James Pays A Lesbian Couple For Kinky Sex Part 2 {MFF, Escorts, Anal, Pegging, First Time}

Part 1 [Here](https://www.reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/n85d6w/james_pays_a_lesbian_couple_for_kinky_sex_mff/)

*A commissioned story*

Message me for details on getting your own erotic fantasy brought to life in a short story!

Chapter 2

**Girls Celebrate Their Second Anniversary**

It had been nearly a month since Chloe and Amber met James in the bar and took him home for some fun anal sex exploration. The girls talked often about how much fun he was the last time. They hoped he would be coming back for another night soon. It was also another important anniversary that night. The night marked their second anniversary.

Amber had bought a special gift that she hoped they would both get to share for the annual occasion. She waited until after their night out to dinner and a movie before showing Chloe the gift. They returned home late but both were ready for fun. During the moving, they could not keep their hands or lips to themselves.

“Close your eyes. I have a surprise for you.” Amber said as they entered the house. She guided the taller blonde to the bedroom by her hand.

“Where are we going?” Chloe asked as she began to wonder what could have changed in the house since leaving. The brown-haired girl was only making her walk with her eyes closed to build anticipation.

“Sit on the bed and shut up a second,” the short girl teased before pushing her back on the bed. Then she waited for a second to make sure her girlfriend was not trying to peek. Once the close was clear, Amber took off her tight dress. Underneath she was already wearing a sexy green bra and panty set that she knew Chloe would enjoy as part of the surprise.

Her ass looked amazing in the lingerie while she dug under the bed for the other gift. Amber pulled out a black box before taking off the lid. Inside was a powder blue dildo with a flat base. There was a pump built in for fake cum to be sprayed through to simulate a real male orgasm. Also in the box was a large bottle of fake cum that was made out of a sweet creamy substance.

The brunette filled the dildo full of the cream before setting it on the floor. Her favorite part of this toy was the tiny nubs all over the shaft of the cock to tickle the inside of the user. Then Amber took her phone and set it up to record from the dresser. After the lube was pre-applied to the toy, Amber was ready to get started.

“Get ready for a sexy little show,” the brown-haired girlfriend teased as she started playing music on the speaker in their room.

“Can I open my eyes now?” Chloe asked, wondering what she had planned for the night. She knew her girlfriend was always great at surprises like this.

“Open ‘em up,” Amber said as her tongue licked across the other girl’s lips. They kissed before the blonde even had a chance to see anything different in the room. Their tongue fought for control between the mouths before Chloe wanted to see what the surprise her girl was hiding from her.

“Let me see what you did already,” the eager girlfriend said before pushing Amber off the top of her. The blonde sat up on the bed noting the toy laid out and glistening with lube on the floor. She looked over at Amber to ask a question but forgot when seeing her sexy underwear for the night too.

Chloe could not help herself as she jumped on top of her woman. Their lips reconnected while the blonde started groping Amber’s thick white ass on the bed. She could not believe how great of a woman she had for the past two years. Her lips stopped kissing Amber so she could lick down her chest.

The brunette watched as her girlfriend teases her torso while moving to the lower half of her body. When Chloe reached the green panties she slowly inched them down her curvy hips. Amber pretended to be shy as she closed her legs and covered her pussy, denying visual access to the pixie cut blonde.

“Don’t try to pretend you don’t want this,” Chloe teased, flicking her tongue across her soft thighs. Amber covered her face while keeping up the act but releasing her panties. The short-haired girl moved her mouth to her sweet mound. Her legs held Chloe’s head in place the second her tongue poked out to taste the pink center.

“But this is my first time,” Amber joked pretending that she had not been with her fair share of women.

“Shut up you dirty little slut,” the playfully aggressive blonde said before putting her hand over Amber’s mouth.

Amber still teased back as she licked her palm and winked at her. That made Chloe want to tease back so she started flicking her tongue across her clit. The brunette hummed on her palm after that. Her moans were nearly silent as Chloe muffled them while perfectly maneuvering her tongue.

“Ohh you are really wet tonight,” Chloe pointed out in a sexy voice. Then she started using her tongue ring to tease her clit even more. Her girlfriend was loving it as her grip on Chloe’s head felt tighter.

Since she was getting close to an orgasm, the blonde decided to switch it up. Her tongue quickly slid down the lips of her wet pussy and across her ticklish taint. Amber tried to gasp but the hand stopped that too. Chloe shoved her tongue right inside of the tight asshole below. She barely got to start rimming it before the brunette’s legs were shaking around her face.

