This is the third installment to what my husband calls my “crazy” summer. He refers to it that way because my summer fling and I were very much “active” in the summer and I was close with another couple that lead to a few hot nights. This story is not the last of this relationship with the other couple that summer but was the benchmark for what was acceptable the rest of the summer.
For those who have kept up. This is my summer between year two and year three of college. I made friends with a girl from the high school next to mine during the school year and during summer break, while we both were at family homes, she started dating her high school ex and I dated his best friend. We were all at home so we spent a lot of time together and took a few trips to avoid being at our parents houses. My boyfriend was grant, a tall, built blonde guy and Amanda dated Jason, sort of skinny/lanky with buzzed dark hair. While we had our obvious relationships, there was always some sexual tension between the four of us.
Earlier in the summer, 4th of July weekend, we all went to Grants cabin up north and spent a few nights. The recap is I lost a game and had to streak. Amanda and I flashed some old guys for beer on the river we floated down, Jason and Grant both saw Amanda and I topless and Amanda and Jason also walked in on me riding grant during sex when I was acting embarrassingly like a pornstar. An overall sexual weekend for 2 new couples.
This was our second trip to the cabin 3-4 weeks later. By this point we were all much closer because we had spent a lot of nights at the bar or each other’s places through the previous weeks. Grant and I were always together and typically that led to some sort of sex. We were always making the car, basement, or even a quickie in the bathroom work since we didn’t have our own place, but that definitely didn’t stop us.
We would go up on a Friday and stay Friday night, canoe/kayak on Saturday, party that night and come home Sunday. Each couple had their provisions and we drove up separately to keep two cars.
As soon as we arrived we started drinking and based on what we purchased, it was going to be a drunken weekend. It was a sunny day and we were mostly outside so the boys were shirtless early while they put out the furniture and prepared a fire and Amanda and I had our bathing suits on with simple shorts and tank tops as cover ups. It didn’t take long for Jason to ask if I was wearing the American flag bathing suit again, which I had already given back to Amanda. Instead I did have a new strapless suit from Victoria secret that was multiple neon colors. The cups on it were a little firm, so the only thing I didn’t like is I would pop out a bit if I laid on my back or lifted my arms high. Amanda had on the suit she wore last time but was planning to bring out the American flag on the water.
During the day Amanda and Jason both razzed me about how they wanted to watch us have sex because of how crazy it looked when they barged in on us, and we turned it on them that we were just trying to see if we could actually get as loud as them. The main point is that immediately the sexual tension was high again. We settled in, bbq’ed for dinner, and took the four wheelers out for a light ride before sundown. Once evening hit we went back inside to play games.
We started with the normal ones, round of euchre. A drinking game we used to call “mushroom,” cranium. Once we were drunk and the game’s stopped moving along we once again fell to the more sexual game “truth or dare.” Knowing this group, I knew it could actually be an interesting game and was already pondering what types of truths or dares well we would have.
This was nearly 15 years ago, so I don’t remember the specifics of the game but this is true to memory. In general i remember the mood was really easy going even when I didn’t expect it to be.
To start, everyone was testing the waters with easier questions. Things like “have you faked an orgasm” or have you “had a wet dream” or “had a one night stand” and it seemed everyone answered honestly and it would often spur the story and others answering the same question.
Probably after a round or two and seriously 30 minutes of discussion Amanda was the first to accept a real sexual dare. Jason seemed ready and recommended that she put on the American flag bathing suit, model it for us and then stay it it for the next hour.
The cabin was small, only 2 bedrooms and a main room/kitchen. There was also a bathroom near the front door but that was it. When Amanda accepted her dare she walked into their bedroom and without closing the door she changed into the flag bottoms. None of us could see but I remember thinking if someone went to the bathroom they would see her in there and get a full show. I’m sure it crossed grants mind. She came out and the suit was just as I remembered. She was spilling out of the triangle tops and the bottoms were basically a thong. She walked around our table a few times, spun, stuck her butt out and lifted her hand to her lips like she was a pin-up girl blowing a kiss. We all cheered, probably me the most. My boyfriend grant was always talking about her so I know he enjoyed and she did look great in that suit…for at least our small group.
I did a dare, which was ultimately to motorboat Amanda. It seemed that was more her dare so we just both motorboated each other in our bathing suit tops. Amanda’s boobs are big and firm so it was sort of fun to “dive into” them.
Finishing the round we simply had the guys strip to boxers. We figured fair is fair since I was already in my bathing suit top and Amanda just changed. The guys undressed at the table, they too started to model and walk around the table and did the pin up pose. Both of the guys were wearing boxer briefs, so you could see quite a bit and it was the first time I saw Amanda take notice of grant in the same way he looks at her body. It made me feel good that she was eyeing him.
