This is part 2 of my story with Jen. Part one is here, the TLDR – I fucked my best friend in a movie theater. There’s a little back story so skip to the — if you want to get to the hot and heavy.
Her comment about wanting me to finish in her mouth had me frantically googling what made cum taste good – I, of course, absolutely inhaled pineapple juice about twice everyday that week.
If you’re just coming here – Jen was about 5″3, C cups, and had a volleyball player’s ass. I included a little more detail in the first story.
Picking up where we left off –
I get a text from her as soon as she gets into the taxi. We did a little debrief about it and talked about some of the highlights. We were still a little shy around each other in person, but once we started texting – she opened up about how she felt like such a slut in there and how much getting fucked from the back turned her on. She regretted not spending enough time with my balls in her mouth.
I got some notes too – she wanted me to be more vocal, rougher, and treat her like my little slut. It was strange, adding “my” allowed me to say just about anything and she loved it.
She had sent me naughty snaps before, but tonight was different. It started how we usually did, writing a fantasy about our characters. It was usually along the lines of – teacher bending the naughty student over the desk. This time, we’d decided on a confessional (dw, we didn’t actually do it there).
Something about being a good catholic girl, kneeling on the confessional with a cock in her mouth, drove her wild. She sent me a snap of her sucking on a handle of a makeup brush (it had a thick rounded end). We took that and ran with it
“be a good little slut and suck on the tip, then lick all along the length, and take it in your mouth”. And she sends me a snap of that.
“now get on your back, spread eagle, and rub the handle along your pussy”. She points the camera at the mirror in her room and does better – her freshly shaved pussy glistening in anticipation, she puts the tip inside her. It always starts as “just the tip”
With some encouragement, her next snap is of her fucking herself with the hairbrush while moaning something like “yes, fuck me harder, use me like *your* dirty little slut”. We finished off that night with her sucking on hairbrush, and we talked about what we would do when we skipped mass this week.
We built out our fantasy through the week, and we eventually got to anal. It started simple, I had Jen lick her fingers and put them in ass – she seemed to quite like that. By Friday night, she’d graduated to putting the makeup brush in her ass and fucking herself.
I think the cashier at CVS could sense my excitement when I brought the lube. Jen and I knew that it was going to be wild.
—-
I walked inside the church and she was waiting for me by the stairs. “Well don’t you look absolutely adorable”.
She looked like a perfect little slut – innocent but fuckable, *my* fucktoy. She was wearing a short white and black skirt with a tank top. I could tell from her nipples poke through the fabric that she wasn’t wearing a bra. The older ladies at church were starting daggers into her, but we weren’t around long and I think that turned her on a little.
We snuck onto the third floor using the stairs, and I playfully slapped her ass as we went up. She raced to the top and lifted up her skirt, giving me a peak – she wasn’t wearing any underwear.
The floor was empty except for an auditorium filled with chairs. We’d been going here for years and knew this place inside out. I playfully grabbed her ass as we made a beeline to the handicapped bathroom in the back that no one ever came by.
I got in first and then a minute or two later – Jen followed me in, locking the door behind her. I grabbed her, pushed her back against the wall, and started making out with her. We weren’t nervous this time, just horny and excited.
I spun her around so that she was facing the wall and pressed her up against it. Lifting up her top so her breasts were flush against the cold tiles. I wrap one hand around her neck and the other makes it way down to her already wet pussy. I kiss the nape of her neck and whisper into her ear – “you’re *my* little whore now”. Jen teases – “someone’s getting a little excited”.
I moved my hand up from her pussy to her mouth so she could suck on my sopping wet fingers. It turned me on so much to see her taste herself.
“My little three hole slut, I’m going to take your pussy, then your ass, and your warm little mouth.” Jen – “fuck, make me your dirty slut. I want you to fill all my holes”. We’d been practicing our lines.
I turn her around, kiss her and then push her to her knees. (at some point, I’d also taken off my shirt for her to kneel on – not that it helped much). She takes my cock out of my shorts and I’m already hard. She excitedly grips it and licks my cock, swirling her tongue over the tip, before giving the head a little kiss.