Chloe released her mouth so she could hear the sweet moans finally be released. The blonde kept going in her ass until Amber had to push her head away to force a little momentum break, She was pushing her hair out of her face when Amber was kissed and able to taste her own juices. That always turned her on even more.

“Do you want to see our new toy now?” Amber asked as she got up from the bed. Her legs still felt weak but she wanted to finish her show.

“Of course I do. Now show me how you can ride that thing,” Chloe cheerfully said while slapping Amber’s fat ass exiting the bed.

“You have to help,” the brunette said before she started explaining the toy, “It is top of the line. It even has a fake cum feature.” Amber picked up the toy to show her the pump to make it squirt out the cream before asking, “I thought since it was our special night you would want to control the load. So do you wanna?” The bottomless girl smiled waiting to hear her answer.

“Get down there and get the show started,” Chloe said as she sat close beside her to watch. The blonde slipped out of her panties so she could have some fun too. From under the bed, she grabbed a wand vibrator to pleasure herself.

Amber slowly lowered herself down to the new dildo. Her pussy was spread open as it slipped right into her wet hole. She loved the feeling of the little nubs teasing her walls. It was even better than she had expected. They made the toy almost too intense. Those thick thighs raised and lowered her round ass over and over again as it stuffed her pink pussy. Chloe waited with the wand on her pussy and the cum control in her hand.

Both girl’s moans filled the room as they watched each other masturbating. Amber was bouncing her ass off the floor, letting her pussy swallow the blue toy. Chloe circled her clit with the tip of the wand in between hard presses against the little pleasure bean.

“I-I-I’m cumming all over this toy,” Amber moaned euphorically as she felt her legs getting weak again. The toy was shoved all the way in as she dropped to the floor. She was determined to have an intense climax so she kept thrusting her hips back and forth. Chloe waited for her girlfriend’s twerking ass to reach the pinnacle of her orgasm before releasing the load.

Just as she was about to reach her apex Chloe let off a few hard pumps of the cream inside her pussy. The wand started making her have an orgasm watching and she gave it another two pumps of white cream inside Amber. She could not take the feeling of the gooey cum in her pussy as she moaned out louder. The brunette slipped the toy out just as Chloe was squeezing the pump again. This time it unloaded on the outside of her hole.

Fake cum covered her juicy pink mound. Amber looked down as she went to sit behind the toy. That launched the cum across her chest before it splattered across her face. Chloe had her eyes closed pumping the toy as fast as she could during her own climax. She had no clue that it was covering the thick girl’s body.

“You sure made a mess with this toy,” the brunette joked while licking some of the cream that she collected on her finger. Then she told Chloe, “Felt like you shoved a water hose up there when you squeezed the pump so hard. I kinda liked it but it was too intense during my orgasm.” She wiped more cream from her tits before licking it.

“I got you something too,” Chloe admitted as she tried to catch her breath. She grabbed a small box from the nightstand. Amber took it and opened it while the blonde started licking her body clean.

“Aww, you are the sweetest girlfriend ever,” Amber proclaimed as she opened the diamond promise ring in the black box. The blonde smiled while looking up at her happy girlfriend with her tongue cleaning her tits. They kissed for a hot second before Chloe finished licking her torso clean. Then Amber said, “I promise to be yours forever.”

Chloe slid the ring onto her finger before teasing more, “You wanna know the best part about tonight’s dessert?”

“What’s that?” Amber asked while giggling. She honestly had no clue what the crazy blonde girl was leading to.

Then Chloe pushed her back on the floor saying, “The creamy center.” Then her head went back between her legs to get the cream from her toy out. It was a great excuse to eat pussy and get a sweet snack.

After a few more minutes of teasing each other, Amber said, “I have to go take a shower. That cream has me all sticky like it was actual cum. You think they would take that part out. Or maybe they wanted it to be realistic.” Then she went to the shower to get cleaned up.

Chloe noticed the phone set up on the dresser and figured it was recording. When she walked over her suspicion was proved right. She stopped the recording as she got a bright idea for the video. The blonde knew it had to be hot after being a part of herself so she sent it to James to see what he thought of it. Chloe knew that it would get him worked up but hoped it would make him want to come over for another night of fun together.