During the next round I remember it being more about Amanda and I. With the motor boating, I think they wanted more. The dare was for Amanda to give me a lapdance, which amanda willingly did and was amazingly good at, and then they made it a challenge that I had to give her a lapdance, and then they would vote. I took off the shorts and had just my bathing suit left. Making it even with her outfit. I gave her a lapdance and felt super awkward dancing, especially since we didn’t have music going. My dance only lasted 30 seconds or so and hers was by far the better performance. The guys still voted a tie though because I earned big points when Amanda pulled my top to the side and showed my nipple…the nudity had already begun.
For the guys we thought it would be funny to make them take a shower together, like they wanted from us the first weekend we spent together. With boxers on, they both go into the tiny shower and we were able to take a couple funny pictures of them with shampoo in their hair and such. It was nothing sexual but we thought it was funny. That dare only lasted a few minutes, so they dried off changed into some sweatpants or basketball shorts, and returned to the main room. The shower dare was disrupting enough that we never really got back into the game. Instead, the guys starting talking about how they should have gotten the lapdance and not the girls, and that they were stupid it to think of that originally.
They, Jason mostly, continued to banter about this and suggested a round 2 of the lapdance challenge. Jason noted it would need to be on both of them to “make it fair and compare apples to apples,” while he looked to grant for approval
I wasn’t really entertaining it but Amanda was jabbing back and forth about how embarrassing it already was, and conceding that I won even though she looked like she had done it before. It became pretty clear the guys wouldn’t let it go.
Jason was finally able to break down Amanda for one more round, and that made it impossible for me to back down. At this point it was just for the benefit of the whining guys, and I figured it would be really quick. Amanda, per usual, was willing to go first and we discussed her starting with Jason then grant, then I would do the opposite since we would be more comfortable starting with our boyfriends. Jason then set up all of these rules and guidelines. No touching from the guys, It needed to be the whole song, equal time between the two guys, etc. This made it a lot more real and suddenly I was really nervous. That’s a long time and dancing is so uncomfortable…especially sexy dancing
The guys moved two kitchen chairs out from the table and Amanda put on music to some upbeat song I was unfamiliar with. She started dancing in front of all of us and shaking her ass. She always made things like this look easy due to her confidence. If I didn’t know better she had been a stripper before. For the first 30 seconds or so she gyrated in front of them and skipped around. She then approached Jason. Spread his legs and turned around to drop her ass in his lap. Grant readjusted to ensure he could get the best view. Jason quickly broke his own rule and put his hands on Amanda’s chest while she was grinding on his crotch for a second. She then got up and turned around to straddle him. This put her boobs right in his face, so he did the same motorboating I performed earlier. She rode him from the straddle position and he was oblivious to anything else in the room. She then moved over to grant who looked so nervous. I wasn’t sure if she would be more timid, but she ended up doing almost the exact same actions. Only difference was grant didn’t go in for the motorboat like Jason did. The hesitance is what prompted Jason to chant “take it off, take it off.” Amanda, who always seemed to follow Jason’s direction pulled the flag top apart and smothered Grant with her boobs. He didn’t even have a chance to avoid them, but also didn’t appear to try and stop the situation. Amanda stood back up, boobs still out and the song was still going. Now being the awkward end, she walked over to me and danced for a few second me before covering up and calling it quits. Grant stood there a bit dumbfounded and Jason was having the time of his life and saying she was a 9, “leaving just enough room for a potential dark horse.”
I was so happy she went first as I was able to steal some moves or understood expectations. I remember as much as I was nervous i rationalized that it wasn’t any worse than grinding on someone at a dance club, which I was familiar with, and obviously knew these three much better and this wasn’t really new for our group.
My song was Britney Spears – Breath on me. That’s always been my song for getting ready and feeling sexy. Amanda was the one who set up the music again while the guys sat in their chairs after minutes of discussion about Amanda’s performance and specifically Grants look after she smothered her boobs in his face. Just before I started Jason said “I’m looking forward to this” which was the thing I needed to hear to turn me on enough together started. Amanda hit the music and I started dancing in front of the two of them. I’m wearing the strapless neon patch Victoria secret bathing suit, and the bottoms are not quite as small as Amanda’s, but I was impressed I was willing to buy them.
