Chapter 1 [Here](https://www.reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/n2j5my/lauren_discovers_her_college_roommate_ariyana_is/) | Chapter 2 [Here](https://www.reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/n5kahq/ariyana_and_her_girlfriend_lauren_get_blackmailed/)
*A commissioned sequel*
Message me to get your own fantasy brought to life in a custom erotic short story!
**Chapter 3**
A couple of minutes later he heard them coming into the boat. Ariyana turned on music in the main room before they entered the bedroom already kissing. Lauren fell back onto the bed wearing only an oversized black band shirt. When falling the shirt came up exposing her pussy as she laid on her back. Ari climbed on top dropping a little black bag on the bed. They kissed passionately as he watched from the closet. He had to look through different slits in the door to see all of them but he got a great view. Both were only wearing big shirts with no panties on the bed kissing. Tommy was hard within seconds of getting both pussies stacked on display for him. Ariyana was shaved, unlike Lauren.
He could not pick a favorite as he switched while starting to jerk his dick. After a few minutes of kissing, Lauren’s shirt was peeled from her body. Her large tits were pushed together by Ari’s small hands before she sucked each of them causing stiff nipples. Lauren spanked her girl’s tight little ass leaving red imprints behind. It was hard for Tommy to control his pace from the closet as he saw their true slutty side.
Ariyana moved down her body giving her pussy a few quick kisses before the short-haired lesbian ordered her, “Put that ass up here for me.” Lauren moaned when she got spanked while obeying.
“Are you going to fuck it?” She playfully asked while shaking the thick white cheeks. Ari slapped each cheek without answering.
Then her head went down between the soft mounds. Her small fingers dug into the soft white cheeks while spreading her open. Tommy could finally see a good angle as her tongue teased the tight asshole of Lauren. He could see it winking as she traced the rim. Ari leaned back, spitting into the dark hole before going back to teasing it with her tongue. The moaning showed how much Lauren was enjoying it.
“You’re a horny butt slut tonight,” Ari claimed as she forced a deep moan out of the brunette by shoving her tongue inside. She wiggled it around in there before taking it out to ask, “What do you want me to do?”
“Please, fuck my ass Ariyana,” Lauren moaned out wanting more to go inside her butt. Spit ran down the crack from her ass to her pussy.
Ari grabbed the bag from the bed and unzipped it. Inside was only a realistic white strap-on dildo that looked like a cock and a bottle of lube. She made Lauren suck on the dildo before putting it on her hips, covering her pink pussy. Once it was on, she started getting the brunette ready for anal. She poured some lube on her ass before teasing the hole with her fingers. Lauren moaned loudly as she felt the two skinny fingers slipping inside her body. She bit on the sheets as Ari started flicking them around inside to tickle her walls.
“You are already opening up tonight for me,” Ari teased as she spread her ass open with two fingers to spit inside. The girl moaned feeling it going down the tube. Then the petite girl put in a third finger as she said, “You could probably take them all you little butt slut.”
“Give me the dick please,” Lauren begged from the bed. The petite girl slapped the fake cock against her white ass cheeks teasing her before lubing it up.
Just as the tip was pressed against her asshole, Lauren let out a deep exhale before gasping at the pressure. Tommy was just as excited as her as he stroked himself harder. He got caught up in the moment and leaned too far forward. The small boat doors could not support his weight causing them to burst open. Both girls screamed when he surprised them falling onto the floor.
“What the fuck are you doing Tommy,” Ariyana yelled when she noticed who it was. He was getting up from the floor and trying to cover his dick with his pants around his ankles. It took him a second to fully recover as Lauren hid under the sheets. Ari was in shock as the tiny girl stood wearing only a strap-on.
Tommy did not have time to respond before Ari said, “What are you doing in there? I am going to get your mother.”
Thinking on his toes Tommy took control of the situation quickly, “Are you going to tell her you are having sex with Lauren too? I know your parents will not be too happy about that one.” All of them froze after the threats were made to see who would break first.
“Just let him go, Ari, we don’t need you pulled out of college for this,” Lauren said trying to end the awkward silence. She knew that they could not tell on him for being a creep.
“Fine, get out of here,” Ari replied as she pointed at the door.