The video worked like a charm because he texted back an hour later saying, “That is the sexiest video I have seen in a while. I have been meaning to call you girls again. Just have been busy with other stuff.” James was lying but the girls did not need to know that. He had been thinking about that night nonstop since it happened. To control himself and not get addicted to paying them for sex, he limited himself to once a month. Or at least he tried.\

He was a few days short of a month when Chloe replied to his message with a phone call. They chatted for a few minutes catching up and talking about the sexy anniversary video. Then the promiscuous blonde asked if he planned on coming to see them again. James admitted that he wanted to do it soon. He even said this time he wanted a night where anything was open and it was all paid for upfront. The man did not want any more last-minute bonus fees this time with the seductive women.
They hashed out the details of the night loosely before Chloe threw out a steep price. James considered it before offering a counteroffer that was still fair. The girl agreed before asking when he would be free. There were not many nights that James and the girls were not busy at the same time but they finally agreed on Saturday. That was perfect because it gave Chloe almost a full week for her to set up.

After their conversation on the phone, Chloe was excited for the night with James. She was also excited for the big payday that she could now count on too. The money was burning a hole in her pocket before she even got it. The blonde grabbed her laptop as Amber was coming out of the shower.

“Who were you talking to on the phone?” The brunette asked while drying her hair.

“James, he is coming over Saturday night for sex,” Chloe said while spending some of the money prematurely on surprise gifts. Most of them were coming to her house but one was going to James. She texted him for his address and told him to expect a delivery before their date Saturday. Then the girls start getting ready for bed while Chloe shares some of the planned details of the night coming up.

Friday morning the surprises all arrive in boxes when Chloe tells her girlfriend she is not allowed to open them until right before James comes. Then she texted him to confirm that his gift had also arrived and he knew not to open it until before the coming over. He agreed not to peek inside and only open it before leaving to meet her. Chloe was excited to know it was all set up. The only thing left was the girl’s spa day to prepare their sexy bodies for a romantic evening with James.

At the spa they got full-body massages together, a full body wax to be smooth for sex, hair and nails were done to look sexy, and mudbath before the steam room to relax. It was the perfect way to prepare for a long night of fun sex with their favorite customer. On the way out of the mall, the spontaneous ladies decide to stop at the jewelry store. They went in for new rings for their piercing but ended up deciding to get matching belly button piercings done. Chloe got a pink butterfly while Amber got a light blue one. The girls headed home eager for tomorrow night’s date.

**James Arrives Round 1**

A few hours before James was due to arrive, the girls started getting themselves ready for the night. Amber did her hair in two long pigtails that reached down to her hips. The blonde did not have much she could do with her hair besides brush the pixie cut. She knew it would not stay that neat anyway. After they looked their sexiest, Chloe locked Amber out of the bedroom so she could finally open the boxes.

She got out what was needed to prepare and hid the rest in the closet as a surprise for the group later. Then Chloe called her girlfriend back into the bedroom to finish getting ready. The brunette entered the room and froze when seeing what Chloe was holding in her hand. There was a pretty smile before she ran to kiss her girlfriend to show thanks. It was a long fox tail butt plug that was super pretty.

“I saw it in your search history and knew I had to get it for you,” Chloe told her while holding it high over her head to tease the shorter girl. Amber jumped to try to snatch it but missed. It gave her girlfriend a good look at her bouncing boobs as she leaped up though.

“Just give it to me so I can try it out,” the needy girl begged while giving up on taking it away from her.

“How bad do you want it?” Chloe asked to tease her further. The brunette looked deep in her eyes as she thought about a way to show she really wanted the toy.

Amber said nothing as she dropped down to her knees in front of her girlfriend. She put her hands together to gesture herself desperately begging but only moaning instead of asking. Then the thick girl slowly turned and crawled onto their bed. Her ass was arched high into the air so Chloe could get a good look. Amber’s face dropped to the mattress as both hands went behind her back. Her ass faced directly at Chloe’s face when finally speaking,

“Please stuff my new tail in my big tight ass baby,” the brunette moaned out hoping to have shown enough.

Chloe was grinning as she moved her head down to tease her with a wet tongue. The blonde licked from the clit to her asshole before spitting on the clenched hole. Then she slapped Amber’s thick ass before teasing her hole with the plug of the tail. She moaned deeply as Chloe started pushing it inside her butt.

“You are keeping this in all night,” the blonde warned as it popped into position. She even gave the furry tail a little tug to check that it was secure. Then Chloe told her, “Stand up! I wanna see how it looks with those sexy little pigtails.” Before Amber could react she was getting a slap on her soft ass again.

The brunette got up from the bed before strutting around the room like a runway model. Her round ass looked amazing with the tail sticking out of the center. It just barely avoided dragging on the ground as she walked around. The pigtails were long enough to end on either side of her ass cheeks where the tail began. She had tails from her head to the floor in length.

