*Thanks for everyone who read Part 1! If you haven’t feel free to read it on my profile*
So lets go back a few months. I decided that if sex with another guy was something for me, I needed to prepare. I read plenty of advice stating that it would hurt the first time and to use plenty of lube. But I wanted it to feel good. To ensure this I purchased an anal training kit. It arrived with four butt plugs, from small to XL and instructions as and when to increase the size. I inserted the small butt plug into my ass with plenty of lube and… it felt really good! Not going to lie, it hurt at first, but the second/third time of wearing it felt amazing with no discomfort. After a week, and every week after, I’d train my ass by increasing the size and by the end of the month the XL buttplug fit me like a glove. I felt prepared.
But back to the present story. The ringing of “I want to fuck you was ringing in my ears”. I was shook and nervous but felt compelled to do it. I wanted it. This was the very thing I’d been working myself up to. “I’ve got a buttplug in” I told him, as I wasn’t sure whether sex was on the cards the first time. “That’s fucking hot” he replied. “Can I take it out for you?” God that got me hard, the thought that he was taking a buttplug out of my ass so he could see me open, knowing minutes later his cock would be in the same place. I agreed, but wanted to unclothe first. We both stripped off naked as I reached over for the lube. He started to masturbate himself, making himself even harder and more erect.
“Are you sure you wanna do this?” He asked me. A mixture of euphoria and nerves came over me but I wanted it so so bad. “Please yeah!” I replied.
“Condom on/off?” He asked me. FUCK! My cock instantly got rock solid. Just imagine a raw cock inside me? Hot salty precum entering my ass and his cum eventually filling me up, pouring out my ass minutes/hours later. Was this what I wanted? The raw experience?
“No condom!” I replied (He was tested negative for HIV days before, and showed me the results at the coffee meet). He told me to go on all fours, head into the pillow and ass up. I felt a hand on my ass, slowly moving towards my hole. He slowly pulled at the butt plug, as it widened my ass on exit. He looked in awe down into my hole, prelubed from the buttplug, slightly hairy but presenting to him. “Fuck that’s hot.” He said.
I knew my ass was turning him on, knowing that he was about to take my virginity from me. “Are you ready?” He asked me whilst lubing up his fully erect cock. “You bet I’m ready” I said, bent over on the bed, my cock fully hardened, sensitivity at an all time high.
He shuffled towards me, knowing that in the next 10 seconds it’ll start. I closed my eyes.
It felt like an eternity, but then it hit. Pressure hit my asshole. His wet cock head slowly pushing towards my hole. “Fuck!” I was in heaven. He slowly pushed harder. My asshole was so inviting, allowing him more and more entry inside me. He let out a moan, as my asshole slowly wrapped around his hard cock, till I felt the whole of him inside me. To this day, I have never felt something more euphoric. The thoughts and feelings rushing around my head were like a drug. I loved it. I loved this. His balls touched mine, and I knew he was fully inside me. He let out another groan. I knew this felt good for him.
And then it began. Back and forth, slowly at first but building up speed. My cock was rock hard leaking precum as he began to pick up the pace fucking me. The noise of his body and mine connecting on every push inside me was ringing round my ears, turning me on more and more.
I let out the sluttiest moan ever. A noise like I’d never made before. I was compelled to make it. I fucking love this. I felt alive. This feeling was something I’d never felt before. He continued to pound me, groaning and moaning as our enjoyment of the experience synchronised together. “You like that?” He said. “Fuck yeah, fuck me harder” I replied, feeling evermore slutty. In my head, I imagined seeing his cock deep inside me, his precum leaking into me, the salty warm fluid building up and being left in my ass.
My cock was swinging the harder I was being fucked. I couldn’t help but let out slutty moans. I’d never experienced this feeling before, and it was amazing! And then….
“Knock, Knock, Knock”.
(Thanks for the responses to Part 1, hopefully people enjoy this part and I can keep writing it if the demand is there, I’ve got hundreds of stories to write from my experiences over the past few years. Please let me know if you want more parts/stories and feedback is appreciated!) :)
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/mmkg2a/from_straight_to_curious_part_2_m24