Tommy thought about bolting out the door before thinking about how horny he was to see them have anal sex. He knew he had dirt on them but he was unsure what it was worth to them. There was only one way for him to find out.
“So they won’t pay for your college if they find out about this?” Tommy asked after putting it together from Lauren’s statement. He grinned before continuing, “I think we are not even then if I need to lie to my family about you two ladies.” Tommy was teasing them but desperately needed to see them finish.
“What do you mean?” Ari asked while Lauren waited to hear too.
“I think that me being caught in here is not as bad as your secret so you two are in debt to me,” he claimed with the boner rising back in his shorts showing he was regaining his confidence. Then he told them, “I want to keep watching.”
The girls looked disgusted by the request while Ari said, “No way, you are my cousin you pervert.”
“Then I guess I will send this image to your mom tonight,” Tommy said while pulling out his phone to show them the picture of them kissing and groping each other’s asses on the porch.
“Can’t you just be cool about this?” Ari asked realizing that he was serious.
“I am not going to tell them if you are cool and let me watch you two have some fun. I have been watching you the past few nights anyway,” Tommy told them with an evil grin. He liked watching them realize how much he saw them do since arriving at the beach house.
“So we let you watch us finish and you never tell her parents anything?” Lauren asked from under the blanket.
“Well you will be doing a little more on the trip for me but it is the only way to keep me quiet tonight,” he explained to the desperate college girls. Ariyana did not want to deal with the backlash and have to leave school. Lauren was just being a good girlfriend as she agreed to follow Ari through either decision.
She was not as cocky when she finally gave into Tommy, “Fine! Sit over there and you can watch us tonight.”
Tommy sat down on the ottoman in the corner as he waited for the girls to resume. Ariyana whispered to Lauren to ensure she was okay with it before she nodded yes. The brunette was loyal so she wanted to help in any way possible. She figured it was worse for Ari since she had to have sex in front of her cousin.
Lauren got back into doggy position in front of Ari as no one in the room spoke. Ari looked hatefully at Tommy as she reapplied lube to her toy. The strap-on slowly was pushed inside Lauren’s tight ass. Even though she was unhappy about being watched the brunette could not deny the pleasure of getting stuffed in the ass.
“Don’t act like you hate it so much,” Tommy told Ari from the corner as he pulled out his cock to start jerking off again.
She flipped him off before turning back to Lauren’s body. Little Ariyana gripped on her hips while working the fake cock in and out of her ass slowly. With each push, she went a little harder. Lauren could not help but moan each time it was fully penetrating. The quicker she was stuffed, the quicker she moaned. They were smart to bring this out of the house because they would have been busted inside for sure.
“Fuck that feels so good in my ass,” Lauren said as she tried to get Ari into it more.
That was the little nudge needed to make her stop hate fucking her ass. Ariyana grabbed her long brown hair from behind and pulled it. Tommy could not believe how rough the girls liked to get in bed. With her other hand, Ari slapped her pale white ass hard enough to make her yelp.
“Are you two always this slutty?” Tommy asked while precumming in his own hand.
Ariyana rolled her eyes at him like a brat before Lauren moaned out, “I’m only a butt slut for Ari.” The petite girl slapped her ass again for answering but enjoyed hearing it.
“What about you Ariyana?” He asked to test her boundaries.
Ari waited a second before replying, “I am the one who got her into it.” Tommy smiled knowing that she was letting down her walls for her him.
He sat in the chair watching and jerking off until he could not hold it back any longer. Ari was pounding her girlfriend in the ass from behind making her moan like an animal. He wanted to wait until she had an orgasm but he could not hold it. His dick erupted with a burst of cum that landed on the floor. There were a few large puddles on the floor below as he relaxed in the chair to watch them finish. He stroked his sensitive cock even after cumming.
Lauren did not last much longer than Tommy. A few minutes later Ari spits on her asshole before starting to rub her clit below. That was the magic move because the next thing to happen was her long legs started shaking. The brunette was moaning deeply for more until reaching her climax. Tommy watched as her pussy started dripping on the bed below while having her orgasm. The girls were both out of breath after Lauren finished.
“You two are a dirty couple of sluts,” Tommy told them as the toy slipped from her gaping ass. Ari let spit drop from her sexy lips in it one last time as it slipped right down the open hole.