I look down at her, “well? slut”. She looks up at me expectantly, “please fuck my mouth”. She wraps her lips around my cock and does some of her best work yet. I say “you’re not leaving until I cum deep in your throat” as she attempts to make eye contact.
I put the toilet seat down and sit on it. She gets into a cowgirl position. Thank fuck for handicapped bathrooms with those supports. She lifts up her skirt and I slowly slide her down until I’m deep inside. It was clumsy and a little awkward but I forgot about that quickly. She felt perfect – wet, warm, and tight. She wraps her hands around my neck and starts bouncing on my cock. “Fuck, ugh you’re so tight.”
Soon, I grip her ass with both hands and stand up with my cock still inside her. I push her back against the wall and thrust up into her. Jen – “Aah fuck, you feel so good inside me”, before burying her face in my neck.
My legs get tired and I left her down, my cock slipping out. I kiss her and start to take off the few clothes she is wearing. She gets on the toilet with her knees on the seat and her hands on the handicap support behind.
“Do you want to try anal?”. Jen thinks about it for a minute and says “get the lube”.
“who would have thought, my innocent little catholic girl, naked and about to get raw dogged in the ass at church” and she moans. She’s playing with herself as I find the lube (strawberry flavored) and rub some onto my cock and her ass. I enter slowly and she lets out a moan. “careful, people will hear us” – this only makes her louder. Encouraged, I start fucking her hard and throwing caution to the wind – loudly spank her ass a few times. If taboo made anal hotter, this made it a 100 times better.
My cock pops out, Jen – “why’d you pull out” and “please put it back in”. I say something like “beg for it”. In her sluttiest voice says “fuck my ass and ruin it, make me your whore”.
My cock – already wet from what was probably a mix of lube, spit, and Jen’s wetness – slides right back in and I pick up the pace. Then, I take both of her wrists with one hand and pin them behind her back – fucking her as hard as our precarious position would allow.
I pull my cock out, this time on purpose – she turns around and sits on the seat. She takes my cock straight from her ass into her mouth and goes as deep as she can. I love it when she makes those deep throat noises. “Fucck, can you taste yourself on me”. She moans something incomprehensible as my fingers tangled through her hair – guiding her.
We get up and I bend her over the sink. “spread your ass” and she does, giving me the perfect view of her tight pussy and asshole – I could swear it winked at me. I use my cock to play with her pussy, rubbing her clit, before I disappear inside her. Jen – “fuck me harder, I want your cock deep inside me”.
I grab her hair to pull her head up, her pussy gripping my cock as I roughly thrust in and out of her. “Keep this up slut and you’re going to make me cum” and I bottom out inside her.
Jen – “oh no, please cum in my mouth. please, please, please. I want to taste you cum”
I pull out, she immediately gets on her knees in front of me. I slap her hands away from my cock and tell her I’m going to use her mouth. “fuuckk” as I slide past her lips.
I let out a sigh as she sucked one of my balls into her mouth. She took the other one in too, and let her tongue run across them.
“I’m close”, she moves away, opens her mouth wide and sticks her tongue out. Jen – “come for me, come in my slutty little mouth”. There are few things hotter than a girl telling you to cum in her mouth and that sent me over.
I’m jerking off faster now, I put my cock on her tongue and the first shot hits the back of her throat. She takes over from there, her mouth covers the head. She keeps sucking on it and jerking me off until I’ve emptied my entire load into her mouth.
Kneeling on the floor, completely naked she opened her mouth so I could see her swallow my cum – it was probably the hottest thing I’d ever seen. Porn wouldn’t be the same again.
We got dressed and I helped her get cleaned up. We sneak out of the bathroom. We sit in the stairwell and chat until someone comes to pick us up.
That was the last time that I saw her for two years, she moved away to a different country. We’re still friends and she’s dating a guy who she absolutely adores. He’s moving to South Africa next month and I imagine that’s difficult. I still meet her whenever we’re both back for the holidays. Was Jen the “one that got away”?
I think I have a few interesting stories left, but not with Jen. I stumbled my way into sex in the college library and on the school pianos.
Drop me a comment or a message, I’d love any suggestions on my writing.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/oakwuc/mf_anal_in_a_church_with_my_best_friend
Yep Jen WAS the one that got away.