“I love it so much, Thank you, babe,” Amber said while twirling the tail around by her hip. She was trying to be sexy but knew James would be there soon so a quickie was off the table. There was only time for a little teasing.

“Now I need to finish getting everything ready before he gets here. You can go wait to let him in with your new tail since he should be here any minute,” Chloe explained as she sent the girlfriend out of the room again.

While waiting for his arrival, Chloe got a couple of bottles of champagne and water to put in an ice bucket for the room. She did not want to be leaving the fun this time to gather drinks for the group. Then she returned to the room to get herself strapped up for James’ arrival shortly. The sexy blonde could not wait to show him all the surprises she got together for the night and hoped he followed her instructions before coming over.

The doorbell rang right on time. Amber was wearing a thin white shirt that barely covered her hips as she answered it just in case it was not James or the neighbors were around. There was a seductive grin on her face when seeing it was their expected guess when opening the door. James instantly could see that she was wearing nothing under the nearly sheer top.

James decided to tease her a bit as he grabbed her pierced nipple poking out towards him through the fabric. Amber giggled as she swatted his hand playfully from his chest. “Come in. We have been waiting for you,” the shy girl admitted while grabbing his hand to guide him into their home,

“Here is the money Chloe and I agreed on,” James said as he handed her a thick white envelope. She reached out and grabbed it before flipping open the top. Her thumb shuffled through the cash making sure it all seemed fine. Then she put it in a drawer in the living room with a lock and key to keep it secure.

Amber teased James while putting away the money. Her short legs were held straight as she bent at the hips to expose her ass to him. It made him realize that she had a long fox tail stuffed in her ass. He felt his boner throbbing in his jeans at the sight.

“Now we can go see what Chloe has been preparing in the bedroom,” the thick brunette said as she turned to head to their room.

Her hands went down to her waist to grab the bottom of her shirt. Amber seductively stripped her only clothing off before looking back at James with lustful eyes. She did a slow spin to tease him and flaunt her perfect young body. The man noticed the little belly ring dangling as she did the twirl in front of him. Her torso was covered in piercings and it turned on James incredibly.

“Look who’s here,” Amber said when opening the bedroom door. Chloe was standing with her hand on her hips in a powerful position when they entered.

Both of them were mesmerized by her beautiful body supporting a new toy. Chloe had a new strap-on dildo attached to her hips for the night. It had a fancy black leather harness with silky pink lace on it to resemble a pair of panties. From her crotch hung a new toy cock that was brand new and even bigger than the last.

“You got yourself a new toy too?” The brunette asked as she walked closer to check it out. James watched her small hand grab the girthy to feel it out. Then Amber noticed something else new about as James noticed the matching belly button rings of different colors. The brunette said jealousy, “You got two?”

“I’m liking the new piercings but what is the other toy?” James asked as his interest was peaked by her statement.

“She isn’t the only one with a new plug,” Chloe said as she slowly turned around and bent down to touch her toes. Her tight little ass looked amazing with the new chrome butt plug inside. On the end was even a pink crystal to match her new strap-on and belly button ring. Her cock hung low between her legs as she flaunted her plugged hole. James could not help but start groping his stiff erection through his jeans as he sat down on the bed.

“While you are busy touching yourself, I gotta ask. Did you prepare as I told you to?” Chloe sternly reminded him.

“Yes, I did. Every day since we talked on the phone,” James admitted to the girl with the short haircut.

“And did you get my little reward before coming over tonight?” Chloe asked a follow-up question.

“I got it with me now,” he told her knowing he did everything he was asked. James liked seeing the girl be a little dominant to him even though he was not a very submissive man. It just fit her well.

“We will see if you are telling the truth,” the blonde said before ordering Amber, “Get his clothes off since we are already naked for him.”

The brunette went over to the man and lifted the shirt from his body. Her soft hands grazed down his torso as they went for his pants. There was a bulge that Amber let her fingers tease for a moment before unzipping them for James. Her fingers crawled under his pants and underwear as James stood from the bed so she could remove them.

“Wow you are very excited tonight,” Amber playfully said as the cock sprung into her face when freed. It was throbbing so she pulled it down with one finger to watch it pop right back up with the pierced tip. That was when she noticed that James had a new toy too. There was a shiny black plug in his ass too.

“Chloe got us all one it looks like,” James said when he noticed the girl looking at his stuffed ass from below.