“We are even,” Ari said as she put her oversized shirt back on and removed the strap-on. She was putting it back in the bag waiting for Lauren to put her shirt back on.
“For tonight,” Tommy replied smirking.
“What else could you want us to do after that?” Ari stupidly asked out of frustration.
“Anything I tell you to for the rest of this trip,” he replied before pulling up his pants and walking back to the house. He climbed in the window as the girls followed him up to their room.
The girls had to talk about what was happening with the blackmail in private that night. They were angry at first but Lauren pointed out that so far they just had to let him watch. Their sluttiness clouded their judgment as they talked about it being sort of erotic to be watched being butt sluts.
“It could be much worse,” Lauren said before Ari agreed to see what happens. The two of them went to sleep soon after their conversation.
The next morning Tommy woke up to go see what the girls were up to after thinking last night could have been a dream. His mom said they were on a walk on the beach if he wanted to hang out with them. That was his intention but he got another idea in the spur of the moment. Tommy went up to their room to see what he could find snooping around. Besides the bag containing the strap-on, there was not much. He found a dirty pair of Lauren’s panties that he sniffed before stuffing in his pocket. Then he found a bottle of sleeping pills that Lauren had brought on the trip. Tommy thought they could come in handy as he grabbed four pills, two doses.
Not finding anything fun he decided to get something himself. He borrowed his mom’s car to drive into the city. Tommy bought two items before returning to the beach house. He hid them in his nightstand with the sleeping pills and went to find the girls. When he went searching, he found the entire family watching a movie in the living room after lunch, except the girls. Tommy wandered through the house looking for the two missing college girls. They were nowhere to be found inside so he went outside.
He did not see them on the beach either when looking from the porch, so he went checking to see if all the cars were there. They were so the girls had to be around there somewhere. Then he thought about the boat out on the dock. Tommy quickly made his way towards the dock. He jumped on the boat and headed for the cabin room. Before he even opened the door he heard them inside.
“Came out to our secret spot without me,” Tommy teased as he opened the door. Ariyana was instantly annoyed by his presence when they stopped making out on the bed. They sat up as they looked at the man barging in,
“What do you want Tommy?” Ari asked in a sarcastic tone. She was not in the mood to deal with him after last night.
“Remember what I told you before I left last night?” He asked to remind her.
“You really want us to just do whatever you say?” Lauren asked hoping he would back down. They had agreed last night to do it but only if they have to.
“I am not going to make you do anything too crazy or that you wouldn’t do anyway,” Tommy teased as he closed the door.
“We finally get some alone time from the family and we have to let you watch us like some creep?” Ari snarled as she felt backed into the corner.
“You can continue making out,” He told them as he sat down on the ottoman. Tommy stretched out making himself comfortable as he motioned for them to continue.
Lauren tried to keep Ari calm as she pulled her small face over towards her’s. The brunette gently kissed her trying to take her mind off Tommy. She was not happy about it either but watching them kiss was not even as bad as last night. They were passionate with each other as Lauren massaged Ari’s lower back.
“Show me how you use your tongues,” Tommy said like he was directing a pair of actors.
Both girls reluctantly listened as they started deeply french kissing on the bed. It made the older man hard in his shorts as he pulled it out. Neither of them was paying attention as he had his cock in one hand and his phone in the other. Tommy took a photo of the hot girls kissing on the bed in their unisex clothing. Lauren looked like a woman with her long hair and curves but Ari could have passed for a small man kissing an older lady. Still, the scene was hot in the cabin of the boat.
As he jerked off Lauren noticed but did not want to make Ari mad again. She pretended not to notice as their hands explored each other on the bed. When he noticed Lauren being naughty and keeping his secret, he stood up and approached them quietly. Ari was on top as the girls kissed on the bed. Tommy took a picture of his throbbing cock over her petite ass with her lower back and panties slightly exposed. It was just enough of a thrill for him causing him to bust all over her back. She felt it hit her exposed ass crack before jumping up from the bed. Cum was on her shirt, back, and pants as she looked back to see what happened.
“What the fuck Tommy!” Ari yelled as Lauren realized what he did. His dick was still in his hand while grinning at the girls getting upset. Before he could even attempt to make an excuse she tells him, “Just get the fuck out of here.” He decides that letting her cool off is probably his best option anyway. Then leaves them alone for a while.
