This happened while I was in college with a woman, I’d been dating for close to two years at the time. We had some friends we hung out with a lot, a single guy and single girl. He was into her, but she was not into him. Thankfully, it didn’t have a negative impact on the fun we had as a group.
The girlfriend and I lived together in a small one-bedroom apartment that was part of a small complex. Next to it, was the pool that was fenced in and attached to the end unit of one of the apartment rows. It was technically closed after dark and locked up, but a good friend of mine lived in the apartment that was directly connected to the pool.
Our friends were over one night and as usual we had been drinking. It was a hot summer evening, so we decided to go swimming, this really wasn’t uncommon. However, this night we ended up skinny dipping.
My buddy spent most of the evening across the pool from the three of us. As the drinking continued so did the fun and games. Eventually, truth or dare happened.
This initial portion of the game consisted of the usual stupid dares. All four of us ended up standing out of the pool one at a time. Then my buddy was dared to get hard. That didn’t go so well, stress wasn’t his friend.
Then I was dared by out female friend to get hard. I dreaded being asked to do the same thing after my buddy had been dared a failed. Luckily for me, my girlfriend had me sit on the side of the pool while she stroked me hard.
The other woman accused us of cheating but that didn’t stop her from watching intently. The dares quieted down after that. This is when the truth portion of the game really picked up.
It was all the standard, have you done this or that. What stood out was our two shock at how adventurous my girlfriend and I were. We’d experimented a lot and as she was always down, we had a lot of roadside and public sex.
Our female friend countered as best she could talking about the three-ways she’d been in. All of them had being either FMF or MFF. She much preferred the FMF, but with the right woman she’d be up for an MFF.
The only person in that pool that lacked subtlety more than me was her. She talked directly to me and my girlfriend. She had also moved to my side in the pool pressing her naked body to my side opposite my girlfriend.
Their hands taking turns touching and stroking my hard cock under the water. My buddy took read the sign and made up an excuse to leave. Once he was gone, we agreed it was time to get out of the pool.
We wrapped ourselves in towels and carried out suits back to the apartment. Once back in the apartment the lady’s towels went on their heads and mine went on its hook. I grabbed the three of us another drink.
Our lady friend headed to the bathroom which gave my girlfriend time to pull me into our bedroom. I assumed it was to start the fun. I was wrong.
She told me she couldn’t go through with it, but if I really wanted too, she would try. As much as little brain wanted to do this, I couldn’t make her do something she didn’t want to do. I told her not to worry about it and I’d let our friend know and see her out.
My girl got into bed and I killed the lights for her and shut the door. Our friend was waiting on the couch touching herself when I came out of our bedroom. It was a beautiful sight to behold.
She asked me the standard, “What were you two up too in there?”. It was hard not to just watch her play, but I had to tell what was up. She wasn’t upset, but she also didn’t stop playing with herself while we talked.
When she got up, she grabbed her cloths and as she passed me to go get dressed in the bathroom, she put her fingers in my mouth and squeezed my cock.
I almost came right there. Holy fuck! Once she was gone the girl and I fucked like there was no tomorrow. We were both raw the next day.
Our group of friends continued to hang out together the rest of the summer, but no more shenanigans of any kind. Our friend did tell me later she was happy we didn’t go through with it. Well in the moment she did, but once the alcohol wore off the felt extremely guilty. The main driver for the guilt was her desire to fuck me. Apparently, my girl at the time liked to talk about out sex life in graphic detail.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/lhrh6h/mff_missed_it_by_that_much