Chapter 10 – [M]y little [F]ucktoy – Joining In [MFF]

Chapter 10 – Previous in Profile

With Ellie back, and a weekend of fun filled times with Jim and Lucy, there was little time to focus on Cindy. This ended up being fine with all involved, as Cindy was focused on family and other events. We did communicate via text a bit and most of them were very steamy, including graphic details on what I would do to Cindy when I next had her alone. Closer to home, Ellie and I regularly talked about the fun things we could do with Cindy, which was great, because it always ended with us getting it on. The consistent turn on for Ellie was wanting to watch without Cindy knowing. We talked about facetime versus in person, but finally decided in person would be so much hotter.

Our chance finally arrived last Friday: I had taken the day off, so I was free, and my dumbass brother was on another trip to the city to meet with clients. My text first thing in the morning to Cindy was instructive and clear: “I’ll be there at 10. Leave the door unlocked, get naked, and be on your bed waiting, plug in. I am going to tie you to the bed and fuck your dirty little asshole until I pump you full of cum. Then, I’m going to do it again.” Her response made me smile: “Yes sir.” I ended the conversation with one other reminder: “And slut, make sure that fun little riding crop is close by.”

The texting happened while I was still in bed, and I must be honest, texting her the instructions and knowing Ellie would be sneaking in to watch had me rock hard. Upon seeing my state, Ellie acted, quickly taking me into her mouth. With her mouth engulfing my cock and her hand massaging my balls, it took no time for pre-cum to start leaking from the tip. Unfortunately, this signaled Ellie to stop and slow down. She spent the next twenty minutes torturing me, getting me so close to the edge before stopping and waiting for me to calm down. My cock ached with the need to erupt, but Ellie knew exactly what she was doing and left me wanting.

“Just making sure you’ll be frustrated enough you’ll fuck her ass hard for me today!” Ellie exclaimed with a smile as she quickly laid back and spread her legs. “Now get down here and make me cum. No games, I need it bad. And before you complain, I am not going to use and abuse my sister-in-law later, so eat me out.” I thought about protesting but knew better than to push it. Eagerly, I got on my knees and buried my face in Ellie’s waiting wetness. She tasted like a mix of sweat, pussy, and of course, cum, having fell asleep directly after riding me last night. I had long ago gotten used to the taste of cum, whether it by mine or Jim’s, so while it still was not something I really liked, I was okay enough to bury my tongue in her hot pussy, letting her tighten against me as I probed her wetness.

After a few minutes of tongue fucking her, she grabbed my head, pulling me up, urging me to give her clit the attention it deserved. I sucked in while flicking her with my tongue. Her hands and thighs tightened against me as I continued to suck and lick. I continued to suck hard against her squirming and moaning, licking slowly and forcefully against her smooth little button. As she grew closer, I finally slid a few fingers in her tight pussy, giving her something to clamp down against as she continued to build. As promised, no games, I brought her to a head crushing orgasm within minutes, barely escaping her clutches with my head and fingers intact. I left her to catch her breath and stop her shaking legs and headed to the shower.

A few minutes before 10, we arrived at my brother’s house. Ellie was dressed in a short skirt with a rather form fitting top. She had purposely picked a skirt with easy access, knowing she would likely be touching herself as she watched the show. I warned her again she needed to be quiet and not moan or she could risk us getting caught. The door was unlocked as asked and we entered the house. I headed to the stairs while Ellie quietly took a seat in the living room. The plan was for me to text her once I had Cindy tied and blindfolded and ready for fun.

As I entered the bedroom, Cindy was there as promised, completely naked (and fully tanned may I add), legs open, and arms already in position to be tied down. It was impossible not to notice how wet her glistening pussy lips were already, and, in her position, legs slightly bent, I could clearly see the silver handle of the plug nestled between her cute, soon to be very red, ass cheeks. She was watching me with a look of pure desire and lust. After dropping my bag, I walked over to the edge of the bed, reached out, and pinched her closest nipple. As she cried out, I added a quick slap, landing it against the same breast, watching it jiggle as her look changed from lust to hatred. “Morning Cindy” I remarked with a smirk. “Fuck you, Jake!” was her response.

