“Hey Sarah could I ask you something?” Mike was calling down the hallway.
Sarah turned around to see Mike waving for her to come over. She gave him a bit of a confused look and started his way.
“What could he possibly want with me?” Sarah wondered, a bit apprehensively. She was usually one to hide in the far corner of class and keep to herself quietly. She never really talked or socialized with the other students, so she couldn’t imagine what Mike wanted to ask her.
“Yes?” Sarah asked as she came up to Mike.
“Hey Sarah, great, just the person I needed to talk to.” He started, “Hey do you get this stuff? You know the stuff from class?”
“You mean Biomes?” Sarah asked with a bit of confusion in her voice. It had been the topic from the last lecture.
“Ya those! You’re so smart,” Mike exclaimed. “Hey, do you have time to help me tonight? We got that exam coming up, and I really need a study partner.”
Sarah sighed a little, of course it was something like that; the curse of being the good student. She didn’t really need a study partner, but on the other hand teaching someone else was a great way to make sure you understand a subject well. Besides, how could she say no to Mike?
“Um okay sure,” Sarah replied, “I have some time after 6 tonight if that works?”
“Hey that’s great, you’re so awesome, thank you so much!” Mike sounded relieved. “What’s your number I’ll send you my address.”
They swapped numbers and Sarah headed off, her heart beating a little faster.
——
“Mike, like the Mike from Bio that you have a crush on? 😮” Sarah’s friend Keith was texting her back.
“yup that one 🤷♀️”
“and you’re going to his place tonight? Interesting… 🤔”
“🙄 it’s just to study for the midterm tomorrow”
“uh huh sure 😏”
“😡 oh stop it I just wanted to let you know where I was going to be”
“sorry couldn’t help myself 🙃 go have fun I’ll check in on you”
“thx 💕 see you later”
————
It was 10 minutes before six when Sarah rang the doorbell. After a second or two there was a rustling. The door opened and standing there was a taller blonde woman with long hair. Sarah instantly recognized her.
Her jaw dropped to the floor “Kate?”
Kate stood there for a second equally befuddled “S… Sarah?” she stammered, “Oh my god it’s little Sarah Smella from high school!”
Sarah cringed at her old nickname. It was one she’d been very happy to leave behind these last two years of college.
“Umm… ya hi. I was actually looking f…” Sarah started.
“She’s looking for me babe” Mike poked his head around the corner. “Hi Sarah, so wait, you two know each other?”
Sarah nodded “yes from high school.” She glanced up at Kate, “guess we didn’t get along the best back then.”
Kate gave a wicked smile, “Oh don’t worry I’ve matured a lot these last two years, and you are still an adorable little bookworm it seems.”
Sarah felt her temper rising, but Mike cut in before she could say anything. “That is so hot, like really weird but really hot!”
The two girls looked at him completely confused, and Sarah felt slightly creeped out.
“Hey come in and grab a seat I’ll be right back down with my books. I just need to ask Kate something real quick.”
Sarah went into the living room and sat down on the floor. She opened her backpack and textbook and put them on the coffee table, thumbing through her notes until she found the right section and started reviewing while waiting for Mike. Mike was taking longer than expected, but eventually he strolled into the room and sat down on the sofa. “Hey sorry can we get started?”
“Oh no worries, I was just reviewing a bit. Where did you want to start? Is there a part you were having trouble with?” Sarah asked curiously.
Mike laughed, “I dunno, maybe let’s start at the beginning?”
Sarah started to wonder just how much Mike even paid attention. “Um okay, well how about we walk through the review questions one by one then?”
Mike looked down at Sarah, “you have really pretty eyes.”
Sarah was completely dumbstruck by the comment, “oh umm… uh… th.. thank you.” She stammered. “Um so, page 52… what do you think the answer is for the first question?”
“He’s right, I always was jealous of them,” Kate had moved into the doorway to the kitchen unnoticed and had been watching the two of them.
“Oh uh… thanks.” Sarah said awkwardly. After all the years Kate had spent bullying her, Sarah wasn’t really sure how to respond to what sounded like a genuine compliment.
“You’re welcome,” Kate smiled back and went over and sat down next to Mike on the couch. She ran her long nails through Mike short hair, caressing it gently. Then she leaned in against his shoulder and looked curiously at the textbook that was out on the table. “I never really got animals and all that stuff” she added
Mike laughed “ya me neither, but I gotta do 6 science credits, so I guess I better figure it out!”
Sarah tried to be encouraging “oh don’t worry I’m sure you’ll get it in no time!” With that the two of them started reviewing. They were about 6 questions in when Mike let out this deep primal groan. Sarah looked up in surprise and saw Kate had her hand on Mike’s sweatpants and had begun rubbing his dick! It was partly erect now, and you could see it clearly through the thin fabric.
Kate caught Sarah staring, “Oooo sorry, I just got so bored listening to the two of you” Kate giggled.
“It’s okay babe, rub away” Mike chimed in, “I’m sure Sarah doesn’t mind.”
