[MF] Convincing the Innocent Girl to Cheat (Part 2)

After Alyssa and I had our car rendezvous, she didn’t respond to me for a while. I didn’t know if she would ever talk to me again. She could’ve felt guilty about the whole situation, acting like nothing ever happened to help her forget about it. I had figured that this was true, so I didn’t bother trying to badger her for a response.

A couple of weeks went by and I finally got a message from her. It was a text message that read “I can’t stop thinking about that night”. I would have to agree, I couldn’t stop thinking about that night either. I spent countless times masturbating to my memory of that night. I responded to her message saying, “Me either, it was amazing.” We exchanged a few messages before I asked her the question that had been on my mind for quite a while. “Are you still with your boyfriend… did you ever tell him?”. She told me that she was indeed still dating him and no he has no idea. To be honest, hearing that turned me on. She told me that her sex life hasn’t been the same since, she had never had a cock the size of mine, and her boyfriend was a few inches smaller and not nearly as thick. She also told me he was never rough with her or played with her ass, something I absolutely love doing.

She also told me that she wasn’t going to end things with him anytime soon, because they had such a great relationship with everything other than their sex life. She did tell me that she wanted to meet up with me again. It was hard to find a time to meet up because of our distance from each other, or if she did come home she was with her boyfriend. When the semester ended, her and her boyfriend came back to our hometown where they stayed at her parents house so she could visit with her family.

One night I was out at the local beer garden with some friends, and to my surprise, Alyssa and her boyfriend were seated at a table by themselves. I never told any of my friends about me and Alyssa’s night, but they did know her because of our time in high school together. We sat down and ordered some beers. After a while, I noticed Alyssa make eye contact with me and her face was surprised but she smirked a little bit as she turned away. I ended up getting up to use the restroom and their table was in the direction where I was headed.

I got near their table and stopped and said hi to Alyssa. Alyssa and I played it very cool and we acted like we hadn’t seen each other since high school. She introduced me to her boyfriend, I’ll call him Ty, and I shook his hand. In my head, all I could think about was how a few weeks earlier I had his girlfriend naked in the backseat of my car, pounding her and tongue fucking her asshole. His innocent girlfriend was my slut for a night. Our meeting was brief, and I continued to the bathroom.

I walked back to my table, and my friends and I ended up heading back home after about an hour more of drinking there. I didn’t want to send her any messages knowing that she was with her boyfriend. Late that night, around 1am, I received a message from Alyssa. It was a classic, “what are you doing right now?” text. I was surprised she would even message me while she was in town with her boyfriend. I told her I was still up and just watching Netflix and she told me that Ty was asleep and she wanted to come over. I gladly sent her my address and told her to come over.

My roommates never ask questions when girls come over this late, because most of us have had late night tinder matches come over. Alyssa showed up and I brought her into my room. She told me she has been waiting for this for too long. We started making out and I pushed her onto my bed. She slid her hand into my pants and started to stroke by cock which was already almost fully hard. I slid my hands into her pants and gripped her round ass cheeks tightly. We started to take each other’s clothes off.

Alyssa was wearing a matching black lace lingerie set, and she looked so fucking good in it. I bent her over the edge of my bed, and slid her panties down to her ankles. I started eating her pussy out from behind, grabbing and groping her ass cheeks as I did it. I started to move my tongue up to her asshole and I could feel her whole body squirm in excitement.

I then stood up and slid my cock into her wet pussy, not even thinking about grabbing a condom first. She looked back at me and I asked her if she wanted me to grab one and she said “fuck no this feels so much better”. I could feel her tight pussy lips gripping my cock tightly. I started stroking slowly, and began to go faster and faster. My balls were slapping the bottom of her pussy making a loud clapping sound. I couldn’t care less about my roommates because we have all had to deal with a late night fucking being heard from the other room.

I had my thumb pressing on her asshole as I continued to fuck her. I pulled out and had her lay on her back. I put her legs over my shoulders and began stroking again. While I was fucking her, I was using my thumb to rub her clit. She was trying so hard to hold in the moans but some would escape her. I then laid on my back and had her straddle me and we fucked in that position for a few minutes. I pulled her close to me and told her “ride me reverse cowgirl baby” as she responded “yes daddy”. She turned around and I started fucking her, staring at her bubble butt of an ass in all its glory. Watching it jiggle and shake while I stuffed her pussy.

I got her off when I felt I was getting close to finishing. I had her get on her knees in front of me and I started jacking off getting ready to bust. She opened her mouth and stuck her tongue out as I blew my load all over her. I got some in her mouth, some on her face and hair, and some dripped down to her chest and tits.

We were both exhausted after that. I grabbed a towel and helped her clean off, giving her a playful slap on the ass after. I pushed her close to me grabbing her ass with both my hands, gripping it tightly, and saying “You’re a slut for my cock aren’t you”. She just looked me in the eyes and responded with “Anything for you daddy”. I watched her put her clothes back, wishing she could spend the night in my bed with me. Before she left I asked her if I would see her again anytime soon and she said “We better see each other soon” and she walked out.

I couldn’t help but think she was going home to sleep with her boyfriend, without even showering having my dry cum still on her. This innocent girl is actually a slut when it comes to a big cock. Needless to say, I slept like a baby that night.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ly71t5/mf_convincing_the_innocent_girl_to_cheat_part_2