I made short work of getting her arms tied down to the bed. Like a previous time, I used a second piece to tie her legs right above her knees, so her knees were practically touching her chest. Unlike last time, as an added measure, I wrapped her ankles as well. As I kneeled on the bed, producing a sturdy piece of black fabric I would be using as a blindfold, Cindy looked a little worried and questioned: “Um Jake, what’s that?” I stopped and gently slapped her cheek, chiding her “Don’t be stupid, you know what this is. It’s a fucking blindfold or did you lose the last bit of brain cells you had? It’ll be more fun not knowing when and how I’m going to punish your slutty little in-law body today, won’t it?”

Without waiting for an answer, I roughly put the blindfold on, pulling her head up as I did. She behaved and did not respond, although the roughness did solicit a few “ows” as I tightened the fabric hard against her head. After ensuring she was snug and unable to move at all, I stepped back and texted Ellie. While she crept silently up the stairs, I removed my clothes and looked around the room for the crop. Again, as instructed, Cindy had left the crop on the dresser.

I picked it up and moved to the bed, locking eyes with my beautiful fiancé, who had just come into the room and was watching. I landed the first snap across her right ass cheek. The room was filled with the sound of pleather hitting flesh, followed immediately by a loud cry from Cindy. Despite knowing it was coming, Ellie also jumped, letting a small cry of surprise out, which was thankfully lost in Cindy’s louder cry. I followed the first quickly with a second, landing it on her closer, left cheek. As I looked down, watching the crop hit against ass, I noticed how tightly Cindy’s ass clenched at the plug while her body involuntarily tightened with the smack.

I paused, letting Ellie see the red marks quickly forming on Cindy’s exposed cheeks. Cindy had already relaxed again, waiting for round two. I added two more marks, one on each side, with rapid flicks of my wrist. Again, Cindy cried out, whimpering as the second lines started to appear. Looking to my side, I could see Ellie was already touching herself. “Fuck Cindy, your pussy is dripping and I’m just getting started.” She moaned in response, which only set Ellie’s hand to move faster. I got off the bed and grabbed the small chair they had in the corner, moving it to the end of the bed, angled in a way so Ellie, once sitting, would be able to give me a show while receiving one in return.

“Jake” Cindy asked, questioningly: “Is there someone else here?”

“Yes Cindy, I have a slew of people watching your slutty little housewife ass being abused. Of course not, you stupid slut. Why do you ask?” It was fun watching her tense as I degraded her and I knew full well she was thoroughly enjoying it. “I thought I smelled Ellie’s perfume” was her answer. I moved to the head of the bed, kneeling close to Cindy, before I playfully (and gently) smacked my cock against her cheek. “Oh Cindy, you are such a naïve slut. You think this dick is only for you?” I asked as I rubbed my cock over her lips. “So cute, but no, just thinking about using you again as my little fucktoy had me so turned on this morning that Ellie was all over me. She had her lips all over this cock” pausing, I pushed my cock in her mouth, at a weird angle, pushing against her cheek. “sucking me until I licked her pussy dry. So yeah, you get to be sloppy seconds to her this morning. You’re lucky all you’re smelling is her perfume on me.”

Getting up, I looked at Ellie, biting her hand in an attempt not to laugh, call out, or god knows what. He other hand was still between her legs, which she spread more to show me she had two fingers in. Not able to help myself, I stopped and pulled her head to me, urging her to suck my cock, her lips gliding over the same area Cindy slurped over moments ago. Feeling her heavenly lips on my cock almost made me forget where I was and why, but I was able to elicit control and get back on the bed, landing two more whacks to each ass cheek as Ellie looked hungrily at my glistening cock.

Cindy’s ass was red with new lines and her pussy was dripping. I decided it was time to feel her warmth, so I lined up and thrust my cock deep inside her, grabbing her ankles and pushing back as I did. With her legs tied together, her pussy was even tighter than usual. Sliding in Cindy was still a surprise to me, given she has had two kids and was still so fucking tight. I moaned as I slowly stroked in and out of her sopping pussy. “fuck Jake, your cock feels so good” Cindy cried out in between moans. Before looking back to see what Ellie was doing, I reached both hands around Cindy’s legs and grabbed her nipples, twisting with just the right amount of force to show I was in control. I pulled and pinched while quickening my pace.