Sarah caught her face turning redder, “Um you know if you guys need a moment maybe I should go” she said nervously.
“No, no don’t go,” Mike interjected, “why don’t you come and sit up here too?”
Sarah’s jaw dropped, “wait you want me to what?”
Kate broke in “he’s got a bit of a crush on you, you know?” smiling down at Sarah, “and from what I can see I’m pretty sure it’s mutual.”
Sarah was now really embarrassed, she looked back and forth at the couple who were both smiling down at her.
Kate reached out her hand and grabbed Sarah’s “here come!” and with a tug she pulled Sarah up to the couch. Mike scooted over to make room and Sarah sat down between the two of them reluctantly. “Um wait, I’m not so sure about this” Sarah stammered.
“Let me help you with the top now,” Kate smiled.
Mike and Kate both grabbed one of Sarah’s arms and then lifted up her shirt over her head. “Um wait, I’m not…” Sarah interjected as they pulled her sweatshirt off. After the shirt popped off Sarah quicked covered her face with her hands. What she had been trying to say is she didn’t have a bra on, she was now sitting topless between her crush and her old high-school bully! The awkwardness was almost too much to bear!
“Oh my word, you are a little slut!” Kate teased “I always had you figured for a good girl too”
“No I just, they’re uncomfortable, and since…” Sarah blubbered.
“No no they’re beautiful!” Mike interjected. “Let’s see the bottom half too!”
“Um what?” Sarah interjected. Her brain was still racing to catch up with the events of the last 30 seconds, but any hope of a coherent response went away when Mike leaned in and gave her left nipple a firm squeeze. Sarah yelped in surprise, and Nike quickly went to kneading her breasts.
“Now these are perfect, not too big, not too small!” he said, and with that Kate started undoing the button on Sarah’s pants.
“Wait, wait!” Sarah called out but with a tug her jeans and panties were quickly over her hips. The couple worked quickly to remove them while Sarah sat there in a state of shock. She was now naked, sitting in between the two of them.
Mike got up from the sofa, gathered up Sarah’s clothes, and took them across the room. He placed them in a pile on the floor and stood in front of it smiling back at the two girls on the couch. “Hey Sarah, why don’t you crawl over here at suck my dick?”
Sarah looked at Mike and then at Kate, worried and confused. Kate grinned “you better do what he wants. If I know Mike that’s the only way you’re getting your clothes back.”
“But… but isn’t he your boyfriend?” Sarah asked, feeling very uncertain about this whole situation.
“Yup, and I want him to be happy” Kate replied, and gave Sarah a little wink.
Slowly, reluctantly Sarah slid off the couch onto her knees. She put her hands on the ground and paused a moment. She breathed deeply, trying to think again. She had had the biggest crush on Mike for a long time, and the sheer craziness that she was somehow kneeling here naked in front of him was making her feel very aroused. On the other hand though she hadn’t really agreed to any of this, and wasn’t sure she really was okay with what was happening right now. This didn’t feel right, but her befuddled mind couldn’t wrap itself around any coherent sentence to object with.
“That’s it, now get going slut!” Kate yelled, and with that landed a firm slap on Sarah’s backside. For her part Sarah yelped softly and reluctantly began crawling toward Mike.
“Aww yeah, look at those tits sway!” Mike commented, staring down at Sarah as she crawled forward. She reached Mike and looked up into his eyes.
“God you look so sexy” Mike said in awe as Sarah kneeled there. He pulled down his sweatpants and out popped his uncut 7” penis, nearly fully erect and yearning for some excitement.
“Suck him slut!” Kate cheered from the other side of the room, clearly amused by all this.
Mike grasped Sarah by the hair, and with a firm tug pulled her forward, pressing her lips against his dick. “Open!” he said in a firm domineering voice.
Sarah opened her mouth and Mike slid inside.
He thrusted slowly at first, giving Sarah a chance to adjust to his girth. Then he started moving faster, Sarah just kneeled there, keeping her mouth agape and letting Mike use her face. Unknown to the two of them Kate and been undressing across the room. She strutted over to join the two of them now, fully naked.
“Now don’t think I’m going to let you please my man without getting anything in return!” Kate whispered with a sly voice into Sarah’s ear.
In a single movement Kate grabbed Sarah by the shoulders and threw her to the ground on her back. Then she climbed on top of Sarah, pinning her arms down with legs, kneeling with her pussy right over Sarah’s mouth. “Now you can show me what a good slut you are” Kate said in a teasing voice. “Do a good job and you can go back to my boyfriend,” and with that Kate planted her pussy straight down onto Sarah’s surprised mouth.
After a gasp of surprise Sarah looked up at Kate. Kate’s eyes told Sarah she was serious. Sarah desperately wanted to get away now, but pinned there under Kate there seemed other option but to comply. So slowly, reluctantly, Sarah extended her tongue. Her tongue traced over the folds of Kate vulva, inside and out. It caressed Kate softly, and Sarah moved up teasing Kate’s clit just a bit with a few small swirls on her tongue.