That night when they are relaxing by the fire before bed, Tommy goes out to make it up to them. At least that is what he wanted them to think. He brought them both hard lemonades like they had been drinking already. The difference was these had two of the sleeping pills in each of them. He mixed them in after crushing them up in the kitchen. Ariyana and Lauren did not accept his apology but they took the drinks. They worked like a charm. An hour later both of them went into their bedroom and were sound asleep.
Tommy waited a little longer to ensure everyone was in bed before sneaking into their room through the window. He was already getting hard when he saw that Ariyana was sleeping in only a pair of panties as usual. Bedside, he looked down at them laying on the bed knocked out. Tommy grinned as he shook the both of them. Neither woke up but he was not too worried if they did anyway. He would be able to convince them to accept it for the secret but this was easier and a little more fun for the freak.
His hands started to caress Ari first since she was already almost naked. Her petite body felt tiny in his large hands. Every inch of her was soft while running his hands across her body. She barely had enough boobs to be squeezed but he enjoyed her tight little ass in his big groping paws. Once he felt what little curves she had to offer, he moved onto Lauren.
Lifting her long black shirt, he discovered she was fully nude underneath. The girls were awfully comfortable around each other. He lifted the shirt all the way up to expose her fully before feeling her up too. She had more to squeeze, more to grope, more to enjoy. Tommy let her D cup tits fill his hands as he rubbed his boner against her thigh. He still had on his shorts but started to think about removing them.
Then he got her to roll over so he could see her wonderful ass. The two round mounds were ready for his hands as he squeezed them roughly. When she did not budge, he knew he was in the clear. Tommy looked to make sure the door was locked then pulled down his shorts. His hard cock now was able to rub on her bare thigh as he realized why Ari loved her ass so much. It was perfect for a tomboy white girl.
As he spread open the cheeks he noticed how great her ass felt, it was so soft. His mouth could not stay away after seeing the girls enjoy licking it. Tommy’s tongue teased outside of the asshole as he nervously tasted it. When there was no bad taste, he became an animal licking at her tight hole. It was soaking wet from his saliva within seconds. He wondered if he could do more.
Tommy rubbed his two fingers in the spit before trying to push in the tip of one. Surprisingly it went in with ease. Her ass was tight but he wanted to see if a second was just as easy. It needed an extra nudge but it got inside. He gathered his saliva before spitting it all in her asshole to start fingering her. His eyes watched her ass open up and expand for him while her pussy got wet below. Then he noticed her pussy opening and closing slightly like it was breathing. That made him move his fingers faster until he saw her having an orgasm while still asleep. Her thighs trembled when he did not stop. Tommy kept going until her pussy was leaking juices and her body relaxed on the bed.
His finger slipped out as he put his dick between her ass cheeks. Tommy was not willing to go all the way but he lubed his cock with spit and started rubbing it against her soft mounds. It was the most erotic moment of his life as he used her sleeping ass to get off. He looked over at Ari in the bed to check out her petite body again. Those soft cheeks did not take long to milk his cock. Tommy grunted as he thrust down hard on her ass. Sweat dripped from his forehead onto her back as he finally got to cum. It sprayed from between her ass cheeks to cover her lower back.
Tommy kept stroking himself against her until he felt empty. He wiped the sweat as he got up from her back. First, he had to take a picture of them sleeping with his cum on her back. Then there was a pair of her dirty panties that he picked up to clean up his cum. He thought about keeping them but threw them in the dirty clothes basket. That was enough for him that night. He had 24 hours left with the girls and had big plans to get the most out of his secret.
There was no rush the next morning since he knew they would be sleeping in. Tommy woke up just before noon. He left his room to find Ari and Lauren. There was no searching today as they sat on their bed drinking coffee. Tommy went back to his room grabbing the gifts he bought yesterday before going back to deliver them.
Ariyana was being bratty as normal when Lauren asked, “What is it today Tommy?” She had no idea what he had in mind. Tommy said nothing. He pulled the boxes out from behind his back. Then handed one to each of them. “What are these?” Lauren asked. Still, Tommy said nothing. The girls slowly opened them not knowing what to expect.
“You are so fucking gross,” Ari told him as she threw the gift back at him. Lauren held her’s, checking it out. Tommy laughed as he caught the shining chrome butt plug that he had bought for each of them.