Between moaning and cries of pleasure/pain, Cindy stated she was close to coming. I let go of her nipples, landing a good slap to both milky breasts, then pulled out, letting my pussy coated cock stand at attention. Ellie’s look practically begged for my cock and I knew she wanted to taste Cindy’s sweetness on my cock. Still kneeling on the bed, I positioned myself so she could access, but I could still twist and use the crop on Cindy. So, in a slightly awkward position, I found myself getting quite the blow job, Ellie making sure she licked up every drop of Cindy’s juices from my cock, all while I landed several smacks of the crop against Cindy’s ass.

By the time I was finished, her ass was red and on fire. I could hear her weeping quietly, an involuntary reaction to the lashing. Her pussy told the rest of the story, juices flowing between her legs and coating the blanket underneath. The ultimate punishment will be having to do laundry when I left. No way I could take much more of the teasing, so I pulled back, leaving a pouting Ellie to sit back and watch again. With one hand massaging Cindy’s fiery ass, tracing the heat from the red lines formed crisscrossed against skin, I used the other to twist and pull the plug free.

Immediately, juices still flowing from a moaning Cindy coated her slightly gaping asshole. I lined up my spit-soaked cock, well lubed thanks for Ellie, and began to push into Cindy’s fine ass. She took me with ease as a slowly buried myself until my legs could feel the heat from her ass cheeks. Using three long, slow strokes, I let her moan against my cock as she got used to the feeling. After the third stroke, I gave up control and began to slam my cock balls deep into her perfectly tight asshole. I lasted maybe two minutes before burying myself, with a grunt, and shooting the entirety of my pent-up frustration deep into her clenching ass.

Pulling out, I got off the bed, standing close to Ellie as we both watched Cindy’s ass clench, causing my milky cum to leak down her crack before pooling on the blanket. Ellie, deciding to alter from our previously agreed script, knelt on the bed and wordlessly buried her face in Cindy’s pussy. Cindy tensed against the onslaught of sucking and licking, but before long, her body was relaxed, and she was moaning. “Oh fuck Jake, that feels so good. Oh shit, just like that. Oh fuck, oh fuck.” Oh well, so much for the plan. Well, fuck it. Seeing as Ellie decided she wanted to dive in, I figured no time like the present to take it up a notch. I walked up to the head of the bed, being sure not to make noise.

“Well Cin, I guess now’s as good a time” she tensed immediately, smartly understanding there was no way I could talk and suck her clit at the same time, “as any to let you know you’re no longer just my fuck toy. With Ellie back, you do her bidding as well.” I pulled off the blindfold, roughly grabbing at Cindy’s head as I did, making sure her first view was of Ellie’s head buried in her snatch. “You’re lucky she usually treats her pets pretty well and she’s rewarding you now for being such a good cum slut.”

Cindy looked at me, nothing but lust in her eyes, moaning as Ellie continued to eat her out. I put a finger to her lips, telling her “just be smart for once and keep that annoying mouth shut.” For effect, I gave her a smack on the cheek, firm enough to make sure she knew she had no control here. She put her head back, moaning and straining against the ropes as Ellie brought her to orgasm. Ellie, no longer needing to be quiet, asked “you stupid bitch, you’ve been fucking my man for how long now and you think I wouldn’t know? I bet you had no clue I knew he was banging you on Paul’s desk last week while I was downstairs, did you? Such a stupid little slut.”

As she said this, Cindy was still coming down from her orgasm, so she stayed quiet. Ellie quickly got on the bed and positioned herself kneeling over Cindy’s face. “Now bitch, you’ll return the favor. Make me cum, harder than I have before, or Jake’s done using your sorry ass.” Cindy was quick to focus on trying to meet Ellie’s pussy, moaning and urging as Ellie lifted just out of reach. “Sucks knowing I’m so close, yet you can’t touch or move, doesn’t it.”

“Jake, fill this bitches ass up again” Ellie commanded. Generally, I try not to argue with Ellie, but when it came to being told what, who, and how to fuck, never ever would I argue. I jumped back on the bed, positioned my quickly hardening cock back up against Cindy’s ass, and got ready to push in. Ellie had collapsed onto Cindy’s face, smothering her with her pussy. She was already grinding against Cindy’s tongue, using her and showing her she was at Ellie’s mercy.

