Casual hookup with [M]y ex [F] led to a new obsession

So, I dated this girl for several years during college – we tried twice to make it work with a several month break in between because she cheated on me.

That left the door to romance firmly closed, but she was always delightfully slutty in bed. The weird thing is I used to be so paranoid about the idea of getting people pregnant even with birth control, so I’d never really cum inside her intentionally. Sure, we’d had a condom break in the past, but that wasn’t very fun because we were young and too worried about getting plan B quickly.

So one night I was single and horny, and I decided what the hell…she might be down for something casual. She was living with her grandma at the time while she figured out her situation with continuing school, but her grandma was hard of hearing and slept with a CPAP – so no worries about being overheard. Lo and behold, she was indeed down to fuck. So I headed on over.

When I got there, she met me in the garage wearing a nerdy T-shirt and a short little frilly skirt. She was a thicker brunette with blue eyes, big tits, and plenty of hips. We’ll call her Kiki.

The two of us started catching up a bit on the intervening years in the garage over a couple beers from the nearby mini fridge, and eventually things got quiet.

“Sooo…you still wanna fuck?” I asked.

“Hell yeah!” She replied, “Let’s go to the basement.”

She led me downstairs and turned around in front of the twin guest bed. She had always been a bit on the submissive side, and I could tell she wanted me to start. I grabbed her by the hips and kissed her a few times, sliding one hand around to smack her ass, and noticed that I felt no panty lines. Oh yeah, that’s the slutty girl I remembered.

“On your knees…” I whispered. She obliged, and without prompting started unbuckling my pants. She pulled down my jeans and boxers together, and my cock sprung free – I’m decently endowed and uncut.

Her lips parted a bit and she stared hungrily as she started to stroke. I hooked a finger under her chin and pulled her face closer to my cock – she got the hint. She started by pushing spit out between her lips and rubbing them all over the head – she always used to say feeling the smooth skin of a cock on her lips was one of her favorite things. Eventually she took it into her mouth and I started thrusting a bit, grabbing her by the ponytail.

It wasn’t too long before she took it out of her mouth and looked up with big soft eyes. “Aren’t you gonna fuck me already?” She asked.

I grabbed her by the collar and pulled her to her feet, pushing her back on the bed she’d been kneeling in front of. I took her legs by the knees and raised them, standing before her – as her skirt fell back I could see just how eager her swollen hole was. Her big puffy pussy lips were glistening.

I lowered my cock across her pussy and slowly sawed forward and back between her lips. She moaned and bit her lip muttering, “You fucking tease, fuck me already!”

I slid back and slowly wedged the tip of my cock into her opening, “You want it that bad, huh?” She nodded. So I obliged – three firm thrusts, and I was buried balls deep.

“Fuck, I’ve missed your cock!” She groaned. I wasn’t about to engage in small talk though. I was hungry for her, myself, and I got to work with long steady thrusts. Every once in a while I’d pull myself out and watch her whine to have it back – rubbing my foreskin against her clit to tease her more.

But I was in a strange mood that night, and I suddenly had a weird thought go through my head.

“Hey…have you been good about your birth control?” I asked, pausing deep inside her.

She looked up at me, confused, “Um, yeah I guess…why?”

“I was thinking I might go ahead and cum in you this time.”

Gush. Her pussy actually gushed a little flood of extra juices on my cock as her eyes got all wide and she stammered, “Y-you…want to cum in me? Holy shit…do it!”

She didn’t need to tell me twice. I started driving myself into her harder, pushing her legs back to get as deep as I could. Her eyes got all fiery as we locked gazes , and her mouth fell open as she panted and grabbed onto my hips to pull me against her with each stroke.

“Come on, do it already!” She grunted.

That did it – I bottomed out in the back of her and felt my orgasm start. As I began to throb inside her she rocked her hips back ever so slightly, eagerly inviting my load in as her walls began to twitch around me. The flood of warmth was exquisite – I could barely move, let alone bring myself to slide out.

She reached down and began furiously rubbing her clit as she panted – it didn’t take long before she came around my cock. Finally I’d had enough, and I slid free as the mess came pouring out of her.

We did that a few more times that summer before she went back to school, and I’ve had a creampie kink ever since.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/obvj2i/casual_hookup_with_my_ex_f_led_to_a_new_obsession