“You have to do ANYTHING I tell you,” Tommy reminded her as he tossed it back to her on the bed. Then he explained what he wanted, “I want you two to wear them for the rest of the day since it is our last night together.” They seemed to have no idea what he had done to them last night and that made it even hotter for him.
“We have talked about trying these before,” Lauren admitted before Ari flashed her an angry look to shut her up. Tommy shrugged his shoulders pretending not to care as he turned to leave.
“Stop, don’t be an asshole!” Ari angry snapped. She did not verbally agree but told him to lock the door. Tommy turned and quickly locked it before waiting to see them be put in.
Ariyana got the lube from her black bag before applying it to Lauren’s plug. She took it and had the tall brunette bend over. Her round ass looked great as she slowly accepted her metal butt plug inside her tight hole. Then she awkwardly stood up to make sure it would not fall out. Lauren seemed proud of herself as she strutted around the room to test herself.
“Your turn,” Lauren said eagerly pushing the petite girl down over the corner of the bed. She did not even use the lube. The slutty girl sucked on the metal knob before gagging herself with it. That caused her saliva to pile up on the toy before let the extra drip down on Ari’s puckered asshole. Ari flinched as the pressure was applied. With one deep breath, her tiny body took in the toy like it was nothing. “Such a dirty little slut,” Lauren said slapping her on the ass.
When Ari stood up she walked around the room. The girls were not too upset with Tommy after getting the gifts even though they still hated him. He made them bend over in front of him as he admired the different shaped asses side by side with the claim of wanting to check the plugs. Tommy groped one of each of their ass cheeks in each hand before Ari pulled away.
“I will be checking them throughout the day,” he warned before telling them they could get dressed now.
Throughout the day he teased them many times while checking them for the toys. Once, he made them pull down their pants in the kitchen for him to see both still supporting the metal objects inside their holes. Later, he snuck up behind Lauren by the dock and groped her ass through the pants. He could feel the toy was still inside as he whispered that he was proud in her ear and pressed it deeper inside. During dinner, Ari and Tommy were sent to get the pie and forks. The man took the opportunity to check her as he made the petite girl pull it out for him. He added his saliva to it before making her put it back in. She was gaping after hours when he sent her back to finish dinner with the family.
Tommy waited until just before midnight to head into their room. Both of them were still up as they waited to be able to remove the toys. He showed up just in time to ruin the special moment. They were sitting on the bed when he came in to check on them.
“Ready to take out your toys?” Tommy teasingly asked. Both of them nodded to let him know they were. Then he let him in on the rest of his plan, “In a minute you can. I have decided how we can forget about this once and for all.”
“How?” Ariyana asked annoyed but wanting to end it with her cousin. He was smiling when she took the bait so easily.
“One of you is going to have to fuck me,” Tommy said with his evil smirk. He knew that leaving the choice to them would make it hotter for him and more fun. They were looking at each other like they were speaking telepathically. “In the ass of course,” he said as if it was the end to his offer. Then the cousin chuckled in front of them.
They started whispering together as Ari asked if Lauren was willing to fuck him since it was her cousin. Lauren understood why it was not going to be Ari but was hesitant to let Tommy fuck her in the rear. She had seen he was pretty large and figured he was not going to be as careful as Ariyana typically was inside. It took them a few minutes of talking before Lauren agreed. Ari told her that she was the best girlfriend ever.
“We can go out to the boat then. Bring that lube,” Tommy told them as he walked towards the window. They followed him out the window down to the boat in the middle of the night.
In the boat, Ari said, “I will wait out here in the main room.” She did not want to have to watch her cousin fuck her girlfriend.
“You are going to sit on the ottoman just like I had to,” Tommy demanded not taking no for answer. He was ready to take Lauren’s nice ass. There was a little part of him feeling like he was missing out on Ari but decided it was for the best. Lauren had a much nice ass and tits, as well as not being his cousin.
Ariyana reluctantly followed them into the room and sat down on the little chair in the corner of the room. She watched as her girlfriend got on the bed to get ready for him. Part of it was sexy but she was not happy about it so she had to pretend to hate it all.
Tommy pulled out his semihard cock from his shorts as he dropped them to the floor. “Suck it first,” he ordered the brunette.