Cindy’s ass was still relaxed from earlier and with the mix of her juices and my earlier cum, I was able to easily push in, feeling the tight stickiness as I slid in. “Fuck her ass Jake, fuck her for me” Ellie commanded more. Ellie told me later she was caught up in seeing Cindy tied up and just had an urge to be involved. I let her take over, riding Cindy’s gagging face as she told me when to “bury my cock” and when to “tease her ass with just the head.” Ellie was in her element and came quickly, flooding Cindy’s open mouth with her wetness.

Reaching back, Ellie, who was still clothed, pulled the skirt higher and grabbed her ass cheeks, spreading them as she told Cindy “Eat my ass bitch. That is it, stick your tongue in and fuck it.” Watching and hearing her, I could not help but quicken my pace, fucking Cindy’s ass like there was no tomorrow. “Jake, my love, you still liking that ass or has this slut gotten too loose?” I smirked and grunted, slamming my cock into Cindy harder, showing Ellie how much I was still enjoying her.

Ellie let go of her ass cheeks, letting them fall against Cindy’s face. As she rode Cindy’s tongue, still buried in her ass, Ellie started fingering herself, playing with pussy and clit. I was building and was not sure how long I could hold off. Ellie, looking directly at me with a devious smile, asked “So Jake, you like teaching this slut what a real man is capable of? Unlike her dickless husband? You think she even feels anything when he pathetically fucks her? I bet she secretly thinks about you abusing her ass while he fucks her. I mean, come on, no real man would be able to ignore his wife’s ass being bruised and red.”

That did it. While Cindy moaned against Ellie’s ass, I buried my cock into her very tight ass and flooded it with the second climax in a short amount of time. As she felt the rush of fluid escape my exploding cock, Cindy tightened in her own climax, brought on by Ellie’s words coupled with my cock fucking her ass. Ellie continued grinding for several minutes until she again climaxed all over Cindy’s face. Once she was sufficiently satisfied, she got off the bed, turning to inspect her work. Cindy’s head was a mess, hair matted with sweat and face slick with juices. Despite that, she looked like she was in heaven.

Ellie, turning to me, started to kiss me passionately, letting Cindy know who was in charge and who I belonged to. After leaving me breathless, she wandered towards the door, remarking “we should leave the stupid cunt here, so Paul finds her. Serve both right if we did.” I saw the look of fear cross Cindy’s face as Ellie continued, laughing “nah, that would be no fun. I have plans for you.” With that, Ellie left the room, heading to the bathroom to clean up.

As I untied Cindy, admiring how much of a mess she was, face still a mess, ass leaking cum, she immediately started: “Jake, what the fuck? Fucking Ellie? Oh my god, what the fuck.” I laughed, telling her to chill: “You really think I wouldn’t share this with the love of my life? Unlike you and Paul, Cindy, we share everything. Get used to it or this all ends.” She was crying slightly and for a minute, I thought I may have crossed a line. I grabbed her hair as she started to get off the bed, pulling her towards me. Looking in her teary eyes, I asked “Do you understand what’s happening here? You’re just a fucktoy for me, nothing else. And if I decide to share you, you get shared.”

The look of lust was back, mixed with that ever-present hatred of who I was and what I did for (and to) her. Still holding her hair, I reached between her legs, sliding my hand through her wetness before fingering her ass, which was still leaking my cum from it. I brought the cum soaked finger to her lips, forcing it into her mouth. She moaned and sucked, cleaning my finger of all fluids. “Good” I said, “Go find Ellie, kiss her, and thank her like a good little girl.” With that, I let go and pushed her towards the door before cleaning up.

From the hall, I could hear Ellie remark “there may be hope for you just yet.” A few minutes later, she came in, letting me know Cindy was going to shower and we were going to head out. I was dressed and everything was packed back up, so we headed out, Ellie excitedly talking about the next time and everything she had planned. I started to fear I created a monster and was starting to feel a bit like I was getting pimped out!

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/nzuj8w/chapter_10_my_little_fucktoy_joining_in_mff