My dancing is nothing special. I basically just gyrated my hips and bounced around a little while the guys watched. I leaned over and showed off my ass while I tried to twerk and failed, but caused laughter. I remembered that the strapless suit would be a little revealing if I raised my arms so I put them over my head while I shook my hips for a second. I knew they got a peak based on the reaction it received. Each reaction was more fuel to me. After what felt like forever, I then walked over to grant. I did the same thing that Amanda did. I spun around and sat in his lap while continuing to gyrate. I could feel him hard and I concentrated my movement on that while trying to also stick my chest out or flare my legs in some way to make it look like I knew what I was doing. Grant followed Jason’s lead and put his hands on my boobs while I was grinding and facing away. I then got up and straddled him and raised my arm like a cowgirl while I rode him and started to act like when they barged in on us. This had everyone laughing again. As a finale pulled my top to the side and pulled grants face into my chest while i shook it. When I pulled away he again looked dazed. I then got back up and started dancing while I adjusted my top back on
Next I had to give Jason a lapdance. This was an odd moment as we were all close but Jason always seemed extra flirty with me, and he was always pushing the limits of the situation while grant went along with anything. I walked up to him and danced right in front of him. Spun around and bent over and he couldn’t resist giving it a slap. I snapped up and looked at Grant to see if he would say anything, which he didn’t. I then pulled jasons knees apart and spun to a seated position on him. I could also tell he was hard, but it was sort of sideways so I just ended up moving around for a second then lifting my ass up closer to his chest. Again with my ass right in his face he grabs both cheeks, which again snaps me back into standing up and another quick confirmation glance from grant.
At this point I knew that grant didn’t really care what happened, and there was still quite a bit of song left. I then pushed Jason’s knees together and straddled him. This time he must have adjusted himself because it felt like his hard on was tucked into the waistband of his sweatpants and that he only had his sweatpants on. It was a huge turn on suddenly and I began to grind on him. I wanted to get into it because it felt so good so I played it off again like I was a cowgirl and put my hand in the air like I had a lasso. Meanwhile it was only a couple thin layers of clothing and I remember being so wet and thinking my bottoms were soaked. It was hard for me to forget my boyfriend was watching so I looked at him and he seemed relaxed and into it. After ensuring not to let myself go too far, Jason took the honors to separate my top and started to suck on one of my nipples. At nearly the same moment, the music ended and it snapped everyone in the room back to some sort of normal. After a few seconds for everyone to react to each other, Jason says, “It’s a 9 for Elise. A tie breaker is necessary to make the final decision”. He had been thinking of how he would score this for a while and we all booed him that he needed to pick a winner.
Again with much debate and bartering, Jason somehow talked us into having the loser do a consolation lapdance for 1 minute. Even though it was already a crazy night, it seemed they were not yet content. Knowing Amanda was always the confident one, she was again the obvious winner,still, they decided to make her lose, probably for the better final lapdance.
Amanda then had to do 1 more minute as her “penalty for the loss”. As soon as the music started and she approached Jason to start dancing, I joined her feeling it was only fair after all of the nights progression. I jumped on grant and we both did our routines. With us both there, we definitely stayed longer than 30 seconds. But Jason made the call early that it was for both of them. Amanda and I once again caught eyes and backed off each of them while we adjusted and switched.
After the last few antics with Jason, I was timid at first. I looked over at grant and I saw one of Amanda’s little pencil eraser nipples in his mouth. He was definitely in his own world and Amanda seemed totally into it. Her top wasn’t just moved, it looked almost torn off. Grants hands were on her ass and she was grinding on him.
The jealousy, anxiety and amount of turn on that came from watching them was really intense. By the time I turned back to Jason my top was already pulled down and around my waist. Jason was all over my chest, squeezing my boobs together and licking/nibbling at my nipples. I was fully straddling him and started to rock and get into it myself. I looked at him and awkwardly he kissed me. It wasn’t just a peck, he was shoving his tongue down my throat, which felt more intimate that the lapdance to be honest. Even still, I kept my tits out and found my groove back on his hard on. I put more pressure down onto him and was near finishing myself off. I then felt his hands on my ass and he started to push and pull it to keep us all on the same pace, then whispered in a way only I could hear “fuck me elise”. I seriously was on the precipice of cumming when the song stopped and and in turn so did we. I looked over at grant concerned he saw how intense Jason and I were and he looked like a deer in headlights with Amandas too on the floor and her on top of him. Her bottoms were all yanked, so in started to assume they may have gone further.
We all knew it was getting carried away, and surprisingly, Amanda was the first one to say she was getting tired and wanted to go to bed, followed by noting her and Jason would be loud for a minute.
We cleaned up a bit to avoid the morning drudge and then headed to our rooms. As Amanda stated, they had quick and loud sex. Embarrassed from the last time, grant and I were also intimate but stayed very quiet. Grant didn’t last very long but it didn’t matter because I finished in about 3 seconds after he entered me.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/odeyd9/fun_summer_break_during_college_part_3