“I thought you said anal,” Ari interjected from the corner angrily.
“We will get to that eventually. I am not an animal,” he teased as he looked deep into her eyes. She was furious as he turned back and put his hand on the top of Lauren’s head.
The brunette did not resist, her mouth opened letting it slide in between her soft lips. He went into the back of her throat until she pushed on his hips to stop him. Then he started thrusting that deep in her each time. Sometimes he went too far and made her gag but he loved the way her wet mouth accepted his hard cock. She let her tongue glide across the bottom of his shaft with saliva dripping from it.
Tommy used her mouth until he was lubed up and fully erect. He pushed her head back as he made her lay back on the bed. Her perky tits bounced when she fell back. His hands groped them before using his hand to slap his wet dick on her moist mound. Lauren let a soft moan escape her lips before biting on the bottom one to stop the following moans.
“She wants it,” Tommy said as he looked over at Ari in the corner. He was just trying to antagonize her at that point but it got him off.
They ignored his comment. Tommy started to push his head into her tight pussy from the side of the bed as she gripped on the sheets. Lauren gasped when it started to penetrate her. It was bigger than her usual toys so she had to adjust to the size. He slowly went in and out until she was able to take the large rod a little easier. Once she was warmed up, Tommy started to give it to her. His strong arms propped up his body over her as he pumped down inside. It felt good but it was not what got the tall brunette off sexually. He was enjoying his time inside her wet hole, mostly because it was driving Ariyana wild. She could not admit it was hot and touch herself in front of him willingly.
He was almost grunting as he told Lauren, “Time to feel how tight that ass really is. You better live up to being a “butt slut” as you two naughty girls call it.” She did not get a say in the matter as he rolled her over on the bed. He slapped her thick white ass before pulling her back into position. Tommy had her ass bent over the edge of the bed as she rested on her knees. It was the perfect angle for him to plow the tall anal whore.
Tommy made little Ariyana pretend to hate watching as she handed them the lube. He covered his cock in the slippery liquid before finally grabbing the chrome plug in her ass. There was a long moan as he slowly pulled it out, followed by a sigh of relief after it had been inside most of the day. He tossed the warm toy to her girlfriend before spitting right into the gaping hole. Lauren moaned as it seeped down inside her. Then he squirted lube right in to follow.
Lauren was starting to quiver as he pushed the head right inside. There was not much resistance because she wore the plug all day but it was still tight once he got deeper. It felt amazing on his dick being squeezed. Tommy was not gentle at all as he started humping her against the mattress. He pulled her long brown hair to see her moaning facial expressions as he spread her open even more.
The slut loved anal so much that she learned something new during that encounter. She was not asexual or lesbian, she was just a woman who enjoyed getting her ass used. Lauren moaned heavily as he released her head and slapped her on the butt. He left a big handprint before starting to pump as hard as he could. Sweat was dripping from his face as he started grunting.
“This is how you treat a real butt slut,” Tommy said while looking right at Ariyana. He wanted to tease the both of them and that he did. Lauren was in anal heaven but Ari still tried to hide how wet she was under those jeans. She could not wait to get Lauren back from Tommy so she could use her better, or at least try to compete. The petite girl was starting to feel a little insecure as she watched her girlfriend be pleased like never before.
He felt her quivering on his cock before she had an orgasm from anal sex. All of them were shocked as Lauren moaned out, “I am cumming.” Ari could tell by her face it was true and Tommy did not need to see. He felt a warm gushing liquid spray out on his balls as they slapped against her pussy.
Feeling the girl squirt was overwhelming on his sack. He grunted, “She squirted on my balls. Fuck I am going to cum too.” Tommy held onto her hips for dear life as he emptied himself into her tight ass. Lauren moaned out feeling the warm cum seeping deeper inside as he unloaded.
“Fuck you girls really are sluts,” Tommy said as he gave Lauren’s ass one last slap goodbye. He walked out of the room with his legs feeling weak after the intense sex. Tommy was able to go back to his room feeling like he got the most out of the simple information he learned on vacation. He also knew that he could use it in the future if he truly wanted to be mean to the young lesbian couple.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/n5kbsx/ariyana_and_her_girlfriend_lauren_get_blackmailed