“I figured it was only fair,” Chloe joked as she walked over to James and Amber beside the bed. The blonde loved how his cock was fully erect whenever he was being stuffed by a toy. She wondered if he would enjoy a real dick but did not want to push his boundaries too far too fast.

While Amber is still on the ground, she starts sucking his cock playfully. Her wet mouth took his pierced dick inside as he started making out with Chloe above. His hands groped her perky white breasts as the blonde’s tongue slipped into his mouth. They kissed passionately while he got his cock serviced by the brunette.

James stopped kissing her so he could suck on her tits. His lips took in the entire areola as he let his tongue tease the little nub. Then he switched over to the other one to get it stiff too. Chloe was enjoying it but wanted to return the favor. She pulled back from him as his mouth was left open hoping the tit would return.

“Move down to his balls,” Chloe ordered her girlfriend before her fingers traced the bar of his piercing on the tip. The blonde tugged it gently before kissing it to balance out the sex karma. Then her lips wrapped around the head and slowly swallowed his cock.

James watched the two girls eagerly use their mouths on his dick and balls. He thought about how the money was well worth the experience. Chloe got her taste before putting Amber back on his cock and standing back to watch. The man grabbed onto her pigtails before pulling her head all the way down his length. Her throat opened to accept him inside while stopping her airflow. James released her for just enough time to get some air before going again. Amber did not take long to learn the routine.

Chloe’s hand had slipped under the strap-on harness to tease her clit while watching the scene unfold. He used her face like a pussy as he held her long hair to keep her still. The blonde knew that she could take it and figured Amber was probably enjoying it. On their anniversary night, they agreed that she would be more submissive to the blonde.

“Climb on the bed and show me that fat ass,” James said while pulling Amber to her feet by the pigtails.

“Anything for you,” the slutty brunette said to turn on the man even more. She climbed into the bed with her ass high in the air again. This time she shook it side to side so James could watch it jiggle in his face. It looked like her long foxtail was wagging on the bed.

“The tail was an excellent choice,” James replied before slapping her on the ass with a swift hand. It stung but Amber enjoyed the pain. A moan left her lips as she looked back at him with her tongue out to play the part.

“She is going to be a very good girl tonight,” Chloe said while petting her soft brown hair, “Isn’t that right Amber?” The girls looked into each other’s eyes with a deep passion before Amber shook her head to agree. Then they started kissing in front of the man.

With Amber already in the position to be fucked doggy style, he decided that he could go ahead and try to slip in with them. His hand slowly lifted the tail hoping she would not notice. Then his hard cock was pressed right inside of her wet pussy. Amber moaned loudly when surprised by the cock.

“He must have felt left out,” Chloe said watching while the man started to push himself inside her girlfriend.
“Or he just could not resist my nice ass anymore,” Amber joked while twerking on his cock. James laid the tail up her back so it followed her spine. The girls continued to kiss while Chloe fondled the other girl’s pierced tits below.

“It was a little of both but now I feel better inside your tight pussy,” James replied while rubbing his hands on her thick ass cheeks. He loved how soft they felt on his hands and the way he could grope the squishy curves.

“Let me eat your pussy,” Amber said while looking at the blonde’s sexy body. Chloe reached behind to unstrap the bottom of her dildo so it could flip out of the way. It laid on her thigh giving access to her pussy. The brunette noticed the little nub on the back of the harness meant to tease Chloe’s clit while fucking with it. Her finger rubbed it as she joked, “This must be nice to have in there.”
Chloe did not answer her. Instead, the blonde pulled her pigtails between her long legs. Amber followed her guidance before starting to lick her clit. She moved her tongue like a professional lesbian to get her girlfriend off. It did not take long before both girls were moaning from the fun threesome.

The man watches over Amber’s naked body while fucking. His grip on her curvy hips was slowly becoming tighter while watching the oral lesbian sex. He could feel himself getting close but so were the girls by the sound of their moans. James decided to try to hold back to share the moment together.

Chloe was first to start having an orgasm from the playful tongue. Watching her thighs shake around the brunette’s head made it impossible for James to keep going. Just as he was pulling out he could feel Amber’s wetness. One hand started rubbing her clit below while his other stroke his cock to completion. His cum sprayed across her thick ass and got on her furry tail as he unloaded from behind.

Chloe was just reaching her climax as James got Amber to her orgasm after a short delay. They were all breathing heavily as James waited for the little brunette to climax. Once she relaxed on the bed he laid down on the bed. Only this time he knew there would likely be no breaks between the sex.

Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/n9plhv/james_pays_a_lesbian_couple_for_kinky_sex_part_2