It was Halloween and my friends were all split in different directions that year. My ex-FWB, Penny, was hosting a party and invited almost all my friends to go over to her place. Most of them opted to go since there would be a lot more girls there and a slightly better chance to hook up with them. One of my buddies, Kurt, was heading over there later but was down to go out to the bars with me first. Another friend of mine, Pete, had not been invited to go because Pete was a bit of an asshole. That said, Pete was down to hang out with me and invited some of his friends — including a girl he had dated a few years prior, I’ll call her Karly.
I let a few other people know where we would be and over the course of the night a few stragglers came and went. One person that showed up was someone I’ve identified before as Vanessa. I had met her a few months before on OkCupid, but she wasn’t my type. She was a pretty, smart, redhead — which I liked — however, she wasn’t quite my type physically and her ‘Minnie Mouse’ voice was incredibly irritating after a while.
Additionally, my friend Kurt had an insane crush on Vanessa. She had rejected him pretty hard a few times and he was pretty raw about it. The last time that she turned him down, she had told him that she had only flirted with him in the past in an attempt to make me jealous. She thought that her interest in my friends would make me desire her the way she wanted me. Kurt had told me about it after-the-fact and when I reflected on all the times he and I hung out with her it made a lot of sense and I felt a little dumb about it.
Well, when Vanessa showed up to the bar she brought along her new boyfriend. Kindofa nerdy guy who reminded me a lot of Kurt. Kurt felt the same way and was pretty upset about it so he bolted a little early to go to Penny’s party. Pete and I hung out with a few friends and Vanessa for a while before Pete split to go meet his ex, Karly, somewhere else downtown — apparently she had gotten lost.
The strange thing was, Vanessa was flirting with me hard. Every time her boyfriend would walk away to hit the head she would turn all of her attention to me and lay things on thick. When he came back she would pretend to be into him again, but started to play footsie with me under the table or reach over and put her hand on my thigh when she didn’t think he could see. The more I drank the more interested I was and I wasn’t surprised to see her name pop up on my phone a few minutes after she had left the bar.
“I’m just going to let him drop me off at home. If you’re going to stay out for a while let me know and maybe I’ll take a cab back.”
“I’m not going to be out too much longer.” I sent first, followed quickly by, “But you should come back for some fun.”
“Okay.”
Everyone but the guy who lived down the street was gone from the group when I got a text from Vanessa again saying she was on her way back. I paid my tab and tipped heavily, then Vanessa walked into the bar a few minutes later without a boyfriend. She walked right up to me, plopped down, and smiled the widest grin I had ever seen.
“Lets get out of here.” I told her as I grabbed her hand and led her outside. I had about three moments of hesitation — all quickly batted away by the devil that lived on my shoulder. ‘Are you sure this is a good idea?’ the first Angel asked. Bam. ‘You aren’t even into her.’ Bam. ‘What about Kurt?’ Bam. I pushed her up against a chain link fence and kissed her for the first time. She kissed me back right away and started to run her hands all over my body. I grabbed her thick ass and gave it a firm squeeze as I moved in to kiss her neck.
A car drove by and yelled something out the window that spurred us on farther and I grabbed her tits. Her moan was sexy and breathy. I guided her back to my apartment only a block or two away and we stopped every few feet to make out more. When we finally got to my place I let us in, checked to see if anyone else was home — one of my roommates was hosting his brother for the weekend — and I was pleasantly surprised that no one was around. I escorted Vanessa back to my bedroom and we began to disrobe each other right away.
Vanessa’s body was confusing. I didn’t know the term at the time, but she was the definition of a PAWG and/or slim-thick. She had big breasts, huge hips, a phat ass (which was surprisingly firm), and a teeny-tiny waist and flat little tummy. I had assumed she was just… thick all over based on the way she dressed, but that wasn’t the case at all and her look was actually turning me on a lot. Also, my dick was in her mouth; so that helped.
Vanessa was a fucking pro. I don’t know where she got her skills from, but she immediately started to bob and swirl exactly the way I wanted it. She was eager too. She had been wanting to suck my cock for almost a year at this point and this was her big day. It didn’t take me long to want to return the favor and lick her pussy, so I transitioned us to the bed and lay her on her back. She was way more flexible than I had anticipated and parted her legs into a split to give me perfect access. Her pussy lips were smooth and she had the tiniest little red bush. I sucked on two of my fingers and slid them into her as I touched my tongue to her clit. Her high pitched voice had a surprisingly sexy gasp.
