muttering under his breath satisfactorily that he could go up and join his girlfriend now.
He leaned forward slightly as he was about to get up having waited long enough as he suddenly heard light footsteps coming down the stairs. He sat back, a bit excited and nervous as Jessica was probably going to flip out. When she came into view, Ben tilted his head slightly at her as he was struck by Jessica’s petite, shadowy figure moving limberly like a cat skillfully maneuvering herself down the remaining stairs and towards the front door. Despite no lights being on in the house, the moonlight peering through the windows was enough to give him a decent look at her. Lingering in his viewing of her body, he watched as she made it to the front door and placed her hands on her hips.
“Locked…?” Jessica said in a slightly excited whisper, wondering where Todd went.
She backed away from the door a bit and then turned her head and body to scan the room when she spotted the seated figure on the sofa. She started walking in his direction quietly, but a bit more quickly now.
“Babe…I was wondering where you were hiding.” Jessica said with a enthusiastic whisper, not wanting to wake anyone else in the house.
***Huh? Did she just call me, ‘babe’?***
Suddenly, Ben’s plan of flipping the light on to reveal himself to her was nowhere to be found in his mind as he sat there with his heart rate increasing slightly and was essentially frozen. His hands were now stuck, glued to the cushions without movement. The lamp was only a lean and reach away, but he was mesmerized by Jessica’s hypnotic movement towards him. He watched as she inched closer and closer to him, her bare feet lightly moving across the floor as she seductively shifted her hips with each step. She was finally standing in front of him and slightly between his seated legs as his eyes followed her until he looked up at her face. He couldn’t believe the sight of her. The night sky and moonlight nearby provided him with an ample view of her body now, but fortunately for him, seemed to prevent her from distinguishing his features based on their positioning. Jessica stood there now, leaning her knees slightly into Ben’s, causing himself to begin to feel aroused by her light contact. The bulge in his pants was beginning to become noticeable to him now, but he looked down, a bit concerned that Jessica would also notice. Realizing that she was still standing there like a statue, he started to look up slowly, his view beginning with her bare thighs until his gaze was on her dark-colored thong. Past her slender stomach, he saw the outline of her dark-colored bra until he saw her long blonde hair beside her shoulders and then looked back up at her face. Stammering for words, he tried to say something, but nothing came out.
“You’re still mad at me?” Jessica asked in a sweet, yet playfully pouty voice. She received no response except what she could see as a slight movement of the figure’s head seemingly in confusion. She continued with a more sexually alluring tone, “Okay…you don’t have to say anything. Let me make it up to you.”
***Mad? What’s she-***
With that, she gently reached down and laid her hands on his knees, gently running them up his thighs. Her soft feminine hands and fingertips grazed him through his jeans, causing him to shudder slightly. Completely floored by what was transpiring before him, he resolved to say nothing and just let Jessica make it up to him. After all, he reasoned that maybe she did know it was him and was making up for her general treatment of him. It wasn’t believable, even to him, but it could make for a good cover if things went sideways. She knelt down slowly, placing herself on her knees in front of Ben’s spread legs like a cat waiting for her treat. Ben stared on, still not believing that he and the hot, older neighbor girl — his secret crush of many years — were finally going to have sex.
She ran her smooth hands up his thighs, moving closer until he reached the crotch area of the jeans. She gently massaged the bulge in his pants as she looked up for a moment.
“You can stay mad, baby, but you can’t hide how excited you are right now.” Jessica giggled softly.
She reached and began to unbutton and unzip his jeans now, sending Ben’s mind into a frenzy of conflicting thoughts. She began to slowly tug on his jeans and boxers until she got them down to his ankles with a bit of Ben’s help.
***Oh, damn, what if Kelly finds out? I can’t let that happen. I have to stop Jessica…in a minute.***
Suddenly, his thoughts were interrupted by a soft, warm, dainty left hand, grabbing the shaft of the nearly fully erect cock. He twitched a bit, but then hoped that Jessica wouldn’t find his behavior strange or unexpected. She placed her right hand on his bare left inner thigh, leaving it there for the contact. He looked down at her as she slowly inched her face closer to his cock, staring at it as she got closer until she stopped in her tracks with her face tilted slightly to the right as her eyes moved towards his face again. Ben looked down, feeling very aroused by Jessica’s hand around his cock, but yet held his breath in fear now as he saw that she was staring a hole right through him. From his view, he saw his nearly fully erect cock blocking part of Jessica’s mouth and yet her eyes were seemingly glaring at him, just being seen over his member.
***OH, DAMN…she knows…she’s going to kill me…! I have to get out of here fast!***
The tension lasted for what seemed forever to Ben — although it was 10 or 15 seconds at most — until suddenly, Jessica said in a seductively controlling voice, “ready?”
