This was years ago me and my ex (Shelly) at the time had been broken up about 2 weeks. She was having a party and wanted me to come. Also during this time my ex before her (Tina) was in town We had been texting for a few weeks since she had been back from college.
Shellys party was on a Saturday started at about 8:30-9. I was there early helping her set stuff up. Eventually everybody made it and the party was jumping. Drinks,beer pong, girls dancing guys having a good time. It was a good party I must say.
Throughout the night me and Tina were texting, I was drunk feeling good and she knew it. She knew I was at my ex’s house party because I told her and her best friend was there. I’ll go ahead and say it now me and Tina broke up because of Shelly. Surprisingly Tina wasn’t too bothered with me partying with Shelly, I like to think it’s because her friend was there so she had someone keeping a eye on me and boy was she!
Back to the party, me and Shelly was on the pong table kicking ass. I was carrying the team. She’s good when she’s drunk but there’s a limit. She’d get too confident (more drunk lol) and start missing so I had to hold it down! Anyways it was fun and she was looking sexy having a good time. We were on the table all night, partly because of house rules but mainly because I was busting ass? okay I’m done.
Night goes on people start to leave about 12:30-1, we started cleaning up picking up cups and whatever cans were out. As we were cleaning the pong table I asked if she wanted to play one last game of pong but we had to strip for every cup made…you can guess where this going! Lol She agreed but she knew I’d win. Her words were this isn’t gonna be fair. I told her Id take my shirt off to give her the one up on me, she agreed! Lol
While all this going on me and Tina were still texting periodically. I was surprised she was still awake as though I wasn’t texting back right away. She had asked me to come over after the party I told her I’d come but it would be late when I got there. She kept telling me I’d better come even if it’s late she just wanted to see me. If I remember correctly she was going to the beach with some friends that upcoming week.
Back to The beer pong game, I was winning of course. She was down to just her White Lace thong which I have a very vivid memory of stuck in my head. Big tits out, pale nipples oh man! Anyways we made out in the living room/dining area but I could tell she wasn’t comfortable not being in her room, she was innocent little slut my innocent slut. We went to her room and come to find out she was on her period so we didn’t have sex but she did start rubbing my dick eventually giving me handjob leading to a blow job. She’s not a swallower so as she lays between my legs sucking me I came on her tits. We laid there for a little before she got up and cleaned off, she came back to bed and fell asleep.
I texted Tina asking asking if she was up, she replied back quickly “of course you still coming?” I replied yes. Soon as I went to get up to leave Shelly ask where I was going she was half sleep I told her I was heading home gave her a hug before heading to Tina’s!
I arrived at Tina’s house to the door being unlocked, I walk upstairs and she’s in bed waiting for me. I didn’t mention earlier that when we were texting Tina sent me a few pics in some lingerie telling me to hurry up! When me and her were dating I convinced her to buy some sexy lingerie, so she went out and got a Victoria secret set! But had never worn it for me since we had broken up.
( the lingerie set look similar to this ->
She had it on this night and it was so sexy I couldn’t believe she was wearing it for me. We eventually laid down kissing and hugging leading to me eating her pussy. After eating her Pusey for about 10 minutes she pulled me up told me lay on my back, She took my pants off exposing my hard dick.( I don’t wear underwear) She licked from balls to the head of my dick I about came it was sexy the way she looked at me. She blew for little before I pulled her up and put her on back slid my dick in her, she was so tight and warm. I gave her slow long strokes speeding up every now and then. Some of my strokes I’d make a circular motion, I could feel her pussy getting wetter leading to her orgasm her legs lock around me she was shaking but still locked on me dick inside her after about 20 seconds her body relaxes. I went to give her a kiss and noticed she is crying, I was thrown off and asked if she was okay she replied yes it was just really good and really care about you! I agreed we ended up laying there falling asleep.
Tina told her best friend and she was so mad that she texted me saying you think you can have your cake and eat it too? I replied ain’t that’s what you’re supposed to do!….She never replied back, I was really honest with both of them through out the time I was talking to them both. It was a night to remember!
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/nar4kc/had_my_cake_mff