I finger fucked her aggressively as I sucked on her pretty little clit. She tasted fantastic and she started a round of dirty talk that was next level sexy. “Eat my little pussy. I want to feel your fat cock inside me. I’m going to cum on your face. Treat me like a whore.” Hearing that little tiny voice say such sultry and nasty things was turning me into a wild man. When she came — and it was a big orgasm — I moved in close and started to rub the head of my cock up and down her slit. She begged me to fuck her and I pushed in all the way to the sound of her gasping for air.
Her pussy was incredible, she had some control on the grip of her snatch and was able to fuck me back just as much as I fucked her. Her big tits were similarly beautiful, very firm, and swayed erotically as I slammed my cock in and out of her. We switched positions a few times so that I could get a good view of her phat ass as I took her from behind and so that I could watch her face as she rode me like a cowgirl.
At one point while she was grinding her pussy onto me and I supplied some helpful thrusts as she would rock backwards. After one of those thrusts she admitted to me how good of a fuck I was. “I thought you were just a braggart.” She said in between moans, “When you talked about how good you were in bed. But I was wrong. You are fucking incredible.” I was pleased to know that I was able to please. As those of you who read my stories can probably tell I am the kind of person that likes to share my stories and brag about my sex life. Unlike most people, however, I don’t exaggerate to make myself sound better than I am. When I’m bad, I’m bad and I admit it. When I’m good, I’m good and I talk about it. That night, I was fucking her good.
She came again as she rode me and then let me flip her over onto her back so I could fuck her the way I liked. I finally pulled out and came all over her tummy and pussy before giving her a big kiss and giving us a chance to rest for a few minutes. I texted Pete, who was supposed to be staying at my place, to see where he and Karly were. He had found her and they were at a bar about 10 blocks away getting hammered. “Cool, want to have a four way tonight? I just fucked that girl Vanessa and she was really good.”
“Fuck yes. I’ll text you when we get there.”
Vanessa and I passed out shortly after that only to wake up to my roommate knocking on my bedroom door. He told me that Pete had shown up and was pounding on the front door to be let in and woke everyone else up. I got dressed and went to the kitchen to find Pete and Karly drinking water and yelling at each other — I was pretty pissed off that they didn’t call me and that they were being so rude at 2:30 in the morning. I told them to bring their water and to come with me up to my room and we could all just crash.
So here we were, 2:30 am, Halloween, four people in a queen bed. Vanessa was nude, Pete got down to his skivvies, I got naked and back in bed, and Karly had no idea what was going on. Pete started to make out with Karly once she finally joined us in bed and I asked the only question that there was to ask.
“Everyone ready to fuck?”
Vanessa immediately got up, moved down to my crotch and started to suck my cock like she owned it. Pete and Karly started to watch her and I got turned on instantly knowing that I was putting on a show.
“Oh my god.” Karly said, “She’s sucking his cock.”
“Yeah, you better suck mine now.” Pete demanded of her.
Karly nodded her head in compliance and stripped off all her clothes as Pete whipped out his cock. Karly was very pretty, but a complete asshole to be around. Long dark hair, beautiful blue eyes, enormous tits, and a decent figure. She started to suck his cock and suddenly there were two pretty women sucking two big cocks in my bed.
I wanted to fuck, so I got up, moved around behind Vanessa, and took her doggy style. Vanessa responded to my thrusts right away and started to beg me to slap her ass and pull her hair. The next thing I knew she started talking about how she wanted to eat ‘the other girl’s pussy’ and ‘take two cocks at the same time.’ I was starting to really regret not fucking Vanessa earlier; she was a fucking freak and I loved it.
Karly, however, did not seem interested in sharing Pete’s cock. It had been a few years since they dated, but apparently she was still hung up on him and incredibly jealous. She decided to move them down to the floor beside the bed so they could fuck, but she accidentally kneed him in the balls and he freaked out. When she tried to move away she accidentally twisted his dick into the carpet and gave him a rugburn on his shaft and he started to whine like a bitch. She apologized and I decided I didn’t give a fuck what they were doing anymore. Maybe it wouldn’t be the fourway I wanted, but I was still going to cum.
Vanessa and I continued for ten or fifteen minutes. She came twice for me and then finally told me to cum inside her pussy which I did gladly. We tried to get Pete and Karly to join us for another round, but Pete wouldn’t stop complaining about getting kneed in the balls and Karly was just boring. We all got back in bed — eventually — and fell asleep. A few hours later Vanessa woke up and bailed, leaving just me, Karly, and Pete in bed.
When the sun came up I found myself spooning Karly and running my hands all over her body. Her skin felt great and her tits were amazing so I started to get very turned on. Pete woke up and I asked him if he wanted to share her with me and he was down for it… unfortunately she was not. So, we went to brunch, parted ways, and that was that. Not quite a fourway, but still a surprisingly great fuck.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/nbf2rr/i_took_home_minnie_mouse_on_halloween_had_amazing