Not expecting an answer and before Ben could process what she said, she immediately licked the tip of his cock, letting her tongue wrap itself around it for a sensually wet hug. The sensation of Jessica’s tongue against Ben’s cock was too much for him and he let out a hushed moan as the fear and fright left him as quickly as it had entered. With the tension now leaving him, his shoulders relaxed and the feeling in his body returned. She smirked slightly as she pulled away to hear his satisfactory response as well as noticing what she perceived to be her excellent ability to suck as Ben was writhing around in his seat. She then continued, taking him fully into her mouth, first the head and then the shaft more sensually, seeing as she wanted to take her time with her apology. She pulled him out of her mouth to gently and passionately kiss the tip a few times, each kiss causing Ben to squirm a bit more in his seat, though he tried to tone down his expressions of shock. She stroked his cock gently as she turned it upward to lick his balls a bit as well. She went from his balls up to the tip of his cock several times with long, slow, intentional licks.
***I’m such a horny slut right now….Todd seems bigger than before…by a good bit actually…wow, I can’t even think straight now…or even remember***
Jessica loved sucking her boyfriend’s cock and she was fiercely loyal to him as they had been going out for nearly 6 months now, but a slight rift in their relationship recently had caused a bit of separation. This was the first time they were having sex again since their last fight, or so Jessica thought. His increase or seemingly perceived increase in size only made the experience that much better for her. She continued to take him into her mouth, his musty scent filling her nostrils with more passion as she continued. Now with her eyes closed as she used her left hand to gently twist at his shaft, returning his cock back into her warm inviting mouth. Ben cautiously reached out with his left hand and inched closer to Jessica’s right hand that was on his thigh as he slowly touched hers and let his fingers interlock with her fingers so that they were holding hands. Jessica opened her eyes slowly for a moment to glance at her boyfriend holding her hand, appreciating that he was enjoying the blowjob and his warmth towards her. Just as she did, she felt Ben’s right hand gently caress the back of her head, helping her to bob her head even more across his length. The only noise in the room was the passionate slurping, licking, and sucking of Ben’s cock by Jessica and Ben’s own mild breathing.
After nearly 15 minutes of passionate cock sucking from Jessica with a few breaks for light stroking, Ben pondered just how he managed to avoid blowing his load into her mouth after the first few minutes. He tried to detach himself from the situation in his head, keeping his thoughts on other things as he wanted to avoid cumming right away. After all, he still wanted to pound the princess’s pussy while he had this golden opportunity in front of him. At the rate this apology was going, Jessica was going to make sure he took her pussy regardless of if he wanted to or not. He couldn’t afford to show up for that empty handed.
She pulled him out of her mouth slowly as the cock leaving her mouth left a popping noise that was deviously sensual with trails of spit following. Ben’s hands were back to the sides again as Jessica was overly enthusiastic already on her own for the blowjob. She looked up at the shadowy figure’s face, still being unable to recognize the guy sitting there. She had no reason to suspect it was anyone else anyway as who would engage in such trickery anyway? She smugly wiped her mouth with the back of her right hand and then used her fingers to trace the outline of her lips and residual spit from them. She was proud of her work as Ben sat there twitching a bit as Jessica moved her left hand underneath his balls to gently massage them in her soft grip while she wiped her mouth.
Unable to contain herself, she kept her hand wrapped around his balls and continued to massage as she used her right hand to tip his cock towards her as she met him with her mouth. She started to slurp against the tip as though she was sucking from a straw. She did this a few times before she stopped. Her action didn’t go unnoticed as Ben moaned again in response, to Jessica’s delight.
***Damn, she is perfectly amazing…Kelly is good too, but Jessica…Jessica…is…hmm…I must be pretty similar to her boyfriend if she’s not realizing that anything is wrong yet.***
“Hmm…I don’t know why you’re harder and bigger now, but I’m not complaining…” Jessica said in a seductive whisper that stroked Ben’s ego as well as she had stroked his cock. She leaned her head towards his cock once more, kissing the tip softly before backing away and releasing him. She wiped her mouth again, not having expected to go back for more as she did.
Jessica crawled upward a bit towards Ben’s face, wanting to kiss him now. Ben realized that she would undoubtedly be able to tell the difference between him and her boyfriend while kissing and even while getting that close to his face. In a slight panic, he reached up with his right index finger and put it to Jessica’s lips, stopping her early on and indicating that he didn’t want to kiss her. A bit stunned, she backed down a bit, but was undeterred in her want and need to please him.
“Oh, still mad?….Okay….I know what you want…” She replied, more determined to satisfy her boyfriend than before.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/on2k8c/an_uneasy_proposition_mfdomsubblackmail_part_2