“Oh my fucking world!” Kate moaned in pleasure. “How the hell did you learn to…” Kate groaned again and bit down on her lip. Sarah’s tongue felt mind blowing, probing in and around, wetting and caressing. Kate’s body was wasting no time in responding either, a wave of pleasure was building inside her, and she felt her first orgasm was close already.
“Dammit, you two are the sexiest bitches I’ve ever seen” Mike marvelled. “I need some of this too.” He kneeled between Sarah’s legs, spreading them apart as he went.
Sarah was lost in the moment too, concentrating on pleasing Kate, her heart was pounding. She felt Mike’s hands lifting her legs and a brief moment later there was pressure on her pussy lips. With a moan from Sarah and a grunt from Mike, Mike slipped inside.
Kate’s body had begun to shake now, as a wave of pleasure crested. Mike let Sarah’s legs fall aside and grasped onto Kate’s breasts. He gave them a firm squeeze and ran his fingers over Kate’s nipples. “I love you babe” he said. Kate moaned back, consumed with pleasure. Mike took his hands and started running them slowly through Kate’s long hair. Starting near her head and tracing down the length of her strands. When he reached the end he wrapped his arms back around her squeezing her tight.
As Kate’s orgasm was subsiding Sarah could feel her’s rising. Mike’s relentless assault on her pussy was driving her mad, as he seemed to thrust in rhythm just right with his rocking motion building her pleasure in turn. A few seconds later it was Sarah’s turn and her mind was awash in ecstasy as she moaned softly. A part of her hated what was happening right now, but oh it felt so darn good!
Seeing Sarah climax was too much for Mike, he was barely holding on already and now his cock started to stiffen. “Oh ya, fuck ya!” she started shouting, his thrusts sharpening.
Kate noticed this and leaned back a bit. “This slut’s pussy isn’t worthy of your sperm love, Plaster her face instead please?”
With that Kate leaned forward and slipped off Sarah’s mouth. A split second later Sarah felt the rush of emptiness as Mike pulled out of her. Mike stumbled forward and before Sarah knew it she was staring down the shaft of a penis about to erupt! Mike held it firmly as it jumped. Semen lurched out and Sarah clamped her eyes shut tight! She could feel the wet sticky splashes of Mike’s sperm covering her face and neck. After a brief moment she opened her eyes and looked up into Mike’s grinning face.
“Wow that was awesome!” Mike shouted “You girls are amazing!” While Mike was basking in his own pleasure. Kate stood up and went to get Sarah’s clothes.
To Sarah’s surprise though she didn’t bring them to her but instead started walking towards the front door. “Wait, what are you doing?” Sarah asked in alarm.
“Giving you your stuff back!” Kate joked as she opened the door and tossed Sarah’s clothes outside.
Face still dripping with semen, hands trying hard to cover her nudity, Sarah bolted outside. She made her way for her sweatshirt and gathered it up quickly, covering up her breasts. Then she headed for her pants which had landed several feet away. An older man who had been walking his dog across the street stopped to stare in amazement at the sight unfolding before him. While Sarah was gathering her pants Kate chucked her backpack and books outside as well.
“Have a good night slut!” She yelled, and closed the door with a mockingly friendly wave. Sarah could hear Mike laughing hard in the background.
Mortified Sarah gathered up her things, and using the side of the house for some cover started dressing. Thankfully the old man had moved on quickly. Looking to do the same Sarah wiped away Mike’s semen away with her sweatshirt, dashed to her car, and drove quickly home.
——
“Hey beautiful, just wanted to let you know both me and Kate had an amazing time tonight. You really are a hot little thing 🔥🔥🔥,” Mike message stirred Sarah’s phone to life.
Sarah stared at the screen for a bit “it wasn’t so good for me! Wtf was Kate thinking, throwing my clothes outside?!” She texted back angrily.
“Lol, ya that wasn’t right. Still was an amazing evening though. You want to come back and do it again sometime?”
“Ya I don’t think so, I had enough of Kate’s bullying in high school. I don’t need any more.”
“You sure? If she’s been bad she needs to be punished. I just might have a pair of handcuffs and a blindfold we could put her in if you’re interested in getting even? 🤔😉”
Sarah stared at her phone a minute pondering for a moment. Okay this might actually be fun, getting some revenge on her old highschool bully while having sex with her bully’s boyfriend? Kate wouldn’t be able to stop them from doing anything she didn’t want them to either this time. Now this idea had potential!
“Well how’s that sound beautiful?” Mike texted again after a moment.
Sarah smiled a devilish smile “Count me in! 😈” she texted back.
——-
Hello again horny friends and strangers! 😊
I thought I’d try something different this time to mix things up and challenge myself. This story idea is courtesy of a fellow redditor who wished to remain anonymous, so a big thank you to them for the idea! As always I love hearing what you liked or didn’t like about the story, or any ideas or ways to improve. Still learning as I’m going after all!
Hope you all have a sexy day 😘
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/ohn8em/by_request_tutoring_the_crush_mff_domsub
Looking forward to the revenge, can’t wait